We address individual-level hypotheses from Braithwaite’s shaming theory
using Russian survey data. The results are mixed. Disintegrative shaming is
associated with future misconduct, but being reintegratively shamed is also
positively predictive of projected crime/deviance while participating in gossip is
unrelated to future deviance. Interdependency does not seem to enhance the effects
of shaming variables. In addition, guilt and fear of losing respect from others for
potential misbehavior do not seem to be related to past shaming experiences nor do
they mediate supposed relationships between past shaming experiences and misconduct.
These results, in conjunction with the collective body of evidence already compiled,
suggest that the theory may need further refinement.
Ahmed, Eliza
(2001) ‘Shame Management: Regulating
Bullying’, in
E. Ahmed
,
N. Harris
,
J. Braithwaite
and
V. Braithwaite
(eds) Shame Management through Reintegration, pp.
211-311.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
2.
Ahmed, Eliza
,
Nathan Harris
,
John Braithwaite
and
Valerie Braithwaite
(2001) Shame Management through Reintegration.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
3.
Aiken, Leona S.
and
Stephen G. West
(1991) Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting
Interactions.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications
.
4.
Ajzen, Icek
(1991)
‘The Theory of Planned Behavior’
, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes50(2):
179-204
.
5.
Akers, Ronald L.
(1996)
‘Is Differential Association/Social Learning Cultural Deviance Theory?’
, Criminology34(2):
229-256
.
6.
Akers, Ronald L.
(2000) Criminological Theories: Introduction, Evaluation, and
Application.
Los Angeles, CA: Roxbury
.
7.
Akers, Ronald L.
and
Gary F. Jensen
(2003) Social Learning Theory and the Explanation of
Crime.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction
.
8.
Albarracin, Dolores
,
Blair T. Johnson
,
Martin Fishbein
and
Paige A. Muellerleile
(2001)
‘Theories of Reasoned Action and Planned Behavior as Models of
Condom Use: A Meta-Analysis’
, Psychological Bulletin127(1):
142-161
.
9.
Anderson, Elijah
(1978) A Place on the Corner.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
10.
Anderson, Elijah
(1999) Code of the Streets: Decency, Violence, and the Moral
Life of the Inner City.
New York: W.W. Norton
.
11.
Baier, Colin
and
Bradley R. Entner Wright
(2001)
‘If You Love Me, Keep My Commandments: A Meta-Analysis of the
Effect of Religion on Crime’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency38(1):
3-21
.
12.
Baumer, Eric P.
,
Richard Wright
,
Kristum Kristinsdottir
and
Helgi Gunnalaugsson
(2002)
‘Crime, Shame, and Recidivism: The Case of Iceland’
, British Journal of Criminology41(1):
40-59
.
13.
Bellair, Paul E.
(1997)
‘Social Interaction and Community Crime: Examining the Importance
of Neighborhood Networks’
, Criminology35(4):
677-703
.
14.
Benda, Brent B.
(2002)
‘Religion and Violent Offenders in Boot Camp: A Structural
Equation Model’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency39(1):
91-121
.
15.
Braithwaite, John
(1981)
‘The Myth of Social Class and Criminality Reconsidered’
, American Sociological Review46(1):
36-57
.
16.
Braithwaite, John
(1989) Crime, Shame and Reintegration.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
17.
Braithwaite, John
(1999)
‘Restorative Justice: Assessing Optimistic and Pessimistic Accounts’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research25:
1-127
.
18.
Braithwaite, John
(2001a)
‘Crime in a Convict Republic’
, The Modern Law Review64(1):
11-50
.
19.
Braithwaite, John
(2001b)
‘Restorative Justice and a New Criminal Law of Substance Abuse’
, Youth and Society33(2):
227-248
.
20.
Braithwaite, John
(2002) Restorative Justice and Responsive Regulation.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
21.
Braithwaite, John
and
Valerie Braithwaite
(2001) ‘Shame and Shame
Management’, in
E. Ahmed
,
N. Harris
,
J. Braithwaite
and
V. Braithwaite
(eds) Shame Management and Regulation, pp.
3-69.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
22.
Cialdini, Robert B.
,
Richard E. Petty
and
John T. Cacioppo
(1981)
‘Attitude and Attitude Change’
, Annual Review of Psychology32:
357-404
.
23.
Clelland, Donald
and
Timothy J. Carter
(1980)
‘The New Myth of Class and Crime’
, Criminology18(3):
319-336
.
24.
