Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The 2016 presidential election saw the rise and fall of third-party candidates Jill Stein and Gary Johnson. This essay proposes that such third-party candidates are challenged in navigating the dichotomous nature of the myth of the American Dream that serves as the basis of party master narratives. Suggesting that third-party candidates attempt to create alternative narratives through what Rushing and Frentz called dialectical transformation and dialectical synthesis, the essay examines how such strategies were put to use by Stein and Johnson, and how they demonstrate a significant disadvantage for third parties.

Keywords

third parties narrative American Dream presidential campaigns 2016 election

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agiesta

(2016, July 17). Poll: Advantage Clinton as conventions begin. CNN. Retrieved from http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/17/politics/hillary-clinton-donald-trump-cnn-poll/

Balz

Clement

(2016, September 25). Poll: Clinton, Trump in virtual dead heat on eve of first debate. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/poll-clinton-trump-in-virtual-dead-heat-on-eve-of-first-debate/2016/09/24/b99c95de-81cb-11e6-8327-f141a7beb626_story.html?utm_term=.17428c398eea

Bennett

W. L.

Edelman

(1985). Toward a new political narrative. Journal of Communication, 35, 156-171. doi:10.1111/j.1460-2466.1985.tb02979.x

Burke

(1966). Language as symbolic action: Essays on life, literature, and method. Berkeley: University of California Press.

CNN Green Party presidential town hall [Transcript]. (2016, August 17). Retrieved from http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1608/17/se.01.html

Dart

(2016, August 7). “Jill not Hill”: Can Green candidate woo Sanders fans not settling for Clinton? The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/aug/07/jill-stein-green-party-convention-sanders-clinton-us-election

Dearin

(1997). The American dream as depicted in Robert J. Dole’s 1996 presidential nomination acceptance speech. Presidential Studies Quarterly, 27, 698-713.

DeCosta-Klipa

(2016, September 6). A new 50-state poll shows appetite for third-party candidates. But will it be too little, too late? Boston.com . Retrieved from https://www.boston.com/news/politics/2016/09/06/a-new-50-state-poll-shows-appetite-for-third-party-candidates-but-will-it-be-too-little-too-late

Elahi

Cos

(2005). An immigrant’s dream and the audacity of hope: The 2004 convention addresses of Barack Obama and Arnold Schwarzenegger. American Behavioral Scientist, 49, 454-465. doi:10.1177/0002764205279755

10.

Exclusive: Green Party’s Jill Stein announces she is running for president on Democracy Now! (2015, June 22). Democracy Now. Retrieved from https://www.democracynow.org

11.

FBN Exclusive: Gary Johnson announces Libertarian run for president. (2016, January 6). Fox News. Retrieved from http://insider.foxnews.com/2016/01/06/gary-johnson-announces-libertarian-run-president

12.

Fields

(1998). Reading conventions: Political stories from 1998. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 1, 89-116. doi:10.1353/rap.2010.0180

13.

Fisher

W. R.

(1973). Reaffirmation and subversion of the American Dream. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 59, 160-167. doi:10.1080/00335637309383164

14.

Gillespie

J. D.

(2012). Challengers to duopoly: Why third parties matter in American two-party politics. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press.

15.

Harold

C. L.

(2001). The green virus: Purity and contamination in Ralph Nader’s 2000 presidential campaign. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 4, 581-603. doi:10.1353/rap.2001.0072

16.

Johnson

(2015, October 13). Why I would run for president. Retrieved from http://govgaryjohnson.tumblr.com/post/131107358880/why-i-would-run-for-president

17.

Johnson/Weld money comet [Video]. (2016, July 18). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9u2kxW81cRM

18.

Kiefer

(2016, May 27). With Trump vs. Clinton looming, Libertarians get a look. Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved from http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2016/0527/With-Trump-vs.-Clinton-looming-Libertarians-get-a-look

19.

Laslo

(2016, November 2). This is the wrong election to vote for a third-party candidate. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/nov/02/wrong-eleciton-to-vote-third-party-gary-johnson-jill-stein

20.

Libertarian presidential town hall [Transcript]. (2016a, June 22). CNN. Retrieved from http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1606/22/se.01.html

21.

Libertarian presidential town hall [Transcript]. (2016b, August 3). CNN. Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1608/03/se.01.html

22.

McCarthy

(2016, September 30). Americans’ desire for third-party persists this election year. Gallup. Retrieved from http://www.gallup.com/poll/195920/americans-desire-third-party-persists-election-year.aspx

23.

Medhurst

M. J.

(2016). LBJ, Reagan, and the American Dream: Competing visions of liberty. Presidential Studies Quarterly, 46, 98-124. doi:10.1111/psq.12253

24.

Mocarsky

(2016, September 22). Presidential hopeful Jill Stein pitches “Green New Deal” in Wilkes-Barre. Times Leader. Retrieved from http://timesleader.com/news/local/589457/presidential-hopeful-jill-stein-pitches-green-new-deal-in-wilkes-barre

25.

Nelson

(2016a, June 21). National poll: Clinton lead narrows in 4-way race. Politico. Retrieved from http://www.politico.com/story/2016/06/poll-clinton-trump-2016-224584

26.

