Despite recommendations, people with heart failure have poor access to palliative care.
Aim:
To identify the evidence in relation to palliative care for people with symptomatic heart failure.
Design:
Systematic review and narrative synthesis. (PROSPERO CRD42016029911)
Data sources:
Databases (Medline, Cochrane database, CINAHL, PsycINFO, HMIC, CareSearch Grey Literature), reference lists and citations were searched and experts contacted. Two independent reviewers screened titles and abstracts and retrieved papers against inclusion criteria. Data were extracted from included papers and studies were critically assessed using a risk of bias tool according to design.
Results:
Thirteen interventional and 10 observational studies were included. Studies were heterogeneous in terms of population, intervention, comparator, outcomes and design rendering combination inappropriate. The evaluation phase studies, with lower risk of bias, using a multi-disciplinary specialist palliative care intervention showed statistically significant benefit for patient-reported outcomes (symptom burden, depression, functional status, quality of life), resource use and costs of care. Benefit was not seen in studies with a single component/discipline intervention or with higher risk of bias. Possible contamination in some studies may have caused under-estimation of effect and missing data may have introduced bias. There was no apparent effect on survival.
Conclusion:
Overall, the results support the use of multi-disciplinary palliative care in people with advanced heart failure but trials do not identify who would benefit most from specialist palliative referral. There are no sufficiently robust multi-centre evaluation phase trials to provide generalisable findings. Use of common population, intervention and outcomes in future research would allow meta-analysis.
MehtaPADubreySWMcIntyreHF, et al. Improving survival in the 6 months after diagnosis of heart failure in the past decade: population-based data from the UK. Heart2009; 95(22): 1851–1856.
2.
MitchellPMarleDDonkorA, et al. National heart failure audit, April 2013–March 2014. London: NICOR (National Institute for Cardiovascular Outcomes Research) and The British Society for Heart Failure (BSH), 2015.
3.
CostanzoMRMillsRMWynneJ.Characteristics of ‘stage D’ heart failure: insights from the acute decompensated heart failure national registry longitudinal module (ADHERE LM). Am Heart J2008; 155(2): 339–347.
4.
IqbalJFrancisLReidJ, et al. Quality of life in patients with chronic heart failure and their carers: a 3-year follow-up study assessing hospitalization and mortality. Eur J Heart Fail2010; 12(9): 1002–1008.
5.
GoodlinSJHauptmanPJArnoldR, et al. Consensus statement: palliative and supportive care in advanced heart failure. J Card Fail2004; 10(3): 200–209.
6.
HagaKMurraySReidJ, et al. Identifying community based chronic heart failure patients in the last year of life: a comparison of the Gold Standards Framework Prognostic Indicator Guide and the Seattle Heart Failure Model. Heart2012; 98(7): 579–583.
7.
HollingworthWBiswasMMaishmanRL, et al. The healthcare costs of heart failure during the last five years of life: a retrospective cohort study. Int J Cardiol2016; 224: 132–138.
8.
World Health Organization. WHO definition of palliative care, 2002. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2011.
9.
VanbutseleGPardonKVan BelleS, et al. Effect of early and systematic integration of palliative care in patients with advanced cancer: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Oncol2018; 19(3): 394–404.
10.
HigginsonIJBauseweinCReillyCC, et al. An integrated palliative and respiratory care service for patients with advanced disease and refractory breathlessness: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Respir Med2014; 2(12): 979–987.
11.
SmithSBrickAO’HaraS, et al. Evidence on the cost and cost-effectiveness of palliative care: a literature review. Palliat Med2014; 28(2): 130–150.
12.
HigginsonIJFinlayIGGoodwinDM, et al. Is there evidence that palliative care teams alter end-of-life experiences of patients and their caregivers. J Pain Symptom Manage2003; 25(2): 150–168.
13.
National Institute of Clinical Excellence. Chronic heart failure in adults. NICE Quality Standard [QS9], 2011, https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs9
14.
BraunLTGradyKLKutnerJS, et al. Palliative care and cardiovascular disease and stroke: a policy statement from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association. Circulation2016; 134(11): e198–e225.
15.
McKelvieRSMoeGWCheungA, et al. The 2011 Canadian Cardiovascular Society heart failure management guidelines update: focus on sleep apnea, renal dysfunction, mechanical circulatory support, and palliative care. Can J Cardiol2011; 27(3): 319–338.
16.
GadoudAKaneEMacleodU, et al. Palliative care among heart failure patients in primary care: a comparison to cancer patients using English family practice data. PLoS ONE2014; 9(11): e113188.
17.
GreenerDTQuillTAmirO, et al. Palliative care referral among patients hospitalized with advanced heart failure. J Palliat Med2014; 17(10): 1115–1120.
18.
BarclaySMomenNCase-UptonS, et al. End-of-life care conversations with heart failure patients: a systematic literature review and narrative synthesis. Br J Gen Pract2011; 61(582): e49–e62.
19.
CraigPDieppePMacintyreS, et al. Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidance. BMJ2008; 337: a1655.
20.
AikenLSButnerJLockhartCA, et al. Outcome evaluation of a randomized trial of the PhoenixCare intervention: program of case management and coordinated care for the seriously chronically ill. J Palliat Med2006; 9(1): 111–126.
21.
BekelmanDBPlomondonMECareyEP, et al. Primary results of the Patient-Centered Disease Management (PCDM) for heart failure study: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Intern Med2015; 175(5): 725–732.
22.
