Various studies have demonstrated that while the lower educated support economic redistribution more than the higher educated do, they nonetheless dislike welfare support for immigrants more strongly. This paper aims to explain this remarkably particularistic application of the principle of economic egalitarianism (‘welfare chauvinism’) by testing three theories by means of survey data representative of the Dutch population (N = 1972). The first theory asserts that the low level of political competence of the lower educated is responsible, the second focuses on their weak economic position, and the third claims that their limited amount of cultural capital is decisive. Only the latter explanation is confirmed and implications for debates about ethnocentrism, deservingness and welfare state legitimacy, as well as the ideological profile of the lower-educated working class are discussed.
Achterberg, P. ( 2006a) ‘Considering Cultural Conflict: Class Politics and Cultural Politics in Western Societies’. Maastricht : Shaker Publishing.
2.
Achterberg, P. ( 2006b) ‘Class Voting in the New Political Culture: Economic, Cultural and Environmental Voting in 20 Western Countries’ , International Sociology21(2): 237-62.
3.
Achterberg, P. and Houtman, D. ( 2006) ‘Why Do So Many People Vote "Unnaturally"? A Cultural Explanation for Voting Behavior’, European Journal of Political Research45(1): 75-92.
4.
Achterberg, P. and Houtman, D. ( 2009) ‘Ideologically "Illogical"? Why Do the Lower-Educated Dutch Display So Little Value Coherence?’, Social Forces87(3): 1649-70.
5.
Alford, R.R. ( 1967) ‘Class Voting in the Anglo-American Political Systems’ , in S.M. Lipset and S. Rokkan (eds) Party Systems and Voter Alignments: Cross-National Perspectives. New York: Free Press.
6.
Applebaum, L. ( 2002) ‘Who Deserves Help/Opinions about the Deservingness of Different Groups Living in Germany to Receive Aid’, Social Justice Research15(3): 201-25.
7.
Bay, A.-H. and Pedersen, A. ( 2006) ‘The Limits of Social Solidarity: Basic Income, Immigration and the Legitimacy of the Universal Welfare State’, Acta Sociologica49(4): 419-36.
8.
Bell, D. ( 1976) The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism. New York: Basic Books.
9.
Blank, T. ( 2003) ‘Determinants of National Identity in East and West Germany: An Empirical Comparison of Theories on the Significance of Authoritarianism , Anomie, and General Self-Esteem’, Political Psychology24(2): 259-88.
10.
Bobo, L. and Licari, F.C. ( 1989) ‘Education and Political Tolerance: Testing the Effects of Cognitive Sophistication and Target Group Affect’, Public Opinion Quarterly53(2): 285-308.
11.
Bourdieu, P. ( 1984) Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste . London: Routledge.
12.
Bourdieu, P. ( 1986) ‘The Forms of Capital’, in J.G. Richardson (ed.) Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. New York: Greenwood Press.
13.
Budge, I. ( 2000) ‘Expert Judgements of Party Policy Positions: Uses and Limitations in Political Research’, European Journal of Political Research37(1): 103-13.
14.
Campbell, A., Converse, P.E., Miller, W.E. and Stokes, D.E. ( 1960) The American Voter. New York / London/ Sydney: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
15.
Carmines, E.G. and Stimson, J.A. ( 1982) ‘Racial Issues and the Structure of Mass Belief Systems’, The Journal of Politics44(1): 2-20.
16.
Clark, T.N. ( 1996) ‘Structural Realignments in American City Politics. Less Class, More Race, and a New Political Culture’, Urban Affairs Review31(6): 367-403.
17.
Clark, T.N. and Lipset, S.M. ( 1991) ‘Are Social Classes Dying?’, International Sociology6(4): 397-410.
18.
Coenders, M. ( 2001) Nationalistic Attitudes and Ethnic Exclusionism in a Comparative Perspective. Nijmegen: Interuniversity Center for Social Science Theory and Methodology.
19.
Converse, P.E. ( 1964) ‘The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Publics’ in D.E. Apter (ed.) Ideology and Discontent, International Yearbook of Political Behavior Research, Volume 5. New York: Free Press.
20.
De Koster, W., Van der Waal, J. , Achterberg, P. and Houtman, D . (2008) ‘The Rise of the Penal State: Neo-Liberalization or New Political Culture’, British Journal of Criminology 48(6): 720-34.
21.
De Witte, H. ( 1997) ‘De ideologische cultuur van arbeiders in Vlaanderen. Een replicatie en uitbreiding op basis van de IPSO-data’ [The Ideological Culture of Workers in Flanders. A Replication and Elaboration with IPSO-data] , Tijdschrift voor Sociologie18(1-2): 53-78.
22.
Derks, A. ( 2006) ‘Populism and the Ambivalence of Egalitarianism. How Do the Underprivileged Reconcile a Right Wing Party Preference with Their SocioEconomic Attitudes?’World Political Science Review2(3): article 1.
23.
DiMaggio, P. ( 1982) ‘Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of U. S. High School Students’ , American Sociological Review47(2): 189-201.
