Abstract
Introduction
Overweight and obesity are the most important risk factor for non-communicable diseases (NCDs) particularly diabetes. 1 Although in recent decades, there have been a partly downwards trend regarding their prevalence especially in developing countries, modeled estimates have predicted a significant increase in this epidemic by 2030. 2
Genuinely, there is a direct correlation between overweight and increasing in inflammatory factors, adipokines in particular which plays a crucial role in causing metabolic disorders such as diabetes.3,4
Recent outcomes emphasis that modest changes in life style and dietary intake can lead to delay the outset these complications specifically for people with prediabetes. 5
Consumption of products containing high omega-3 fatty acids is considered as an effective way in this regard due to their anti-inflammatory properties. Proposed mechanisms include regulating adipokine, such as adiponectin and leptin; alleviating adipose tissue inflammation and promoting adipogenesis. 6 Flaxseed oil as a rich source of omega-3 provides high content of the a-linolenic acid (ALA) which might contribute to a significant extent to reduce inflammation. 7 This source of ALA has potential health benefits, such as anti-chemotactic, anti-inflammatory, anti-atherosclerotic, and antioxidant. 8
The systematic review and meta- analysis represented the effectiveness of flaxseed and its products on the improvement of inflammatory markers in various groups, however, results emphasized on the lack of sufficient evidence in prediabetes individuals. 9
The systematic review to evaluate the anti- inflammatory effects of flaxseed did not find sufficient proof in terms of effectiveness of flaxseed on diminishing C-reactive protein. All the same, it seems that this supplement can ameliorate this index in obese populations. 10
The systematic review in 2019 declared that flaxseed products can decrease circulating concentration of HS – C– reactive protein and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα), but it is not able to alter C-reactive protein and Interleukin 6 (IL6). 11 Regarding to lack of data in prediabetes individuals, its results could not be generalized to all prediabetes. Nevertheless, investigations on obese men and women with prediabetes show that daily ground flaxseed consumption had no significant effect on sensitivity C-reactive protein, adiponectin, and high-sensitivity interleukin-6. 5
Systematic analyses of RCTs showed that flaxseed is a good option for improving body composition and weight management especially in overweight and obese groups, however, it emphasizes that more research is needed to prove these results. 12 The systematic review and meta- analysis aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of herbal medicine in obesity and metabolic syndrome managements demonstrates that flaxseed can reduce appetite, but its anti- obesity effects is still controversial. 13
Although these researches have strongly supported the efficiency of flaxseed consumption in enhancing inflammation and body composition, there is nothing in the way of accurate findings regarding this influence in overweight prediabetes patients. So the aim of present study is evaluating the effect of flaxseed oil on body composition and inflammatory indices in overweight adults with pre-diabetes.
Methods
Trial design
This study was a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial registered in the Iranian registry of clinical trials (www.irct.ir: IRCT20120913010826N27). In the current study, overweight individuals with impaired fasting glucose(IFG) 14 (fasting blood glucose 100-125 mg/dl) and BMI 25-29.9 were included. Exclusion criteria were as follows: receiving hypoglycemic oral medications or insulin, acute and chronic disease apart from glucose tolerance disorder, any sensitivity to flaxseed oil, history of smoking, extreme activity or special diet (more than 150 minutes of aerobic activity with a moderate intensity per week or 75 minutes of aerobic activity with heavy intensity per week, eliminating one or more than 1 group of foods from their routine diet, amenorrhea, taking anti-inflammatory medications (steroidal and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs); consuming flaxseed, flax oil, or fish oil supplement (once or several times a week constantly), consuming fish by over 340 g per week, and using soybean once or several times a week routinely. 15
The procedures followed in this study were according to the Helsinki Declaration. Among 323 overweight patients without history of diabetes aged 30-48 years old (referred to Isfahan cardiovascular research center, Isfahan, Iran, between January and May 2016), only 80 people were included. All participants were informed about protocol of the study. Written informed consent was obtained from all subjects prior to the intervention.
Study design
Participants were allocated to the two treatment arms to receive flaxseed oil supplement (2000-mg, Barij Essence Co., Kashan, batch number 226016) or placebo containing oral paraffin (2000-mg paraffin) twice a day for 14 weeks. Flaxseed oil supplements and placebos capsules were similar in shape and size and manufactured by Barij Essence (Kashan, Iran).
Randomization assignment was performed using randomly computer-generated numbers by a third party in the research group. All participants (patients, healthcare providers, data collectors, and outcome assessors) were blinded by unawareness of the groups.
To assess compliance, the remaining supplements were counted and subtracted from the amount of supplements provided to the subjects. To increase compliance, the drug quota of the individuals was delivered as 2 weeks to the participants, and after this period, they were contacted and invited to receive the next quota. The individuals who did not follow the study protocol were excluded.
