Scholars interested in the relationship between social context and health have recently turned attention further “upstream” to understand how political, social, and economic institutions shape the distribution of life chances across contexts. We compare minority health inequalities across 22 European countries (N = 199,981) to investigate how two such arrangements—welfare state effort and immigrant incorporation policies—influence the distribution of health and health inequalities. We examine two measures of health from seven waves of the European Social Survey. Results from a series of multilevel mixed-effects models show that minority health inequalities vary across contexts and persist after accounting for socioeconomic differences. Cross-level interaction results show that welfare state effort is associated with better health for all groups but is unrelated to levels of inequality between groups. In contrast, policies aimed at protecting minorities from discrimination correlate with smaller relative health inequalities.
AlbaRichard. 2005. “Bright vs. Blurred Boundaries: Second-generation Assimilation and Exclusion in France, Germany, and the United States.” Ethnic and Racial Studies28(1):20–49.
2.
AlbaRichardFonerNancy. 2014. “Comparing Immigrant Integration in North America and Western Europe: How Much Do the Grand Narratives Tell Us?” International Migration Review48:S263–91.
3.
AntecolHeatherBedardKelly. 2006. “Unhealthy Assimilation: Why Do Immigrants Converge to American Health Status Levels?” Demography43(2):337–60.
4.
AspinallPeter J.2007. “Approaches to Developing an Improved Cross-national Understanding of Concepts and Terms Relating to Ethnicity and Race.” International Sociology22(1):41–70.
5.
BacakValerioOlafsdottirSigrun. 2017. “Gender and Validity of Self-rated Health in Nineteen European Countries.” Scandinavian Journal of Public Health45(6):647–53.
6.
BailChristopher A.2008. “The Configuration of Symbolic Boundaries against Immigrants in Europe.” American Sociological Review73(1):37–59.
7.
BambraClare. 2006. “Health Status and the Worlds of Welfare.” Social Policy and Society5(1):53–62.
8.
BambraClareEikemoTerje A.2009. “Welfare State Regimes, Unemployment and Health: A Comparative Study of the Relationship between Unemployment and Self-reported Health in 23 European Countries.” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health63:92–98.
9.
BambraClarePopeD.SwamiV.StanistreetD.RoskamA.KunstA.Scott-SamuelA.2009. “Gender, Health Inequalities and Welfare State Regimes: A Cross-national Study of 13 European Countries.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health63(1):38–44.
10.
BeckfieldJasonBambraClareEikemoTerje A.HuijtsTimMcNamaraCourtneyWendtClaus. 2015. “An Institutional Theory of Welfare State Effects on the Distribution of Population Health.” Social Theory & Health13(3–4):227–44.
11.
BeckfieldJasonKriegerNancy. 2009. “Epi + Demos + Cracy: Linking Political Systems and Priorities to the Magnitude of Health Inequities. Evidence, Gaps, and a Research Agenda.” Epidemiologic Reviews31(1):152–77.
12.
BeckfieldJasonOlafsdottirSigrunBakhtiariElyas. 2013. “Health Inequalities in Global Context.” American Behavioral Scientist57(8):1014–39.
13.
BergqvistKerstiYngweMonica ÅbergLundbergOlle. 2013. “Understanding the Role of Welfare State Characteristics for Health and Inequalities: An Analytical Review.” BMC Public Health13:1234. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-13-1234
14.
BloemraadIrene. 2006. “Becoming a Citizen in the United States and Canada: Structured Mobilization and Immigrant Political Incorporation.” Social Forces85(2):667–95.
15.
BlomNielsHuijtsTimKraaykampGerbert. 2016. “Ethnic Health Inequalities in Europe. The Moderating and Amplifying Role of Healthcare System Characteristics.” Social Science & Medicine158:43–51.
16.
BolliniPaolaPampallonaSandroWannerPhilippeKupelnickBruce. 2009. “Pregnancy Outcome of Migrant Women and Integration Policy: A Systematic Review of the International Literature.” Social Science & Medicine68(3):452–61.
17.
BradyDavidFinniganRyan. 2013. “Does Immigration Undermine Public Support for Social Policy?” American Sociological Review79(1):17–42.
18.
BrennenstuhlSarahQuesnel-ValléeAmélieMcDonoughPeggy. 2012. “Welfare Regimes, Population Health and Health Inequalities: A Research Synthesis.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health66(5):397–409.
19.
de BruinA.PicavetH. S.NossikovA., eds. 1996. Health Interview Surveys: Towards International Harmonization of Methods and Instruments. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe.
20.
CeballosMiguelPalloniAlberto. 2010. “Maternal and Infant Health of Mexican Immigrants in the United States: The Effects of Acculturation, Duration, and Selective Return Migration.” Ethnicity & Health15(4):377–96.