24.
DiMaggio, P. and Mohr, J. ( 1985) ‘Cultural Capital, Educational Attainment, and Marital Selection’, American Journal of Sociology90(6): 1231-61.
25.
Dumais, S.A. ( 2002) ‘Cultural Capital, Gender, and School Success: The Role of Habitus’, Sociology of Education75(1): 44-68.
26.
Eisinga, R. and Scheepers, P. ( 1989) Etnocentrisme in Nederland: Theoretische en empirische verkenningen [Ethnocentrism in the Netherlands: Theoretical and Empirical Explorations]. Nijmegen: Interuniversity Center for Social Science Theory and Methodology.
27.
Eitle, T.M. and Eitle, D.J. ( 2002) ‘Race, Cultural Capital, and the Educational Effects of Participation in Sports’, Sociology of Education75(2): 123-46.
28.
Elchardus, M. and Smits, W. ( 2002) Anatomie en oorzaken van het wantrouwen [The Anatomy and Causes of Distrust]. Brussels: VUBPRESS.
29.
Emler, N. and Frazer, E. ( 1999) ‘Politics: The Education Effect’, Oxford Review of Education25(1-2): 251-73.
30.
Farnen, R.F. and Meloen, J.D. ( 2000) Democracy, Authoritarianism and Education: A Cross-National Empirical Survey. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
31.
Federico, C. ( 2005) ‘Racial Perceptions and Evaluative Responses to Welfare: Does Education Attenuate Race-of-Target Effects? ’ Political Psychology26(5): 683-98.
32.
Fiske, S.T. and Kinder, D.R. ( 1981) ‘Involvement, Expertise, and Schema Use: Evidence from Political Cognition’ in N. Cantor and J. Kihlstrom (eds) Personality, Social Cognition, and Social Interaction. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
33.
Fleishman, J.A. ( 1988) ‘Attitude Organization in the General Public: Evidence for a Bidimensional Structure’, Social Forces67(1): 159-84.
34.
Gabennesch, H. ( 1972) ‘Authoritarianism as World View’, American Journal of Sociology77(5): 857-75.
35.
Gilens, M. ( 1995) ‘Racial Attitudes and Opposition to Welfare’ , The Journal of Politics57(4): 994-1014.
36.
Hechter, M. ( 2004) ‘From Class to Culture’, American Journal of Sociology110(2): 400-45.
37.
Houtman, D. ( 2001) ‘Class, Culture and Conservatism: Reassessing Education as a Variable in Political Sociology’ in T.N. Clark and S.M. Lipset (eds) The Breakdown of Class Politics. A Debate on Post-Industrial Stratification . Washington DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
38.
Houtman, D. ( 2003) Class and Politics in Contemporary Social Science. ‘Marxism Lite’ and its Blind Spot for Culture. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
39.
Houtman, D., Achterberg, P. and Derks, A. ( 2008) Farewell to the Leftist Working Class. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
40.
Hyman, H.H. and Wright, C.R. ( 1979) Education’s Lasting Effect on Values. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press .
41.
Inglehart, R. ( 1997) Modernization and Postmodernization: Cultural, Economic, and Political Change in 43 Societies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
42.
Jackson, T.H. and Marcus, G.E. ( 1975) ‘Political Competence and Ideological Constraint’ , Social Science Research4(1): 93-111.
43.
Jensen, R. ( 1995) ‘The Culture Wars, 1965-1995: A Historian’s Map’, Journal of Social History29 (October): 17-37.
44.
Jenssen, A.T. and Engesbak, H. ( 1994) ‘The Many Faces of Education: Why Are People with Lower Education More Hostile towards Immigrants than People with Higher Education ?’ Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research38(1): 33-50.
45.
Judd, C. and Krosnick, J. ( 1989) ‘The Structural Bases of Consistency among Political Attitudes: Effects of Political Expertise and Attitude Importance’ in A.R. Pratkanis, J. Beckler and G.F. Greenwald (eds) Attitude Structure and Function. Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum.
46.
Katsillis, J. and Rubinson, R. ( 1990) ‘Cultural Capital, Student Achievement, and Educational Reproduction: The Case of Greece’, American Sociological Review55(2): 270-79.
47.
Kitschelt, H.P. ( 1995) The Radical Right in Western Europe: A Comparative Analysis . Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
48.
Lamont, M. ( 1987) ‘Cultural Capital and the Liberal Political Attitudes of Professionals: Comment on Brint’, American Journal of Sociology92(6): 1501-06.
49.
Lerner, R. , Nagai, A.K. and Rothman, S. ( 1991) ‘Elite vs. Mass Opinion: Another Look at a Classic Relationship’, International Journal of Public Opinion Research3(1): 1-31.
50.
Lipset, S.M. ( 1981) Political Man. The Social Bases of Politics, 2nd ed. Baltimore, MD: The John Hopkins University Press.
51.
Lutterman, K.G. and Middleton, R. ( 1970) ‘Authoritarianism, Anomia, and Prejudice’ , Social Forces48(3): 485-92.
