Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2013-11
The impact of teachers’ expectations on students’ educational opportunities in the life course: An empirical test of a subjective expected utility explanation
The objective of this paper is to integrate the idea of Pygmalion or self-fulfilling prophecy research into the subjective expected utility framework of inequality in educational opportunities. The theoretical section develops a formal model about the impact of teachers’ expectations on students’ educational transitions in sense of a self-fulfilling prophecy. In the empirical section, I test this model to predict both students’ educational success (in terms of high school graduations) and their university transitions. Analyses control for selection bias and unobserved heterogeneity by means of a bivariate probit model. I find that even net of both students’ performance and motivation, teachers’ expectations show significant effects on students’ educational success (Abitur), but not on their university transitions. This finding is stable against several robustness checks.
AshenfelterOHarmonCOosterbeekH (1999) A review of estimates of the schooling/earnings relationship, with tests for publication bias. Labour Economics6(4): 453–470.
3.
BeckerR (2000) Klassenlage und Bildungsentscheidungen – Eine empirische Anwendung der Wert-Erwartungstheorie. Zeitschrift für Soziologie52(3): 450–474.
4.
BeckerR (2003) Educational expansion and persistent inequalities of education. European Sociological Review19(1): 1–24.
5.
BeckerR (2012a) Bildungsungleichheit im Lichte aktueller Theorieanwendung in der soziologischen Bildungsforschung. Bildung – Arbeit – Erwachsenwerden. Ein interdisziplinärer Blick auf die Transition im Jugend und jungen Erwachsenenalter. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 43–75.
6.
BeckerR (2012b) Der Übergang ins Hochschulstudium Prozesse und Mechanismen am Beispiel der deutschen Schweiz. In: BergmannMMHupka-BrunnerSMeyerT. (eds) Bildung – Arbeit – Erwachsenwerden. Ein interdisziplinärer Blick auf die Transition im Jugend und jungen Erwachsenenalter. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 305–331.
7.
BeckerRHeckenAE (2009a) Higher education or vocational training? An empirical test of the rational action model of educational choices suggested by Breen and Goldthorpe and Esser. Acta Sociologica52(1): 25–45.
8.
BeckerRHeckenAE (2009b) Why are working-class children diverted from universities? An empirical assessment of the diversion thesis. European Sociological Review25(2): 233–250.
9.
BernardiF (2012) Unequal transitions: selection bias and the compensatory effect of social background in educational careers. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility30(2): 159–174.
10.
BiggsM (2009) Self-fulfilling prophecies. In: BaermanPHedströmP (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Analytical Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 294–314.
11.
BirkelbachK (2011) Teacher evaluations over the life course: valid prognosis or self-fulfilling prophecy?. In: MicaAPeisertAWinczorekJ (eds) Sociology and the Unintended – Robert Merton Revisited. Frankfurt aMain: Peter Lang, pp. 133–153.
12.
BishopJH (1989) Is the test score decline responsible for the productivity growth decline?American Economic Review79(1): 178–197.
13.
BlalockHMWilkenPH (1979) Intergroup Processes: A Micro-Macro Perspective. New York: The Free Press.
14.
BoissiereMKnightJBSabotRH (1985) Earnings, schooling, ability, and cognitive skills. American Economic Review75(5): 1016–1030.
15.
BoudonR (1974) Education, Opportunity and Social Inequality: Changing Prospects in Western Society. New York: John Wiley & Sons
16.
BrattesaniKAWeinsteinRSMarshallHH (1984) Student perceptions of differential teacher treatment as moderators of teacher expectation effects. Journal of Educational Psychology76(2): 236–247.
17.
BreenR (1999) Beliefs, rational choice and Bayesian learning. Rationality and Society11(4): 463–479.
18.
BreenRGarcía-PeñalosaC (2002) Bayesian learning and gender segregation. Journal of Labor Economics20(4): 899–922.
19.
BreenRGoldthorpeJH (1997) Explaining educational differentials: towards a formal rational action theory. Rationality and Society9(3): 275–305.
20.
BreenRJonssonJO (2000) Analyzing educational careers: a multinomial transition model. American Sociological Review65(5): 754–772.
21.
BuisML (2011) The consequences of unobserved heterogeneity in a sequential logit model. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(3): 247–262.
22.
CappellariLJenkinsSP (2003) Multivariate probit regression using simulated maximum likelihood. Stata Journal3(3): 278–294.
23.
ChettyRFriedmanJNRockoffJE (2011) The long-term impact of teachers: teacher value added and student outcomes in adulthood. NBER Working Paper Series17699: 1–94.
24.
CoxDR (1990) Role of models in statistical analysis. Statistical Science5(3): 169–174.
25.
CunhaFHeckmanJJ (2007) Identifying and estimating the distributions of ex post and ex ante returns to schooling. Labour Economics14(6): 870–893.