21.
ChoYoungtaeFrisbieW. ParkerHummerRobert A.RogersRichard G.2004. “Nativity, Duration of Residence, and the Health of Hispanic Adults in the United States.” International Migration Review38(1):184–211.
22.
ChungHaejooMuntanerCarles. 2006. “Political and Welfare State Determinants of Infant and Child Health Indicators: An Analysis of Wealthy Countries.” Social Science & Medicine63(3):829–42.
23.
ConleyDaltonSpringerKristen W.2001. “Welfare State and Infant Mortality.” American Journal of Sociology107(3):768–807.
24.
CorriganOwen. 2014. “Migrant Deprivation, Conditionality of Legal Status and the Welfare State.” Journal of European Social Policy24(3):223–39.
25.
DoorslaerEddy vanKoolmanXander. 2004. “Explaining the Differences in Income-related Health Inequalities across European Countries.” Health Economics13(7):609–28.
26.
DowdJennifer BeamToddMegan. 2011. “Does Self-reported Health Bias the Measurement of Health Inequalities in U.S. Adults? Evidence Using Anchoring Vignettes from the Health and Retirement Study.” Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences66B(4):478–89.
27.
EikemoTerje A.BambraClareJoyceK.DahlEspen. 2008. “Welfare State Regimes and Income-related Health Inequalities: A Comparison of 23 European Countries.” European Journal of Public Health18(6):593–99.
28.
EikemoTerje A.HuismanMartijnBambraClareKunstAnton E.2008. “Health Inequalities According to Educational Level in Different Welfare Regimes: A Comparison of 23 European Countries.” Sociology of Health & Illness30(4):565–82.
29.
EloIrma T.2009. “Social Class Differentials in Health and Mortality: Patterns and Explanations in Comparative Perspective.” Annual Review of Sociology35(1):553–72.
30.
Esping-AndersenGøsta. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
European Social Survey. 2014. ESS Rounds 1–7: European Social Survey Round 7 Data, Data File Edition 2.1 [MRDF]. Bergen, Norway: Norwegian Centre for Research Data, [distributor].
32.
FonerNancy. 2015. “Is Islam in Western Europe Like Race in the United States?” Sociological Forum30(4):885–99.
33.
FreemanGary P.2004. “Immigrant Incorporation in Western Democracies.” International Migration Review38(3):945–69.
34.
FrisbieW. ParkerChoYoungtaeHummerRobert A.2001. “Immigration and the Health of Asian and Pacific Islander Adults in the United States.” American Journal of Epidemiology153(4):372–80.
35.
HadjarAndreasBackesSusanne. 2013. “Migration Background and Subjective Well-being: A Multilevel Analysis Based on the European Social Survey.” Comparative Sociology12(5):645–76.
36.
HardyMelissa A.AcciaiFrancescoReyesAdriana M.2014. “How Health Conditions Translate into Self-ratings: A Comparative Study of Older Adults across Europe.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior55(3):320–41.
37.
HarzingAnne-Wil. 2006. “Response Styles in Cross-national Survey Research A 26-country Study.” International Journal of Cross Cultural Management6(2):243–66.
38.
HelblingMarc. 2013. “Validating Integration and Citizenship Policy Indices.” Comparative European Politics11(5):555–76.
39.
HuddlestonThomasBilgiliOzgeJokiAnne-LindeVankovaZvezda. 2015. Migrant Integration Policy Index. Brussels: British Council and Migration Policy Group.
40.
HuismanMartijnvan LentheFrankMackenbachJohan. 2007. “The Predictive Ability of Self-assessed Health for Mortality in Different Educational Groups.” International Journal of Epidemiology36(6):1207–13.
41.
IdlerEllen L.BenyaminiYael. 1997. “Self-rated Health and Mortality: A Review of Twenty-seven Community Studies.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(1):21–37.
42.
IkramUmar Z.MalmusiDavideJuelKnudReyGrégoireKunstAnton E.2015. “Association between Integration Policies and Immigrants’ Mortality: An Explorative Study across Three European Countries.” PLoS ONE10(6):e0129916. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0129916
43.
JormAnthony F.RyanSiobhan M.2014. “Cross-national and Historical Differences in Subjective Well-being.” International Journal of Epidemiology43(2):330–40.
44.
JürgesHendrik. 2007. “True Health vs Response Styles: Exploring Cross-country Differences in Self-reported Health.” Health Economics16(2):163–78.
45.
JylhäMarjaGuralnikJack M.FerrucciLuigiJokelaJukkaHeikkinenEino. 1998. “Is Self-rated Health Comparable across Cultures and Genders?” Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences53B(3):S144–52.
