Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article focuses on the dynamics of autocratization processes in the context of contested elections and shrinking civic space, using the case of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan as an example. Kyrgyzstan exemplifies the characteristics of autocratization processes through the manipulation of elections and continuous attempts to restrict civic space. After two “revolutions,” the Republic faces a third autocratization process where elections are used to consolidate power and reshape the political system. This article explores the response strategies of citizen election observers to autocratization. This process has triggered different reactions, such as coalition building, mobilization, adaptation, and resignation. Theoretically, this study connects to academic debates on the third wave of autocratization, shrinking civic spaces and electoral integrity. It proposes the concept of electoral resilience and its sources for citizen election observers to explain why they are able to respond to restrictions. The empirical findings suggest that the existence of formal electoral networks and the organizational health are important sources for electoral resilience. International aid can build electoral resilience through financial support; however, it can also have negative impacts on the resilience of citizen election observers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adger

W. Neil

. 2000. “Social and Ecological Resilience: Are They Related?” Progress in Human Geography, 24(3):347–364; doi: 10.1191/030913200701540465

Alliance. 2009. “Final Pre-Election Report—July 17, 2009 Based on Independent Long-Term Monitoring of the Presidential Elections in Kyrgyzstan on July 23, 2009”. Available from: https://www.ndi.org/sites/default/files/Alliance%20Full%20Pre-election%20Report_English%20%283%29.pdf [Last accessed: August 19, 2022].

Amnesty International. 2024. “Kyrgyzstan: Highly Restrictive NGO Legislation Passed by Parliament Must Be Vetoed.”. Amnesty International. Available from: https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/03/kyrgyzstan-highly-restrictive-ngo-legislation-passed-by-parliament-must-be-vetoed/ [Last accessed: March 31, 2024].

Anderson

John

. 1999. Kyrgyzstan: Central Asia’s Island of Democracy?. Taylor & Francis.

Anderson

John

. 2000. “Creating a Framework for Civil Society in Kyrgyzstan.” Europe-Asia Studies, 52(1):77–93; doi: 10.1080/09668130098271

Bakiev

Erlan

. 2021. “The Power Shift from Government to Organized Crime in Kyrgyzstan.” In Between Peace and Conflict in the East and the West: Studies on Transformation and Development in the OSCE Region, ed. Mihr

Anja

. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 139–55; doi:10.1007/978-3-030-77489-9_7

Bayalieva-Jailobaeva

Kanykey

. 2014. “A New Look: Professionalization of NGOs in Kyrgyzstan.” Central Asian Survey, 33(3):360–374; doi: 10.1080/02634937.2014.953813

Beaulieu

Emily

and Hyde

Susan D.

. 2009. “In the Shadow of Democracy Promotion—Strategic Manipulation, International Observers, and Election Boycott.” Comparative Political Studies, 42(3):392–415.

Berger‐Kern

Nora

, Hetz

Fabian

, Wagner

Rebecca

, and Wolff

Jonas

. 2021. “Defending Civic Space: Successful Resistance Against NGO Laws in Kenya and Kyrgyzstan.” Global Policy, 12(S5):84–94; doi: 10.1111/1758-5899.12976

10.

Bermeo

Nancy

. 2016. “On Democratic Backsliding.” Journal of Democracy, 27(1):5–19.

11.

Birch

Sarah

and Van Ham

Carolien.

. 2017. “Getting Away with Foul Play? The Importance of Formal and Informal Oversight Institutions for Electoral Integrity.” European Journal of Political Research, 56(3):487–511; doi: 10.1111/1475-6765.12189

12.

Birru

Jalale Getachew

and Wolff

Jonas

. 2018. “Negotiating International Civil Society Support: The Case of Ethiopia’s 2009 Charities and Societies Proclamation.” Democratization Special Issue, 26(5):832–850.

13.