26.
CunhaFHeckmanJJNavarroS (2005) Separating uncertainty from heterogeneity in life cycle earnings. Oxford Economic Papers57(2): 191–261.
27.
DaidoKItohH (2005) The Pygmalion and Galatea effects: an agency model with reference-dependent preferences and applications to self-fulfilling prophecy. CESifo working papers, 1444. Available at: http://ideas.repec.org/p/ces/ceswps/_1444.html
28.
DavisKMooreWE (1945) Some principles of stratification. American Sociological Review10(2): 242–249.
29.
DiPreteTAEirichGM (2006) Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality: a review of theoretical and empirical developments. Annual Review of Sociology32: 271–297.
30.
ElashoffJDSnowRE (1971) Pygmalion Reconsidered: A Case Study in Statistical Inference: Reconsideration of the Rosenthal-Jacobson Data on Teacher Expectancy. Worthington, OH: C. A. Jones Pub. Co.
31.
ElsterJ (1985) Making Sense of Marx. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
EndersCK (2010) Applied Missing Data Analysis. New York: The Guilford Press.
33.
EriksonRSJonssonJO (1996) Introduction: explaining class inequality in education: the Swedish test case. In: EriksonRSJonssonJO (eds) Can Education be Equalized? The Swedish Case in Comparative Perspective. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 1–63.
34.
EsserH (1996) What is wrong with “variable sociology”?European Sociological Review12(2): 159–166.
EsserH (2010) Das Modell der Frame-Selektion. Eine allgemeine Theorie der Sozialwissenschaften. In: AlbertGSigmundS (eds) Soziologische Theorie kontrovers [Sonderheft 50 der Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie]. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 50–62.
37.
FestingerL (1957) A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Evanston, IL: Row, Peterson.
38.
FreedmanDASekhonJS (2010) Endogeneity in probit response models. Political Analysis18(2): 138–150.
39.
GambettaD (1998) Concatenations of mechanisms. In: HedströmPSwedbergR (eds) Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 102–124.
40.
GanglM (2010) Causal inference in sociological research. Annual Review of Sociology36: 21–47.
41.
GillSReynoldsAJ (1999) Educational expectations and school achievement of urban African American children. Journal of School Psychology37(4): 403–424.
42.
GoldthorpeJH (1996) Class analysis and the reorientation of class theory: the case of persisting differentials in educational attainment. British Journal of Sociology47(3): 481–505.
43.
GoldthorpeJH (2001) Causation, statistics, and sociology. European Sociological Review17(1): 1–20.
44.
GottfredsonLS (1981) Circumscription and compromise: a developmental theory of occupational aspirations. Journal of Counseling Psychology28(6): 545–579.
45.
GourierouxCMonfortARenaultE. (1987) Generalised residuals. Journal of Econometrics34(1–2): 5–32.
46.
GreeneWH (2003) Econometric Analysis. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
47.
GrossN (2009) A pragmatist theory of social mechanisms. American Sociological Review74(3): 358–379.
48.
HanushekEAKimkoDD (2000) Schooling, labor-force quality, and the growth of nations. American Economic Review90(5): 1184–1208.
49.
HeckmanJJ (1979) Sample selection bias as a specification error. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society47(1): 153–161.
50.
HedströmP (2005) Dissecting the Social. On the Principles of Analytical Sociology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
HedströmPSwedbergR (1996) Social mechanisms. Acta Sociologica39(3): 281–308.
52.
HedströmPYlikoskiP (2010) Causal mechanisms in the social sciences. Annual Review of Sociology36: 49–67.
53.
HeiderF (1946) Attitudes and cognitive organization. Journal of Psychology21(1): 107–112.
54.
HillmertSJacobM (2010) Selections and social selectivity on the academic track: a life-course analysis of educational attainment in Germany. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility28(1): 59–76.
55.
HinnantJBO’BrienMGhazarianSR (2009) The longitudinal relations of teacher expectations to achievement in the early school years. Journal of Educational Psychology101(3): 662–670.
56.
HolmAJægerMM (2011) Dealing with selection bias in educational transition models: the bivariate probit selection model. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(3): 311–322.
57.
HoxJJ (2010) Multilevel Analysis – Techniques and Applications. 2nd ed.New York and Hove: Routledge.
58.
HymanH (1953) The Value systems of different classes: a social psychological contribution to the analysis of stratification. In: BendixRLipsetSM (eds) Class, Status and Power. Glencoe: The Free Press, pp. 426–442.
59.
JacksonMEriksonRSGoldthorpeJH. (2007) Primary and secondary effects in class differentials in educational attainment. Acta Sociologica50(3): 211–229.
60.
