When the first oral contraceptive pill was approved in the United States in 1960, scientific information for potential users was scant. Newspapers were one of the few sources of lay pill-related content. This study offers a critical-rhetorical analysis of the earliest New York Times coverage of the oral contraceptive pill (N = 292), to assess how audiences were guided to understand and interpret this new technology. Findings reveal that, of the major news genres represented (e.g. stock, religion, and science reports), all provided indirect information about the pill for potential consumers, with conflicting news-genre-specific narratives highlighting the pill’s: (a) volatility and unpredictability, (b), divisiveness and complexity, and (c) placement within the trajectory of scientific progress, respectively. Lay people interested in using the pill were not primary audiences for this coverage but were, instead, unintended or secondary audiences, and evidence of women’s thoughts or professional opinions about the pill were rarely included.
AdlerABiggsMAKallerSSchroederRRalphL (2023) Changes in the frequency and type of barriers to reproductive health care between 2017 and 2021. JAMA Network Open6(4): e237461.
2.
AppletonSF (2016) The forgotten family law of Eisenstadt v. Baird. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism28(1): 1–54.
3.
BaileyB (1997) Prescribing the pill: Politics, culture, and the sexual revolution in America’s heartland. Journal of Social History30(4): 827–256.
4.
BaileyMJ (2010) “Momma’s got the pill”: How Anthony Comstock and Griswold v. Connecticut shaped U.S. childbearing. American Economic Review100(1): 98–129.
5.
BarrettG (1963a) Catholics and birth control: Role of research. New York Times, 6August, pp. 1, 16.
6.
BarrettG (1963b) Catholics and birth control: Growing debate. New York Times, 5August, pp. 1, 12.
7.
BarrettG (1963c) Catholics and birth control: Puerto Rico clinics. New York Times, 7August, pp. 1, 18.
8.
BedingfieldRE (1964) Gain in earnings seen for Syntex. New York Times, 11June, p. 43.
9.
BurnhamJC (1982) American medicine’s golden age: What happened to it?Science215(4539): 1474–1479.
10.
ChouWSGaysynskyACappellaJN (2020) Where we go from here: Health misinformation on social media. American Journal of Public Health110(53): S273–S275.
11.
ClarkFIllmanDL (2006) A longitudinal study of The New York Times science times section. Science Communication27(4): 496–513.
12.
CogleyJ (1965) Nobel Laureates petition the Pope. New York Times, 22June, pp. 1, 42.
13.
ColenS (1986) “With respect and feelings”: Voices of West Indian child care workers in New York City. In: ColeJB (ed.) All American Women. New York, NY: Free Press, pp. 46–70.
14.
ConradP (1999) Uses of expertise: Sources, quotes, and voice in the reporting of genetics in the news. Public Understanding of Science8(4): 285–302.
15.
CornishMJRudermanFASpivakSS (1963) Doctors and Family Planning. New York, NY: National Committee on Maternal Health.
16.
CullinanMEZimdarsMNaK (2024) Their truth is out there: Scientific (dis)trust and alternative epistemology in online health groups. Social Media + Society 10(3). Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051241269288
17.
DotyRC (1964) 3 prelates urge Vatican review of birth control. New York Times, 30October, pp. 1, 16.
18.
DuganG (1965) A priest praises Jewish harmony. New York Times, 29January, p. 32.
19.
DunwoodyS (2008) Science journalism. In: BucchiMTrenchB (eds) Handbook of Public Communication of Science and Technology. New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 15–25.
20.
EdwardsSN (2022) Understanding the present through the past: A comparison of Spanish news coverage of the 1918 flu and COVID-19 pandemics. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly99(1): 12–43.
FisherK (2006) Birth Control, Sex and Marriage in Britain, 1918–1960. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
23.
FisherKSzreterS (2003) “The prefer withdrawal”: The choice of birth control in Britain, 1918–1950. Journal of Interdisciplinary History34(2): 263–291.
24.
FlamianoD (2000) Covering contraception: Discourses of gender, motherhood and sexuality in women’s magazines, 1938–1969. American Journalism17(3): 59–81.
25.
FowlerEM (1964) Little time given to leisure shares by many investors. New York Times, 21June, p. F10.
26.
GarnerAC (2015) Wicked or warranted? US press coverage of contraception 1873–1917. Journalism Studies16(2): 228–242.
27.
GarnerACMichelAR (2016) “The birth control divide”: U.S. press coverage of contraception, 1873–2013. Journalism & Communication Monographs18(4): 180–234.
28.
