Zoora Shah was convicted of murder after she poisoned and killed Mohammed Azam. Her
appeal against her murder conviction (among others) was rejected by the Court of
Appeal. This article provides a queer theory reading of the Court of
Appeal’s judgment and argues that the court’s decision was based
upon the construction of Zoora as an unintelligible gender. Drawing upon the work of
Judith Butler, the article analyses the notion of gender as performativity and
argues that Zoora’s construction as an unintelligible gender was due to
her failure to conform to a number of gender and racial scripts. In particular, the
article examines the court’s use of the term ‘unusual
woman’ to describe Zoora and analyses how this labelling significantly
contributed to her construction as an unintelligible gender. The article will argue
that the construction of Zoora as an unintelligible gender prevented her from
telling the ‘truth’ of her situation.
Butler, J.
(1990) ‘Performative Acts and Gender
Constitution: An Essay in Phenomenology and Feminist Theory’,
pp. 270-282 in
S. E Case
(ed.) Performing Feminisms: Feminist Critical Theory and Theatre.
London: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
2.
Butler, J.
(1990/1999) Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of
Identity.
London: Routledge
.
3.
Butler, J.
(1993) Bodies that Matter: On the Discursive Limits of
‘Sex’.
London: Routledge
.
4.
Butler, J.
(1997) Excitable Speech: A Politics of the
Performative.
London: Routledge
.
5.
Butler, J.
(2004) ‘Changing the Subject: Judith
Butler’s Politics of Radical Resignification’, pp.
325-356 in S. Salih The Judith Butler Reader.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
6.
Chunn, D. E.
and
D. Lacombe
(2000) Law as a Gendering Practice.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
7.
Collier, R.
(1997)
‘After Dunblane: Crime, Corporeality, and the (Hetero)Sexing of
Bodies of Men’
, Journal of Law and Society24:
177-198
.
8.
Conaghan, J.
(2000)
‘Reassessing the Feminist Theoretical Project in Law’
, Journal of Law and Society27(3):
251-385
.
9.
Cossins, A.
(2003)
‘Saints, Sluts and Sexual Assault: Rethinking the Relationship
Between Sex, Race and Gender’
, Social & Legal Studies12(1):
77-103
.
10.
Cossman, B.
(2002)
‘Gender Performance, Sexual Subjects and International Law’
, Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence15:
281-296
.
11.
Daly, K.
(1997)
‘Different Ways of Conceptualizing Sex/Gender in Feminist Theory
and their Implications for Criminology’
, Theoretical Criminology1(1):
25-51
.
12.
De Beauvoir, S.
(1989) The Second Sex.
London: Picador
.
13.
Delgado, R.
(1982)
‘Words that Wound: A Tort Action for Racial Insults, Epithets,
and Name-Calling’
, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review17:
133-181
.
14.
Derrida, J.
(1972/1992) ‘Signature Event
Context’, pp. 80-111 in
P. Kamuf
(ed.) A Derrida Reader, Between the Blinds.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
15.
Detmold, M. J.
(1997)
‘Provocation to Murder: Sovereignty and Multiculture’
, Sydney Law Review19(5):
5-31
.
16.
Donnelly, M.
(1993)
‘Battered Women Who Kill and the Criminal Law Defences’
, Irish Criminal L J3(2):
161-172
.
17.
Edwards, S.
(1997)
‘Battered Women - in Fear of Luc’s Shadow’
, Denning LJ:
75-105
.
18.
Fraser, M.
(1999)
‘Classing Queer: Politics in Competition’
, Theory, Culture & Society16(2):
107-131
.
19.
Gatens, M.
(1983/1996) Imaginary Bodies: Ethics, Power and
Corporeality.
New York: Routledge
.
20.
Howe, A.
(1987)
‘ “Social Injury” Revisited: Towards a
Feminist Theory of Social Justice’
, International Journal of the Sociology of the Law15(4):
426-438
.
21.
Hunter, R.
and
K. Mack
(1997) ‘Exclusion and Silence: Procedure and
Evidence’, pp. 171-192 in
N. Naffine
and
R. J. Owens
(eds) Sexing the Subject of Law.
London: Sweet & Maxwell
.
22.
Keywood, K.
