Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2015-04
Risk of Behaviors Associated with Lethal Violence and Functional Outcomes for Abused Women Who Do and Do Not Return to the Abuser Following a Community-Based Intervention
To determine the differential risk of behaviors associated with lethal violence and functioning outcomes for abused women with children who received an intervention of shelter or justice services and return to the abuser were compared with women who did not return.
Methods:
The study was carried out using a matched-pair analysis of 152 women. Measures of risk of behaviors associated with lethal violence, type, and severity of abuse, and poor mental health symptoms were measured every 4 months for 24 months.
Results:
Irrespective of service used, women returning to the abuser reported significantly (p<0.001) more risk of behaviors associated with lethal violence compared to women who did not return. Additionally, severity of physical abuse was significantly higher (p<0.01) for women returning to the abuser who had been in a shelter but not for women who received a protection order. Similarly, levels of depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, and anxiety were significantly higher (p<0.01) for sheltered women who returned to the abuser but not for women using a protection order who returned.
Conclusions:
Risk of behaviors associated with lethal violence increases when abused women return to live with the abuser. Abused women should be informed of the heightened risk and greater probability for poor mental health.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
World Health Organization (WHO). Global and regional estimates of violence against women: Prevalence and health effects of intimate partner violence and non-partner sexual violence. Geneva: WHO, 2013.
2.
CampbellJC. Health consequences of intimate partner violence. Lancet, 2002; 359:1331–1336.
3.
BreidingMJ, BlackMC, RyanGW. Chronic disease and health risk behaviors associated with intimate partner violence—18 US states/territories, 2005. Ann Epidemiol, 2008; 18:538–544.
4.
EllsbergM, JansenHA, HeiseL, WattsCH, Garcia-MorenoC. Intimate partner violence and women's physical and mental health in the WHO multi-country study on women's health and domestic violence: An observational study. Lancet, 2008; 371:1165–1172.
5.
SymesL, McFarlaneJ, NavaA, GilroyH, MaddouxJ. Association of pain severity and pain interference with abuse experiences and mental health symptoms among 300 mothers: Baseline data analysis for a seven-year prospective study. Issues Mental Health Nurs, 2013; 34:2–16.
6.
BonomiAE, AndersonML, ReidRJ, RivaraFP, CarrellD, ThompsonRS. Medical and psychosocial diagnoses in women with a history of intimate partner violence. Arch Internal Med, 2009; 169:1692–1697.
7.
ShahPS, ShahJS. Maternal exposure to domestic violence and pregnancy and birth outcomes: A systemic review and meta-analyses. J Womens Health, 2010; 19:2017–2031.
8.
SilvermanJG, DeckerMR, ReedE, RajA. Intimate partner violence victimization prior to and during pregnancy among women residing in 26 U.S. states: Association with maternal and neonatal health. Am J Obstet Gynecol, 2006; 195:140–148.
9.
LipskyS, HoltVL, EasterlingTR, CritchlowCW. Impact of police-reported intimate partner violence during pregnancy on birth outcomes. Obstet Gynecol, 2003; 102:557–564.
10.
El KadyD, GilbertWM, XingG, SmithLH. Maternal and neonatal outcomes of assaults during pregnnacy. Obstet Gynecol, 2005; 105:357–363.
11.
McFarlaneJ, SoekenK. Weight Pattern of infants, age birth to 12 months, born to abused women. Pediatr Nurs, 1999; 25:19–23.
12.
McFarlaneJ, CampbellJ, SharpsP, WatsonK. Abuse during pregnancy and femicide: Urgent implications for women's health. Obstet Gynecol, 2002; 100:27–36.
13.
McFarlaneJ, MaddouxJ, CesarioS, et al.Abuse during pregnancy impacts maternal child safety and functioning for 24-Months after delivery. Obstet Gynecol, 2014; 123: 839–847.
14.