Assessment of anthropometric measures
Weight and body composition was measured in the fasting state with bare feet and minimal clothing by scale and Omron body composition monitor. Calculating body composition in Omron’s algorithm is based on the Bioelectrical Impedance Method as well as height, weight, age, and gender.
The height was measured with bare feet on the nearest 0.5 centimeter (cm) using a height Seca wall stadiometer while 4 parts of the body being attached against the wall. The method of calculating BMI was dividing weight by height squared in meters.
Lifestyle assessment
The three-day food records and International Physical Activity Questionnaire 16 were completed to detect the energy, macro- and micronutrient intake and level of physical activity at the beginning of the study along with the 7th and 14th weeks. Furthermore, participants were requested not to change their ordinary physical activity, diet, drug regimens, and lifestyle and not to take any nutritional supplements during the treatment.
Biochemical assessment
At baseline and end of the intervention, after 10 to 12 hours of fasting 5 ml of blood sample was taken from all participants. Serum samples were disjoined from the whole blood by centrifugation at 2606.8×
Colorimetric enzymatic kit (Pars Azmoon Co.) was used for measuring fasting blood glucose concentration. TNF-α was also measured using ELISA method by Orgenium kit. In addition, hs-CRP concentration was determined by means of ELISA (via Hitachi911 chemistry and immunoassay(Sentinel) analysis).
Statistical analysis
Data with normal distribution were reported by means (±SD) and data with abnormal distribution were reported by medians (±IR). To investigate normal distribution of the variables, Shapiro-Wilk and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests were applied. Independent sample t-test and Mann-Whitney were used to examine the dietary intake and participant characteristic variation between 2 groups. Differences in the beginning and end of the study in each group were evaluated by paired t-test or Wilcoxon.
Repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) was done for evaluating statistical significance and time and type of intervention as the factors.
For assessing the correlation between dietary intake and time and intervention multivariate analysis was performed.
Through continuous data sample size determinations, a sample size of 35 participants was necessary to provide a power of 80% to detect a minimum 1 mg/l decrease in CRP with a standard deviation of 1.5 at 95% confidence.5,17 Hence, a preliminary number of 40 number per group was enrolled to supply sufficient numbers to identify differences by repeated measurement analysis of variance and allow for a 13% dropout rate in each group over the course of the study.
Result
Forty participants in control group and 40 participants in intervention group were enrolled. During the follow up, 4 participants in control group and 8 participants in intervention group were failed (Figure 1). In both groups the overall compliance was about 90%. So, statistical analysis was conducted with 32 participants as treatment group and 36 participants as control. Sixty-eight individuals completed the study (32 in intervention group & 36 in control group).

Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) flow diagram.
There were no statistically significant differences in BMI (28.07 ± 1.55 kg/m²) and age (44.92 ± 10.97 years) of participants before treatment between intervention and control group. No significant differences were found in other variables at baseline (Tables 1 and 2).
Baseline characteristics of individuals in the two groups.
Values are the means ± SD.
Median ± Interquartile range.
Dietary intakes of study participants throughout the study.
Data presented as means ± SD. (n = 68 for all dietary intake values presented).
Median ± Interquartile range.
Comparison of the mean value of body composition and inflammatory indices has been shown in Table 3.
Mean of body composition and biomarkers of inflammation at the baseline and after 14 weeks of flaxseed oil supplementation in overweight pre-diabetes patients.
Abbreviations: SD, Standard deviation. * Median ±Interquartile range.
At the end of this survey, Weight (
In addition, analysis showed that mean changes of C reactive protein (
The skeletal muscle% had a significant rise in the intervention group (
The data indicated a significant decrease in Visceral fat level in the intervention group (
Discussion
To the best of our knowledge, no study has reported the effect of flaxseed oil supplement on inflammatory biomarkers and body composition in pre-diabetic overweight people. So, we examined the effect of flaxseed oil on these indices during fourteen weeks. Flaxseed oil has significant amount of ω-3/ω-6 fatty acids. Investigations have declared that consuming the minimum of 2 gr flaxseed oil for at least 12 weeks is sufficient to obtain the greatest increase in RBC n–3 FA content and other tissue which can lead to effective conversion alpha linolenic acid.18,19 Hence, effectiveness of this dose have been evaluated over this study. Our study declared that flaxseed oil consumption over 14-week period cannot improve inflammation and body composition in overweight prediabetes people.
