Biocompatibility is one of the main prerequisites for the clinical use of biomaterials. Central to the testing of biocompatibility is the estimation of cytotoxicity, which can be assessed in vitro by using a variety of different target primary cells or cell lines. The influence of toxic agents derived from biomaterials on cellular functions and cell viability can be characterised by reductions in cell adhesion, alterations in cellular morphology, reduced cellular proliferation, and cell death, demonstrated by an absence of metabolic activity, structural disintegration and cell lysis. A brief review of the basic mechanisms of cytotoxicity and the use of different in vitro methods for testing the cytotoxicity of biomaterials is presented.
WilliamsD.F., BlackJ., and DohertyP.J. (1992). Second Consensus Conference on Definitions in Biomaterials. In Advances in Biomaterials, Vol. 10, Biomaterials–Tissue Interfaces (ed. DohertyP., WilliamsR.L., WilliamsD.F., LeeA.J.C.), 525 pp. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
2.
WolfH., KarwathR., & GrothT. (1988). Interaction of blood with biomedical polymers — some basic aspects. In Advances in Biomedical Measurements (ed. CarsonE.R., KneppoP., KrekuleI.), pp. 133–142. New York & London: Plenum Press.
3.
KlinkmannH., WolfH., and SchmittE. (1984). Definition of biocompatibility.Contributions in Nephrology37, 70–77.
4.
WilliamsD.F. (1986). Definitions in biomaterials. In Proceedings of a Consensus Conference of the European Society for Biomaterials, pp. 3–5. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
5.
Anon. (1992). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 1: guidance on selection of tests.London: International Organisation for Standardisation
6.
Anon. (1994). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 6: tests for local effects after implantation.London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
7.
Anon. (1992). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 2: animal welfare requirements.London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
8.
FrazierJ.M., and GoldbergA.M. (1990). Alternatives to and reduction of animal use in biomedical research, education, and testing.The Cancer Bulletin42, 238–245.
9.
Anon. (1992). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 4: selection of tests for interactions with blood.London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
10.
GrothT., PodiasA., and MissirlisY. (1994). Platelet adhesion and activation under static and flow conditions.Colloids and Surfaces B. Biointerfaces3, 241–249.
11.
GrothT, CampbellE., HermannK., and SeifertB. (1995). Applications of enzyme immuno assays for testing haemocompatibility of biomedical polymers.Biomaterials16, 1009–1015.
12.
GrothT., GronertA., ZiemerS., and HesseR. (1992). The haemocompatibility of reference materials in vitro: comparative investigation of platelet adhesion/activation and platelet aggregability. In The Reference Materials of the European Communities (ed. LemmW.), pp. 183–192. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publisher.
13.
HaycoxC.L., and RatnerB. (1993). In vitro platelet interactions in whole human blood exposed to bio-material surfaces: insights on blood compatibility.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research27, 1181–1193.
14.
DawidsS. ed. (1993). Test procedures for the blood compatibility of biomaterials, 684 pp. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publisher.
15.
SchmidtB. (1994). Experimental test systems for the assessment of the blood compatibility of materials used in extracorporeal circuits.Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation9, Suppl. 2, 77–82.
16.
DidisheimP., DewanjeeM.K., KayeM.P., FriskC.S., FassD.N., TirrellM.V., and ZollmannP.E. (1984). Nonpredictability of long-term in vivo response from short-term in vitro or ex vivo blood/material interactions.Transactions of the American Society for Artificial Internal Organs30, 370–376.
17.
DidisheimP., DewanjeeM.K., FriskC.S., KayeM.P., and FassD.N. (1984). Animal models for predicting clinical performance of biomaterials for cardiovascular use. In Contemporary Biomaterials (ed. BoretusJ.W., EdenM.), pp. 132–179. Park Ridge, NJ, USA: Noyes Publications.
18.
Anon. (1992). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 5: tests for cytotoxicity: in vitro methods.London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
19.
Anon. (1995). ISO/DIS 7405 Dentistry: preclinical evaluation of biocompatibility of medical devices used in dentistry: test methods (Revision of ISO/TR 7405).London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
20.
PizzoferatoA., ArciolaC.R., CenniE., CiapettiG., and SassiS. (1995). In vitro biocompatibility of a polyurethane catheter after deposition of fluorinated film.Biomaterials16, 361–367.
21.
AdamsA.M., SoamesJ.V., and SearleR.F. (1995). Morphological changes in cultured human periodontal ligament cells exposed to dental materials.Biomaterials16, 1031–1035.
22.
ZamboninG., and GranoM. (1995). Biomaterials in orthopaedic surgery: effects of different hydroxyapatites and demineralized bone matrix on proliferation rate and bone matrix synthesis by human osteoblasts.Biomaterials16, 397–402.
23.