46.
KarimSyahirah AbdulEikemoTerje A.BambraClare. 2010. “Welfare State Regimes and Population Health: Integrating the East Asian Welfare States.” Health Policy94(1):45–53.
47.
KeslerChristel. 2006. “Social Policy and Immigrant Joblessness in Britain, Germany and Sweden.” Social Forces85(2):743–70.
48.
KingGaryMurrayChristopher J. L.SalomonJoshua A.TandonAjay. 2004. “Enhancing the Validity and Cross-cultural Comparability of Measurement in Survey Research.” American Political Science Review98(1):191–207.
49.
KoopmansRuud. 2013. “Indices of Immigrant Rights: What Have We Learned, Where Should We Go?” Comparative European Politics11(5):696–703.
50.
KoopmansRuudMichalowskiWaibelStine. 2012. “Citizenship Rights for Immigrants: National Political Processes and Cross-national Convergence in Western Europe, 1980–2008.” American Journal of Sociology117(4):1202–45.
51.
KunstAnton E.BosVivianLahelmaEeroBartleyMelLissauIngeRegidorEnriqueMielckAndreasCardanoMarioDalstraJetty A. A.GeurtsJosé J. M.HelmertUweLennartssonCarinRammJorunSpadeaTeresaStroneggerWillibald J.MackenbachJohan P.2005. “Trends in Socioeconomic Inequalities in Self-assessed Health in 10 European Countries.” International Journal of Epidemiology34(2):295–305.
52.
LahelmaEeroArberSara. 1994. “Health Inequalities among Men and Women in Contrasting Welfare States.” European Journal of Public Health4(3):213–26.
53.
LamontMichèleMolnárVirág. 2002. “The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences.” Annual Review of Sociology28:167–95.
54.
LevecqueKatiaVan RossemRonan. 2015. “Depression in Europe: Does Migrant Integration Have Mental Health Payoffs? A Cross-national Comparison of 20 European Countries.” Ethnicity & Health20(1):49–65.
55.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.1995. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior35(Extra Issue):80–94.
56.
LundbergOlleYngweMonica ÅbergBergqvistKerstiSjöbergOla. 2015. “Welfare States and Health Inequalities.” Canadian Public Policy41(Suppl. 2):S26–33.
57.
LundbergOlleYngweMonica ÅbergStjärneMaria KölegårdElstadJon IvarFerrariniTommyKangasOlliNorströmThorPalmeJoakimFritzellJohan. 2008. “The Role of Welfare State Principles and Generosity in Social Policy Programmes for Public Health: An International Comparative Study.” Lancet372(9650):1633–40.
58.
LutfeyKarenFreeseJeremy. 2005. “Toward Some Fundamentals of Fundamental Causality: Socioeconomic Status and Health in the Routine Clinic Visit for Diabetes.” American Journal of Sociology110(5):1326–72.
59.
MackenbachJohan P.StirbuIrinaRoskamAlbert-Jan R.SchaapMaartje M.MenvielleGwennLeinsaluMallKunstAnton E.2008. “Socioeconomic Inequalities in Health in 22 European Countries.” New England Journal of Medicine358(23):2468–81.
60.
MalmusiDavide. 2015. “Immigrants’ Health and Health Inequality by Type of Integration Policies in European Countries.” European Journal of Public Health25(2):293–99.
61.
ManorOrlyMatthewsSharonPowerChris. 2000. “Dichotomous or Categorical Response? Analysing Self-rated Health and Lifetime Social Class.” International Journal of Epidemiology29(1):149–57.
62.
MauSteffenBurkhardtChristoph. 2009. “Migration and Welfare State Solidarity in Western Europe.” Journal of European Social Policy19(3):213–29.
63.
MeulemanBartDavidovEldadBillietJaak. 2009. “Changing Attitudes toward Immigration in Europe, 2002–2007: A Dynamic Group Conflict Theory Approach.” Social Science Research38(2):352–65.
64.
MollenkopfJohnHochschildJennifer. 2010. “Immigrant Political Incorporation: Comparing Success in the United States and Western Europe.” Ethnic and Racial Studies33(1):19–38.
65.
NavarroVicenteMuntanerCarlesBorrellCarmeBenachJoanQuirogaÁguedaRodríguez-SanzMaicaVergésNúriaPasarínM. Isabel. 2006. “Politics and Health Outcomes.” Lancet368(9540):1033–37.
66.
NelsonKennethFritzellJohan. 2014. “Welfare States and Population Health: The Role of Minimum Income Benefits for Mortality.” Social Science & Medicine112:63–71.
