This paper sketches out the contours of the philosopher G W F Hegel's geographical thought. Until now, geographers have shown little interest in Hegel's geographical writing. He has figured minimally in histories of geography, and critical geographers who have engaged with Hegel have done so indirectly, either through Karl Marx's work or through Marxist and postcolonial scholars' readings of Hegel. This paper offers a more direct reading. It begins from an understanding of geographical thought as both an intellectual and a practical endeavor with its own distinct historical geographies. It examines Hegel's concepts of ‘nature’ (Natur) and ‘space’ (Raum); his understanding of geography's relationship to history and anthropology; his relationship to Carl Ritter and Alexander von Humboldt; and the significance of ‘territory’ in his political philosophy. It highlights the ambiguity that characterized Hegel's thinking about geography, especially in his discussion of climate's influence on humans. It also challenges Henri Lefebvre's reading of Hegel's view on the state's relationship to territory. Finally, it suggests that Hegel's conceptions of nature, space, and geography mattered not only for his philosophies of history, nature, and subjective spirit, but for his understanding of modernity's geographies as well.
AnunchinV A, 1977 [1960] Theoretical Problems in Geography translated FuchsR JDemkoG J (Ohio State University Press, Columbus, OH)
2.
Aristotle, 1941The Basic Works of Aristotle Ed. McKeonRichard (Random House, New York)
3.
AvineriS, 1972Hegel's Theory of the Modern State (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
4.
BeckH, 1973Geographie: Europäische Entwicklung in Texten und Erläuterungen (K Alber, Freiburg, Germany)
5.
BernasconiR, 1998, “Hegel at the court of Ashanti”, in Hegel after Derrida Ed. BarnettS (Routledge, London) pp 41–63
6.
BernasconiR, 2000, “With what must the philosophy of history begin? On the racial basis of Hegel's Eurocentrism”Nineteenth-Century Contexts22171–201
7.
BernasconiR, 2003, “Hegel's racism: A reply to McCarney”Radical Philosophy11932–37
8.
BernasconiR, 2011, “‘The ruling categories of the world’: The trinity in Hegel's philosophy of history and the rise and fall of peoples”, in A Companion to Hegel, Ed. HoulgateSBaurM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 315–331
9.
BonettoS, 2006, “Race and racism in Hegel—an analysis”Minerva: An Internet Journal of Philosophy1035–64
10.
Buck-MorssS, 2000, “Hegel and Haiti”Critical Inquiry26821–865
11.
Buck-MorssS, 2009Hegel, Haiti and Universal History (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
12.
BurgessR, 1978, “The concept of nature in geography and Marxism”Antipode101–11
13.
CaseyE S, 1997The Fate of Place: A Philosophical History (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
14.
CastreeN, 1996, “Birds, mice and geography: Marxisms and dialectics”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series21342–362
15.
CollingeC, 2008, “Positions without negations? Dialectical reason and the contingencies of space”Environment and Planning A402613–2622
16.
DickinsonR E, 1969The Makers of Modern Geography (Routledge, London)
17.
DriverF, 1992, “Geography's empire: Histories of geographical knowledge”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1023–40
18.
EldenS, 2004Understanding Henri Lefebvre: Theory and the Possible (Continuum, London)
19.
EldenS, 2008, “Dialectics and the measure of the world”Environment and Planning A402641–2651
20.
EldenS, 2009, “Reassessing Kant's geography”Journal of Historical Geography353–25
21.
EldenS, 2013The Birth of Territory (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
GerbiA, 2010 [1955] The Dispute of the New World: The History of a Polemic, 1750–1900 translated by MoyleJeremy (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
24.
GidwaniV, 2008, “The subaltern moment in Hegel's dialectic”Environment and Planning A402578–2587
25.
GlackenC J, 1967Traces on the Rhodian Shore: Nature and Culture in Western Thought from Ancient Times to the End of the Eighteenth Century (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
GregoryD, 1998, “Power, knowledge and geography”Geographische Zeitschrift8670–93
28.
GünzelS, 2002, “Philosophische Geographien: Nietzsche und Hegel”, in Hegel-Jahrbuch, Phänomenologie des Geistes, 2. Teil Eds ArndtABalKOttmannH (Akademie Verlag, Berlin) pp 294–302
29.
HartshorneR, 1939The Nature of Geography: A Critical Survey of Current Thought in the Light of the Past (American Association of Geographers, Lancaster, PA)
30.
HarveyD, 1981, “The spatial fix: Hegel, von Thünen, Marx”Antipode131–12
31.
