By analyzing the Panel Study of Income Dynamics data combined with the Assisted Housing Database, this study explores the associations between the five statuses related to receiving or leaving from a certain type of housing assistance and the subsequent housing instability experience. These statuses include households that (1) reside in a public or project-based subsidized housing (PH) unit, (2) leave a PH unit, (3) receive a Housing Choice Voucher (HCV), (4) withdraw from the HCV program, and (5) are unsubsidized but income-eligible to receive housing assistance. The results reveal that, although all subsidized households tend to experience less housing instability than do income-eligible, unsubsidized households, HCV recipients are relatively more likely to experience housing instability than are PH residents. In addition, the likelihood of experiencing housing instability among PH and HCV leavers does not differ significantly from the likelihood among the unsubsidized households, suggesting that they may leave their programs prematurely.
BeerAndrew. 2011. Housing Transitions through the Life Course : Aspirations, Needs and Policy. Bristol: Policy Press.
2.
BrissonDanielCovertJennifer. 2015. “Housing Instability Risk among Subsidized Housing Recipients: Characteristics Associated with Late or Nonpayment of Rent.” Social Work Research39 (2): 119–28. doi:10.1093/swr/svv009.
3.
BurgardSarah A.SeefeldtKristin S.ZelnerSarah. 2012. “Housing Instability and Health: Findings from the Michigan Recession and Recovery Study.” Social Science & Medicine75 (12): 2215–24.
4.
ChamberlainGary. 1980. “Analysis of Covariance with Qualitative Data.” The Review of Economic Studies47:225–38.
5.
ClarkSherri Lawson. 2010. Housing Instability: Toward a Better Understanding of Frequent Residential Mobility among America’s Urban Poor. Washington, DC: Center for Housing Policy.
6.
CohenRebeccaWardripKeith. 2011. “Should I Stay or Should I Go? Exploring the Effects of Housing Instability and Mobility on Children.” Journal of Housing Economics11:381–417.
7.
ColeyRebekah LevineLeventhalTamaLynchAlicia DoyleKullMelissa. 2013. “Relations between Housing Characteristics and the Well-Being of Low-Income Children and Adolescents.” Developmental Psychology49 (9): 1775–89. doi:10.1037/a0031033.
8.
CollinsonRobertEllenGould IngridLudwigJens. 2016. “Low-Income Housing Policy.” In Economics of Means-Tested Transfer Programs in the United States, edited by MoffittRobert A., vol. 2, 59–73. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
9.
CoultonClaudiaTheodosBrettTurnerMargery A. 2009. Family Mobility and Neighborhood Change. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
10.
CrowderKylePaisJeremySouthScott J. 2012. “Neighborhood Diversity, Metropolitan Constraints, and Household Migration.” American Sociological Review77 (3): 325–53.
11.
CrowleySheila. 2003. “The Affordable Housing Crisis: Residential Mobility of Poor Families and School Mobility of Poor Children.” The Journal of Negro Education72 (1): 22–38.
12.
CunninghamMaryGalvezMarthaArandaClaudia L.SantosRobWissokerDougOnetoAlyse D.PitingoloR.CrawfordJames. 2018. A Pilot Study of Landlord Acceptance of Housing Choice Vouchers. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
13.
CuttsDiana BeckerMeyersAlan F.BlackMaureen M.CaseyPatrick H.ChiltonMarianaCookJohn T.GeppertJoni, et al. 2011. “U.S. Housing Insecurity and the Health of Very Young Children.” American Journal of Public Health101 (8): 1508–14.
14.
DarrahJenniferDelucaStefanie. 2014. “‘Living Here Has Changed My Whole Perspective’: How Escaping Inner-City Poverty Shapes Neighborhood and Housing Choice.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management33 (2): 350–84. doi:10.1002/pam.21758.
15.
DawkinsCaseyJeonJae Sik. 2018. “Housing Cost Burden in the Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research20 (1): 39–62. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26381220.
16.
DeLucaStefanieGarbodenPhilip M. E.RosenblattPeter. 2013. “Segregating Shelter: How Housing Policies Shape the Residential Locations of Low-Income Minority Families.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science647 (1): 268–99.