Colvin, Mark
(2000) Crime and Coercion: An Integrated Theory of Chronic
Criminality.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
25.
Colvin, Mark
,
Francis T. Cullen
and
Thomas Vander Ven
(2002)
‘Coercion, Social Support, and Crime: An Emerging Theoretical Consensus’
, Criminology40(1):
19-42
.
26.
Cureton, Stephen R.
(2005) Crip’n in Hoover (forthcoming).
27.
Durkheim, Emile
(1951 [1897]) Suicide: A Study in Sociology. Trans.
J.A. Spaulding and G. Simpson. Ed. with an introduction by
G. Simpson
. Reprint.
Glencoe, NY: Free Press
.
28.
Evans, T. David
,
Francis T. Cullen
,
R. Gregory Dunaway
and
Velmer S. Burton, Jr
(1995)
‘Religion and Crime Re-Examined: The Impact of Religion, Secular
Controls, and Social Ecology on Adult Criminality’
, Criminology33(2):
195-224
.
29.
Fischer, Claude S.
(1984) The Urban Experience (2nd edn).
New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
.
30.
Fishbein, Martin
and
Icek Ajzen
(1975) Beliefs, Attitudes, Intention and Behavior.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
31.
Froese, Paul
(2004)
‘Forced Secularization in Soviet Russia: Why an Atheistic
Monopoly Failed’
, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion43(1):
35-50
.
32.
Gordon, Rachel A.
,
Benjamin B. Lahey
,
Eriko Kawai
,
Rolf Loeber
,
Magda Stouthamer-Loeber
and
David P. Farrington
(2004)
‘Antisocial Behavior and Youth Gang Membership: Selection and Socialization’
, Criminology42(1):
55-87
.
33.
Goskomstat
(2002) Regions with Population of 3000 and More.
Moscow, Russia: Federal’naia Sluzhba
Gosudarstvennoy Statistiki
. Retrieved June 2005.
34.
Gottfredson, Michael R.
and
Travis Hirschi
(1990) A General Theory of Crime.
Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press
.
35.
Gove, Walter R.
(ed.) (1980) The Labelling of Deviance: Evaluating a
Perspective (2nd edn).
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications
.
36.
Grasmick, Harold G.
and
Robert J. Bursik, Jr
(1990)
‘Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice: Extending
the Deterrence Model’
, Law and Society Review24(3):
837-861
.
37.
Grasmick, Harold G.
,
Robert J. Bursik, Jr
and
Bruce J. Arneklev
(1993)
‘Reduction in Drunk Driving as a Response to Increased Threats of
Shame, Embarrassment, and Legal Sanctions’
, Criminology31(1):
41-67
.
38.
Green, Donald E.
(1989)
‘Measures of Illegal Behavior in Individual-Level Deterrence Research’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency26(3):
253-275
.
39.
Hagan, John
(1992)
‘The Poverty of a Classless Criminology’
, Criminology30(1):
1-19
.
40.
Harris, Nathan
(2001) ‘Shaming and Shame: Regulating
Drink-Driving’, in
E. Ahmed
,
N. Harris
,
J. Braithwaite
and
V. Braithwaite
(eds) Shame Management through Reintegration, pp.
73-207.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
41.
Hay, Carter
(2001)
‘An Exploratory Test of Braithwaite’s Reintegrative
Shaming Theory’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency38(2):
132-153
.
42.
Hirschi, Travis
(1996)
‘Theory without Ideas: Reply to Akers’
, Criminology34(2):
249-256
.
43.
Kachev, Nikolai V.
and
Alexander G. Pipiya
(1994)
‘Crime and Human Rights in Russia: Review of Basic Legislation’
, Demokratizatsiya: Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization2:
358-363
.
44.
Katz, Jack
(1988) Seductions of Crime: Moral and Sensual Attractions in
Doing Evil.
New York: Basic Books
.
45.
Kim, Sang-Weon
and
William A. Pridemore
(2005)
‘Social Change, Institutional Anomie and Serious Property Crime
in Transitional Russia’
, British Journal of Criminology45(1):
81-97
.
46.
Kornhauser, Ruth Rosner
(1978) Social Sources of Delinquency: An Appraisal of
Analytic Models.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
47.
Kuznetsova, Ninel F.
(1994)
‘Crime in Russia: Causes and Prevention’
, Demo-kratizatsiya; Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization2:
442-452
.
48.
Liebow, Elliott
(1967) Tally’s Corner: A Study of Negro
Streetcorner Men.
