Multilevel models are increasingly used in sociology and other social sciences to analyze variation of tie outcomes in egocentrically sampled network data, particularly in studies of social support. Existing research assumes that the personal networks in the data do not overlap (i.e., they do not have actors in common), which makes standard hierarchical models suitable for analysis. This assumption is unrealistic in certain sampling designs, including the case of egos sampled from higher level groups or via link-tracing methods. We describe different types of ego-network overlap and propose a method to detect overlapping actors and analyze the resulting data with cross-classified multilevel models. The method is demonstrated with an application to research on personal networks and social support among Hispanic immigrants in rural U.S. destinations. Overlap detection and modeling result in better model fit, more correct partition of tie variation among different sources, and the ability to test new substantive hypotheses.
BurtRonald S.1984. “Network Items and the General Social Survey.” Social Networks6(4):293–339.
2.
CampbellKaren E.LeeBarrett A.. 1992. “Sources of Personal Neighbor Networks: Social Integration, Need, or Time?” Social Forces70(4):1077–00.
3.
ChuaVincentMadejJuliaWellmanBarry. 2011. “Personal Communities: The World According to Me.” Pp. 101–15 in The Sage Handbook of Social Network Analysis, edited by ScottJ.CarringtonP. J.. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
4.
CornwellBenjaminLaumannEdward O.. 2011. “Network Position and Sexual Dysfunction: Implications of Partner Betweenness for Men.” American Journal of Sociology117(1):172–208.
5.
CrossleyNickBellottiElisaEdwardsGemmaEverettMartin G.KoskinenJohanTranmerMark. 2015. Social Network Analysis for Ego-nets. London, England: Sage.
6.
DrouhotLucas G.2017. “Reconsidering ‘Community Liberated’: How Class and the National Context Shape Personal Support Networks.” Social Networks48:57–77.
7.
GoldsteinHarvey. 2010a. “Cross-classified Data Structures.” Pp. 243–54 in Multilevel Statistical Models. Chichester, England: Wiley.
GuoGuangZhaoHongxin. 2000. “Multilevel Modeling for Binary Data.” Annual Review of Sociology26:441–62.
10.
HadfieldJarrod D.2010. “MCMC Methods for Multi-response Generalized Linear Mixed Models: The MCMCglmm R Package.” Journal of Statistical Software33(2):24381.
11.
De la HayeKaylaGreenHarold D.KennedyDavid P.ZhouAnnieGolinelliDanielaWenzelSuzanne L.TuckerJoan S.. 2012. “Who Is Supporting Homeless Youth? Predictors of Support in Personal Networks.” Journal of Research on Adolescence22(4):604–16.
12.
De Miguel LukenVerónicaTranmerMark. 2010. “Personal Support Networks of Immigrants to Spain: A Multilevel Analysis.” Social Networks32(4):253–62.
13.
HeckathornDouglas D.CameronChristopher J.. 2017. “Network Sampling: From Snowball and Multiplicity to Respondent-driven Sampling.” Annual Review of Sociology43(1):101–19.
14.
HerzAndreas. 2015. “Relational Constitution of Social Support in Migrants’ Transnational Personal Communities.” Social Networks40:64–74.
15.
HooverMatthew A.GreenHarold D.BogartLaura M.WagnerGlenn J.MutchlerMatt G.GalvanFrank H.McDavittBryce. 2016. “Do People Know I’m Poz? Factors Associated with Knowledge of Serostatus among HIV-positive African Americans’ Social Network Members.” AIDS and Behavior20(1):137–46.
16.
HouseJ. S.UmbersonD.LandisK. R.. 1988. “Structures and Processes of Social Support.” Annual Review of Sociology14(1):293–318.
17.
KennedyDavid P.WenzelSuzanne L.BrownRyanTuckerJoan S.GolinelliDaniela. 2013. “Unprotected Sex among Heterosexually Active Homeless Men: Results from a Multi-level Dyadic Analysis.” AIDS and Behavior17(5):1655–67.
18.
KrivitskyPavel N.MorrisMartina. 2017. “Inference for Social Network Models from Egocentrically Sampled Data, with Application to Understanding Persistent Racial Disparities in HIV Prevalence in the US.” The Annals of Applied Statistics11(1):427–55.