Bleck

Jaimie

and Logvinenko

Igor

. 2018. “Weak States and Uneven Pluralism: Lessons from Mali and Kyrgyzstan.” Democratization, 25(5):804–823; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2017.1422245

14.

Bourbeau

Philippe

. 2018. On Resilience—Genealogy, Logics, and World Politics. Cambridge; New York; Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.

15.

Brechenmacher

Saskia

. 2017. “ Civil Society Under Assault—Repression and Responses in Russia, Egypt, and Ethiopia.”

16.

Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung. 2016. “Dokumentation: Vorläufige Erklärung der Bewegung ‘Golos’ zu den Ergebnissen der Beobachtung der Dumawahlen.”. bpb.de. Available from: https://www.bpb.de/themen/europa/russland-analysen/nr-321/234717/dokumentation-vorlaeufige-erklaerung-der-bewegung-golos-zu-den-ergebnissen-der-beobachtung-der-dumawahlen/ [Last accessed: October 14, 2023].

17.

Burnell

Peter

and Calvert

Peter

. 1999. “The resilience of democracy: An introduction.” Democratization, 6(1):1–32.

18.

Bush

Sarah Sunn

. 2015. The Taming of Democracy Assistance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

19.

Bush

Sarah Sunn

and Prather

Lauren

. 2017. “The promise and limits of election observers in building election credibility.” The Journal of Politics, 79(3):921–935; doi: 10.1086/691055

20.

Buxton

Charles

. 2009. “NGO networks in Central Asia and Global Civil Society: Potentials and limitations.” Central Asian Survey, 28(1):43–58; doi: 10.1080/02634930902775129

21.

Buyse

Antoine

. 2018. “Squeezing civic space: Restrictions on civil society organizations and the linkages with human rights.” The International Journal of Human Rights, 22(8):966–988.

22.

Carothers

Thomas

and Brechenmacher

Saskia

. 2014. Closing Space—Democracy and Human Rights under Fire. Washington, D.C: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

23.

Chaudhry

Suparna

. 2016. “ The Assault on Democracy Assistance: Explaining State Repression of NGOs.” Dissertation. Yale University.

24.

Cheeseman

Nic

and Dodsworth

Susan

. 2023. “Defending civic space: When are campaigns against repressive laws successful?” The Journal of Development Studies, 59(5):619–636; doi: 10.1080/00220388.2022.2162882

25.

Cheeseman

Nic

and Klaas

Brian

. 2018. How To Rig An Election. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

26.

Christensen

Darin

and Weinstein

Jeremy M.

. 2013. “Defunding dissent: Restrictions on aid to NGO’s.” Journal of Democracy, 24(2):77–91.

27.

CIVICUS. 2018. “State of Civil Society Report 2018—the Year in Review: Top Ten Trends.”

28.

Collins

Kathleen

and Gambrel

Robert

. 2017. “Corruption and popular support for democracy and government in transitional contexts: The case of Kyrgyzstan.” Europe-Asia Studies, 69(8):1280–1309; doi: 10.1080/09668136.2017.1384449

29.

Common Cause. 2024. “Our Mission.” Oбщее Дело. Available from: http://commoncause.kg/en/about/mission [Last accessed: January 9, 2024].

30.

Coppedge

Michael

, Gerring

John

, Knutsen

Carl Henrik

, Lindberg

Staffan I

, Teorell

Jan

, Altman

David

, Bernhard

Michael

, et al. 2019. “V-Dem Dataset 2019.” doi:10.23696/VDEMCY19

31.

Danaher , Davies

Patrick Alan Andy

, George-Walker

Linda De

, Jones

Janice K

, Matthews

Karl J

, Midgley

Warren

, Arden

Catherine H

, and Baguley

Margaret

. 2014. “Resilience and Capacity-Building.” In Contemporary Capacity-Building in Educational Contexts, London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, 113–25; doi:10.1057/9781137374578_9

32.