GinsburgFDRappR (eds) (1995) Conceiving of the New World Order. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
29.
GoliaJA (2016) Courting women, courting advertisers: The woman’s page and the transformation of the American newspaper, 1895-1935. Journal of American History103(3): 606–628.
30.
GordonL (2007) The Moral Property of Women: A History of Birth Control Politics in America. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
31.
GreeneJAHerzbergD (2010) Hidden in plain sight: Marketing prescription drugs to consumers in the twentieth century. American Journal of Public Health100(5): 793–803.
32.
GreenwaldMS (1990) Gender representation in newspaper business sections. News Research Journal11(1): 68–74.
33.
HallinDCBrandtMBriggsCL (2013) Biomedicalization and the public sphere: Newspaper coverage of health and medicine, 1960s-2000s. Social Science & Medicine96: 121–128.
34.
HammerAR (1965) Syntex, profits up, jumps 23 points on American list. New York Times, 2December, pp. 59, 62.
35.
HaydenS (1997) Reclaiming bodies of knowledge. Western Journal of Communication Studies61(2): 127–163.
36.
HopwoodNJonesPMKassellLSecordJ (2015) Introduction: Communicating reproduction. Bulletin of the History of Medicine89(3): 379–404.
37.
HuberAY (2023) The invisible frontline of the COVID-19 pandemic: Examining sourcing and the underrepresentation of female expertise in pandemic news coverage. Public Understanding of Science32(8): 1021–1032.
38.
HussSDwightL (2018) Planned parenthood: 100 years of leadership and controversy. In: BegganJKAllisonST (eds) Leadership and Sexuality. Fremont, CA: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 37–53.
39.
IslamR (2002) The Right to Tell: The Role of Mass Media in Economic Development. Washington, DC: WBI Development Studies.
40.
JensenRE (2021) Theorizing chemical rhetoric: Toward an articulation of chemistry as a public vocabulary. Journal of Communication71(3): 431–453.
41.
KennedyPP (1964) Syntex: Clinical study of a stock. New York Times, 19May, pp. 35, 41.
42.
KingSS (1960) British find birth-control pills cause too many side effects. New York Times, 31March, p. 41.
43.
KoerberA (2018) From Hysteria to Hormones: A Rhetorical History. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
44.
KrallMA (2023) Regulatory rhetoric and mediated health narratives. Rhetoric of Health & Medicine6(3): 304–334.
45.
KruvandM (2012) The pill at fifty: How the New York Times covered the birth control pill, 1960–2010. American Journalism29(4): 34–67.
46.
LackieEFairchildA (2016) The birth control pill, thromboembolic disease, science and the media: A historical review of the relationship. Contraception94(4): 295–302.
47.
LaurenceWL (1959) Science in review. New York Times, 27December, p. E9.
48.
LeivaRKimberD (2022) A persistent gender bias in Chilean press: The influence of journalist’s gender and editor’s gender. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly99(1): 156–182.
49.
LindbergLDKantorLM (2022) Adolescents’ receipt of sex education in a nationally representative sample, 2011–2019. Journal of Adolescent Health70(2): 290–297.
50.
MarshMRonnerW (2008) The Fertility Doctor: John Rock and the Reproductive Revolution. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
51.
MastroSZimmer-GembeckMJ (2017) Let’s talk openly about sex: Sexual communication, self-esteem and efficacy as correlates of sexual well-being. In: Van de BongardtDYuRDekovićM, et al. (eds) Romantic Relationships and Sexuality in Adolescence and Young Adulthood. New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 1–19.
52.
MayET (2010) America and the Pill: A History of Promise, Peril, and Liberation. New York, NY: Basic Books.
53.
McGeeMC (1990) Text, context, and the fragmentation of contemporary culture. Western Journal of Speech Communication54(3): 274–289.
54.
McKerrowRE (1989) Critical rhetoric. Communication Monographs56(2): 91–111.
55.
MetzR (1963) Market surges to record level. New York Times, 18December, pp. 59, 62.
56.
MetzR (1964) Drug issues rise as market sags. New York Times, 28May, pp. 53, 56.
57.
MorrisCE (2002) Pink herring and the fourth persona. Quarterly Journal of Speech88(2): 228–244.
58.
New York Times (1951) Chemical is found to control births. New York Times, 21October, p. 15.
59.
New York Times (1954) Family planning is upheld in Rome. New York Times, 3September, p. 14.
60.
New York Times (1958a) Birth-control pill hit. New York Times, 13June, p. 47.
61.
New York Times (1958b) Pill held success as contraceptive. New York Times. 19September, p. 25.