Boston, MA: Little Brown
.
49.
Lu, Hong
(1999)
‘Bang Jiao and Reintegrative Shaming in China’s Urban Neighborhoods’
, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Justice23(1):
115-125
.
50.
McCall, Nathan
(1994) Makes Me Wanna Holler: A Young Black Man in
America.
New York: Random House
.
51.
Makkai, Toni
and
John Braithwaite
(1994)
‘Reintegrative Shaming and Compliance with Regulatory Standards’
, Criminology32(3):
361-383
.
52.
Meier, Robert F.
(ed.) (1985) Theoretical Methods in Criminology.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications
.
53.
Messner, Stephen F.
,
Marvin D. Krohn
and
Allen E. Liska
(eds) (1989) Theoretical Integration in the Study of Deviance
and Crime: Problems and Prospects.
Albany, NY: State University of New York Press
.
54.
Miethe, Terance D.
,
Hong Lu
and
Erin Reese
(2000)
‘Reintegrative Shaming and Recidivism Risks in Drug Court:
Explanations for Some Unexpected Findings’
, Crime and Delinquency46(4):
522-541
.
55.
Moffitt, Terrie E.
(1990) ‘The Neuropsychology of Delinquency: A
Critical Review of Theory and Research’, in
N. Morris
and
M. Tonry
(eds) Crime and Justice, vol. 12, pp.
99-169.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
.
56.
Moffitt, Terrie E.
(1993)
‘Adolescence-Limited and Life-Course-Persistent Antisocial
Behavior: A Developmental Taxonomy’
, Psychological Review100(4):
674-701
.
57.
Murray, Glenn F.
and
Patricia G. Erickson
(1987)
‘Longitudinal Research: An Empirical Comparison of Projected and
Subsequent Criminality’
, Social Science Research16(1):
107-118
.
58.
Murray, Sandra L.
,
Paul Rose
,
Gina M. Bellavia
,
John G. Holmes
and
Anna Garret Kusche
(2002)
‘When Rejection Stings: How Self-Esteem Constrains
Relationship-Enhancement Processes’
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology83(3):
556-573
.
59.
Paternoster Raymond
,
Robert Brame
,
Paul Mazerolle
and
Alex Piquero
(1998)
‘Using the Correct Statistical Test for the Equality of
Regression Coefficients’
, Criminology36(1):
859-866
.
60.
Paternoster, Raymond
,
Linda Saltzman
,
Gordon Waldo
and
Theodore G. Chiricos
(1983)
‘Perceived Risk and Social Control: Do Sanctions Really Deter?’
, Law and Society Review17(3):
457-479
.
61.
Paternoster, Raymond
,
Linda Saltzman
,
Gordon Waldo
and
Theodore G. Chiricos
(1985)
‘Assessments of Risk and Behavioral Experience: An Exploratory
Study of Change’
, Criminology23(3):
417-433
.
62.
Pearson, Frank S.
and
Neil Alan Weiner
(1985)
‘Toward an Integration of Criminological Theories’
, Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology76(1):
116-150
.
63.
Pogarsky, Greg
(2004)
‘Projected Offending and Contemporaneous Rule-Violation:
Implications for Heterotypic Continuity’
, Criminology42(1):
111-135
.
64.
Pogarsky, Greg
and
Alex R. Piquero
(2003)
‘Can Punishment Encourage Offending? Investigating the Resetting Effect’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency40(1):
95-120
.
65.
Pridemore, William A.
(2002)
‘Vodka and Violence: Alcohol Consumption and Homicide Rates in Russia’
, American Journal of Public Health92(12):
1921-1930
.
66.
Pridemore, William A.
(2003)
‘Measuring Homicide in Russia: A Comparison of Estimates from the
Crime and Vital Statistics Reporting Systems’
, Social Science and Medicine57(8):
1343-1354
.
67.
Pridemore, William A.
and
Vladimir M. Shkolnikov
(2004)
‘Education and Marriage as Protective Factors Against Homicide
Mortality: Methodological and Substantive Findings from Moscow’
, Journal of Quantitative Criminology20(2):
173-187
.
68.
Raine, Adrian
(1993) The Psychopathology of Crime.
New York: Academic Press
.
69.
Sampson, Robert J.
(1991)
‘Linking the Micro- and Macrolevel Dimensions of Community Social Organization’
, Social Forces70(1):
43-64
.
70.