EbisawaY., KokuboT., OhuraK., and YamamuroT. (1993). Bioactivity of Fe2O3-containing CaO-SiO2 glasses: in vitro evaluation.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine4, 225–232.
24.
OhuraK., NakamuraT., YamamuroT., EbisawaY., KokuboT., KotouraY., and OkaM. (1992). Bioactivity of CaO-SiO2 glasses added with various ions.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine3, 95–100.
25.
CornelisM., DupontC., and WepierreJ. (1991). In vitro cytotoxicity tests on cultured human skin fibroblasts to predict the toxic potential of surfactants.ATLA19, 324–337.
26.
TanziM.C., VerderioP., LampugnaniM.G., ResnatiM., DejanaE., and SturaniE. (1994). Cytotoxicity of some catalysts commonly used in the synthesis of copolymers for biomedical use.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 393–396.
27.
LugscheiderE., KnepperM., HeimbergB., DekkerA., & KirkpatrickC.J. (1994). Cytotoxicity investigations of plasma sprayed calcium phosphate coatings.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 371–375.
28.
JenssenJ., and SyversenT. (1991). Effects of high pressure and metal salts on cell growth.ATLA19, 245–250.
29.
Anon. (1992). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 3: tests for genotoxicity, carcinogenicity and reproduction toxicity.London: International Organistion for Standardisation.
30.
SchweiklH., and SchmalzG. (1991). Evaluation of the mutagenic potential of root canal sealers using the Salmonella/microsome assay.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine2, 181–185.
31.
CellotiL., and BianchiV. (1990). Applications of human peripheral blood lymphocytes in genotoxicity and cytotoxicity.ATLA18, 231–241.
32.
AmesB.N. (1979). Identifying environmental chemicals causing mutations and cancer.Science (New York)204, 587–593.
33.
HoldenH.E. (1982). Comparison of somatic and germ cell models for cytogenetic screening.Journal of Applied Toxicology2, 196–200.
34.
WatahaJ.C., HanksC.T., and CraigR.C. (1993). The effect of cell monolayer density on the cytotoxicity of metal ions which are released from dental alloys.Dental Materials9, 172–176.
35.
TracanaR.B., PereiraM.L., AbreuA.M., SousaJ.P., and CarvalhoG.S. (1995). Stainless steel corrosion products cause alterations on mouse spleen cellular populations.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine6, 56–61.
36.
DionI., BordenaveL., LefebreF., BareilleR., BaqueyC., MontiesJ.R., and HavlikP. (1994). Physicochemistry and cytotoxicity of ceramics. Part III. Cytotoxicity of ceramics.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 18–24.
37.
DionI., LahayeM., SalmonR., BaqueyC., MontiesJ.R., and HavlikP. (1993). Blood haemolysis by ceramics.Biomaterials14, 107–110.
38.
SchendelK.U., LenhardtM., FusenigN.E., and KomposchG. (1992). Testung der Toxizität von in der Kieferorthopädie verwendeten Kunststoffen.Fortschritte in der Kieferorthopädie53, 263–272.
39.
GrothT., and AltankovG. (1995). Fibroblast spreading and proliferation on hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces is related to tyrosine phosphorylation in focal contacts.Journal of Biomaterials Science, Polymer Edition7, 297–305.
40.
ErtelS.I., RatnerB.D., KaulA., SchwayM.B., and HorbettT.A. (1994). In vitro study of the intrinsic toxicity of synthetic surfaces to cells.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research28, 667–675.
41.
RosenbluthS.A., WeddingtonG.R., GuessW.L., and AutianJ. (1965). Tissue culture method for screening toxicity of plastic materials to be used in medical practice.Journal of Pharmacological Science54, 156–159.
42.
GuessW.L., RosenbluthS.A., SchmidtB., and AutianJ. (1965). Agar diffusion method for toxicity screening of plastics on cultured cell monolayers.Journal of Pharmacological Science54, 1545–1547.
43.
WennbergA., HasselgrenG., and TronstadL. (1979). A method for toxicity screening of bio-materials using cells cultured on Millipore filters.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research13, 109–120.
44.
HanksC.T., DiehlM.L., CraigR.G., MakinenP.L., and PashleyD.A. (1989). Characterization of the “in vitro pulp” chamber using the cytotoxicity of phenol.Journal of Oral Pathology18, 97–104.
45.
SchmalzG. (1992). Characterization of a simple dentine barrier test.Journal of Dental Research71, 599–607.
46.
Anon. (1994). ISO-10993: biological evaluation of medical devices — Part 12: sample preparation and reference materials.London: International Organisation for Standardisation.
47.
EloyR., PicardC., BellevilleJ., and BouetT. (1992). Biocompatibility evaluation of reference materials. In The Reference Materials of the European Communities: Results of Haemocompatibility Tests (ed. LemmW.), pp. 237–248. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publisher.