JaegerMMHolmA (2011) Relative risk aversion and educational decision making: a dynamic model with ability updating and heterogeneous RRA behavior. Paper presented at the 2011 Spring Meeting of the ISA RC28, University of Essex, UK, 13–16 April. Available at: https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/uploads/paper/document/38/rc28_jaeger_holm.pdf
61.
JægerMMHolmA (2012) Conformists or rebels? Relative risk aversion, educational decisions and social class reproduction. Rationality and Society24(2): 221–253.
62.
JonssonJO (1999) Explaining sex differences in educational choice: an empirical assessment of a rational choice model. European Sociological Review15(4): 391–404.
63.
JürgesHSchneiderK (2006) Age at school entry and teachers’ recommendations for secondary school track choice in Germany. Paper presented at the 20th annual ESPE conference, Verona, Italy, 22–24 June.
64.
JussimL (1986) Self-fulfilling prophecies: a theoretical and integrative review. Psychological Review93(4): 429–445.
65.
JussimL (1989) Teacher expectations: self-fulfilling prophecies, perceptual biases, and accuracy. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology57(3): 469–480.
66.
JussimLHarberKD (2005) Teacher expectations and self-fulfilling prophecies: knowns and unknowns, resolved and unresolved controversies. Personality and Social Psychology Review9(2): 131–155.
67.
JussimLEcclesJMadonS (1996) Social perception, social stereotypes, and teacher expectations: accuracy and the quest for the powerful self-fulfilling prophecy. In: ZannaMP (ed.) Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, pp. 281–388.
68.
KellerSZavalloniM (1964) Ambition and social class: a respecification. Social Forces43(1): 58–70.
69.
KronebergC (2006) The Definition of the Situation and Variable Rationality: The Model of Frame Selection as a General Theory of Section (Sonderforschungsbereich 504 Publications), University of Mannheim, Mannheim. Available at: http://ideas.repec.org/p/xrs/sfbmaa/06-05.html
70.
KronebergC (2011) Die Erklärung sozialen Handelns. Grundlagen und Anwendung einer integrativen Theorie. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
71.
KronebergCKalterF (2012) Rational choice theory and empirical research: methodological and theoretical contributions in Europe. Annual Review of Sociology38: 73–92.
72.
LaddHFWalshRP (2002) Implementing value-added measures of school effectiveness: getting the incentives right. Economics of Education Review21(1): 1–17.
73.
LauenDL (2007) Contextual explanations of school choice. Sociology of Education80(3): 179–209.
74.
MadonSJussimLEcclesJ (1997) In search of the powerful self-fulfilling prophecy. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology72(4): 791–809.
75.
MadonSJussimLKeiperS. (1998) The accuracy and power of sex, social class, and ethnic stereotypes: a naturalistic study in person perception. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin24(12): 1304–1318.
76.
MadonSWillardJGuyllM. (2006) Self-fulfilling prophecy effects of mothers’ beliefs on children’s alcohol use: accumulation, dissipation, and stability over time. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology90(6): 911–926.
77.
MareRD (1980) Social background and school continuation decisions. Journal of the American Statistical Association75(370): 295–305.
78.
MareRD (1981) Change and stability in educational stratification. American Sociological Review46(1): 72–87.
79.
MareRD (1993) Educational stratification on observed and unobserved components of family background. In: BlossfeldH-PShavitY (eds) Persistent Inequality – Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 351–376.
80.
MechtenbergL (2009) Cheap talk in the classroom: how biased grading at school explains gender differences in achievements, career choices and wages. Review of Economic Studies76(4): 1431–1459.
81.
MertonRK (1948) The self-fulfilling prophecy. Antioch Review8(2): 193–210.
82.
MertonRK (1987) Three fragments from a sociologist’s notebooks: establishing the phenomenon, specified ignorance, and strategic research materials. Annual Review of Sociology13: 1–29.
83.
MeulemannH (1979) Klassenlage, Entscheidungsfeld und Bildungsaspirationen - Ein Versuch zur theoretischen Präzisierung und kausalen Erklärung von Zusammenhängen zwischen sozialer Struktur und individueller Lebensplanung. Zeitschrift für Soziologie8(4): 391–414.
84.
MistryRSWhiteESBennerAD. (2009) A longitudinal study of the simultaneous influence of mothers’ and teachers’ educational expectations on low-income youth’s academic achievement. Journal of Youth and Adolescence38(6): 826–838.
85.
MorganSL (1998) Adolescent educational expectations. Rationality and Society10(2): 131–162.
86.
MorganSL (2002) Modeling preparatory commitment and non-repeatable decisions. Rationality and Society14(4): 387–429.
87.
MullerCKatzSRDanceLJ (1999) Investing in teaching and learning: dynamics of the teacher-student relationship from each actor’s perspective. Urban Education34(3): 292–337.
88.