Doolotkeldieva

Asel

. 2021. “The 2020 Violent Change in Government in Kyrgyzstan Amid the Covid-19 Pandemic: Three Distinct Stories in One.” In Between Peace and Conflict in the East and the West: Studies on Transformation and Development in the OSCE Region, ed. Mihr

Anja

. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 157–74; doi:10.1007/978-3-030-77489-9_8

33.

Dupuy

Kendra E.

, Ron

James

, and Prakash

Aseem

. 2015. “Who survived? Ethiopia’s regulatory crackdown on foreign-funded NGOs.” Review of International Political Economy, 22(2):419–456.

34.

Dupuy

Kendra

, Ron

James

, and Prakash

Aseem

. 2016. “Hands Off My Regime! Governments’ restrictions on foreign aid to non-governmental organizations in poor and middle-income countries.”. World Development: 299–311.

35.

Engvall

Johan

. 2014. “Why are public offices sold in Kyrgyzstan?” Post-Soviet Affairs, 30(1):67–85; doi: 10.1080/1060586X.2013.818785

36.

Engvall

Johan

. 2018. “From monopoly to competition.” Problems of Post-Communism, 65(4):271–283; doi: 10.1080/10758216.2016.1276399

37.

Engvall

Johan

. 2022. Between Bandits and Bureaucrats: 30 Years of Parliamentary Development in Kyrgyzstan. Central Asia-Caucasus Institute & Silk Road Studies Program. Available from: https://silkroadstudies.org/publications/silkroad-papers-and-monographs/item/13434-between-bandits-and-bureaucrats-30-years-of-parliamentary-development-in-kyrgyzstan.html [Last accessed: June 11, 2023].

38.

frontlinedefenders. 2023. “Golos—Movement for Defence of Voters’ Rights ‘Golos.’” Front Line Defenders. Available from: https://www.frontlinedefenders.org/en/organization/golos [Last accessed: December 29, 2023].

39.

Fukuyama

Francis

. 2001. “Social capital, civil society and development.” Third World Quarterly, 22(1):7–20.

40.

Gamboa

Laura

. 2022. Resisting Backsliding: Opposition Strategies against the Erosion of Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; doi:10.1017/9781009164085

41.

Gemzell

Martin

. 2017. “Cambodia: Shrinking Spaces versus Empowerment of Communities—Analysis of Framework Conditions & Options for Strengthening Civil Society, Democracy & Human Rights in Cambodia.”

42.

Giffen

Janice

, Earle

Lucy

, and Buxton

Charles

. 2005. “ The Development of Civil Society in Central Asia.”: 143.

43.

Grömping

Max

. 2017a. “Domestic Election Monitoring and Advocacy: An Emerging Research Agenda.” Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 35(4):407–423; doi: 10.1080/18918131.2017.1401776

44.

Grömping

Max

. 2017b. “Domestic Monitors.” In Election Watchdogs—Transparency, Accountability and Integrity, eds. Norris

Pippa

and Nai

Alessandro

. New York: Oxford University Press.

45.

Grömping

Max

. 2021. “Agents of resistance and revival? Local election monitors and democratic fortunes in Asia.” Democratization, 28(1):103–123; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2020.1845150

46.

Haggard

Stephan

and Kaufman

Robert R

. 2021. “ BACKSLIDING—Democratic Regress in the Contemporary World.”

47.

Hellmeier

Sebastian

and Bernhard

Michael

. 2022., and “Mass Mobilization and Regime Change. Evidence From a New Measure of Mobilization for Democracy and Autocracy From 1900 to 2020”. Available from: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=4019439 [Last accessed: January 12, 2024].

48.

Higashijima

Masaaki

. 2022. The Dictator’s Dilemma at the Ballot Box. University of Michigan Press. Available from: https://press.umich.edu/Books/T/The-Dictator-s-Dilemma-at-the-Ballot-Box2 [Last accessed: December 19, 2023].

49.

