The study of policy transfer appeals to geography and cognate disciplines because it offers a powerful way of conceptualising how policy regimes travel and internationalise. This is reflected in its use for understanding uneven processes of recent state restructuring, usually referred to as neoliberalisation. In this paper I adopt an assemblage perspective on policy transfer that, instead of emphasising broad processes of change, focuses on how the objects of a transferred policy are constituted in different places. Using the case of the transfer of the creative industries policy concept from the UK to New Zealand as an example, I argue that the rendering of policy objects using, in this case, specific calculate techniques constitutes them as a global form universal to different places. However, this process does not run smoothly; it requires that the policy object is articulated in a policy assemblage in the new site. The work of assembly requires a range of different kinds of work, including the alignment of divergent political motivations, the translation of different ideas, and the invention of new concepts and programmes. This demonstrates how policy transfer is political and technical, and that its study can benefit from analyses that traverse both these aspects.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenJCochraneA, 2007, “Beyond the territorial fix: Regional assemblages, politics and power”Regional Studies411161–1175.
2.
AminA, 2002, “Spatialities of globalisation”Environment and Planning A34385–399.
3.
BarkerG, 2000Cultural Capital and Policy (New Zealand Film Commission, Wellington).
4.
BarnettC, 2005, “The consolations of ‘neoliberalism’”Geoforum367–12.
5.
BarryA, 2001Political Machines: Governing a Technological Society (The Athlone Press, London).
6.
BlairT, 1998The Third Way: New Politics for a New Century (Fabian Society, London).
7.
BlomfieldP, 2002, “The designer fashion industry in New Zealand: A scoping study”, commissioned by Industry New Zealand, Wellington; copy available from New Zealand Trade and Enterprise, PO Box 2878, Wellington 6140, http://www.nzte.govt.nz.
BraunB, 2006, “Environmental issues: Global natures in the space of assemblage”Progress in Human Geography30644–654.
10.
CallonM, 1986, “Some elements of a sociology of translation: Domestication of the scallops and the fishermen of St Brieux Bay”, in Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge? Ed. LawJ (Routledge, London) pp 196–233.
11.
CardyT, 2000, “Arts funding body hits back at ‘outdated’ report”Evening Post 19 July, page 10.
12.
CastreeN, 2006, “From neoliberalism to neoliberalisation: Consolations, confusions, and necessary illusions”Environment and Planning A381–6.
13.
ChristophersB, 2007, “Enframing creativity: Power, geographical knowledges and the media economy”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series32235–247.
CollierS J, 2006, “Global assemblages”Theory, Culture and Society23399–401.
17.
CollierS JOngA, 2005, “Global assemblages, anthropological problems”, in Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems Eds OngACollierS J (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 3–21.
18.
Creative New Zealand, 2000a, “Cool Aotearoa?”, transcript, Creative New Zealand, Wellington; copy available from R Prince, School of People, Environment and Planning, Massey University, Palmerston North.
19.
Creative New Zealand, 2000b, “Rt. Hon. Chris Smith—creative industries forum”, transcript, Creative New Zealand, Wellington; copy available from R Prince.
CzarniawskaBSevonG, 2005, “Translation is the vehicle, imitation its motor, and fashion sits at the wheel”, in Global Ideas: How Ideas, Objects and Practices Travel in the Global Economy Eds CzarniawskaBSevonG (Liber and Copenhagen Business School Press, Copenhagen) pp 7–12.
DeLandaM, 2006A New Philosophy of Society: Assemblage Theory and Social Complexity (Continuum, London).
25.
Department for Trade and Industry, 1998Our Competitive Future: Building the Knowledge Driven Economy Cm 4176 (The Stationery Office, London).
26.
DolowitzDMarshD, 1996, “Who learns what from whom: A review of the policy transfer literature”Political Studies44343–357.
27.
DoucheR, 2001, “The New Zealand music industry: A scoping review of the New Zealand music industry for Industry New Zealand”, R P Douche Consulting Ltd, and Industry New Zealand, Wellington, http://www.nzte.govt.nz/section/13609/11213.aspx.