MüllerWKarleW (1993) Social selection in educational systems in Europe. European Sociological Review9(1): 1–23.
89.
Müller-BenedictV (2007) Wodurch kann die soziale Ungleichheit des Schulerfolgs am stärksten verringert werden?Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie59(4): 615–639.
90.
NeedADe JongU (2001) Educational differentials in the Netherlands. Rationality and Society13(1): 71–98.
91.
NeugebauerMSchindlerS (2012) Early transitions and tertiary enrolment: the cumulative impact of primary and secondary effects on entering university in Germany. Acta Sociologica55(1): 19–36.
92.
ParsonsT (1959) The school class as a social system: some of its functions in American society. Harvard Educational Review29(4): 297–318.
93.
PietschMStubbeTC (2007) Inequality in the transition from primary to secondary school: school choices and educational disparities in Germany. European Educational Research Journal6(4): 424–445.
94.
RaudenbushSW (1984) Magnitude of teacher expectancy effects on pupil IQ as a function of the credibility of expectancy induction: a synthesis of findings from 18 experiments. Journal of Educational Psychology76(1): 85–97.
95.
RaudenbushSW (1994) Random effects models. In: CooperHHedgesLV (eds) The Handbook of Research Synthesis. New York: SAGE, pp. 301–321.
96.
ReadyDDWrightDL (2011) Accuracy and inaccuracy in teachers’ perceptions of young children’s cognitive abilities. American Educational Research Journal48(2): 335–360.
97.
RivkinSGHanushekEAKainJF (2005) Teachers, schools, and academic achievement. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society73(2): 417–458.
98.
RogosaD (1987) Casual models do not support scientific conclusions: a comment in support of Freedman. Journal of Educational Statistics12(2): 185–195.
99.
RosenthalR (1987) “Pygmalion” effects: existence, magnitude, and social importance. A reply to Wineburg. Educational Researcher16(9): 37–41.
100.
RosenthalRDiMatteoMR (2001) Meta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annual Review of Psychology52: 59–82.
101.
RosenthalRJacobsonL (1968) Pygmalion in the Classroom: Teacher Expectation and Pupils’ Intellectual Development. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
102.
RosenthalRRubinDB (1978) Interpersonal expectancy effects: the first 345 studies. Behavioral and Brain Sciences1(3): 377–415.
103.
RothBM (1995) We can throw teacher expectations on the IQ scrap heap. New York Times, 02January1995, A25.
104.
SchindlerSLörzM (2012) Mechanisms of social inequality development: primary and secondary effects in the transition to tertiary education between 1976 and 2005. European Sociological Review28(5): 647–660.
105.
SchneiderT (2008) Social inequality in educational participation in the German school system in a longitudinal perspective: pathways into and out of the most prestigious school track. European Sociological Review24(4): 511–526.
106.
SewellWHHallerAOOhlendorfGW (1970) The educational and early occupational status attainment process: replication and revision. American Sociological Review35(6): 1014–1027.
107.
SewellWHHallerAOPortesA (1969) The educational and early occupational attainment process. American Sociological Review34(1): 82–92.
108.
ShavitYBlossfeldH-P (1993) Persistent inequality. Changing educational attainment in thirteen countries. San Francisco, CA/Oxford: Westview Press.
109.
SmithML (1980) Meta-analysis of research in teacher expectation. Evaluation in Education4: 53–56.
SørensenAB (1998) Theoretical mechanisms and the empirical study of social processes. In: HedströmPSwedbergR (eds) Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 238–266.
112.
SorhagenNS (2013) Early teacher expectations disproportionately affect poor children’s high school performance. Journal of Educational Psychology105(2): 465–477.
113.
StockéV (2007) Explaining educational decision and effects of families’ social class position: an empirical test of the Breen Goldthorpe model of educational attainment. European Sociological Review23(4): 505–519.
114.
StockéV (2009) Adaptivität oder Konformität? Die Bedeutung der Bezugsgruppe und die Leistungsrealität der Kinder auf die Entwicklung elterlicher Bildungsaspirationen am Ende Grundschulzeit. Bildungsentscheidungen. Sonderheft der Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaften12: 257–280.
115.
StockéV (2011) Educational aspirations and inequality in educational opportunity: the difference between realistic and idealistic aspirations. Paper presented at the 2011 Spring Meeting of the ISA RC28, University of Essex, UK, 13–16 April.
116.
ThorndikeRL (1968) Review of Pygmalion in the classroom. American Educational Research Journal5(4): 708–711.
117.
VellaF (1998) Estimating models with sample selection bias: a survey. Journal of Human Resources33(1): 127–169.
118.
Von WrightGH (1971) Explanation and Understanding. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
119.
WeberM (1968) Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology (eds RothGWittichC) New York: Bedminster Press.
120.
WooldridgeJM (2002) Econometric Analysis of Cross-Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
