The healthcare sector has been facing major reforms, among which the introduction of the Clinical Directorate (CD) model for hospitals. The purpose of this work is to explore the degree of implementation of innovative Human Resource Management (HRM) practices within CDs, in order to understand whether, after more than 15 years from their introduction, they have been able to transform their managerial approach concretely, in line with the CD model’s objectives. The tools have been attributed to three main HR initiatives: training, control, and evaluation ones.
Design and methods
During on-site visits in 33 Italian hospitals, data were collected by conducting semi-structured interviews with their CEOs and Clinical Directors. Data concerned both the mere adoption of HRM tools within CDs, as well as their effective degree of implementation. The answers to the questions were translated into a system of percentage scores, so as to detect mean percentages of implementation in each CD.
Findings: The general degree of implementation of HRM practices is still somewhat distant from a theoretically excellent and full implementation, especially if we consider the important lag of time since the reforms affected the sector. Nevertheless, results open the way to important considerations about the effectiveness of the CD model.
Original value: The original methodology and scoring system suggested in this work produce a concise evaluation of the development of an effective HRM system within CDs. Our framework of analysis allows interesting benchmarking activities among different CDs of an organization and, ultimately, among different organizations. Moreover, the methodology presented may constitute a valid source of information in order to carry out future research on the items able to affect the implementation of such tools.
VasselliSFilippettiGSpizzichinoL. Misurare la performance del sistema sanitario. Proposta di una metodologia. [Measuring the performance of National Health Service. Proposal of a methodology]. Il Pensiero Scientifico Editore, Roma, Italy, 2009.
2.
MasciaDMorandiFCicchettiA.Hospital restructuring and physician job satisfaction: An empirical study. Health Policy2014;
114: 118–127.
3.
MasciaDMorandiFCicchettiA.Looking good or doing better? Patterns of decoupling in the implementation of Clinical Directorates. Health Care Manage Rev2013;
39: 111–123.
4.
HannanMFreemanJ.The population ecology of organizations. Am J Sociol1977;
82: 929–964.
5.
HannanMFreemanJ.Structural inertia and organizational change. Am Sociol Rev1984;
49: 149–164.
6.
BraithwaiteJWestbrookMTHindleDet al., Hospital sector organizational restructuring: evidence of its futility. In: McKee L, Ferlie E and Hyde P (eds) Organizing and reorganizing: power and change in health care organizations. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008, pp.33-45.
7.
McnultyTFerlieE.Process transformation: limitations to radical organizational change within public service organizations. Organiz Studies2004;
25: 1389–1412.
8.
GoesJ. Achieving organizational change in health care through people and culture: a commentary. In: Jason AW, Heather H, Mark JM, Len F and Grant TS (eds) Advances in health care management.2011, Vol. 10, pp.117–121.
BartunekJRousseauDRudolphJet al.
On the receiving end: sense-making, emotion, and assessmentof an organizational change initiated by others. J Appl Behav Sci2006;
42: 182–206.
11.
GeorgeJJonesG.Towards a process model of individual change in organizations. Human Relat2001;
54: 419–444.
12.
ArmenakisAHarriSFieldH.Making change permanent: a model for institutionalizing change interventions. In: PasmoreWWoodmanR(eds) Research in organizational change and development. 12. ed.
Stamford, CT:
JAI Press, 1999, pp.97–128.
13.
LinesR.Influence of participation in strategic change: resistance, organizational commitment and change goal achievement. J Change Manage2004;
4: 193–215.
14.
WanbergCBanasT.Predictors and outcomes of openness to changes in a reorganizing workplace. J Appl Psychol2000;
85: 132–142.
15.
JudgeTThoresenCPucikVet al.
Managerial coping with organizational change: a dispositional perspective. J Appl Psychol1999;
84: 107–122.
16.
StanleyDMeyerJTopolnytskyL.Employee cynicism and resistance to organizational change. J Business Psychol2005;
19: 429–459.
17.
MetselaarE.Assessing the willingness to change: construction and validation of the DINAMO. PhD Thesis, Free University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997.
18.
AlexanderJHearldL.The science of quality improvement implementation: developing capacity to makea difference. Med Care2011;
49: S6–S20.
19.
NembhardIAlexanderJHoffTet al.
Why does the quality of health care continue to lag? Insights from management research. Acad Manage Perspect2009;
23: 24–42.
20.
HeroldDFedorDCaldwellS.Beyond change management: a multilevel investigation of contextual and personal influences on employees’ commitment to change. J Appl Psychol2007;
92: 942–951.
21.
AndersonRMcdanielR.Managing health care organizations: where professionalism meets complexity science. Health Care Manage Rev2000;
25: 83–92.
22.
MeyerJRowanB.Institutionalize organizations: formal structure as myth and ceremony. Am J Sociol1977;
83: 340–363.
23.
HallettTVentrescaM.How institutions form: loose coupling as mechanism in Gouldner’s patterns of industrial bureaucracy. Am Behav Sci2006;
49: 908–924.
24.
WestphalJZajacE.Decoupling policy from practice: the case of stock repurchase programs. Admin Sci Quarter2001;
46: 202–228.
25.
MorandiF.Managerial solutions to hospitals’ challenges.
Hauppauge, NY:
Nova Science Publishers, 2016.
26.
CollisDMontgomeryC.Corporate strategy.
Milan, Italy:
McGraw Hill, 1998.