EnglandKEakinJGastaldoDMcKeeverP, 2007, “Neoliberalizing home care: Managed competition and restructured home care in Ontario”, in Neoliberalization: States, Networks, Peoples Eds EnglandKWardK (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 169–194.
30.
EvansM, 2004Policy Transfer in Global Perspective (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants).
31.
FranklinS, 2005, “Stem Cells R Us: Emergent life forms and the global biological”, in Global Assemblages: Technology Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems Eds OngACollierS J, (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 59–78.
32.
GarnhamN, 2005, “From cultural to creative industries: An analysis of the implications of the ‘creative industries’ approach to arts and media policy making in the United Kingdom”International Journal of Cultural Policy1115–29.
33.
GiddensA, 1998The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy (Polity Press, Cambridge).
34.
GoldfinchSMalpassD, 2007, “The Polish shipyard: Myth, economic history and economic policy reform in New Zealand”Australian Journal of Politics and History53118–137.
35.
GoodrumALarnerWMolloyM, 2004, “Wear in the world? Fashioning Auckland as a globalising city”, in Almighty Auckland? Eds CarterICraigDMatthewmanS (Dunmore Press, Palmerston North) pp 257–274.
36.
HaythornthwaiteP, 2002, “Design industry scoping review: An appraisal of the current status of the New Zealand design profession/industry”, Palmerston North, Massey University College of Design, Fine Arts and Music and Industry New Zealand, http://www.nzte.govt.nz/section/13608/10949.aspx.
37.
HesmondhalghDPrattA, 2005, “Cultural industries and cultural policy”International Journal of Cultural Policy111–13.
38.
Hot Nation Project Team, 2000The Heart of the Nation: A Cultural Strategy for Aotearoa New Zealand (McDermott Miller, Wellington).
39.
HughsonJInghsD, 2001, “‘Creative industries’ and the arts in Britain: Towards a ‘Third Way’ in cultural policy?”International Journal of Cultural Policy7457–478.
40.
JessopBPeckJ, 2001, “Fast policy/local discipline: The politics of time and scale in the neo-liberal workfare offensive”, Department of Sociology, University of Lancaster, Lancaster.
41.
JonesDSmithK, 2005, “Middle-Earth meets New Zealand: Authenticity and location in the making of The Lord of the Rings”Journal of Management Studies42923–945.
42.
KainoL2007, “Cultural policy formation and the development of creative industries in Australia and New Zealand: A focus on feature film industries”New Zealand Sociology22239–259.
43.
LarnerW, 2003, “Neoliberalism?”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21509–512.
44.
LarnerW, 2009, “Neoliberalism, Mike Moore, and the WTO”Environment and Planning A411576–1593.
45.
LarnerWLe HeronR, 2002, “The spaces and subjects of a globalising economy: A situated exploration of method”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space20753–774.
46.
LarnerWLe HeronRLewisN, 2007, “Co-constituting ‘after neoliberalism’: Political projects and globalising governmentalities in Aotearoa/New Zealand”, in Neoliberalization: States, Networks, Peoples Eds EnglandKWardK (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 223–247.
47.
LathamA, 2002, “Re-theorizing the scale of globalization: Topologies, actor-networks, and cosmopolitanism”, in The Geography of Power: Making Scale Eds HerodAWrightM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 115–144.
48.
LeadbeaterC, 1999Living on Thin Air: The New Economy (Penguin, London).
LendvaiNStubbsP, 2007, “Policies as translation: Situating trans-national social policies”, in Policy Reconsidered: Meanings, Politics and Practices Eds HodgsonS MIrvingZ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 173–189.
51.
LewisNLarnerWLe HeronR, 2008, “The New Zealand designer fashion industry: Making industries and co-constituting political projects”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series3342–59.
52.
LiT M, 2007, “Practices of assemblage and community forest management”Economy and Society36263–293.
53.
LofgrenO, 2005, “Cultural alchemy: Translating the experience economy into Scandinavian”, in Global Ideas: How Ideas, Objects and Practices Travelin the Global Economy Eds CzarniawskaBSevonG (Liber and Copenhagen Business School Press, Copenhagen) pp 15–29.