Nelson

(2016b, July 7). Gary Johnson compares Libertarian ticket to “comet” hitting “two-party dinosaur.” Politico. Retrieved from http://www.politico.com/story/2016/07/gary-johnson-libertarian-ticket-225243

27.

Neville-Shepard

(2014a). Presidential campaign announcements: A third-party variant. Southern Communication Journal, 79, 130-146. doi:10.1080/1041794X.2013.866157

28.

Neville-Shepard

(2014b). Triumph in defeat: The genre of third-party presidential concessions. Communication Quarterly, 62, 214-232. doi:10.1080/01463373.2014.890119

29.

Neville-Shepard

(2016). Unconventional: The variant of third-party nomination acceptance addresses. Western Journal of Communication, 80, 121-139. doi:10.1080/10570314.2015.1128560

30.

Nichols

(2016, May 11). Could a Libertarian be the biggest beneficiary of Trump’s GOP takeover? Capital Times, p. 41.

31.

Presidential candidates Dr. Jill Stein & Gov. Gary Johnson, Part 1 [Transcript]. (2016, October 31). Tavis Smiley. Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/wnet/tavissmiley/interviews/presidential-candidates-dr-jill-stein-gary-johnson-pt-1/

32.

Ritter

K. W.

(1980). American political rhetoric and the Jeremiad tradition: Presidential nomination acceptance addresses, 1960-1976. Central States Speech Journal, 31, 153-171. doi:10.1080/10510978009368054

33.

Rosenstone

S. J.

Behr

R. L.

Lazarus

E. H.

(1996). Third parties in America: Citizen response to major party failure (2nd ed.). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

34.

Rowland

R. C.

Jones

J. A.

(2001). Entelechial and reformative symbolic trajectories in contemporary conservativism: A case study of Reagan and Buchanan in Houston and beyond. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 4, 55-84. doi:10.1353/rap.2001.0010

35.

Rushing

J. H.

Frentz

T. S.

(1978). The rhetoric of “Rocky”: A social value model of criticism. Western Journal of Speech Communication, 42, 63-72. doi:10.1080/10570317809373925

36.

Smith

L. D.

(1989). A narrative analysis of the party platforms: The Democrats and Republicans of 1984. Communication Quarterly, 37, 91-99. doi:10.1080/01463378909385530

37.

Smith

L. D.

(1990). Convention oratory as institutional discourse: A narrative synthesis of the Democrats and Republicans of 1988. Communication Studies, 41, 19-34. doi:10.1080/10510979009368286

38.

Smith

L. D.

(1992). The platforms as institutional discourse: The Democrats and Republicans of 1988. Presidential Studies Quarterly, 22, 531-543.

39.

Solomon

(1983). Villainless quest: Myth, metaphor, and dream in “Chariots of Fire.” Communication Quarterly, 31, 274-281. doi:10.1080/01463378309369516

40.

Solomon

McMullen

W. J.

(1991). Places in the Heart: The rhetorical force of an open text. Western Journal of Speech Communication, 55, 339-353. doi:10.1080/10570319109374392

41.

Spencer

(2016, May 30). Libertarians pick ex-New Mexico Gov. Gary Johnson for president. Dayton Daily News, p. A2.

42.

Stein

(2016, August 6). Jill Stein accepts the Green Party nomination. Retrieved from http://www.jill2016.com/transcript_jill_stein_accepts_the_green_party_nomination

43.

Stuckey

M. E.

(2005). One nation (pretty darn) divisible: National identity in the 2004 conventions. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 8, 639-656.

44.

Terrell

(2016a, January 7). Ex-Gov. Johnson announces second bid for president. Santa Fe New Mexican. Retrieved from http://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/ex-gov-johnson-announces-second-bid-for-president/article_007a3bee-b4ab-11e5-96bd-7f5f002b5fff.html

45.

Terrell

(2016b, May 29). Time for an outsider? Santa Fe New Mexican. Available at LexisNexis database.

46.

Tonn

M. B.

Endress

V. A.

(2001). Looking under the hood and tinkering with voter cynicism: Ross Perot and “perspective by incongruity.” Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 4, 281-308. doi:10.1353/rap.2001.0032

47.

Westen

(2007). The political brain: The role of emotion in deciding the fate of the nation. Cambridge, MA: Public Affairs.

48.

Wood

(2016, August 6). Third-party candidates Johnson and Weld pitch themselves as antidote to polarization at Utah rally. Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved from http://www.sltrib.com/home/4202564-155/third-party-candidates-johnson-and-weld-pitch

49.

Yaccino

Issenberg

(2016, October 4). Which states can Gary Johnson and Jill Stein spoil? Bloomberg. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2016-10-04/which-states-can-gary-johnson-and-jill-stein-spoil

50.

Zaller

Hunt

(1994). The rise and fall of candidate Perot: Unmediated versus mediated politics—Part 1. Political Communication, 11, 357-390. doi:10.1080/10584609.1994.9963046

51.

Zaller

Hunt

(1995). The rise and fall of candidate Perot: Unmediated versus mediated politics—Part 2. Political Communication, 12, 97-123. doi:10.1080/10584609.1995.9963057