Hug

Adam

. 2021. Introduction: Examining the Pressure on Human Rights in Kyrgyzstan. Foreign Policy Centre. Available from: https://fpc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Retreating-Rights-Examining-the-pressure-on-human-rights-in-Kyrgyzstan.pdf [Last accessed: March 1, 2021].

50.

Hülsemann

Laura

and Chiappa

Claudia

. 2023., and “Russia Arrests Head of Election Watchdog, Shuts Human Rights Group.”. POLITICO. Available from: https://www.politico.eu/article/russia-grigory-melkonyants-golos-election-watchdog/ [Last accessed: October 14, 2023].

51.

Human Rights Watch. 2004. “E.U.-Kazakhstan and E.U.-Kyrgyzstan Cooperation Council Meetings.”. Human Rights Watch. Available from: https://www.hrw.org/news/2004/07/05/eu-kazakhstan-and-eu-kyrgyzstan-cooperation-council-meetings [Last accessed: June 3, 2023].

52.

Human Rights Watch. 2006. “Kyrgyzstan: Assault on Organized Crime Critic.”. Human Rights Watch. Available from: https://www.hrw.org/news/2006/04/13/kyrgyzstan-assault-organized-crime-critic (August 25, 2022).

53.

Human Rights Watch. 2009. “Letter to President Bakiev Regarding Dra1 Ammendments to Laws Regulating Nongovernmental Organizations.”

54.

Human Rights Watch. 2019. “World Report 2019—Events of 2018.” Available from: www.hrw.org

55.

Human Rights Watch. 2020. “Kyrgyzstan: Bad Faith Efforts to Overhaul Constitution.”. Human Rights Watch. Available from: https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/11/21/kyrgyzstan-bad-faith-efforts-overhaul-constitution [Last accessed: June 11, 2023].

56.

Hyde

Susan D

. 2023. “International Actors and Domestic Politics in an Era of Global Challenges to Democracy” eds. Bartels

Larry M

, Daxecker

Ursula E

, HYDE

SUSAN D

, Lindberg

Staffan I

, and Nooruddin

Irfan

. International Studies Review, 25(2): 11–15.

57.

Hyde

Susan D

and Marinov

Nikolay

. 2012. “Which elections can be lost?” Political Analysis, 20(2):191–210; doi: 10.1093/pan/mpr040

58.

ICNL. 2021. Analysis of the Draft Law of the Kyrgyz Republic on Amendments to the Laws of the Kyrgyz Republic on Noncommercial Organizations and on State Registration of Legal Entities. Available from: https://www.icnl.org/resources/civic-freedom-monitor/kyrgyz [Last accessed: March 11, 2021].

59.

IPHR and LPH. 2020. Key Trends in the Protection of Fundamental Rights in Kyrgyzstan—Briefing Paper for EU—Kyrgyzstan Human Rights Dialogue. International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR)/Legal Prosperity Foundation (LPF).

60.

Iphronline. 2021. “Kyrgyzstan: Leading Independent Media Organisation Denied Accreditation to Monitor Parliamentary Elections.”. IPHR. Available from: https://www.iphronline.org/kyrgyzstan-kloop-denied-accreditation-to-monitor-elections.html (January 9, 2024).

61.

Ismailbekova

Aksana

. 2018. “Informal Governance and Corruption—Transcending the Principle Agent and Collective Action Paradigms. Kyrgyzstan Country Report. Part 1 Macro Level.” Available from: https://baselgovernance.org/sites/default/files/2019-04/kyrgyzstan.informalgovernance.country_report.part_1_macro_level_.pdf

62.

Jailobaeva

Kanykey

. 2011. “The Return of the State to Development: The State, Donors, and NGOs in Post-Soviet Kyrgyzstan.” PhD Dissertation. University of Edinburgh.

63.

Juraev

Shairbek

. 2008. “Kyrgyz Democracy? The Tulip Revolution and Beyond.” Central Asian Survey, 27(3–4):253–264; doi: 10.1080/02634930802536464

64.