One study showed that daily consumption of 40 grams of ground flaxseed in people with insulin resistance during 12 weeks does not show changes in CRP, interleukin 6 and TNFα levels. 20 Study in pre-diabetic obese or overweight people also showed that intaking ground flaxseed in various amounts (13 g and 26 g) did not affect on inflammatory markers such as CRP, interleukin-6 and adiponectin. 5 In regard to our study, Consumption of 2 g/day of flaxseed oil for 12 weeks in healthy individuals also had no effect on CRP and TNFα levels. 21 Results from a study by Coblij et al 22 on 62 healthy individuals who consumed 3.6 g of flaxseed oil per day for 12 weeks also showed that taking this supplement did not change the levels of CRP and TNFα in these people. Similarly, results of the present study illustrated that there were no significant changes in inflammatory indices between the 2 groups by the end of the 14th week. Surprisingly, the level of TNFα in control group was significantly unchanged at the end of study. As long as the mean change of this index between 2 groups was not significant at 14th week, this stability may be due to differences in initial levels of RBC n–3 FA content between 2 groups.
In contrast, the investigation on a diabetic rat model declared that flaxseed oil consumption assisted to improve inflammatory indices especially TNFα and IL-6. 23 Furthermore, outcomes demonstrate that flaxseed plays a crucial role in reducing oxidative stress in individuals with T2D, 24 hemodialysis groups with lipid abnormalities 25 and people with ulcerative colitis. 26 Actually, it seems that flaxseed shows better anti- inflammatory effects in people with high levels of inflammation. It is important to conduct more researches to accept this point.
The study on overweight women, who consumed ground flaxseed, emphasized that this supplement cannot improve body composition and insulin- related indices. 27 Additionally, the investigation on hypercholesteremic subjects with overweight also showed that flaxseed oil cannot significantly modulate energy expenditure and body composition. 28
Other studies on overweight adolescences, 28 old adults with overweight 29 did not also support the effectiveness of flaxseed on improving body composition. In fact, these outcomes are consistent with the current survey. However, the systematic review in relation to evaluating the effect of flaxseed supplement on body composition delineates that flaxseed has positive effects on body composition in individuals with BMI of ⩾ 30. 12 Besides, consuming flaxseed oil in obese individuals with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease led to reduction in body fat. 30 It assumed that higher BMI has a potent moderating impact on effectiveness of this supplement regarding body composition. Surprisingly, in this study we observed a significant decrease in visceral fat level as well as skeletal muscle in each group at 14th week. As far as the mean changes for these variations were no significant at the end of study, these improvements may be due to the optimal level of demographic indicators in the study population that followed a healthy lifestyle.
Machado AM and colleagues compared the effects of brown and golden flaxseeds on body weight and BMI in overweight adolescents. This study found that brown and golden flaxseed did not significantly affect these indices. 31 Moreover, Saleh-ghadimi and colleagues showed that supplementation with flaxseed oil did not have a statistically significant effect on anthropometric indices include weight, body mass index, hip circumference and waist circumference. 32 Additionally, other study on overweight hypercholesterolemia individuals ruled out the effectiveness of flaxseed oil on reducing body weight and BMI. 28 These results support our conclusions.
The investigation on overweight and obese adults disclosed that whole flaxseed can considerably decrease body weight. 33 A meta-analysis of 45 RCTs suggested a significant reduction in body weight, BMI and waist circumference after treatment with whole flaxseed. Subgroup analyses showed that using whole flaxseed in doses ⩾30 g d−1 and ⩾12 weeks’ duration of intervention, especially in participants with higher BMI (⩾ 27 kg m−2) had positive effects on body composition. So, whole flaxseed is a good choice for weight management especially in overweight and obese participants. 12 Indeed, further investigations are essential to evaluate the effect of various source of flaxseed on groups with different BMI ranges.
Strengths and limitations
RCT design, acceptable sample size and duration of present study are major strengths of the study. Also, restriction of participants by exclusion criteria for controlling the potential confounders such as hypoglycemic situation and anti-inflammatory drug usage was another strengths of study. In addition, in present study dietary intake and physical activity was evaluated. Unfortunately, RBC n–3 FA content, blood insulin levels and insulin resistance was not measured in this study.
In the previous study, 15 which was conducted by our group, inflammatory indices underwent a significant increase in the control group at the end of study. Hence, we took it for granted that flaxseed oil might have disclosed effectiveness on the very factors on condition that the number of participants had been increased. As a result, two-fold increase in the sample size should be regarded as the prominent differentiation point in the recent study. Moreover, anthropometric indices were also being investigated along with the very factors.
For future, we recommend researchers to separate lignin from your seed in order to observe the effect of lignin and omega-3 separately on inflammatory markers in pre-diabetic individuals. Also, more studies are needed to look at the possible effects of this supplement on people with high inflammatory index and various BMI range. It is suggested that in the future, studies with larger sample sizes, different doses of flaxseed oil and longer intervention time be performed.
Conclusion
Our study declared that flaxseed oil consumption cannot improve inflammation and body composition in overweight prediabetes people.
