Land use plans, a crucial component of statutory master plans, are often deemed failures. To test this hypothesis, an ex-post evaluation of seven master plans from five Indian million-plus cities was conducted using percentage implementation (PI) and conformance variation (CV) as evaluation factors to ascertain variation between proposed and subsequent existing land uses. Contrary to master plans, a significant difference in CV was observed among land uses after performing analysis of variance (ANOVA) across all master plans and land use categories. Post hoc tests revealed that residential, governmental/public and semi-public, industrial, and overall developed/urbanized areas grew relatively as expected compared to recreational use.
AlexanderErnest. 2009. “Dilemmas in Evaluating Planning, or Back to Basics: What Is Planning for?”Planning Theory and Practice10 (2): 233–44. doi:10.1080/14649350902884177.
2.
AltesWillem K. Korthals. 2006. “Stagnation in Housing Production: Another Success in the Dutch ‘Planner’s Paradise?’”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design33 (1): 97–114. doi:10.1068/b31192.
3.
BapatMeera. 1983. “Hutments and City.”Economic and Political Weekly18 (11): 399–401.
4.
BediPrabhTripathiNeha GoelSinghH. B.2019. Smart Tourism Innovations for Smart Region, Case of Jaipur Metropolitan Region, India. Advances in 21st Century Human Settlements. Jaipur: Springer Singapore. doi:10.1007/978-981-10-8588-8_9.
5.
BerkePhilipBackhurstMichaelDayMaxineEricksenNeilLaurianLucieCrawfordJanDixonJennifer. 2006. “What Makes Plan Implementation Successful? An Evaluation of Local Plans and Implementation Practices in New Zealand.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design33 (4): 581–600. doi:10.1068/b31166.
6.
BerkePhilipGodschalkDavid. 2009. “Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-Analysis of Plan Quality Studies.”Journal of Planning Literature23 (3): 227–40. doi:10.1177/0885412208327014.
7.
BhanGautam. 2013. “Planned Illegalities: Housing and the ‘failure’ of Planning in Delhi: 1947-2010.”Economic and Political Weekly48 (24): 58–70.
8.
BharuleShreyas P.KidokoroTetsuo. 2017. “Indian Cities in Transition.”International Conference of Asian-Pacific Planning Societies ICAPPS.
9.
BrodySamuel D.HighfieldWesley E.2005. “Does Planning Work? Testing the Implementation of Local Environmental Planning in Florida.”Journal of the American Planning Association71 (2): 159–75. doi:10.1080/01944360508976690.
10.
BrodySamuel D.HighfieldWesley E.ThorntonSara. 2006. “Planning at the Urban Fringe: An Examination of the Factors Influencing Nonconforming Development Patterns in Southern Florida.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design33 (1): 75–96. doi:10.1068/b31093.
11.
BrownGregKyttäMarkettaReedPat. 2022. “Using Community Surveys with Participatory Mapping to Monitor Comprehensive Plan Implementation.”Landscape and Urban Planning218: 104306. doi:10.1016/j.landurbplan.2021.104306.
12.
BultiDejene TesemaSoriNegera Dinsa. 2017. “Evaluating Land-Use Plan Using Conformance-Based Approach in Adama City, Ethiopia.”Spatial Information Research25 (4): 605–13. doi:10.1007/s41324-017-0125-3.
13.
BurbyRaymond J.2003. “Making Plans That Matter: Citizen Involvement and Government Action.”Journal of the American Planning Association69 (1): 33–49. doi:10.1080/01944360308976292.
14.
CalkinsH. W.1979. “The Planning Monitor: An Accountability Theory of Plan Evaluation.”Environment and Planning A11 (7): 745–58. doi:10.1068/a110745.
15.
ChapinTimothy S.DeyleRobert E.BakerEarl J.2008. “A Parcel-Based GIS Method for Evaluating Conformance of Local Land-Use Planning with a State Mandate to Reduce Exposure to Hurricane Flooding.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design35 (2): 261–79. doi:10.1068/b32114.
16.
ChendrayuduN.ChandrasekarayyaT.2020. “Trend and Growth Pattern of Population in Million Plus Cities of India- An Overview.”Geo Eye9 (1): 8–15. doi:10.53989/bu.ge.v9i1.3.
17.