HarveyD, 1996Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference (Blackwell, Oxford)
32.
HarveyD, 1999, “On fatal flaws and distractions”Progress in Human Geography23557–566
33.
HarveyD, 2006 [1982] The Limits to Capital (Verso, London)
34.
HegelG W F, 1955Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Weltgeschichte, Bd: I, Die Vernunft in der Geschichte Ed. HoffmeisterJ (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
35.
HegelG W F, 1961Briefe von und an Hegel, 4 Bde Ed. HoffmeisterJ (Felix Meiner, Hamburg) translated in 1984 in part as Hegel: The Letters translated by ButlerCSeilerC (Indiana University Press, Bloomington)
36.
HegelG W F, 1970aPhilosophy of Nature3 volumes, translated and edited by PetryM J (Allen and Unwin, London)
37.
HegelG W F, 1970bEnzyklopädie der philosophischen Wissenschaften im Grundrisse (1830), 2. Teil: Die Naturphilosophie [Werke; Bd 9] (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main)
38.
HegelG W F, 1970cPhänomenologie des Geistes [Werke; Bd 3] (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main.)
39.
HegelG W F, 1970dEnzyklopädie der philosophischen Wissenschaften im Grundrisse (1830), 3. Teil, Philosophie des Geistes [Werke; Bd 10] (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main)
40.
HegelG W F, 1970eGrundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts [Werke; Bd 7] (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main)
41.
HegelG W F, 1975Lectures on the Philosophy of World History: Introduction translated by NisbetH B (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
42.
HegelG W F, 1977Phenomenology of Spirit translated by MillerA V (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
43.
HegelG W F, 1978Philosophy of Subjective Spirit3 volumes, translated and edited by PetryM J (D Reidel, Boston, MA)
44.
HegelG W F, 1983Vorlesungen über Naturrecht und Staatswissenschaft. Heidelberg 1817/18 mit Nachträgen aus der Vorlesung 1818/19 Ed. BeckerC [Vorlesungen; Bd 1] (Hamburg, Felix Meiner)
45.
HegelG W F, 1984Hegel: The Letters translated by ButlerCSeilerC (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN)
46.
HegelG W F, 1986Vorlesungen über die Geschichte der Philosophie, Teil 4, Philosophie des Mittelalters und der neueren Zeit Ed. GarnironPJaeschkeW [Vorlesungen; Bd 9] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
47.
HegelG W F, 1990aLectures on the History of Philosophy (1825/26). Vol III: Medieval and Modern Philosophy Ed. BrownR F, translated by BrownR FStewartJ M (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
48.
HegelG W F, 1990bSchriften und Entwürfe I (1817–1825) Ed. HogemannFJammeC [Gesammelte Werke; Bd 15] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
49.
HegelG W F, 1991Elements of the Philosophy of Right Ed. WoodA, translated NisbetH B (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
50.
HegelG W F, 1992aEnzyklopädie der philosophischen Wissenschaften im Grundrisse (1830) Ed. BonsiepenWLucasH-C [Gesammelte Werke; Bd. 20] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
51.
HegelG W F, 1992bWissenschaft der Logik. Die Lehre vom Wesen (1813) Ed. GawollH-J [Gesammelte Werke; Bd. 11] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
52.
HegelG W F, 1995Lectures on Natural Right and Political Science: The First Philosophy of Right. Heidelberg 1817–1818 with Additions from the Lectures of 1818–1819 translated by StewartJ MHodgsonP C (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
53.
HegelG W F, 1996Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Weltgeschichte, Berlin 1822/1823 Ed. IltingK HBrehmerKSeelmannH N [Vorlesungen; Bd 12] (Felix Meiner; Hamburg)
54.
HegelG W F, 2000Vorlesungen über die Philosophie des Rechts, Berlin 1819/1820, nachgeschrieben von RingierJ R, Ed. AngehrnEBondelliMSeelmannH N H N [Vorlesungen; Bd 14] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
55.
HegelG W F, 2002Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Natur. Berlin 1819/20 Ed. BondelliMSeelmannH N [Vorlesungen; Bd 16] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
56.
HegelG W F, 2006Nürnberger Gymnasialkurse und Gymnasialreden (1808–1816) Ed. GrotschK [Gesammelte Werke; Bd 10/1] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
57.
HegelG W F, 2007Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Natur. Berlin 1825/26 Ed. BalKMarmasseGSiegfriedTViewegK [Vorlesungen; Bd 17] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
58.
