Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2018-8
If you build it will they come? The boom in purpose-built student accommodation in central Liverpool: Destudentification,studentification and the future of the city
The wave of UK higher education expansion and the commodification of the student experience have reshaped many towns and cities not least in the development of large swathes of private purpose-built student accommodation. A growing body of research has explored the role of purpose-built student accommodation in the processes of studentification and destudentification of neighbourhoods. This study explores the huge and rapid development of purpose-built student accommodation in Liverpool and, for the first time, raises questions not just about its impacts but about its sustainability. The model upon which many of Liverpool’s purpose-built student accommodation projects are based generates hidden risks and carries a momentum that neglects wider market conditions. We conclude that there will be a disorderly end to Liverpool’s purpose-built student accommodation boom and consider the likely implications for a range of stakeholders.
AdamsRHallR (2018) Vice chancellors fear for financial outlook of UK higher education. Guardian, 1 February.
2.
AkerlofGASchillerRJ (2009) Animal Spirits.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
3.
AllinsonJ (2006)
Over-educated, over-exuberant and over here? The impact of students on cities. Planning, Practice & Research21(1): 79–94.
4.
AndertonD (2017)
Changing leadership in a peripheral city region development: The case of Liverpool’s high technology sectors. Local Economy32: 352–373.
5.
Atlantic Gateway (2012) Business Plan.
Manchester:
Atlantic Gateway.
6.
BagaeenS (2007)
Brand Dubai: The instant city; or the instantly recognizable city. International Planning Studies12: 173–197.
7.
Barnes Y and Tostevin P (2014) Spotlight: World Student Housing. London: Savills.
8.
BolandP (2007)
Unpacking the theory–policy interface of local economic development: An analysis of Cardiff and Liverpool. Urban Studies44: 1019–1039.
9.
BolandP (2010)
‘Capital of culture – You must be having a laugh!’ Challenging the official rhetoric of Liverpool as the 2008 European cultural capital. Social and Cultural Geography11: 627–645.
10.
Boundary Committee for England (2003) Final recommendations on the future electoral arrangements for Liverpool City. Report to the Electoral Commission.
London:
HMSO.
11.
ChattertonP (1999)
Exclusive geographies: University students in the city. Geoforum30: 117–133.
12.
ChattertonP (2010)
Commentary. Environment and Planning A42: 509–514.
13.
ChowdryHDeardenLGoodmanAet al. (2012)
The distributional impact of the 2012–13 higher education funding reforms in England. Fiscal Studies33: 211–235.
CocksM (2016)
Urban entrepreneurialism, global networks and export support: Are UK cities looking east?Local Economy31: 690–708.
16.
CookR (2017) How Liverpool’s ‘New Chinatown’ became a black hole for Asian money. Asia Times, 31 August.
17.
CurryR (2017) Student housing may be a property bubble in waiting. Daily Telegraph, 18 September.
18.
Cushman and Wakefield (2017) UK Student Accommodation Report 2016/17.
London:
Cushman and Wakefield.
19.
DembskiSSchulze BäingASykesO (2017)
What about the urban periphery? The effects of the urban renaissance in the Mersey belt. Comparative Population Studies42: 219–244.
20.
EvansR (2002)
The Merseyside objective one programme: Exemplar of coherent city-regional planning and governance or cautionary tale?European Planning Studies10: 495–517.
21.
GarciaBMelvilleRCoxT (2010) Creating an Impact: Liverpool’s Experience as European Capital of Culture.
Liverpool:
Impacts 08.
22.
GlynAHJ (1980) The British Economic Disaster.
London:
Pluto Press.
23.
HaleT (2018) Investors line up to fund living quarters for students. Financial Times,
13 March.
24.
HarrisonJ (2012)
Life after regions? The evolution of city regionalism in England. Regional Studies46: 1243–1259.
25.
HarrisonJ (2014)
The rise of the non-state ‘place-based’ economic development strategy. Local Economy29: 453–468.
26.
HearnGL (2016) Liverpool Strategic Housing Market Assessment.
Manchester:
GL Hearn.
HoldsworthC (2008)
Between two worlds: Local students in higher education and ‘scouse’/student identities. Population, Space and Place15: 225–237.
29.
HoughtonA (2018) New Chinatown site is a ‘disgrace’ with rats and litter say furious residents. Liverpool Echo, 21 January.
30.
HubbardP (2008)
Regulating the social impacts of studentification: A Loughborough case study. Environment and Planning A40: 323–341.
31.