DasKailash C.2013. “The Growing Number and Size of Towns/Cities in India: Emerging Issues from 2011 Census Data.”International Union for the Scientific Study of Population13.
18.
DeU. S.SoniV. K.2009. “Climate Change, Urbanization–What Citizens Can Do.”Journal of Indian Geophysical Union13 (1): 43–48.
19.
Directorate of Town and Country Planning Madhya Pradesh. 2021. Indore Development Plan 2021. Indore: Directorate of Town and Country Planning Madhya Pradesh.
20.
FaludiAndreas. 1989. “Conformance vs. Performance: Implications for Evaluation.”Impact Assessment7 (2–3): 135–51. doi:10.1080/07349165.1989.9726017.
21.
FaludiAndreas. 2000. “The Performance of Spatial Planning.”Planning Practice and Research15 (4): 299–318. doi:10.1080/713691907.
22.
FinneranKevin. 2009. “Five-Year Plans.”Issues in Science and Technology25 (4): 21–22. doi:10.1176/pn.45.12.psychnews_45_12_009.
23.
GebhardtAmberEaglesPaul F. J.2014. “Factors Leading to the Implementation of Strategic Plans for Parks and Recreation.”Managing Leisure19 (5): 321–44. doi:10.1080/13606719.2014.895127.
24.
GuyadeenDaveSeasonsMark. 2016. “Plan Evaluation: Challenges and Directions for Future Research.”Planning Practice and Research31 (2): 215–28. doi:10.1080/02697459.2015.1081335.
25.
GuyadeenDaveSeasonsMark. 2018. “Evaluation Theory and Practice: Comparing Program Evaluation and Evaluation in Planning.”Journal of Planning Education and Research38 (1): 98–110. doi:10.1177/0739456X16675930.
26.
HanHao YingLaiShih KungDangAn RongTanZong BoWuCi Fang. 2009. “Effectiveness of Urban Construction Boundaries in Beijing: An Assessment.”Journal of Zhejiang University: Science A10 (9): 1285–95. doi:10.1631/jzus.A0920317.
27.
HaoPuSliuzasRichardZhanQingmingGeertmanStan. 2009. “Land Use Deviations from the Plan: A GIS Based Analysis of Urban Development in Shenzhen.” In The 11th International Conference on Computers in Urban Planning and Urban Management, 1–17. Hong Kong.
28.
HeJinghuan. 2015. Evaluation of Plan Implementation. China: Delft University of Technology.
29.
HerspergerAnna M.OliveiraEduardoPagliarinSofiaPalkaGaëtanVerburgPeterBolligerJanineGrădinaruSimona. 2018. “Urban Land-Use Change: The Role of Strategic Spatial Planning.”Global Environmental Change51 (June 2017): 32–42. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.05.001.
JainManishaKorzhenevychArtem. 2020. “Urbanisation as the Rise of Census Towns in India: An Outcome of Traditional Master Planning?”Cities99 (February): 102627. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2020.102627.
32.
Jaipur Development Authority. 1998. Master Development Plan 2011. Jaipur: Government of Rajasthan.
33.
Jaipur Development Authority. 2011. Master Development Plan-2025 Jaipur Region. Jaipur: Government of Rajasthan.
JitenderJitenderKalotraGaurav. 2021. “Internal Migration in India: A Trend of Million-Plus Cities in 2011.”Scholars Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences9 (9): 422–29. doi:10.36347/sjahss.2021.v09i09.006.
36.
KaiserEdward J.GodschalkDavid R.1995. “Twentieth Century Land Use Planning: A Stalwart Family Tree.”Journal of the American Planning Association61 (3): 365–85. doi:10.1080/01944369508975648.
37.
LakshmanaC. M.2014. “Dynamics of Urban Growth, Resource Degradation and Environmental Pollution in Million plus Cities of India.”Environment and Urbanization ASIA5 (1): 49–61. doi:10.1177/0975425314521532.
38.
LaurianLucieCrawfordJanDayMaxineKouwenhovenPeterMasonGregEricksenNeilBeattieLee. 2010. “Evaluating the Outcomes of Plans: Theory, Practice, and Methodology.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design37 (4): 740–57. doi:10.1068/b35051.
39.