19.
LichterDaniel T.2012. “Immigration and the New Racial Diversity in Rural America.” Rural Sociology77(1):3–35.
20.
LubbersMiranda JessicaLuis MolinaJoséMcCartyChristopher. 2007. “Personal Networks and Ethnic Identifications. The Case of Migrants in Spain.” International Sociology22(6):721–41.
21.
LubbersMiranda JessicaMolinaJ. L.LernerJ.BrandesU.ÁvilaJ.. 2010. “Longitudinal Analysis of Personal Networks. The Case of Argentinean Migrants in Spain.” Social Networks32(1):91–104
22.
MarsdenP. V.1990. “Network Data and Measurement.” Annual Review of Sociology16:435–63.
23.
MarsdenPeter V.1987. “Core Discussion Networks of Americans.” American Sociological Review52(1):122–31.
24.
MartíJoelBolíbarMireiaLozaresCarlos. 2017. “Network Cohesion and Social Support.” Social Networks48:192–201.
25.
MaoLiangStacciariniJeanne-Marie R.SmithRebekahWiensBrenda. 2015. “An Individual-Based Rurality Measure and Its Health Application: A Case Study of Latino Immigrants in North Florida, USA.” Social Science & Medicine147:300–308.
26.
McCartyChristopherLubbersMiranda JessicaVaccaRaffaeleLuis MolinaJosé. 2019. Conducting Personal Network Research. A Practical Guide. New York: Guilford Press.
27.
McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynnCookJames M.. 2001. “Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology27:415–44.
28.
McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynnBrashearsMatthew E.. 2006. “Social Isolation in America: Changes in Core Discussion Networks over Two Decades.” American Sociological Review71(3):353–75.
29.
MerliM. GiovannaVerderyAshtonMouwTedLiJing. 2016. “Sampling Migrants from Their Social Networks: The Demography and Social Organization of Chinese Migrants in Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania.” Migration Studies4(2):182–214.
30.
MokDianaWellmanBarryCarrascoJuan. 2010. “Does Distance Matter in the Age of the Internet?” Urban Studies47(13):2747–83.
31.
MollenhorstGeraldVolkerBeateFlapHenk. 2014. “Changes in Personal Relationships: How Social Contexts Affect the Emergence and Discontinuation of Relationships.” Social Networks37:65–80.
32.
MouwT.ChavezS.EdelbluteH.VerderyA.. 2014. “Binational Social Networks and Assimilation: A Test of the Importance of Transnationalism.” Social Problems61(3):329–59.
33.
MouwT.VerderyA. M.. 2012. “Network Sampling with Memory: A Proposal for More Efficient Sampling from Social Networks.” Sociological Methodology42(1):206–56.
34.
PaikAnthonySanchagrinKenneth. 2013. “Social Isolation in America: An Artifact.” American Sociological Review78(3):339–60.
35.
PerryBrea L.BorgattiStevePescosolidoBernice A.. 2018. Egocentric Network Analysis: Foundation, Methods, and Models. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
36.
PerryBrea L.PescosolidoBernice A.. 2012. “Social Network Dynamics and Biographical Disruption: The Case of ‘First-timers’ with Mental Illness.” American Journal of Sociology118(1):134–75.
37.
PerryBrea L.PescosolidoBernice A.. 2015. “Social Network Activation: The Role of Health Discussion Partners in Recovery from Mental Illness.” Social Science & Medicine125:116–28.
38.
PlickertGabrieleCôtéRochelle R.WellmanBarry. 2007. “It’s Not Who You Know, It’s How You Know Them: Who Exchanges What with Whom?” Social Networks29(3):405–29.
39.
PlummerMartynBestNickyCowlesKateVinesKaren. 2006. “CODA: Convergence Diagnosis and Output Analysis for MCMC.” R News6(1):7–11.
40.
RobinsGarryPattisonPipKalishYuvalLusherDean. 2007. “An Introduction to Exponential Random Graph (P*) Models for Social Networks.” Social Networks29(2):173–91.
41.
SmithJeffrey A.MoodyJamesMorganJonathan H.. 2017. “Network Sampling Coverage II: The Effect of Non-random Missing Data on Network Measurement.” Social Networks48:78–99.