BrännströmMBomanK.Effects of person-centred and integrated chronic heart failure and palliative home care. PREFER: a randomized controlled study. Eur J Heart Fail2014; 16(10): 1142–1151.
23.
HoppFPZalenskiRJWaselewskyD, et al. Results of a hospital-based palliative care intervention for patients with an acute exacerbation of chronic heart failure. J Card Fail2016; 22: 1033–1036.
24.
RogersJGPatelCBMentzRJ, et al. Palliative care in heart failure: the PAL-HF randomized, controlled clinical trial. J Am Coll Cardiol2017; 70(3): 331–341.
25.
SahlenK-GBomanKBrännströmM.A cost-effectiveness study of person-centered integrated heart failure and palliative home care: based on a randomized controlled trial. Palliat Med2016; 30: 296–302.
26.
SidebottomACJorgensonARichardsH, et al. Inpatient palliative care for patients with acute heart failure: outcomes from a randomized trial. J Palliat Med2015; 18(2): 134–142.
27.
WongFKYNgAYMLeePH, et al. Effects of a transitional palliative care model on patients with end-stage heart failure: a randomised controlled trial. Heart2016; 102: 1100–1108.
28.
PaesP.A pilot study to assess the effectiveness of a palliative care clinic in improving the quality of life for patients with severe heart failure. Palliat Med2005; 19(6): 505–506.
29.
BakitasMDionne-OdomJNPamboukianSV, et al. Engaging patients and families to create a feasible clinical trial integrating palliative and heart failure care: results of the ENABLE CHF-PC pilot clinical trial. BMC Palliat Care2017; 16(1): 45.
30.
O’DonnellAESchaeferKGStevensonLW, et al. Social worker–aided palliative care intervention in high-risk patients with heart failure (SWAP-HF): a pilot randomized clinical trial. JAMA Cardiol2018; 3: 516–519.
31.
JohnsonMJMcSkimmingPMcConnachieA, et al. The feasibility of a randomised controlled trial to compare the cost-effectiveness of palliative cardiology or usual care in people with advanced heart failure: two exploratory prospective cohorts. Palliat Med2018; 32(6): 1133–1141.
32.
TadwalkarRUdeojiDUWeinerRJ, et al. The beneficial role of spiritual counseling in heart failure patients. J Relig Health2014; 53(5): 1575–1585.
33.
ConnorSRPyensonBFitchK, et al. Comparing hospice and nonhospice patient survival among patients who die within a three-year window. J Pain Symptom Manage2007; 33(3): 238–246.
34.
EnguidanosSMCherinDBrumleyR.Home-based palliative care study: site of death, and costs of medical care for patients with congestive heart failure, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and cancer. J Soc Work End Life Palliat Care2005; 1(3): 37–56.
35.
PattendenJFMasonARLewinR.Collaborative palliative care for advanced heart failure: outcomes and costs from the ‘better together’ pilot study. BMJ Support Palliat Care2013; 3(1): 69–76.
36.
EvangelistaLSLiaoSMotieM, et al. On-going palliative care enhances perceived control and patient activation and reduces symptom distress in patients with symptomatic heart failure: a pilot study. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2014; 13(2): 116–123.
37.
EvangelistaLSLiaoSMotieM, et al. Does the type and frequency of palliative care services received by patients with advanced heart failure impact symptom burden. J Palliat Med2014; 17(1): 75–79.
38.
TaylorGJLeeDMBaicuCF, et al. Palliative care for advanced heart failure in a Department of Veterans Affairs regional hospice program: patient selection, a treatment protocol, and clinical course. J Palliat Med2017; 20(10): 1068–1073.
39.
WongRTanPTSeowYH, et al. Home-based advance care programme is effective in reducing hospitalisations of advanced heart failure patients: a clinical and healthcare cost study. Ann Acad Med Singapore2013; 42(9): 466–471.
40.
Brian CasselJKerrKMMcClishDK, et al. Effect of a home-based palliative care program on healthcare use and costs. J Am Geriatr Soc2016; 64(11): 2288–2295.
41.
EvangelistaLSLombardoDMalikS, et al. Examining the effects of an outpatient palliative care consultation on symptom burden, depression, and quality of life in patients with symptomatic heart failure. J Card Fail2012; 18(12): 894–899.
42.
BleckerSAndersonGFHerbertR, et al. Hospice care and resource utilization in Medicare beneficiaries with heart failure. Med Care2011; 49(11): 985–991.
43.
HussainJABlandMLanganD, et al. Quality of missing data reporting and handling in palliative care trials demonstrates that further development of the CONSORT statement is required: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol2017; 88: 81–91.
44.
McPhersonSBarbosa-LeikerCMcDonellM, et al. Longitudinal missing data strategies for substance use clinical trials using generalized estimating equations: an example with a buprenorphine trial. Hum Psychopharmacol2013; 28(5): 506–515.
45.
JaarsmaTBeattieJMRyderM, et al. Palliative care in heart failure: a position statement from the palliative care workshop of the Heart Failure Association of the European Society of Cardiology. Eur J Heart Fail2009; 11(5): 433–443.
46.
LewinWHSchaeferKG.Integrating palliative care into routine care of patients with heart failure: models for clinical collaboration. Heart Fail Rev2017; 22(5): 517–524.
47.
CampbellRTPetrieMCJacksonCE, et al. Which patients with heart failure should receive specialist palliative care. Eur J Heart Fail2018; 20: 1338–1347.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