(2000)
‘More than a Woman? Embodiment and Sexual Difference in Medical Law’
, Feminist Legal Studies8(3):
319-342
.
23.
Lacey, N.
(1997) ‘On the Subject of
“Sexing” the Subject...’, pp.
65-76 in
N. Naffine
and
R. J. Owens
(eds) Sexing the Subject of Law.
London: Sweet & Maxwell
.
24.
Lacey, N.
(1998) Unspeakable Subjects: Feminist Essays in Legal and
Social Theory.
Oxford: Hart Publishing
.
25.
Law Commission
(2004) Partial Defences to Murder: Provisional Conclusions on
Consultation Paper 173.
London: HMSO
.
26.
Loizidou, E.
(1999)
‘The Trouble with Rape’
, Feminist Legal Studies7:
275-297
.
27.
MacCannell, D.
and
J. F. MacCannell
(1993) ‘Violence, Power and Pleasure: A
Revisionist Reading of Foucault from the Victim Perspective’,
pp. 203-238 in
C. Ramazanoglu
(ed.) Up Against Foucault: Explorations of Some Tensions Between
Foucault and Feminism.
London: Routledge
.
28.
MacKinnon, C. A.
(1987) Feminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and Law.
London: Harvard University Press
.
29.
MacKinnon, C. A.
(1993) Only Words.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
30.
Matsuda, M. J.
(1989)
‘Legal Storytelling: Public Response to Racist Speech:
Considering the Victim’s Story’
, Michigan Law Review87:
2320-2381
.
31.
McColgan, A.
(2000) ‘General Defences’,
pp. 137-158 in N. Nicolson and L. Bibbings Feminist
Perspectives on Criminal Law.
London: Cavendish Publishing
.
32.
Mousourakis, M.
(1998) Criminal Responsibility and Partial Excuses.
Aldershot: Ashgate
.
33.
Naffine, N.
(1997) ‘The Body Bag’, pp.
79-93 in
N. Naffine
and
R. J. Owens
(eds) Sexing the Subject of Law.
London: Sweet & Maxwell
.
34.
Naffine, N.
and
R. J. Owens
(eds) (1997) Sexing the Subject of Law.
London: Sweet & Maxwell
.
35.
Nicolson, D.
and
R. Sanghvi
(1993)
‘Battered Women and Provocation: The Implications of Ahluwalia’
, Crim L ROctober:
728-738
.
36.
Nussbaum, M. C.
(1999)
‘The Hip Defeatism of Judith Butler: The Professor of Parody’
, The New Republic (Feb) 22:
37-45
.
37.
O’Donovan, K.
(1991)
‘Defences for Battered Women Who Kill’
, Journal of Law & Society18:
219-237
.
38.
Smart, C.
(1989) Feminism and the Power of the Law.
New York: Routledge
.
39.
Smart C.
(1990)
‘Law’s Power, the Sexed Body, and Feminist Discourse’
, Journal of Law and Society17:
194-210
.
40.
Taylor, L. J.
(1986)
‘Provoked Reason in Men and Women; Heat of Passion Manslaughter
and Imperfect Self-Defense’
, UCLA Law Review33:
1679-1735
.
41.
Threadgold, T.
(1997)
‘Narrative and Legal Texts: Telling Stories about Women who Kill’
, UTS Review: Cultural Studies and New Writing3(1):
56-73
.
42.
Walker, L.
(1979) The Battered Woman.
New York: Harper & Row
.
43.
Wannop, A. L.
(1995)
‘Battered Woman Syndrome and the Defence of Battered Women in
Canada and England’
, Suffolk Transnational Law Review19:
251-272
.
44.
Williams, G.
(1983) Textbook on Criminal Law.
London: Stevens
.
45.
Williams, G.
(1987)
‘Spirit-Murdering the Messenger: The Discourse of Fingerpointing
as the Law’s Response to Racism’
, Miami Law Review42:
129-139
.
46.
Worrall, A.
(1997) Offending Women: Female Law Breakers and the Criminal
Justice System.
London: Routledge
.
47.
Young, A.
(1991)
‘Conjugal Homicide and Legal Violence: A Comparative Analysis’
, Osgood Hall L J31:
761-808
.
48.
Young, A.
(1996) Imagining Crime, Textual Outlaws and Criminal
Conversations.
London: SAGE Publications
.