HegelG W F, 2008Vorlesungen über die Philosophie des subjektiven Geistes (1822–25) Ed. BaurC J [Gesammelte Werke; Bd 25/1] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
59.
HegelG W F, 2009Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts [1821], Ed. GrotschKWeisser-LohmannE [Gesammelte Werke; Bd 14/1] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
60.
HegelG W F, 2011aVorlesungen über die Philosophie des subjektiven Geistes (1827/28) Ed. BaurC J [Gesammelte Werke; Bd 25/2] (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
61.
HegelG W F, 2011bLectures on the Philosophy of World History, Volume I: Manuscripts of the Introduction and the Lectures of 1822–1823 Ed. BrownR FHodgsonP C, translated by BrownR FHodgsonP C (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
62.
HirschmanA O, 1976, “On Hegel, imperialism and structural stagnation”Journal of Development Economics31–8
63.
HoffheimerM H, 2001, “Hegel, race, genocide”The Southern Journal of Philosophy3935–62
64.
HoffheimerM H, 2005, “Race and racism in Hegel's philosophy of religion”, in Race and Racism in Modern Philosophy Ed. VallsA (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY) pp 194–216
65.
HösleV, 1987, “Raum, Zeit, Bewegung”, in Hegel und die Naturwissenschaften Ed. PetryM J (Frommann, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt), pp 247–292
66.
HoulgateS, 2005An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History, 2nd edition (Blackwell, Oxford)
67.
HumboldtA V, 1806Ideen zu einer Physiognomik der Gewäsche (Cotta'sche Buchhandlung, Tübingen)
68.
HumboldtA V, 1860aBriefe von Alexander von Humboldt an Varnhagen von Ense aus den Jahren 1827 bis 1858, nebst Auszügen aus Varnhagen's Tagebüchern, und Briefen von Varnhagen und Andern an Humboldt, Ed. AssingL (F A Brockhaus, Leipzig)
69.
HumboldtA V, 1860bLetters of Alexander von Humboldt to Varnhagen von Ense from 1827 to 1858, with Extracts from Varnhagen's Diaries, and Letters of Varnhagen and others to Humboldt translated by KappF (Rudd and Carleton, New York)
70.
InnerarityD, 1992, “Hegels Idee von Europa”Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung46381–394
71.
InwoodM J, 1983Hegel (Routledge, London)
72.
JenkinsS, 2010, “Hegel on space: A critique of Kant's transcendental philosophy”Inquiry53326–355
73.
JonesA, 1999, “Dialectics and difference: Against Harvey's dialectical Marxism”Progress in Human Geography23529–555
74.
KantI, 1968aGrundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten [Akademie-Textausgabe; Bd 4] (de Gruyter, Berlin) pp 385–463
75.
KantI, 1968bAnthropologie in pragmatischer Hinsicht [Akademie-Textausgabe; Bd 7] (de Gruyter, Berlin) pp 119–333
76.
KantI, 1998 [1781/87] Kritik der reinen Vernunft (Felix Meiner, Hamburg)
77.
KantI, 2009Vorlesungen über Physische Geographie, Ed. StarkW [Gesammelte Schriften; Bd 26] (de Gruyter, Berlin)
78.
KrellD F, 2000, “The bodies of black folk: From Kant and Hegel to Du Bois and Baldwin”boundary27103–134
79.
LefebvreH, 1991The Production of Space translated by Nicholson-SmithD (Blackwell, Oxford)
80.
LefebvreH, 2000La production de l'espace (Anthropos, Paris)
81.
LettowS, 2013, “Modes of naturalization: Race, sex and biology in Kant, Schelling and Hegel”Philosophy and Social Criticism39117–131
82.
LifschitzA S, 2010, “Translation in theory and practice: The case of Johann David Michaelis's prize essay on language and opinions (1759)”, in Cultural Transfer Through Translation: The Circulation of Enlightened Thought in Europe by Means of Translation Ed. StockhorstS (Rodopi, Amsterdam) pp 29–44
83.
LivingstoneD N, 1992The Geographical Tradition: Episodes in the History of a Contested Enterprise (Blackwell, Oxford)
84.
LivingstoneD N, 1995, “Geographical traditions”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series20420–422
85.
LivingstoneD N, 2002, “Race, space and moral climatology: Notes toward a genealogy”Journal of Historical Geography28159–180
86.
McCarneyJ, 2000Hegel on History (Routledge, New York)
87.
McCarneyJ, 2003, “Hegel's racism? A response to Bernasconi”Radical Philosophy11932–5
88.