54.
McCannE J, 2004, “‘Best places’: Interurban competition, quality of life and popular media discourse”Urban Studies411909–1929.
55.
McCannE J, 2008, “Expertise, truth, and urban policy mobilities: Global circuits of knowledge in the development of Vancouver, Canada's ‘four pillar’ drug strategy”Environment and Planning A40885–904.
MarcusG ESakaE2006, “Assemblage”Theory, Culture and Society23101–106.
59.
MasseyD, 1993, “Power-geometry and a progressive sense of place”, in Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures, Global Change Eds BirdJCurtisBPutnamTRobertsonGTicknerL (Routledge, London) pp 59–69.
MitchellT, 2002Rule of Experts: Egypt, Techno-politics, Modernity (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
63.
Music Industry Export Development Group, 2004, “Creating heat—Tumata kia whita! A strategy to ignite the economic and cultural potential of the New Zealand music industry”, New Zealand Trade and Enterprise, Wellington.
64.
NZIER, 2002, “Creative industries in New Zealand: Economic contribution”, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research and New Zealand Trade and Enterprise, Wellington, http://www.nzte.govt.nz/section/13608/10947.aspx.
OldsK, 2005, “Articulating agendas and travelling principles in the layering of new strands of academic freedom in contemporary Singapore”, in Global Ideas: How Ideas, Objects and Practices Travel in the Global Economy Eds CzarniawskaBSevonG (Liber and Copenhagen Business School Press, Copenhagen) pp 167–189.
67.
OldsK, 2007, “Global assemblage: Singapore, foreign universities, and the construction of a ‘global education hub’”World Development35959–975.
68.
OldsKThriftN2005, “Cultures on the brink: Re-engineering the soul of capitalism—on a global scale”, in Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems Eds OngACollierS J (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 270–290.
PeckJ, 2001, “Neoliberalizing states: Thin policies/hard outcomes”Progress in Human Geography25445–455.
71.
PeckJ, 2002, “Political economies of scale: Fast policy, interscalar relations, and neoliberal workfare”Economic Geography78331–360.
72.
PeckJ, 2003, “Geography and public policy: Mapping the penal state”Progress in Human Geography27222–232.
73.
PeckJ, 2004, “Geography and public policy: Constructions of neoliberalism”Progress in Human Geography28392–405.
74.
PeckJTheodoreN, 2001, “Exporting workfare/importing welfare-to-work: Exploring the politics of Third Way policy transfer”Political Geography20427–460.
75.
PhelpsN APowerMWanjiruR2007, “Learning to compete: Communities of investment promotion practice in the spread of global neoliberalism”, in Neoliberalization: States, Networks, Peoples Eds EnglandKWardK (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 83–109.
76.
RodrikD, 2004, “Industrial policy for the twenty-first century”, Paper prepared for the United Nations Industrial Policy Organisation, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, http://ksghome.harvard.edu/%7Edrodrik/UNIDOSep.pdf.
77.
SmithC, 1998Creative Britain (Faber and Faber, London).
Statistics New Zealand, 1995New Zealand Framework for Cultural Statistics (Statistics New Zealand, Wellington).
80.
StoneD, 2000, “Non-governmental policy transfer: The strategies of independent policy institutes”Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration1345–62.
81.
StoneD, 2004, “Transfer agents and global networks in the ‘transnationalisation’ of policy”Journal of European Public Policy11545–566.
82.
SwainA, 2006, “Soft capitalism and a hard industry: Virtualism, the ‘transition industry’ and the restructuring of the Ukrainian coal industry”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series31208–223.
83.
ThriftN, 2005Knowing Capitalism (Sage, London).
84.
WardK, 2006, “‘Policies in motion’, urban management and state restructuring: The trans-local expansion of business improvement districts”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research3054–75.
YeabsleyJDuncanI, 2002, “Scoping the lasting effects of The Lord of the Rings: A report to the New Zealand Film Commission”, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, Wellington, http://shiva.smst.waikato.ac.nz/∼seanc/LOTR/nzier.lotr.pdf.