Kakachia

Kornely

, Legucka

Agnieszka

, and Lebanidze

Bidzina

. 2021. “Can the EU’s new global strategy make a difference? Strengthening resilience in the eastern partnership countries.” Democratization, 28(7):1338–1356; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2021.1918110

65.

Keck

Markus

and Sakdapolrak

Patrick

. 2013. “What Is social resilience? Lessons learned and ways forward.” Erdkunde, 67(1):5–19; doi: 10.3112/erdkunde.2013.01.02

66.

Kelley

Judith G

. 2012. Monitoring Democracy: When International Election Observation Works, and Why It Often Fails. Princeton, N.J: Princeton University Press.

67.

King

Gary

, Keohane

Robert O

, and Verba

Sidney

. 1994. Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research. Princeton, N.J: Princeton University Press.

68.

Kuchukeeva

Altinay

and O’Loughlin

John

. 2003. “Civic engagement and democratic consolidation in Kyrgyzstan.” Eurasian Geography and Economics, 44(8):557–587; doi: 10.2747/1538-7216.44.8.557

69.

Kuckartz

Udo

. 2016. Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Methoden, Praxis, Computerunterstützung., 3. Auflage. Weinheim und Basel: Beltz Juventa.

70.

Lean

Sharon F

. 2007. “Democracy assistance to domestic election monitoring organizations: Conditions for success.” Democratization, 14(2):289–312; doi: 10.1080/13510340701245835

71.

Leininger

Julia

. 2022. International democracy promotion in times of autocratization: From supporting to protecting democracy. German Institute of Development and Sustainability (IDOS). Available from: https://www.idos-research.de/discussion-paper/article/international-democracy-promotion-in-times-of-autocratization-from-supporting-to-protecting-democracy/ [Last accessed: October 5, 2023].

72.

Lempp

Jakob

and Wolters

Alexander

. 2020. “Das politische System Kirgistans.” In Die politischen Systeme Zentralasiens: Interner Wandel, externe Akteure, regionale Kooperation, eds. Lempp

Jakob

, Mayer

Sebastian

, and Brand

Alexander

. Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien, 75–90. doi: 10.1007/978-3-658-31633-4_5

73.

Levitsky

Steven

and Ziblatt

Daniel

. 2018. How Democracies Die—What History Reveals About Our Future. New York: Penguin Books.

74.

Lührmann

Anna

and Lindberg

Staffan I.

. 2019. “A third wave of autocratization is here: What is new about it?” Democratization, 26(7):1095–1113; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2019.1582029

75.

Macdonald

Robert

and Molony

Thomas

. 2023. “Can domestic observers serve as impartial arbiters?: Evidence from Zambia’s 2021 elections.” Democratization, 30(4):635–653; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2023.2173177

76.

Mahoney

James

and Goertz

Gary

. 2006. “A tale of two cultures: Contrasting quantitative and qualitative research.” Political Analysis, 14(3):227–249.

77.

Marat

Erica

. 2006. “The State-Crime Nexus in Central Asia: State Weakness, Organized Crime, and Corruption in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan.”

78.

Merkel

Wolfgang

and Lührmann

Anna

. 2021. “Resilience of democracies: Responses to illiberal and authoritarian challenges.” Democratization, 28(5):869–884; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2021.1928081

79.

Mey

Günter

and Mruck

Katja

. 2007. “Qualitative Interviews.” In Qualitative Marktforschung in Theorie und Praxis: Grundlagen, Methoden und Anwendungen, eds. Naderer

Gabriele

and Balzer

Eva

. Wiesbaden: Gabler, 249–78.

80.

NDI. 2005. KYRGYZSTAN: CIVIC PARTICIPATION AND PARLIAMENTARY DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM. USAID Cooperative Agreement No. 116-0007-A-00-9014-00. Project Dates: July 25, 1999 to December 31, 2004. National Democratic Institute. Available from: https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACF170.pdf [Last accessed: December 19, 2022].