LaurianLucieDayMaxineBackhurstMichaelBerkePhilipEricksenNeilCrawfordJanDixonJennyChapmanSarah. 2004. “What Drives Plan Implementation? Plans, Planning Agencies and Developers.”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management47 (4): 555–77. doi:10.1080/0964056042000243230.
40.
LaurianLucieDayMaxineBerkePhilipEricksenNeilBackhurstMichaelCrawfordJanDixonJenny. 2004. “Evaluating Plan Implementation: A Conformance-Based Methodology.”Journal of the American Planning Association70 (4): 471–80. doi:10.1080/01944360408976395.
41.
LeoneMichelleBarnesMarthaSharpeErin. 2015. “What Gets Plans Off the Shelf? A Case Study of Municipal Recreation Plan Implementation.”Journal of Park and Recreation Administration33 (4). doi:10.18666/jpra-2015-v33-i4-6470.
42.
LiBingqingWangZhanqiChaiJiZhangDi. 2019. “Index System to Assess Implementation of Strategic Land Use Plans in China.”Land Use Policy88. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104148.
43.
LinYanfenTuWeiHanHuijuanWuXiaoluMaWeichun. 2006. “Strategic Environmental Assessment on the Shanghai Land Use Master Plan: A System Dynamics Approach.”Asian Geographer25 (1–2): 145–71. doi:10.1080/10225706.2006.9684137.
44.
LohCarolyn G.2011. “Assessing and Interpreting Non-Conformance in Land-Use Planning Implementation.”Planning Practice and Research26 (3): 271–87. doi:10.1080/02697459.2011.580111.
45.
LohCarolyn G.2019. “Placemaking and Implementation: Revisiting the Performance Principle.”Land Use Policy81:68–75. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.10.024.
46.
LylesWardBerkePhilipSmithGavin. 2016. “Local Plan Implementation: Assessing Conformance and Influence of Local Plans in the United States.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design43 (2): 381–400. doi:10.1177/0265813515604071.
47.
MabasoAaronShekedeMunyradzi DavisChirisaInnocentZanamweLazarusGwitiraIsaiahBandaukoElmond. 2015. “Urban Physical Development and Master Planning in Zimbabwe: An Assessment of Conformance in the City of Mutare.”Journal for Studies in Humanities and Social Sciences4 (1): 72–88.
MinneryJohnCameronCarolynBrownJanelleNewmanPaula. 1993. “Evaluation in Urban Planning.”Australian Planner31 (1): 8–13. doi:10.1080/07293682.1993.9657595.
53.
MohanMadan. 2013. “Geovisualisation and Spatio-Temporal Model-Ling from Satellite Imagery: A Study of Million+ City, Ghaziabad, NCR Region, India,”1–19.
54.
Ministry of Urban Development. 2014. “Urban and Regional Development Plans Formulation and Implementation (URDPFI) Guidelines, 2014.”Vol. 1. Town and Country Planning Organisation.
OliveiraVítorPinhoPaulo. 2009. “Evaluating Plans, Processes and Results.”Planning Theory and Practice10 (1): 35–63. doi:10.1080/14649350802661741.
63.
OliveiraVitorPinhoPaulo. 2010a. “Developing and Testing a Methodology for Planning Evaluation.”Town Planning Review81 (3): 307–32. doi:10.3828/tpr.2010.7.
64.
OliveiraVitorPinhoPaulo. 2010b. “Evaluation in Urban Planning: Advances and Prospects.”Journal of Planning Literature24 (4): 343–61. doi:10.1177/0885412210364589.
65.
OmolloWilfred Ochieng. 2019. “Conformity Assessment to Development Plan Implementation as a Tool for Development Control in Kisii Town, Kenya.”South African Journal of Geomatics7 (3): 331. doi:10.4314/sajg.v7i3.10.
PetheAbhayNallathigaRamakrishnaGandhiSahilTandelVaidehi. 2014. “Re-Thinking Urban Planning in India: Learning from the Wedge between the de Jure and de Facto Development in Mumbai.”Cities39:120–32. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2014.02.006.
68.
RachelleAltermanMorrisHill. 1978. “Implementation of Urban Land Use Plans.”Journal of the American Planning Association44 (3): 274–85. doi:10.1080/01944367808976905.
69.
RaiN.SinghA. K.2007. Strategic Issues in Infrastructure Development: A Case Study of Lucknow City. Regional Centre for Urban and Environmental Studies.