FredlandN, McFarlaneJ, MaddouxJ, BinderB, MontalvoN. Behavioral functioning of children of abused women: New knowledge for clinical practice. Issues Compr Pediatr Nurs, 2014; 37:212–234.
15.
Graham-BermannSA, CastorLE, MillerLE, HowellKH. The impact of intimate partner violence and additional traumatic events on trauma symptoms and PTSD in preschool-aged children. J Traumatic Stress, 2012; 25:1–8.
16.
Bayarri FernàndezE, EzpeletaL, GraneroR, de la OsaN, DomènechJ M. Degree of exposure to domestic violence, psychopathology, and functional impairment in children and adolescents. J Interpers Violence, 2011; 26:1215–1231.
17.
KernicMA, HoltVL, WolfME, McKnightB, HuebnerCE, RivaraFP. Academic and school health issues among children exposed to maternal intimate partner abuse. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, 2002; 156:549–555.
18.
KitzmannKM, GaylordNK, HoltAR, KennyED. Child witness to domestic violence: A meta-analytic review. J Consult Clin Psychol, 2003; 71:339–352.
19.
FuscoRA, FantuzzoJW. Relationship between type of trauma exposure and posttraumatic stress disorder among urban children and adolescents. J Interpers Violence, 2009; 31:249–256.
20.
BinderB, McFarlaneJ, MaddouxJ, NavaA, Gilroy. Children in distress: Functioning of youngsters of abused women and implications for child maltreatment prevention. J Child Care Pract, 2013; 19:237–252.
21.
WolfeDA, CrooksCV, LeeV, McIntyre-SmithA, JaffePJ. The effects of children's exposure to domestic violence: A meta-analysis and critique. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev, 2003; 6:171–187.
22.
BlairF, McFarlaneJ, NavaA, GilroyH, MaddouxJ. Children who witness violence against their mothers and affects on their behavior: Baseline data analysis for a 7-year study. Pediatr Nurs. (in press).
23.
McFarlaneJ, SymesL, BinderB, MaddouxJ, PaulsonR. Maternal-child dyads of functioning: The intergenerational impact of violence against women on children. Matern Child Health J, 2014; 18:2236–2243.
24.
Office on Women's Health. Safety planning for abusive situations. Available at: http://womenshealth.gov/violence-against-women/get-help-for-violence/safety-planning-for-abusive-situations.htmlWashington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2011. Accessed September1, 2014.
25.
WHO, Pan American Health Organization. Understanding and addressing violence against women: Femicide. WHO technical documents, 2012. Available at: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/77421/1/WHO_RHR_12.38_eng.pdf Accessed September11, 2014.
26.
Institute of Medicine. Clinical preventive services for women: Closing the gaps. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2013.
27.
MoyerVA. Screening for intimate partner violence and abuse of elderly and vulnerable adults: A U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommendation statement. Ann Intern MedJanuary2013.
28.
AndersonDK, SaundersDG. Leaving an abusive partner: An empirical review of predictors, the process of leaving, and psychological well-being. Trauma Violence Abuse, 2003; 4:163–191.
29.
KoepsellJK, KernicMA, HoltVL. Factors that influence battered women to leave. Violence Vict, 2006; 21:131–147.
30.
SchutteNS, MalouffJM, DoyleJS. The relationship between characteristics of the victim, persuasive techniques of the batterer, and returning to a battering relationship. J Soc Psychol, 1988; 128:605–610.
31.
KrishnanSP, HilbertJC, McNeilK, NewmanI. From respite to transition: Women's use of domestic shelters in rural New Mexico. J Fam Violence, 2004; 19:165–173.
GordonKC, BurtonS, PorterL. Predicting the intentions of women in domestic violence shelter to return to partners: Does forgiveness play a role?. J Fam Psychol, 2004; 18:331–338.
34.
BonomiAE, GangammaR, LockeC, KatafiaszH, MartinD. “Meet me at the hill where we used to park:” Processes associated with victim recantation. Soc Sci Med, 2011; 73:1054–1061.