67.
NielsenSigne SmithKrasnikAllan. 2010. “Poorer Self-perceived Health among Migrants and Ethnic Minorities versus the Majority Population in Europe: A Systematic Review.” International Journal of Public Health55(5):357–71.
68.
OlafsdottirSigrun. 2007. “Fundamental Causes of Health Disparities: Stratification, the Welfare State, and Health in the United States and Iceland.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior48(3):239–53.
69.
OlafsdottirSigrun. 2017. “Gendered Health Inequalities in Mental Well-being? The Nordic Countries in a Comparative Perspective.” Scandinavian Journal of Public Health45(2):185–94.
70.
OlafsdottirSigrunBakhtiariElyas. 2015. “Citizenship and Healthcare Policy.” Pp. 561–70 in The Palgrave International Handbook of Healthcare Policy and Governance, edited by KuhlmannE.BlankR. H.BourgeaultI. L.WendtC.London: Palgrave Macmillan.
71.
OlafsdottirSigrunBakhtiariElyasBarmanEmily. 2014. “Public or Private? The Role of the State and Civil Society in Health and Health Inequalities across Nations.” Social Science & Medicine123:174–81.
72.
OlafsdottirSigrunBeckfieldJason. 2011. “Health and the Social Rights of Citizenship: Integrating Welfare-state Theory and Medical Sociology.” Pp. 101–15 in Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness, and Healing, Handbooks of Sociology and Social Research, edited by PescosolidoB. A.MartinJ. K.McLeodJ. D.RogersA.New York: Springer.
73.
OlafsdottirSigrunBeckfieldJasonBakhtiariElyas. 2013. “Contextualizing Disparities: The Case for Comparative Research on Social Inequalities in Health.” Pp. 299–317 in Social Determinants, Health Disparities and Linkages to Health and Health Care, vol. 31, Research in the Sociology of Health Care, edited by KronenfeldJ. J.Bingley, UK: Emerald Group.
74.
PhelanJo C.LinkBruce G.2015. “Is Racism a Fundamental Cause of Inequalities in Health?” Annual Review of Sociology41(1):311–30.
75.
Quesnel-ValléeAmélie. 2007. “Self-rated Health: Caught in the Crossfire of the Quest for ‘True’ Health?” International Journal of Epidemiology36(6):1161–64.
76.
SainsburyDiane. 2006. “Immigrants’ Social Rights in Comparative Perspective: Welfare Regimes, Forms in Immigration and Immigration Policy Regimes.” Journal of European Social Policy16(3):229–44.
77.
SchneiderSilke L.2008. “Anti-immigrant Attitudes in Europe: Outgroup Size and Perceived Ethnic Threat.” European Sociological Review24(1):53–67.
78.
SchnittkerJasonBacakValerio. 2014. “The Increasing Predictive Validity of Self-rated Health.” PLoS ONE9(1):e84933. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0084933
79.
SemyonovMosheRaijmanRebecaGorodzeiskyAnastasia. 2006. “The Rise of Anti-foreigner Sentiment in European Societies, 1988–2000.” American Sociological Review71(3):426–49.
80.
SimonPatrick. 2011. “Collecting Ethnic Statistics in Europe: A Review.” Ethnic and Racial Studies35(8):1366–91.
81.
SinghGopal K.MillerBarry A.2004. “Health, Life Expectancy, and Mortality Patterns among Immigrant Populations in the United States.” Canadian Journal of Public Health95(3):14–21.
82.
StalkerPeter. 2002. “Migration Trends and Migration Policy in Europe.” International Migration40(5):151–79.
83.
Von dem KnesebeckOlafVerdePablo E.DraganoNico. 2006. “Education and Health in 22 European Countries.” Social Science & Medicine63(5):1344–51.
84.
WilliamsDavid R.MohammedSelina A.2013. “Racism and Health I: Pathways and Scientific Evidence.” American Behavioral Scientist57(8):1152–73.
85.
WilliamsDavid R.SternthalMichelle. 2010. “Understanding Racial-ethnic Disparities in Health Sociological Contributions.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(Suppl. 1):S15–27.
86.
WimmerAndreas. 2008. “The Making and Unmaking of Ethnic Boundaries: A Multilevel Process Theory.” American Journal of Sociology113(4):970–1022.
87.
WimmerAndreasSoehlThomas. 2014. “Blocked Acculturation: Cultural Heterodoxy among Europe’s Immigrants.” American Journal of Sociology120(1):146–86.
88.
XuJunLongJ. Scott. 2005. “Confidence Intervals for Predicted Outcomes in Regression Models for Categorical Outcomes.” Stata Journal5(4):537–59.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