81.

Nevitte

Neil

and Canton

Santiago A.

. 1997. “The Rise of Election Monitoring: The Role of Domestic Observers.” Journal of Democracy, 8(3):47–61; doi: 10.1353/jod.1997.0046

82.

Norris

Pippa

. 2015. Why Elections Fail. New York: Cambridge University Press.

83.

O’Grady

Paul

, Lopez-Pintor

Rafael

, and Stevens

Marc

. 2004. Promoting and Defending Democracy: The Work of Domestic Election Observer Groups around the World. London: ERIS.

84.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2000. Kyrgyz Republic Parliamentary Elections 20 February & 12 March 2000— OSCE/ODIHR Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR.

85.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2001. Kyrgyz Republic Presidential Elections 29 October 2000—OSCE/ODIHR FINAL REPORT. OSCE/ODIHR.

86.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2005a. Kyrgyz Republic Presidential Election 10 July 2005—OSCE/ODIHR Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/b/6/17659.pdf ([Last accessed: May 21, 2023].

87.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2005b. Kyrgyzstan, Parliamentary Elections 27 February and 13 March 2005—OSCE/ODIHR Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR.

88.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2009. Kyrgyz Republic Presidential Elections 23 July 2009—OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/f/5/39923.pdf (March 22, 2022).

89.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2010. The Kyrgyz Republic Constitutional Referendum 27 June 2010—OSCE/ODIHR Limited Referendum Observation Mission Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/0/3/70936.pdf [Last accessed: May 22, 2023].

90.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2012. Kyrgyz Republic Presidential Election 30 October 2011—OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/7/b/86926.pdf

91.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2016. Kyrgyz Republic Parliamentary Elections 4 October 2015—OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/a/c/219186.pdf [Last accessed: August 26, 2022].

92.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2018. “Kyrgyzstan, Presidential Election, 15 October 2017: Final Report.” Available from: https://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/kyrgyzstan/374740 [Last accessed: March 31, 2021].

93.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2018. Kyrgyz Republic Presidential Election 15 October 2017—OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation Mission Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/7/7/374740.pdf

94.

OSCE/ODIHR. 2022. The Kyrgyz Republic Parliamentary Elections 28 November 2021—OSCE/ODIHR Final Report. OSCE/ODIHR. Available from: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/6/5/505840_0.pdf [Last accessed: June 11, 2023].

95.

Oxfam. 2018. SPACE TO BE HEARD—Mobilizing the Power of People to Reshape Civic Space. Oxfam. Oxfam Briefing Note.

96.

Petric . Boris . 2012. “Electoral Observation and NGO Coalitions in Kyrgyzstan.” In Democracy at Large: NGOs, Political Foundations, Think Tanks and International Organizations, The Sciences Po Series in International Relations and Political Economy, ed. Petric

Boris

. New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, 49–74. doi: 10.1057/9781137032768_3

97.

Pierobon

Chiara

. 2018. “The Development of Civil Society in Post-Soviet Kyrgyzstan: An Analysis of the National and International Context.” Annali Di Ca’ Foscari. Serie Orientale, 54(1); doi: 10.30687/AnnOr/2385-3042/2018/01/006

98.

Plattner

Marc F

. 2015. “Is Democracy in Decline?” Journal of Democracy, 26(1):5–10.

99.

Podolskaya

Darya

. 2014. “Coalition ‘For Democracy and Civil Society’ Reappoints Its Head Dinara Oshurakhunova.”. 24.kg. Available from: https://24.kg/archive/en/community/173815-news24.html/ [Last accessed: May 8, 2023].

100.

Poppe

Annika Elena

and Wolff

Jonas

. 2015. “From Closing Space to Contested Spaces. Re-Assessing Current Conflicts over International Civil Society Support.”