27.
PressmanJWildavskyA.Implementation.
Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press, 1973.
TaylorAGroeneO.European hospital managers’ perceptions of patient-centred care. A qualitative study on implementation.J Health Organiz Manage2015;
29: 711–728.
30.
WillisCDSaulJBevanHet al.
Sustaining organizational culture change in health systems. J Health Organiz Manage2016;
30: 2–30.
31.
JacobsSWeinerBReeveBet al.
Determining the predictors of innovation implementation in healthcare: a quantitative analysis of implementation effectiveness. BMC Health Serv Res2015;
15: 6.
32.
BrunssonN.Reform as routine. Organizational change and stability in the modern world.
Oxford, UK:
Oxford University Press, 2009, pp.51–55.
33.
AbbottA.The systems of professions. An essay on division of expert labor.
Chicago, IL:
The University of Chicago Press, 1988.
34.
AbernethyMStoelwinderJ.The role of professional control in the management of complex organizations. Account Organiz Soc1995;
20: 1–17.
35.
GoodmanPSDeanJW. Creating long-term organizational change. In: Goodman PS (ed) Change in communication. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1982, pp.226–279.
36.
EllisF.The benefits of partnership for OD and HR: the changing roles of OD and HR create a new partnership dynamic. Strategic HR Rev2007;
6: 32–35.
37.
MossholderKWRichardsonHASettoonRP.Human resource systems and helping in organizations: a relational Richardson perspective. Acad Manage Rev2011;
36: 33–52.
38.
Barratt-PughLBahnSGakereE.Managers as change agents: implications for human resource managers engaging with culture change. J Organiz Change Manage2013;
26: 748–764.
39.
OgilvieJRStorkD.Starting the HR and change conversation with history. J Organiz Change Manage2003;
16: 254–271.
40.
PfefferJ.Competitive advantage through people: unleashing the power of the work force.
Boston, MA:
Harvard Business School Press, 1994.
41.
PfefferJ.The human equation: building profits by putting people first.
Boston, MA:
Harvard Business School Press, 1998.
42.
HuselidMA.The impact of human resource management practices on turnover, productivity, and corporate financial performance. AMJ1995;
38: 635–672.
43.
UlrichDBrockbankW.The HR value proposition.
Boston, MA:
Harvard Business School Press, 2005.
44.
Brisson-BanksC.Managing change and transitions: a comparison of different models and their commonalities. Library Manage2010;
31: 241–252.
45.
OECD. Governance in Transition: Public Management reforms in OECD Countries.
Paris, France:
OECD, 1995.
46.
SchickA. The spirit of reform: managing the New Zealand State Sector in a time of change. A report prepared for the State Services Commission and the Treasury, New Zealand, 1996.
47.
HoodC.The “New Public Management” in the 1980s: variation on a theme. Account Organiz Soc1995;
20: 93–190.
48.
ChristensenTLagreidP.Transcending the new public management. The transformation of public sector reforms. New York, USA:
Ashgate Publishing, 2007.
49.
LegaF.The rise and fall(acy) of clinical directorates in Italy. Health Policy2008;
85: 252–262.
50.
BraithwaiteJWestbrookMHindleDet al.
Does restructuring hospitals result in greater efficiency? An empirical test using diachronic data. Health Serv Manage Res2006;
19: 1–12.
51.
FontanaF. “Dipartimenti e governo clinico in una prospettiva organizzativa e gestionale”. In: A. Cicchetti, I dipartimenti ospedalieri nel Servizio Sanitario Nazionale. Origini, evoluzioni e prospettive. Franco Angeli, Milan, Italy, 2012.
52.
HardingNLeeHFordJ.Who is the “middle manager”?Hum Relat2014;
67: 1213–1237.
53.
GiauqueD.Attitudes toward organizational change among public middle managers. Public Personnel Manage2015;
44: 70–98.
54.
PodsakoffPMackenzieSBMoormanRet al.
Transformational leader behaviors and their effects on followers’ trust in leader, satisfaction and organizational citizens behaviors. Leadership Quarter1990;
1: 107–142.
55.
HerscovitchLMeyerJ.Commitment to organizational change: extension of a three component model. J Appl Psychol2002;
92: 942–951.
56.
Abrell-VogelCRowoldJ.Leaders’ commitment to change and the effectiveness in change- a multilevel investigation. J Organiz Change Manage2014;
27: 900–921.
57.
CostaGGianecchiniM.Risorse umane, persone, relazioni e valori.
Milano, Italy:
McGraw-Hill, 2005.
DaleyDVasuM.Supervisory perceptions of the impact of public sector personnel practices on the achievement of multiple goals. Putting the strategic into human resource management. American Reviews of Public Administration. 2005;
35: 157–167.
60.
Cicchetti A. (ed.) I Dipartimenti Ospedalieri nel Servizio Sanitario Nazionale (Hospital Clinical Directorates in the National Health Service). Milan, Italy: Franco Angeli, 2012.
61.
KimberlyJREvaniskoMJ.Organizational innovation: the influence of individual, organizational and contextual factors on hospital adoption of technological and administrative innovations. Acad Manage J1981;
24: 689–713.
62.
KatzR.The effects of group longevity on project communication and performance. Admin Sci Quarter1982;
27: 81–104.
63.
DamianiGRicciardiG. Manuale di programmazione e organizzazione sanitaria. Idelson- Gnocchi, 2010.
