Since devolution, the United Kingdom has evolved not only in terms of political representation but also in terms of the relationships between civil servants in each of its regions and nations. In this paper, we present an analysis of the distinct professional and educational backgrounds of elite civil servants in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Using a new database of professional biographies of top officials across all four jurisdictions, we assess the extent to which devolved civil servants in these UK regions and nations are organizationally and professionally distinct from one another and from those in the UK-wide departments. We conclude that despite organizational change, the recruitment, demographics, and career structures of top officials in the four jurisdictions are actually quite similar. Comparing our findings to earlier studies by others, it seems that this is because the Cameron government appears to have overseen a resurgence of traditional civil servants.
CarmichaelP (1996) The changing territorial operating code of the United Kingdom: Evidence from Northern Ireland. Public Administration74(3): 413–433.
12.
CarmichaelP (2001) The Northern Ireland Civil Service. Public Money and Management21(2): 33–38.
13.
CarmichaelP (2002) The Northern Ireland Civil Service: Characteristics and trends since 1970. Public Administration80(1): 23–49.
14.
ColeA (2006) Beyond Devolution and Decentralisation: Building Regional Capacity in Wales and Brittany, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
15.
ColeA (2012) Serving the nation: Devolution and the civil service in Wales. The British Journal of Politics & International Relations14(3): 458–476.
16.
Committee on the Civil Service (Fulton Committee) (1967) The Report of the Committee on the Civil Service, Cmnd. 3638, London: HMSO.
17.
DavieG (1961) The Democratic Intellect: Scotland and Her Universities in the Nineteenth Century, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
18.
DeaconRM (2002) The Governance of Wales: The Welsh Office and the Policy Process, 1964-1999, Cardiff: Welsh Academic Press.
19.
FlindersM (2008) Delegated Governance and the British State: Walking Without Order, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
20.
GreerSL (2008) The end of Whitehall? In: HazellR (ed) Constitutional Futures Revisited, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
21.
GreerSLJarmanH (2010) What Whitehall? Definitions, demographics and the changing home civil service. Public Policy and Administration25(3): 251–270.
22.
GreerSLTrenchA (2010) Intergovernmental relations and health in Great Britain after devolution. Policy and Politics38(4): 509–529.
23.
GV314 (2012) New life at the top: Special advisors in British Government. Parliamentary Affairs 65(4): 715–732.
24.
HennessyP (1989) Whitehall, London: Fontana.
25.
HoodCDunsireA (1981) Bureaumetrics: The Quantitative Comparison of British Central Government Agencies, Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
26.
JarmanHGreerSL (2010) In the eye of the storm: Civil servants and managers in the Department of Health. Social Policy and Administration44(2): 172–192.
27.
KeatingMCairneyP (2006) A new elite? Politicians and civil servants in Scotland after devolution. Parliamentary Affairs59(1): 43–59.
28.
KellasJG (1989) The Scottish Political System, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
KnoxCCarmichaelP (2007) The review of public administration. In: Carmichael (ed) Devolution and Constitutional Change in Northern Ireland, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
30.
LodgeGRogersB (2006) Whitehall's Black Box: Accountability and Performance in the Senior Civil Service, London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
31.
LodgeGKalitowskiS (2007) Innovations in Government: International Perspectives on Civil Service Reform, London: IPPR.
32.
LodgeGKalitowskiSPearceN (2013) Accountability and Responsiveness in the Senior Civil Service, London: Cabinet Office/IPPR.
33.
LynnJJayA (1989) The Complete Yes Minister: The Diaries of a Cabinet Minister, by the Right Hon. James Hacker MP, London: BBC Books.
34.
MillerK (2009) Public policy dilemma—Gender equality mainstreaming in UK policy formulation. Public Money and Management29(1): 43–50.
35.
MitchellJ (2003) Governing Scotland: The Invention of Administrative Devolution, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
36.
MitchellJ (2009) Devolution in the UK, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
37.
MorganKMunghamG (2000) Redesigning Democracy: The Making of the Welsh Assembly, Bridgend: Seren.
38.
National Audit Office (2013) Building Capability in the Senior Civil Service to Meet Today's Challenges, London: National Audit Office.
39.
PageEC (2010a) Accountability as a bureaucratic minefield: Lessons from a comparative study. West European Politics33(5): 1010–1029.
40.
PageEC (2010b) Has the Whitehall model survived?International Review of Administrative Sciences76(3): 407–423.
41.
PageEC (2012) Bureaucracy: Disregarding public administration. In: HaywardJConnellyJ (eds) The Withering of the Welfare State: Regression, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
42.
PageECJenkinsB (2005) Policy Bureaucracy: Government with a Cast of Thousands, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43.
ParryR (1987) The centralization of the Scottish Office. In: RoseR (ed) Ministers and Ministries: A Functional Analysis, Oxford: Clarendon.
44.
ParryR (2003) The Scottish Executive and the challenges of complex policy-making. The Political Quarterly74(4): 450–458.
45.
ParryR (2004) The civil service and intergovernmental relations. Public Policy and Administration19(2): 50–63.
46.
ParryR (2009) Quangos: Agencies and the Scottish Parliament. In: JefferyCMitchellJ (eds) The Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
47.
ParryR (2010) Reshaping structures of government across the UK. In: LodgeGSchmueckerK (eds) Devolution in Practice 2010, Newcastle/London: IPPR.
48.
ParryR (2012a) The civil service and intergovernmental relations in the post-devolution UK. The British Journal of Politics & International Relations14(2): 285–302.
49.
ParryR (2012b) What can UK public administration learn from the devolved nations?Public Policy and Administration27(3): 248–264.
50.
PollittC (1993) Managerialism and the Public Services, Oxford: Blackwell.
51.
ProsserSConnollyMHoughR (2006) ‘Making It Happen’ in Public Service: Devolution in Wales As a Case Study, Exeter: Imprint Academic.
52.
Pyper R (2013) The UK coalition and the civil service: A half-term report. Public Policy and Administration 28(4): 364–382.
53.
PyperRBurnhamJ (2011) The British civil service: Perspectives on “decline” and “modernisation”. The British Journal of Politics & International Relations13(2): 189–205.
54.
RhodesRAWCarmichaelPMcMillanJ (2003) Decentralizing the Civil Service, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
55.
RichardsD (2008) New Labour and the Civil Service: Reconstituting the Westminster Model, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
56.
RowlandsT (2004) Whitehall's last stand: The establishment of the Welsh Office, 1964. Contemporary Wales16: 39–52.
57.
SavageG (1996) The Social Construction of Expertise: The English Civil Service and Its Influence, 1919-1939, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
58.
SilbermanBS (1993) Cages of Reason: The Rise of the Rational State in France, Japan, the United States, and Great Britain, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
59.
ThomasIC (1987) Giving direction to the Welsh Office. In: RoseR (ed) Ministers and Ministries: A Functional Analysis, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
60.
TrenchA (2007) The framework of devolution: The formal structure of devolved power. In: TrenchA (ed) Devolution and Power in the United Kingdom, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
61.
Van DorpeKHortonS (2011) The public service bargain in the United Kingdom: The Whitehall model in decline?Public Policy and Administration26(2): 233–252.