52.
Marshall, G. , Newby, H. , Rose, D. and Vogler, C. ( 1988) Social Class in Modern Britain. London : Hutchinson.
53.
Mau, S. and Burkhardt, C.(2009) ‘Migration and Welfare State Solidarity in Western Europe’ , Journal of European Social Policy19(3): 213-29.
54.
McDill, E.L. ( 1961) ‘Anomie, Authoritarianism, Prejudice, and Socioeconomic Status: An Attempt at Clarification’, Social Forces39(3): 239-45.
55.
Middendorp, C.P. ( 1991) Ideology in Dutch Politics, The Democratic System Reconsidered 1970-1985. Assen: Van Gorcum.
56.
Mudde, C. ( 2000) The Ideology of the Extreme Right. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
57.
Nisbet, M.C. ( 2005) ‘The Competition for Worldviews: Values, Information, and Public Support for Stem Cell Research’, International Journal of Public Opinion Research17(1): 90-112.
58.
Olzak, S. ( 1992) The Dynamics of Ethnic Competition and Conflict . Stanford: Stanford University Press.
59.
Roberts, A.H. and Rokeach, M. ( 1956) ‘Anomie, Authoritarianism, and Prejudice: A Replication’ , American Journal of Sociology61(3): 355-58.
60.
Scheepers, P. , Gijsberts, M. and Coenders, M. ( 2002) ‘Ethnic Exclusionism inEuropean Countries’, European Sociological Review18(1): 17-34.
61.
Simpson, M. ( 1972) ‘Authoritarianism and Education: A Comparative Approach’ , Sociometry35(2): 223-34.
62.
Srole, L. ( 1956) ‘Social Integration and Certain Corollaries: An Exploratory Study’, American Sociological Review21(6): 709-16.
63.
Stubager, R. ( 2008) ‘Education Effects on Authoritarian-Libertarian Values: A Question of Socialization’, British Journal of Sociology59(2): 327-50.
64.
Stubager, R. ( 2009) ‘Education-Based Group Identity and Consciousness in the Authoritarian-Libertarian Value Conflict’, European Journal of Political Research48(2): 204-33.
65.
Svallfors, S. ( 1991) ‘The Politics of Welfare Policy in Sweden: Structural Determinants and Attitudinal Cleavages’, British Journal of Sociology42(4): 609-34.
66.
Svallfors, S. ( 2007) ‘Class and Attitudes to Market Inequality: A Comparison of Sweden, Britain, Germany and the United States’ in S. Svallfors (ed.) The Political Sociology of the Welfare State. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
67.
Van der Waal, J. ( 2009) ‘De invloed van immigratie op de lonen in Amsterdam en Rotterdam. De substitutiethese getoetst in twee stedelijke contexten’ [The Impact of Immigration on Wages in Amsterdam and Rotterdam. Testing the Substitution Thesis in Two Urban Contexts], Sociologie5(1): 89-111.
68.
Van der Waal, J. ( 2010) Unravelling the Global City Debate: Economic Inequality and Ethnocentrism in Contemporary Dutch Cities. Rotterdam : Erasmus University Rotterdam.
69.
Van der Waal, J. and Achterberg, P. ( 2006) ‘Stille revolutie, contra-revolutie of cultureel conflict? Veranderingen in de politieke cultuur en hun invloed op het klassengebonden stemgedrag’ [Silent Revolution, Contra-Revolution or Cultural Conflict? Changes in Political Culture and their Influence on Class-Voting], Res Publica46(4): 369-92.
70.
Van der Waal, J. , Achterberg, P. and Houtman, D. ( 2007) ‘Class Is Not Dead - It Has Been Buried Alive: Class Voting and Cultural Voting in Postwar Western Societies (1956-1990)’ , Politics and Society35(3): 403-26.
71.
Van Oorschot, W. ( 2000) ‘Who Should Get What, and Why? On Deservingness Criteria and the Conditionality of Solidarity among the Public’, Policy and Politics28(1): 33-48.
72.
Van Oorschot, W. ( 2006) ‘Making the Difference in Social Europe: Deservingness Perceptions among Citizens of European Welfare States’ , Journal of European Social Policy16(1): 23-42.
73.
Van Oorschot, W. ( 2007) ‘Solidarity towards Immigrants in European Welfare States’, International Journal of Social Welfare17(1): 3-14.
74.
Van Oorschot, W. and Uunk, W. ( 2007) ‘Welfare Spending and the Public’s Concern for Immigrants’, Comparative Politics40(1): 63-86.
75.
Weil, F.D. ( 1985) ‘The Variable Effects of Education on Liberal Attitudes: A Comparative Historical Analysis of Anti-Semitism Using Public Opinion Survey Data’, American Sociological Review50(4): 458-74.
76.
Wilson, B. ( 1982) Religion in Sociological Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
77.
Wright, E.O. ( 1985) Classes. London: Verso.
78.
Zaller, J.R. ( 1992) The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