HubbardP (2009)
Geographies of studentification and purpose-built student accommodation. Leading separate lives?Environment and Planning A48: 1617–1635.
32.
HulseKMartinCJamesAet al. (2018) Private rental in transition: Institutional change, technology and innovation in Australia. AHURI Final Report No. 296.
Melbourne:
Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited.
KenyonEL (1997)
Seasonal sub-communities the impact of student households on residential communities. British Journal of Sociology48(2): 286–301.
35.
KintonCSmithDPHarrisonJ (2016)
De-studentification: Emptying housing and neighbourhoods of student populations. Environment and Planning A41: 1805–1825.
36.
Knight Frank (2017) UK Student Housing Update.
London:
Knight Frank.
37.
LaneT (1987) Liverpool: Gateway of Empire.
London:
Lawrence and Wishart.
38.
Liverpool City Council (2016) The Draft Liverpool Local Plan.
Liverpool:
Liverpool City Council.
LunnE (2014) Student ‘digs’ offer a harsh lesson for investors. Daily Telegraph, 28 May.
45.
MacintyreC (2003)
New models of student housing and their impact on local communities. Journal of Higher Education and Policy Management25: 109–119.
46.
MeeganR (2003) Urban regeneration, politics and social cohesion: The Liverpool case. In: MunckR (ed) Reinventing the City: Liverpool in Comparative Perspective.
Liverpool:
Liverpool University Press, pp. 53–79.
47.
MeeganRKennettPJonesGet al. (2014)
Global economic crisis, austerity and neoliberal urban governance in England. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society7: 137–153.
48.
MunroMTurokILivingstonM (2009)
Students in cities: A preliminary analysis of their patterns and effects. Environment and Planning A41: 1805–1825.
49.
NorthP (2017)
Local economies of Brexit. Local Economy32: 204–218.
50.
Nurse A (2015) Creating the north from the sum of its parts? Research questions to assess the Northern Powerhouse. Local Economy 30: 689–701.
51.
NurseA (2017)
City Centre regeneration to drive economic competitiveness? The case study of Liverpool one. LHI Journal of Land, Housing and Urban Affairs8: 91–102.
52.
NurseAFultonM (2017)
Delivering strategic economic development in a time of urban austerity: European Union structural funds and the English city regions. Local Economy32: 164–182.
53.
ONS Digital (2016) How has the student population changed? ONS Digital, 20 September.
54.
ParkinsonM (1985) Liverpool on the Brink.
London:
Hermitage.
55.
ParkinsonMEvansRMeeganRet al. (2016) The State of Liverpool City Region Report: Making the Most of Devolution.
Liverpool:
University of Liverpool, Liverpool John Moores University.
56.
ReesJLordA (2013)
Making space: Putting politics back where it belongs in the construction of city regions in the North of England. Local Economy28: 679–695.
57.
RuiuML (2017)
Collaborative management of studentification processes: The case of Newcastle upon Tyne. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment32: 843–857.
58.
SageJSmithDHubbardP (2012a)
The rapidity of studentification and population change: There goes the (student)hood. Population, Space and Place18: 597–613.
59.
SageJSmithDHubbardP (2012b)
The diverse geographies of studentification: Living alongside people not likeus. Housing Studies27: 1057–1078.
60.
SageJSmithDHubbardP (2013)
New-build studentification: A panacea for balanced communities?Urban Studies50: 2623–2641.
SmithDP (2002)
Patterns and process of ‘studentification’ in Leeds. Regional Review12: 14–16.
64.
SmithD (2005) Studentification: The gentrification factory? In: AtkinsonRBridgeG (eds) The New Urban Colonialism: Gentrification in a Global Context.
London:
Routledge, pp. 72–89.
65.
SmithD (2008)
The politics of studentification and (un)balanced urban populations: Lessons for gentrification and sustainable communities?Urban Studies45: 2541–2564.
66.
SmithDPHoltL (2007)
Studentification and ‘apprentice’ gentrifiers within Britain’s provincial towns and cities: Extending the meaning of gentrification. Environment and Planning A39: 142–161.
67.
SmithDPHubbardP (2014)
The segregation of educated youth and dynamic geographies of studentification. Area46: 92–100.
68.
Sodexo (2016) The Sodexo University Lifestyle Survey 2016.
London:
Sodexo with Times Higher Education.
69.
UCAS (2016) End of Cycle Report 2016.
Cheltenham:
UCAS.
70.
UKCSIA (2017) International Student Statistics: UK Higher Education.
London:
UKCSIA.