MannG, 2008, “A negative geography of necessity”Antipode40922–934
89.
MartinG J, 2004All Possible Worlds: A History of Geographical Ideas (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
90.
MayJ A, 1970Kant's Concept of Geography and its Relation to Recent Geographical Thought (University of Toronto Press, Toronto)
91.
MeineckeF, 1959Die Entstehung des Historismus [Werke; Bd. 3] edited by HinrichsC (Koehler, Stuttgart)
92.
MollendorfD, 1992, “Racism and rationality in Hegel's Philosophy of Subjective Spirit”History of Political Thought13243–255
93.
MussettS M, 2003, “On the threshold of history: The role of nature and Africa in Hegel's philosophy”, in Tensional Landscapes: The Dynamics and Boundaries of Placements Eds BackhausGMurungiJ (Lexington Books, Lanham) pp 1–18
94.
NeugebauerC, 1990“The racism of Hegel and Kant”, in Sage Philosophy Odera Oruka, (Brill, Leiden) pp 259–270
95.
NeuserW, 1987, “Die Naturphilosophische und naturwissenschaftliche Literatur aus Hegels privater Bibliothek”, in Hegel und die Naturwissenschaften Ed. PetryM J (Frommann, Stuttgart-Bad Canstatt) pp 479–499
96.
ParekhS, 2009, “Hegel's New World: History, freedom, and race”, in Hegel and History Ed. DudleyW (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 111–131
97.
PeetR, 1985, “The social origins of environmental determinism”Annals of the Association of American Geographers75309–333
98.
PeetR, 1998Modern Geographical Thought (Blackwell, Oxford)
99.
PetryM J, 1981, “Hegels Naturphilosophie: Die Notwendigkeit einer Neubewertung”Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung35614–628
100.
PinkardT, 2000Hegel: A Biography (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
101.
PurtschertP, 2010, “On the limit of spirit: Hegel's racism revisited”Philosophy and Social Criticism361039–1051
102.
RatzelF, 1882Anthropo-Geographie oder Grundzüge der Anwendung der Erdkunde auf die Geschichte (J Engelhorn, Stuttgart)
RobertsJ M, 2001, “Realistic spatial abstraction? Marxist observations of a claim within critical realist geography”Progress in Human Geography25545–567
105.
RosenkranzK, 1963 [1844] Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegels Leben (Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, Darmstadt, Germany)
106.
RuddickS M, 2008, “Towards a dialectics of the positive”Environment and Planning A402588–2602
107.
RuddickS M, 2011, “A dialectics of encounter”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space29213–222
108.
SassH-M, 1973, “Die philosophische Erdkunde des Hegelianers Ernst Kapp: Ein Beitrag zur Wissenschaftstheorie und Fortschrittsdiskussion in der Hegelschule”Hegel-Studien8163–181
109.
SchwindM, 1960, “Die Geographischen ‘Grundlagen’ der Geschichte bei Herder, Hegel und Tonybee”Erdkunde143–10
110.
SheppardE, 2008, “Geographical dialectics?”Environment and Planning A402603–2612
111.
SinnhuberK A, 1959, “Carl Ritter 1779–1859”Scottish Geographical Magazine75153–163
112.
SmithN, 2008 [1984] Uneven Development: Nature, Culture, and the Production of Space (University of Georgia Press, Athens, GA)
113.
SojaE W, 1989Postmodern Geographies: The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory (Verso, London)
114.
SojaE W, 1996Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-Imagined Places (Blackwell, Oxford)
115.
StarkW, 2011, “Kant's lectures on ‘physical geography’: A brief outline of its origins, transmission, and development: 1754–1805”, in Reading Kant's Geography Eds EldenSMendietaE (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 69–85
116.
StederothD, 2001Hegels Philosophie des subjektiven Geistes: Ein komparatorischer Kommentar (Akademie Verlag, Berlin)
WalshW H, 1971, “Principle and prejudice in Hegel's philosophy of history”, in Hegel's Political Philosophy: Problems and Perspectives Ed. PelczynskiZ A (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 181–198
119.
WinfieldR N, 1998, “Space, time and matter: Conceiving nature without foundations”, in Hegel and the Philosophy of Nature Ed. HoulgateStephen (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 51–69
120.
WoodR, 1769An Essay on the Original Genius of Homer (London)
121.
WoodR, 1773Versuch über das Originalgenie des Homers translated by MichaelisC F (Adreä, Frankfurt am Main)