Sampson, Robert J.
and
W. Byron Groves
(1989)
‘Community Structure and Crime: Testing Social Disorganization Theory’
, American Journal of Sociology94(4):
774-803
.
71.
Savitsky, Kenneth
,
Nicholas Epley
and
Thomas Gilovich
(2001)
‘Do Others Judge Us as Harshly as We Think? Over Estimating the
Impact of Our Failures, Shortcomings, and Mishaps’
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology81(1):
44-56
.
72.
Scheff, Thomas J.
and
Suzanne M. Retzinger
(1991) Emotions and Violence: Shame and Rage in Destructive
Conflicts.
Lexington, MA: Lexington Books
.
73.
Sheppard, Blair H.
,
Jon Hartwick
and
Paul R. Warshaw
(1988)
‘The Theory of Reasoned Action: A Meta-Analysis of Past Research
with Recommendations for Modification and Future Research’
, Journal of Consumer Research15(3):
325-343
.
74.
Sherman, Lawrence W.
(1993)
‘Defiance, Deterrence, and Irrelevance: A Theory of the Criminal Sanction’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency30(4):
445-473
.
75.
Thornberry, Terence P.
and
Margaret Farnworth
(1982)
‘Social Correlates of Criminal Involvement: Further Evidence of
the Relationship between Social Status and Criminal Behavior’
, American Sociological Review47(4):
505-518
.
76.
Tittle, Charles R.
(1975)
‘Deterrents or Labeling’
, Social Forces53(3):
399-410
.
77.
Tittle, Charles R.
(1980) Sanctions and Social Deviance: The Question of
Deterrence.
New York: Praeger
.
78.
Tittle, Charles R.
(1995) Control Balance: Toward a General Theory of
Deviance.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
79.
Tittle, Charles R.
and
Robert F. Meier
(1990)
‘Specifying the SES/Delinquency Relationship’
, Criminology28(2):
271-299
.
80.
Tittle, Charles R.
and
Raymond Paternoster
(2000) Social Deviance and Crime: An Organizational and
Theoretical Approach.
Los Angeles, CA: Roxbury
.
81.
Tittle, Charles R.
and
Wayne J. Villemez
(1977)
‘Social Class and Criminality’
, Social Forces56(2):
475-502
.
82.
Tittle, Charles R.
and
Michael R. Welch
(1983)
‘Religiosity and Deviance: Toward a Contingency Theory of
Constraining Effects’
, Social Forces61(3):
653-682
.
83.
Tittle, Charles R.
,
Jason Bratton
and
Marc G. Gertz
(2003)
‘A Test of a Micro-Level Application of Shaming Theory’
, Social Problems50(4):
593-618
.
84.
Tittle, Charles R.
,
Wayne J. Villemez
and
Douglas A. Smith
(1978)
‘The Myth of Social Class and Criminality: An Empirical
Assessment of the Empirical Evidence’
, American Sociological Review43(5):
643-656
.
85.
Vagg, Jon
(1998)
‘Delinquency and Shame: Data from Hong Kong’
, British Journal of Criminology38(2):
247-264
.
86.
Waller, Michael
(1994)
‘Organized Crime and the Russian State’
, Demokratizatsiya: Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization2:
364-383
.
87.
Warr, Mark
(2002) Companions in Crime: Social Aspects of Criminal
Conduct.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
88.
Williams, Kirk
and
Richard Hawkins
(1986)
‘Perceptual Research on General Deterrence: A Critical Review’
, Law and Society Review20(4):
545-572
.
89.
Wright, Bradley R. Entner
,
Avshalom Caspi
,
Terrie E. Moffitt
,
Richard A. Miech
and
Phil A. Silva
(1999)
‘Reconsidering the Relationship between SES and Delinquency:
Causation But Not Correlation’
, Criminology37(1):
175-194
.
90.
Zhang, Lening
and
Sheldon Zhang
(2004)
‘Reintegrative Shaming and Predatory Delinquency’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency41(4):
433-453
.
91.
Zhang, Lening
,
Dengke Zhou
,
Steven D. Messner
,
Allen E. Liska
,
Marvin D. Krohn
,
Jianhong Liu
and
Lu Zhou
(1996)
‘Crime Prevention in a Communitarian Society: Bang-Jiao and
Tiao-Jie in the People’s Republic of China’
, Justice Quarterly13(2):
199-222
.
92.
Zhang, Sheldon S.
(1995)
‘Measuring Shaming in an Ethnic Context’
, British Journal of Criminology35(2):
248-262
.