42.
SnijdersT. A. B.2016. “The Multiple Flavours of Multilevel Issues for Networks.” Pp. 15–46 in Multilevel Network Analysis for the Social Sciences, edited by LazegaE.SnijdersTom A.B.. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International.
43.
SnijdersTomBoskerR. J.. 2012. Multilevel Analysis: An Introduction to Basic and Advanced Multilevel Modeling. 2nd ed. London, England: Sage.
44.
SnijdersTomKennyDavid A.. 1999. “The Social Relations Model for Family Data: A Multilevel Approach.” Personal Relationships6(4):471–86.
45.
SnijdersTomSpreenMarinusZwaagstraRonald. 1995. “The Use of Multilevel Modeling for Analysing Personal Networks: Networks of Cocaine Users in an Urban area.” Journal of Quantitative Anthropology5:85–105.
46.
SongLijunSonJoonmoLinNan. 2011. “Social Support.” Pp. 116–28 in The Sage Handbook of Social Network Analysis, edited by ScottJ.CarringtonP. J.. Thousand Oaks, CA. Sage.
47.
TranmerMarkSteelDavidBrowneWilliam J.. 2014. “Multiple-membership Multiple-classification Models for Social Network and Group Dependences.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society)177(2):439–55.
48.
TuckerJoanKennedyDavidRyanGeryWenzelSuzanneGolinelliDanielaZazzaliJamesMcCartyChristopher. 2009. “Homeless Women’s Personal Networks: Implications for Understanding Risk Behavior.” Human Organization68(2):129–40.
49.
Van DuijnMarijtje A. J.van BusschbachJooske T.SnijdersTom. 1999. “Multilevel Analysis of Personal Networks as Dependent Variables.” Social Networks21(2):187–210.
50.
Van DuijnMarijtje A. J.SnijdersTomZijlstraBonne J. H.. 2004. “P2: A Random Effects Model with Covariates for Directed Graphs.” Statistica Neerlandica58(2):234–54.
51.
Van TubergenFrank. 2014. “Size and Socio-economic Resources of Core Discussion Networks in the Netherlands: Differences by National-origin Group and Immigrant Generation.” Ethnic and Racial Studies37(6):1020–42.
52.
Van TubergenFrank. 2015. “Ethnic Boundaries in Core Discussion Networks: A Multilevel Social Network Study of Turks and Moroccans in the Netherlands.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies41(1):101–16.
53.
VaccaRaffaeleSolanoGiacomoLubbersMiranda JessicaLuis MolinaJoséMcCartyChristopher. 2018. “A Personal Network Approach to the Study of Immigrant Structural Assimilation and Transnationalism.” Social Networks53:72–89.
54.
ValenteThomas W.WatkinsSusan C.JatoMiriam N.Van Der StratenArianeTsitsolLouis-Philippe M.. 1997. “Social Network Associations with Contraceptive Use among Cameroonian Women in Voluntary Associations.” Social Science & Medicine45(5):677–87.
55.
VerderyAshton M.MouwTedEdelbluteHeatherChavezSergio. 2017. “Communication Flows and the Durability of a Transnational Social Field.” Social Networks53:57–71.
56.
VölkerBeateFlapHenk. 2007. “Sixteen Million Neighbors. A Multilevel Study of the Role of Neighbors in the Personal Networks of the Dutch.” Urban Affairs Review43(2):256–84.
57.
WalkerMichael E.WassermanStanleyWellmanBarry. 1993. “Statistical Models for Social Support Networks.” Sociological Methods & Research22(1):71–98.
58.
WellmanBarry. 2007. “The Network Is Personal: Introduction to a Special Issue of Social Networks.” Social Networks29(3):349–56.
59.
WellmanBarryFrankKenneth A.. 2001. “Network Capital in a Multi-level World: Getting Support from Personal Communities.” in pp. 233–73Social Capital: Theory and Research, edited by LinN.CookK. S.BurtR. S.. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction.
60.
WellmanBarryWortleyScot. 1990. “Different Strokes from Different Folks: Community Ties and Social Support.” The American Journal of Sociology96(3):558–88.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