DesmondMatthew. 2016. Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City. New York: Crown Publishers.
19.
DesmondMatthewGershensonCarl. 2016. “Housing and Employment Insecurity among the Working Poor.” Social Problems63:46–67.
20.
DesmondMatthewKimbroRachel Tolbert. 2015. “Eviction’s Fallout: Housing, Hardship, and Health.” Social Forces94 (1): 295–324.
21.
DesmondMatthewPerkinsKristin L. 2016. “Are Landlords Overcharging Housing Voucher Holders?” City & Community15 (2): 137–62. doi:10.1111/cico.12180.
22.
DesmondMatthewShollenbergerTracey. 2015. “Forced Displacement From Rental Housing: Prevalence and Neighborhood Consequences.” Demography52 (5): 1751–72.
23.
EggersFrederick J.2017. Characteristics of HUD-Assisted Renters and Their Units in 2013. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
24.
EllenIngrid GouldO’FlahertyBrendan. 2007. “Social Programs and Household Size: Evidence from New York City.” Population Research and Policy Review26 (4): 387–409. doi:10.1007/s11113-007-9036-7.
25.
FinkelMerylBuronLarry. 2001. Study on Section 8 Voucher Success Rates. Washington, DC: Office of Policy Development and Research, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
26.
FreemanLance. 1998. “Interpreting the Dynamics of Public Housing: Cultural and Rational Choice Explanations.” Housing Policy Debate9 (2): 323–53.
27.
FreemanLance. 2005a. “Displacement or Succession? Residential Mobility in Gentrifying Neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review40 (4): 463–91.
28.
FreemanLance. 2005b. “Does Housing Assistance Lead to Dependency? Evidence From HUD Administrative Data.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research8 (2): 115–33.
29.
GalvezMartha. 2010. Getting Past “No”: Housing Choice Voucher Holders’ Experiences with Discrimination and Search Costs. https://prrac.org/pdf/GettingPastNo.pdf.
30.
GalvezMarthaBrennanMayaMeixellBreadyPendallRolf. 2017. Housing as a Safety Net: Ensuring Housing Security for the Most Vulnerable. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
31.
GalvezMarthaSimingtonJasmineTreskonMark. 2017. Moving to Work and Neighborhood Opportunity. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
32.
GellerAmandaCurtisMarah A. 2011. “A Sort of Homecoming: Incarceration and the Housing Security of Urban Men.” Social Science Research40 (4): 1196–1213. doi:10.1016/j.ssresearch.2011.03.008
33.
GellerAmandaFranklinAllyson Walker. 2014. “Paternal Incarceration and the Housing Security of Urban Mothers.” Journal of Marriage and Family76 (2): 411–27.
GravesErin. 2016. “Rooms for Improvement: A Qualitative Metasynthesis of the Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Housing Policy Debate26 (2): 346–61. doi:10.1080/10511482.2015.1072573.
36.
GubitsDanielShinnMarybethWoodMichelleBellStephenDastrupSamuelSolariClaudia D.BrownScott R.McInnisDebiMcCallTomKattelUtsav. 2016. Family Options Study: 3-Year Impacts of Housing and Services Interventions for Homeless Families. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
37.
HowardMadeline. 2007. “Subsidized Housing Policy: Defining the Family.” Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice22 (1): 97–134.
38.
Institute for Children, Poverty & Homelessness. 2011. Profiles of Risk: Characterizing Housing Instability. New York: Institute for Children, Poverty, and Homelessness.
39.
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. 2017. America’s Rental Housing 2017. Cambridge, MA: Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.
40.
KangSeungbeom. 2019. “Why Low-Income Households Become Unstably Housed: Evidence From the Panel Study of Income Dynamics.” Housing Policy Debate29 (4): 559–87.
41.
KimHuiyunBurgardSarah A.SeefeldtKristin S. 2017. “Housing Assistance and Housing Insecurity: A Study of Renters in Southeastern Michigan in the Wake of the Great Recession.” Social Service Review91 (1): 41–70.
42.