48.
SchmalzG. (1980). A cell culture method for screening the biocompatibility of dental materials. In Biomaterials (ed. WinterG.D., GibbonsD.F., PlenkH.), pp. 321–326. New York: J. Wiley & Sons.
49.
HanksC.T., AndersonM., and CraigR.G. (1981). Cytotoxic effects of dental cements on two cell culture systems.Journal of Oral Rehabilitation10, 101–112.
50.
TrommlerA., FriebelJ., and JahrH. (1989). Untersuchungen zur in vitro Biokompatibilität von Haftvermittlern für den stomatologischen Metall-Plast-Verbund.Wissenschaftliche Zeitschrift der Humbuldt Universität Berlin, Medizinische Reihe38, 293–295.
51.
KirkpatrickC.J., and MittermayerC. (1990). Theoretical and practical aspects of testing potential biomaterials in vitro.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine1, 9–13.
52.
JohnsonH.J., NorthupS.J., SeagravesP.A., AtallahM., GarvinP.J., LinL., and DarbyT.D. (1985). Biocompatibility test procedures for materials evaluation in vitro. II. Objective methods of toxicity assessment.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research19, 489–508.
53.
Hensten-PettersenA., and HelgelandK. (1991). Sensitivity of different human cell lines in the biologic evaluation of dental resin-based restorative materials.Scandinavian Journal of Dental Research89, 102–107.
54.
BraunerA., and KadenP. (1989). Die Zellkultur humaner Gingivalfibroblasten zur biologischen Prüfung von in der Mundhöhle verwendeten materialien.Stomatologic8, 533–538.
55.
LehmannF., LeyhausenG., SpahlW., and GeurtsenW. (1993). Vergleichende Zellkultur-Untersuchungen von Kompositbestandteilen auf Zytotoxizität.Deutsche Zahnärztliche Zeitschrift48, 651–653.
56.
MassasR., PitaruS., and WeinrebM.M. (1993). The effects of titanium and hydroxyapatite on osteoblastic expression and proliferation in rat parietal bone cultures.Journal of Dental Research72, 1005–1008.
BorenfreundE., and PuernerJ.A. (1985). Toxicity determined in vitro by morphological alterations and neutral red absorption.Toxicology Letters24, 119–124.
59.
FunaK., DawsonN., JewettP.B., AgrenH., RuckdeschelJ.C., BunnP.A., and GazdarA.F. (1986). Automated fluorescence analysis for drug-induced cytotoxicity assays.Cancer Treatment Reports70, 1147–1151.
60.
JohnsonH.J., NorthupS.J., SeagravesP.A., GarvinP.J., and WallinR.F. (1983). Biocompatib-ility test procedures for materials evaluation in vitro. I. Comparative test system sensitivity.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research17, 571–586.
61.
CiapettiG., SteaS., CenniE., SudaneseA., MarraroD., ToniA., and PizzoferratoA. (1994). Cytotoxicity testing of cyanoacrylates using direct contact assay on cell cultures.Biomaterials15, 63–67.
62.
DionI., BaqueyC., MontiesJ.R., and HavlikP. (1993). Haemocompatibility of Ti6A14V alloy.Biomaterials14, 122–126.
63.
PelusoG., PetilloO., AmbrosioL., and NicolaisL. (1994). Polyetherimide as biomaterial: preliminary in vitro and in vivo biocompatibility testing.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 738–742.
MosmannT. (1983). Rapid colorimetric assay for cellular growth and survival: application to proliferation and cytotoxicity assays.Journal of Immunological Methods65, 55–63.
66.
SgourasD., and DuncanR. (1990). Methods for the evaluation of biocompatibility of soluble synthetic polymers which have potential for biomedical use. I. Use of the tetrazolium-based colorimetric assay (MTT) as a preliminary screen for evaluation of in vitro cytotoxicity.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine1, 61–68.
67.
CiapettiG., CenniE., PratelliL., and PizzoferratoA. (1993). In vitro evaluation of cell/biomaterial interaction by MTT assay.Biomaterials14, 359–364.
68.
DekkerA., HermannsM.I., ValdorM., and KirkpatrickC.J. (1992). Quantitative evaluation of cytotoxicity in vitro of extracts from standard biomaterials. In The Reference Materials of the European Communities: Results of Haemocompatibility Tests (ed. LemmW.), pp. 201–210. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publisher.
69.