70.
RaparthiKiranmayi. 2015. “Assessing Smart-Growth Strategies in Indian Cities: Grounded Theory Approach to Planning Practice.”Journal of Urban Planning and Development141 (4): 05014031. doi:10.1061/(asce)up.1943-5444.0000267.
71.
ReviAromarIdicheriaCharisJainGarimaAnandGeetikaSudhiraH. S.SeddonJessicaWankhadeKavitaRashmiM. K.ShettyPriyadarshini J.DhobleRevati, et al2012. Urban India 2011: Evidence. Urban India 2011: Evidence. Indian Institute for Human Settlements. doi:10.24943/9789350674512.
72.
RyanBrent D.GaoShuqi. 2019. “Plan Implementation Challenges in a Shrinking City: A Conformance Evaluation of Youngstown’s (OH) Comprehensive Plan With a Subsequent Zoning Code.”Journal of the American Planning Association85 (4): 424–44. doi:10.1080/01944363.2019.1637769.
73.
SadashivamT.TabassuShahla. 2016. “Trends of Urbanization in India: Issues and Challenges in the 21st Century.”International Journal of Information Research and Review3 (5): 2375–84.
74.
SaleemSehba. 2019. “Understanding Urban Morphology: Indore City.”World Journal of Engineering Research and Technology5 (4): 176–86.
75.
SeasonsMark. 2002. “Evaluation and Municipal Urban Planning: Practice and Prospects.”The Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation17 (1): 43–71. doi:10.3138/cjpe.017.003.
76.
SelviS. SenthamizhRaheemA. Abdul. 2022. “India’s Urban Agglomeration Growth: A Focus.”International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology7 (4): 678–82.
77.
ShaoZinanSpitTejoJinZhifengBakkerMarthaWuQun. 2018. “Can the Land Use Master Plan Control Urban Expansion and Protect Farmland in China? A Case Study of Nanjing.”Growth and Change49 (3): 512–31. doi:10.1111/grow.12240.
ShenXiaoqiangWangXiangdongZhangZhouLuZhangweiLvTiangui. 2019. “Evaluating the Effectiveness of Land Use Plans in Containing Urban Expansion: An Integrated View.”Land Use Policy80: 205–13. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.10.001.
80.
SinghA. K.JafriS. S. A.2011. “Lucknow: From Tradition to Modernity.”History and Sociology of South Asia5 (2): 143–64. doi:10.1177/223080751100500204.
81.
Smart City Mission Indore. 2016. Smart City Proposal - Indore. Indore: Smart City Mission Indore.
82.
Smart City Mission Jaipur. 2015. India Smart City Profile: Jaipur. Jaipur: Smart City Mission Jaipur.
83.
Smart City Mission Lucknow. 2016. Smart City Proposal- Lucknow. Lucknow: Smart City Mission Lucknow.
84.
Smart City Mission Surat. 2015. India Smart City Profile: Surat. Surat: Smart City Mission Surat.
85.
SudhiraH. S.GururajaK. V.2012. “Population Crunch in India: Is It Urban or Still Rural?”Current Science103 (1): 37–40.
TalenEmily. 1996a. “After the Plans: Methods to Evaluate the Implementation Success of Plans.”Journal of Planning Education and Research16 (2): 79–91. doi:10.1177/0739456X9601600201.
88.
TalenEmily. 1996b. “Do Plans Get Implemented? A Review of Evaluation in Planning.”Journal of Planning Literature10 (3): 248–59. doi:10.1177/088541229601000302.
89.
TalenEmily. 1997. “Success, Failure, and Conformance: An Alternative Approach to Planning Evaluation.”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design24 (4): 573–87. doi:10.1068/b240573.
TianLiShenTiyan. 2011. “Evaluation of Plan Implementation in the Transitional China: A Case of Guangzhou City Master Plan.”Cities28 (1): 11–27. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2010.07.002.
WaldnerLeora Susan. 2004. “Evaluation Models For City Planners.”Berkley Planning Journal17 (1).
94.
ZhangXinchangPanQiongZhaoYuanHuangQiuhua. 2005. “Research on Spatial Deviation Analysis Model of Land-Use Change.” In MIPPR 2005: Image Analysis Techniques. Vol. 6044. doi:10.1117/12.652320.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