KleitRachel GarshickKangSeungbeomScallyCorianne Payton. 2016. “Why Do Housing Mobility Programs Fail in Moving Households to Better Neighborhoods?” Housing Policy Debate26 (1): 188–209.
43.
KushelMargot B.GuptaReenaGeeLaurenHaasJennifer S. 2006. “Housing Instability and Food Insecurity as Barriers to Health Care among Low-Income Americans.” Journal of General Internal Medicine21 (1): 71–77.
44.
LancasterTony. 2000. “The Incidental Parameter Problem since 1948.” Journal of Econometrics95:391–413.
45.
LeeKwan Ok. 2014. “Why Do Renters Stay in or Leave Certain Neighborhoods? The Role of Neighborhood Characteristics, Housing Tenure Transitions, and Race.” Journal of Regional Science54 (5): 755–87.
46.
LundbergIanDonnellyLouis. 2019. “A Research Note on the Prevalence of Housing Eviction Among Children Born in U.S. Cities.” Demography56: 391–404.
47.
MaChristine T.GeeLaurenKushelMargot B. 2008. “Associations Between Housing Instability and Food Insecurity With Health Care Access in Low-Income Children.” Ambulatory Pediatrics8 (1): 50–57.
48.
MarrMatthew D.2005. “Mitigating Apprehension about Section 8 Vouchers: The Positive Role of Housing Specialists in Search and Placement.” Housing Policy Debate16 (1): 85–111.
49.
McClureKirk. 2005. “Rent Burden in the Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research8 (2): 5–20.
50.
McClureKirk. 2008. “Deconcentrating Poverty With Housing Programs.” Journal of the American Planning Association74 (1): 90–99. doi:10.1080/01944360701730165.
51.
McClureKirk. 2017. “Length of Stay in Assisted Housing.” Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
52.
McDonaldLynn. 2011. “Examining Evictions through a Life-Course Lens.” Canadian Public Policy37:S115–33.
53.
McGonagleKatherineSastryNarayan. 2016. “Using the Panel Study of Income Dynamics To Analyze Housing Decisions, Dynamics, and Effects.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research18 (1): 185–99. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4839387/.
MooreKathleen M.2016. “Lists and Lotteries: Rationing in the Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Housing Policy Debate26 (3): 474–87. doi:10.1080/10511482.2015.1129984.
56.
NewmanSandra J.HarknessJoseph. 1999. “The Long-Term Effects of Housing Assistance on Self-Sufficiency: Final Report.” Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. https://www.huduser.gov/portal/Publications/pdf/longterm.pdf.
57.
NewmanSandra J.HarknessJoseph M. 2002. “The Long-Term Effects of Public Housing on Self-Sufficiency.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management21 (1): 21–43. doi:10.1002/pam.1038.
NewmanSandra J.HolupkaC. ScottHarknessJoseph. 2009. “The Long-Term Effects of Housing Assistance on Work and Welfare.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management28 (1): 81–101.
60.
NewmanSandra J.SchnareAnn B. 1997. “‘. . . And a Suitable Living Environment’: The Failure of Housing Programs to Deliver on Neighborhood Quality.” Housing Policy Debate8 (4): 755–62. doi:10.1080/10511482.1997.9521277.
61.
OishiShigehiro. 2010. “The Psychology of Residential Mobility: Implications for the Self, Social Relationships, and Well-Being.” Perspectives on Psychological Science5 (1): 5–21.
62.
OlsenEdgar O.DavisScott E.CarrilloPaul E. 2005. “Explaining Attrition in the Housing Voucher Program.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research8 (2): 95–113.
63.
O’ReganKatherine M.HornKeren M. 2013. “What Can We Learn About the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Program by Looking at the Tenants?”Housing Policy Debate23 (3): 597–613. doi:10.1080/10511482.2013.772909.
64.
PashupJenniferEdinKathrynDuncanGreg J.BurkeKaren. 2005. “Participation in a Residential Mobility Program from the Client’s Perspective: Findings from Gautreaux Two.” Housing Policy Debate16:361–92.
65.
PavaoJoanneAlvarezJenniferBaumrindNikkiInduniMartaKimerlingRachel. 2007. “Intimate Partner Violence and Housing Instability.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine32 (2): 143–46.