BordenaveL., JanvierG., BareilleR., PelletF., RouaisF., AmédéeJ., and BaqueyC. (1992). An in vitro study of a cuff of an endotracheal tube using human tracheal epithelial cells. In Advances in Biomaterials, Vol. 10, Biomaterials–Tissue Interfaces (ed. DohertyP., WilliamsR.L., WilliamsD.F., LeeA.J.C.), pp. 1–6. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
WanH., WilliamsR.L., DohertyP., and WilliamsD.F. (1994). The cytotoxicity evaluation of Kevlar and silicon carbide by MTT assay.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 441–445.
72.
WanH., WilliamsR.L., DohertyP.J., and WilliamsD.F. (1994). A study of the reproducibility of the MTT test.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine5, 154–159.
73.
RoehmN.W., RodgersG.H., HatfieldS.M., and GlasebrookA. (1991). An improved colorimetric assay for cell proliferation and viability utilizing the tetrazolium salt XTT.Journal of Immunological Methods142, 257–265.
74.
AllenP.D., BustinS.A., and NewlandA.C. (1993). The role of apoptosis (programmed cell death) in haemopoiesis and the immune system.Blood Reviews7, 63–73.
75.
ArendsM.J., MorrisR.G., and WyllieA.H. (1990). Apoptosis: the role of endonuclease.American Journal of Pathology136, 593–608.
76.
LeistM., GantnerF., BohlingerL., TiegsG., and WendelA. (1994). Einsatz des BM Cell Death ELISA zur Detektion von TNF-induzierter DNA-Fragmentierung in Organhomogenisaten von Mäuselebern.Boehringer Mannheim Biochemica Information93, 14–15.
77.
PerottiM., TaddeiF., MirabelliF., and BellomoG. (1991). In vitro models for biochemical investigations on programmed cell death.ATLA19, 71–76.
78.
GrothT., AltankovG., and KloszK. (1994). Adhesion of human peripheral blood lymphocytes is dependent on surface wettability and protein pre-adsorption.Biomaterials15, 423–428.
79.
DuvalJ.L., Warocquier-CleroutR., & Sigot-LuizardM.F. (1992). Comparative assessment of the cytotoxicity of various substrates in organ culture and cell culture: a scanning electron microscopy study.Cells and Materials2, 179–192.
80.
KjellstrandP., and BobergU. (1991). Testing of polymer materials: what method should be used.ATLA19, 222–225.
81.
ChawlaA.S. (1992). Toxicity evaluation of a novel filler free silicone rubber biomaterial by cell culture techniques.Journal of Biomedical Materials Research16, 501–508.
82.
ValtolinaM., and ForsterR. (1991). Induction of cytoplasmic vacuolation by two alkyldiamine compounds.ATLA19, 30–38.
83.
TillmanU., PolletD., and MiltenburgerH.G. (1989). Scoring of cytotoxicity by image analysis using animal cell cultures.ATLA17, 109–127.
84.
LeungT., KakarA., HobkirkJ.A., and ThorogoodP. (1994). Behaviour of fibroblasts during initial attachment to a glass-ceramic implant material in vitro: a time-lapse video micrographic study.Biomaterials15, 1001–1007.
85.
ShawA.J. (1994). Defining cell viability and cytotoxicity.ATLA22, 124–126.
KastenF.H., FelderS.M., GettlemanL., and AlchediakT. (1982). A model culture system with human gingival fibroblasts for evaluating the cytotoxicity of dental materials.In Vitro18, 650–660.
88.
CiapettiG., SteaS., CenniE., SudaneseA., MarraroD., ToniA., and PizzoferratoA. (1994). Toxicity of cyanoacrylates in vitro Using extract dilution assay on cell cultures.Biomaterials15, 445–502.
89.
WennbergA. (1976). An in vitro method for toxicity evaluation of water-soluble substances.Acta Odontologica Scandinavica34, 33–41.
90.
CarvalhoG.S., and BravoI. (1993). In vitro immuno-cytotoxicity of iron evaluated by DNA synthesis of human T lymphocytes stimulated via CD2 and CD3.Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine4, 366–371.
91.
FalkenU., and UngerC. (1994). Einfluß von oxidiertem Sterol auf die Zellproliferation von Tumorzellinien: Kritischer Vergleich zwischen radioaktivem Thymidineinbau und einer neuen, modifizierten nichtradioaktiven Methode.Boehringer Mannheim Biochemica Information93, 16–19.
92.
DekkerA., PennartzG., PanfilC., ValdorM., MittermayerC., and KirkpatrickC.J. (1994). Bestimmung des Einbaus von Bromdesoxyuridin als Parameter bei der Zytotoxizitätsprüfung von Biomaterialien.Boehringer Mannheim Biochemica Information94, 14–16.
93.
JohnsonH.J., and NorthupS.J. (1983). Tissue culture biocompatibility testing program. In Cell Culture Test Methods, ASTM STP 810 (ed. BrownS.A.), pp. 25–34. Philadelphia, PA, USA: American Society for Testing and Materials.