62.
New York Times (1959) Progress on birth control pill. New York Times, 12July, p. E9.
63.
New York Times (1962a) New cancer clue is found in blood. New York Times, 18October, p. 48.
64.
New York Times (1962b) New contraceptive pill declared safe by U.S. New York Times, 6February, p. 50.
65.
New York Times (1962c) Science notes: New TB drug. New York Times, 15April, p. E9.
66.
New York Times (1963) Cushing rejects birth pill view voiced in Catholic doctor’s book. New York Times, 20April, p. 6.
67.
New York Times (1964a) Birth control pill approved. New York Times, 29February, p. 22.
68.
New York Times (1964b) Birth control review is hinted by Cardinal and Vatican paper. New York Times, 28May, pp. 1, 8.
69.
New York Times (1964c) Briton who heads birth control clinic defies ban on rites. New York Times, 1June, p. 31.
70.
New York Times (1964d) Foes of birth curb backed by Vatican. New York Times, 19June, p. 5.
71.
New York Times (1964e) Pope says church is making “profound” birth control study. New York Times, 24June, pp. 1, 3.
72.
New York Times (1965a) Best knowns of 1964. New York Times, 11January, p. 116.
73.
New York Times (1965b) Mead Johnson to market new oral contraceptive. New York Times, 17April, p. 28.
74.
NuccioSR (1964) American board ends busy week. New York Times, 18January, pp. 28, 32.
75.
Ortiz-GómezTIgnaciukA (2015) “Pregnancy and labour cause more deaths than oral contraceptives”: The debate on the pill in the Spanish press in the 1960s and 1970s. Public Understanding of Science24(6): 658–671.
76.
OsmundsenJA (1961) New drug tested as contraceptive. New York Times, 14March, p. 28.
77.
ParryM (2013) Broadcasting Birth Control: Mass Media and Family Planning. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
78.
Ramíez de ArellanoABSeippC (1983) Colonialism, Catholicism, and Contraception: A History of Birth Control in Puerto Rico. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
79.
RodgersYZhangJY (2006) A content analysis of sex bias in international news magazines. In: HopeD (ed.) Visual Communication: Perception, Rhetoric, and Technology. New York, NY: Hampton Press, pp. 139–156.
80.
RutterR (1962) Market edges up in slow trading. New York Times, 4August, pp. 23, 26.
81.
SchmeckHM (1961) Pill to be tested in war on cancer. The New York Times, 19 January, p. 31.
82.
SmithG (1963) Market declines in an erratic day: Stocks move up and down. New York Times, 10September, p. 71.
83.
Smith-JonesSE (2023) Introduction: The repeal of Roe V. Wade. Women & Language46(1): 255–257.
84.
SoderlundG (2002) Covering urban vice: The New York Times, “white slavery,” and the construction of journalistic knowledge. Critical Studies in Media Communication19(4): 438–460.
85.
Taragin-ZellerLGolanOTsfatiYShauliNMRozenblumYBaram-TsabariA (2024) The four “R”s: Strategies for tailoring science for religious publics and their prices. Public Understanding of Science33: 902–917.
86.
ToneA (2002) Devices and Desires: A History of Contraceptives in America. New York, NY: Hill & Wang.
87.
Van LeeuwenT (2008) News genres. In: WodakRKollerV (eds) Handbook of Communication in the Public Sphere. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 343–362.
88.
VartanVG (1963a) Counter market is losing issues. New York Times, 22December, pp. F1, F8.
89.
VartanVG (1963b) Boom collapses in Syntex stock. New York Times, 14June, pp. 39, 45.
90.
VartanVG (1964) GD Searle stock soars in first day on the big board. New York Times, 3January, p. 29.
91.
WatkinsES (1998) On the Pill: A Social History of Oral Contraceptives, 1950–1970. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
92.
WatkinsES (2016) Reconceiving the pill: From revolutionary therapeutic to lifestyle drug. In: GreeneJACondrauFWatkinsES (eds) Therapeutic Revolutions: Pharmaceuticals and Social Change in the Twentieth Century. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 43–64.
93.
WestoffLAWestoffCF (1968) From Now to Zero: Fertility, Contraception and Abortion in America. New York, NY: Little, Brown and Company.
94.
WoodruffK (2019) Coverage of abortion in select U.S. newspapers. Women’s Health Issues29(1): 80–86.
95.
WuQLPaskE (2024) How family sex talks can increase daughters’ intentions to engage in sexual health protective behavior: Mediating roles of parents’ direct and indirect sexual communication. Health Communication39: 2896–2905.