101.

Putnam

Robert D

. 1993. Making Democracy Work—Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Chichester, West Sussex: Princeton University Press.

102.

Putz

Catherine

. 2015. “Kyrgyzstan Set to Use Biometric Registration in Next Election.”. the Diplomat. Available from: https://thediplomat.com/2015/08/kyrgyzstan-set-to-use-biometric-registration-in-next-election/ [Last accessed: August 29, 2022].

103.

Reznikova

Ekaterina

and Irgebaeva

Aidai

. 2022., and “Analysis: How Kyrgyzstan is Losing its Transparency.”. KLOOP.KG—Новости Кыргызстана. Available from: https://kloop.kg/blog/2022/08/23/analysis-how-kyrgyzstan-is-losing-its-transparency/ [Last accessed: June 24, 2023].

104.

Roberts

Sean

. 2001. “Evaluation of the National Democratic Institute (NDI) in Kyrgyzstan February 23-March 10, 2001.” doi: 10.13140/RG.2.1.3782.3527

105.

Rohlfing

Ingo

. 2012. Case Studies and Causal Inference: An Integrative Framework. 1st ed. 2012 edition. Basingstoke New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

106.

Rutzen

Douglas

. 2015. “Civil Society under assault.” Journal of Democracy, 26(4):28–39; doi: 10.1353/jod.2015.0071

107.

Sander

Alena

. 2022. “Rethinking shrinking civic space in the global souths—How development donors contribute to the restriction of civil society in Jordan.” Democratization, 30(1):22–39; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2022.2096595

108.

Schock

Kurt.

Unarmed InsurrectionsPeople Power Movements In Nondemocracies, University of Minnesota Press, Minnesota. 2004.

109.

Schock

Kurt

. 2013. “The Practice and Study of Civil Resistance.” Journal of Peace Research, 50(3):277–290.

110.

Schuetze

Benjamin

. 2019. Promoting Democracy, Reinforcing Authoritarianism—US and European Policy in Jordan. Cambridge University Press.

111.

Selçuk

Orçun

and Hekimci

Dilara

. 2020. “The rise of the democracy—authoritarianism cleavage and opposition coordination in Turkey (2014–2019).” Democratization, 27(8):1496–1514; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2020.1803841

112.

Sherrieb

Kathleen

, Norris

Fran H.

, and Galea

Sandro

. 2010. “Measuring capacities for community resilience.” Social Indicators Research, 99(2):227–247; doi: 10.1007/s11205-010-9576-9

113.

Shishkaraeva

Elmira

, Alenkina

Natalia

, Alymbaeva

Aida

, Alymkulova

Anara

, Satarov

Nurdin

, Stakeeva

Bermet

, and Dronov

Eugene

. 2006. Review of the History of Establishment and Development of the NGO Sector in the Kyrgyz Republic. Bischkek: the Assiociation of Civil Society Support Centers.

114.

Smidt

Hannah

. 2018. Shrinking Civic Space in Africa: When Government Crack Down on Civil Society. GIGA German Institute of Global and Area Studies—Leibniz-Institut für Globale und Regionale Studien. GIGA Focus Afric.

115.

Somer

Murat

, McCoy

Jennifer L.

, and Luke

Russell E.

. 2021. “Pernicious polarization, autocratization and opposition strategies.” Democratization, 28(5):929–948; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2020.1865316

116.

Stollenwerk

Eric

, Börzel

Tanja A.

, and Risse

Thomas

. 2021. “Theorizing resilience-building in the EU’s neighbourhood: Introduction to the special issue.” Democratization, 28(7):1219–1238; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2021.1957839

117.

Temirkulov

Azamat

. 2010. “Kyrgyz ‘Revolutions’ in 2005 and 2010: Comparative analysis of mass mobilization.” Nationalities Papers, 38(5):589–600; doi: 10.1080/00905992.2010.503617

118.