35.
GoodmanLA, BennettL, DuttonMA. Obstacles to domestic violence victims' cooperation with the criminal prosecution of their abusers: The role of social support. Violence Vict, 1999; 14:427–444.
36.
CampbellJC. Assessing dangerousness: Violence by sexual offenders, batters, and child abusers. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1995.
37.
BybeeD, Sullivan CM. Predicting re-victimization of battered women 3 years after exiting a shelter program. Am J Community Psychol, 2005; 36:85–96.
38.
BenitezCT, McNielDE, BinderRL. Do protection orders protect?. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2010; 8:376–385.
39.
HoltVL, KernicMA, WolfME, RivaraFP. Do Protection Orders Affect the Likelihood of Future Partner Violence and Injury?. Am J Prevent Med, 2003; 24:16–21.
40.
HoltVL, KernicMA, LumleyT, WolfME, RivaraFP. Civil protection orders and risk of subsequent police-reported violence. JAMA, 2002; 288:589–594.
41.
McFarlaneJ, MalechaA, GistJ, et al.Protection orders and intimate partner violence: An 18-month study of 150 Black, Hispanic, and White women. Am J Public Health, 2004; 94:613–618.
42.
CampbellJC. Assessment of risk of homicide for battered women. Adv Nurs Sci, 1986; 8:36–51.
43.
CampbellR, SullivanCM, DavidsonWS. Women who use domestic violence shelters: Changes in depression over time. Psychol Women Q, 1995; 19:237–255.
44.
MarshallL. Development of the severity of violence against women scales. J Fam Violence, 1992; 7:103–121.
BreslauN, PetersonEL, KesslerRC, SchultzLR. Short screening scale for DSM-IV posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry, 1999; 156:908–911.
49.
BohnertKM, BreslauN. Assessing the performance of the short screening scale for post-traumatic stress disorder in a large nationally-representative survey. Int J Methods Psychiatr Res, 2011; 20, e1–e5.
50.
AchenbachTM, RescorlaLA. Manual for the ASEBA preschool forms and profiles. Burlington, VT: University of Vermont Department of Psychiatry, 2000.
51.
AchenbachTM, RescorlaLA. Manual for the ASEBA school-age forms and profiles. Burlington, VT: University of Vermont Department of Psychiatry, 2001.
52.
McFarlaneJ, NavaA, GilroyH, PaulsonR, MaddouxJ. Testing two global models to prevent violence against women and children: Methods and policy implications for a seven-year prospective study. Issues Ment Health Nurs, 2012; 33:871–881.
53.
Ford-GilboeM, WuestJ, VarcoeC, et al.Modelling the effects of intimate partner violence and access to resources on women's health in the early years after leaving an abusive partner. Soc Sci Med., 2009; 68:1021–1029.
54.
CattaneoLB, BellME, GoodmanLA, DuttonMA. Intimate partner violence victims' accuracy in assessing their risk of re-abuse. J Fam Violence, 2007; 22:429–440.
55.
CampbellJC. Helping women understand their risk in situations of intimate partner violence. J Interpers Violence, 2004; 19:1464–1477.
56.
SullivanCM, BastaJ, TanC, DavidsonI, WilliamS. After the crisis: A needs assessment of women leaving a domestic violence shelter. Violence Vict, 1992; 7:267–275.
57.
SullivanCM, BaptistaI, O'HalloranS, OkrojL, MortonS, StewartC. Evaluating the effectiveness of women's refuges: A multi-country approach to model development. Int J Comp Appl Crim Justice, 2008; 32:291–308.
58.
LyonE, LaneS, MenardA. Meeting survivors' needs: A multi-state study of domestic violence shelter experiences. Final report prepared for the U.S. National Institute of Justice. Harrisburg, PA: National Resource Center on Domestic Violence, 2008.