66.
PhinneyRobin. 2009. “Residential Mobility, Housing Problems, and Child Outcomes in the Women’s Employment Study.” Washington, DC: Center for Housing Policy.
67.
PhinneyRobinDanzigerSheldonPollackHarold A.SeefeldtKristin. 2007. “Housing Instability Among Current and Former Welfare Recipients.” American Journal of Public Health97 (5): 832–37. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2005.082677.
68.
PopkinSusan J.CunninghamMary K. 2000. “Searching for Rental Housing With Section 8 in the Chicago Region.” Urban Institute No. 06910-000-00. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
69.
ReidKristen W.VittinghoffEricKushelMargot B. 2008. “Association between the Level of Housing Instability, Economic Standing and Health Care Access: A Meta-Regression.” Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved19 (4): 1212–28.
70.
RollinsChiquitaGlassNancy E.PerrinNancy A.BillhardtKris A.CloughAmberBarnesJamieHansonGinger C.BloomTina L. 2012. “Housing Instability Is as Strong a Predictor of Poor Health Outcomes as Level of Danger in an Abusive Relationship: Findings From the SHARE Study.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence27 (4): 623–43.
71.
SardBarbara. 2001. “Housing Vouchers Should Be a Major Component of Future Housing Policy for the Lowest Income Families.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research5 (2): 89–110.
72.
SchwartzAlex F.2014. Housing Policy in the United States. 3rd ed.New York: Routledge.
73.
ShinnMarybethWeitzmanBeth C.StojanovicDanielaKnickmanJames R.JiménezLucilaDuchonLisaJamesSusanKrantzDavid H. 1998. “Predictors of Homelessness among Families in New York City: From Shelter Request to Housing Stability.” American Journal of Public Health88 (11): 1651–57. doi:10.2105/AJPH.88.11.1651.
74.
ShroderMark. 2002. “Does Housing Assistance Perversely Affect Self-Sufficiency? A Review Essay.” Journal of Housing Economics11: 381–417. doi:10.1016/S1051-1377(02)00128-6.
75.
SkobbaKimberlyGoetzEdward G. 2013. “Mobility Decisions of Very Low-Income Households.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research15:155–72.
76.
SkobbaKimberlyGoetzEdward G. 2015. “Doubling Up and the Erosion of Social Capital among Very Low Income Households.” International Journal of Housing Policy15 (2): 127–47.
77.
SmithRobin E.NaparstekArthurPopkinSusan J.BartlettLesleyBatesLisaCignaJessicaCraneRussellVinsonElisa. 2002. “Housing Choice for HOPE VI Relocatees.” Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
78.
SmithRobin E.PopkinSusan J.GeorgeTazComeyJennifer. 2015. “What Happens to Housing Assistance Leavers?” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research17 (3): 213–44.
79.
TurnerMargery AustinBriggsXavier De Souza. 2008. “Assisted Housing Mobility and the Success of Low-Income Minority Families: Lessons for Policy, Practice, and Future Research.” Washington, DC: Metropolitan Housing and Communities Center.
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. 2018. Implementing Small Area Fair Market Rents (SAFMR). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
82.
VaradyDavid P.WangXinhaoMittalJay. 2007. “Developing More Accurate Reasonable Rent Estimates in the U.S. Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Geography Research Forum27:52–69.
83.
VijayaraghavanMayaJacobsElizabeth A.SeligmanHilaryFernandezAlicia. 2011. “The Association Between Housing Instability, Food Insecurity, and Diabetes Self-Efficacy in Low-Income Adults.” Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved22 (4): 1279–91.
84.
WilliamsonAnne R.2011. “Can They Afford the Rent? Resident Cost Burden in Low Income Housing Tax Credit Developments.” Urban Affairs Review47 (6): 775–99. doi:10.1177/1078087411417078.
85.
WoodMichelleTurnhamJenniferMillsGregory. 2008. “Housing Affordability and Family Well-Being: Results from the Housing Voucher Evaluation.” Housing Policy Debate19 (2): 367–412.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