The Coalition. 2011. Preliminary Statement On the Conduct of the October 30 Presidential Election in the Kyrgyz Republic October 31, 2011. The Coalition for Democracy and Human Rights. Available from: https://www.ndi.org/sites/default/files/Coalition-Kyrgyzstan-Election-Day-2011-Preliminary-Statement.pdf

119.

Tomini

Luca

, Gibril

Suzan

, and Bochev

Venelin

. 2023. “Standing up against autocratization across political regimes: A comparative analysis of resistance actors and strategies.” Democratization, 30(1):119–138; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2022.2115480

120.

Transparency International. 2023. “Kyrgyzstan/Country Data.”. Transparency.org. Available from: https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/kyrgyzstan (January 5, 2024).

121.

Truong

Nhu

, Ong

Elvin

, and Shum

Maggie

. 2024. “Agents of resistance: Resolve and repertoires against autocratization in Asia.” Democratization, 31(3):513–530; doi: 10.1080/13510347.2024.2318384

122.

UNDP. 2014. Democratic Governance: Promoting Gender Equality in Electoral Assistance: Lessons Learned in Comparative Perspective Country Report for Kyrgyzstan. United Nation Development Programme.

123.

USAID. 2001. “The 2001 NGO Sustainability Index For Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia.” Available from: https://storage.googleapis.com/cso-si-dashboard.appspot.com/Reports/CSOSI-Europe_and_Eurasia-2001.pdf (May 7, 2023).

124.

USAID. 2005. “The 2005 NGO Sustainability Index for Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia.”: 234.

125.

USAID. 2014. “The 2013 CSO Sustainability Index for Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia.” Available from: https://storage.googleapis.com/cso-si-dashboard.appspot.com/Reports/CSOSI-Europe_and_Eurasia-2013.pdf (May 7, 2023).

126.

USAID. 2015. “The 2014 CSO Sustainability Index for Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia.”

127.

USAID. 2018. Democracy, Human Rights, and Governance Assessment of the Kyrgyz Republic. August 2018 [Revised Draft]. USAID. Available from: https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00TDB1.pdf

128.

USAID. 2019. “Facilitating Parliament, Voter Education and Election Observation | Fact Sheet | Kyrgyz Republic.”. U.S. Agency for International Development. Available from: https://www.usaid.gov/kyrgyz-republic/fact-sheet/facilitating-parliament-voter-education-and-election-observation [Last accessed: June 11, 2023].

129.

USAID. 2021. “Nonpartisan Domestic Observation of Elections | Fact Sheet | Kyrgyz Republic.”. U.S. Agency for International Development. Available from: https://www.usaid.gov/kyrgyz-republic/fact-sheet/nonpartisan-domestic-observation-elections (June 11, 2023).

130.

van der Borgh

Chris

and Terwindt

Carolijn

. 2012. “Shrinking Operational Space of NGOs—a Framework of Analysis.” Development in Practice, 22(8):1065–1081; doi: 10.1080/09614524.2012.714745

131.

Wagner

Rebecca

. 2021. “At a Crossroads. Kyrgyzstan after the Recent Elections.”.

132.

Wagner

Rebecca

and Jahn

Philipp C

. 2022., and “Wohin blickt Bischkek?” Available from: https://magazin.zenith.me/de/politik/kurz-erklaert-parlamentswahlen-kirgistan [Last accessed: March 22, 2022].

133.

Wood

Colleen

. 2023. “Between a Rock and a Hard Place: How Kazakhstan’s Civil Society Navigates Precarity.” International Labor and Working-Class History, 103: 44–61; doi:10.1017/S0147547923000157

134.

Youngs

Richard

. 2019. Civic Activism Unleashed: New Hope or False Dawn for Democracy?. New York: Oxford University Press.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.01 MB

0.00 MB

Electoral Resilience of Citizen Election Observers: A Case Study of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References

Supplementary Material