Extensive public debate has been held recently about the rights of British lesbians
to access medically prepared donor sperm. Public statements by the head of the Human
Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) indicate that this agency may be
preparing to reconsider its objections to the acquisition of donor sperm by
lesbians. By examining the evolution of sperm banking in the United States and
Britain, this essay considers the consequences of open market versus state control
over medicalized sperm for lesbians. It argues that sexuality alone does not
determine the ability of lesbians to access sperm under either system and that
officially ending the discriminatory practices of the HFEA may not guarantee access
for all lesbians.
Arnup, K.
and
Boyd, S.
(1995) ‘Familial Disputes? Sperm Donors, Lesbian
Mothers, and Legal Parenthood’, in
D. Herman
and
C. Stychin
(eds) Legal Inversions: Lesbians, Gay Men and the Politics of Law,
pp. 77-101.
Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
.
2.
BBC
(2004)
‘Sperm Donors to Lose Anonymity’
, BBC News. Available at
news.bbc.co.uk/1/health/3414141 (accessed 8 February 2004).
3.
Benkov, L.
(1994) Reinventing the Family: The Emerging Story of Lesbian
and Gay Families.
New York: Crown Publishing
.
4.
Blackstock, C.
(2004)
‘No Need for Fathers in IVF Treatment says Fertility Chief’
, The Guardian 21 January.
5.
Bock, G.
and
James, S.
(eds) (1992) Beyond Equality and Difference: Citizenship,
Feminist Politics and Female Subjectivity.
London: Routledge
.
6.
Boggis, T.
(2000) ‘First Class: Economics and Queer
Families’, in
J. Wells
(ed.) Home Fronts: Controversies in Non-Traditional Parenting,
117-122.
Los Angeles: Alyson Books
.
7.
Boseley, S.
(2003)
‘No Sex Required’
, the Guardian 1 July.
8.
Boseley, S.
(2004)
‘Sperm Donor Clinic for Lesbians’
, the Guardian 8 March.
9.
Cooper, D.
(1995) Power in Struggle: Feminism, Sexuality and the
State.
New York: New York University Press
.
10.
Cooper, D.
and
Herman, D.
(1995) ‘Getting the Family Right: Legislating
Heterosexuality in Britain, 1986-1991’, in
D. Herman
and
C. Stychin
(eds) Legal Inversions Lesbians, Gay Men and the Politics of Law,
162-179.
Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
.
11.
Davis-Floyd, R.
and
Dumit, J.
(eds) (1998) Cyborg Babies: From Techno-Sex to
Techno-Tots.
New York: Routledge
.
12.
Ertman, M.
(2003)
‘What’s Wrong With a Parenthood Market? A New and
Improved Theory of Commodification’
, North Carolina Law Review82 (December):
1-59
.
13.
Fader, Sonia
(1993) ‘Sperm Banking: A Reproductive
Resource’, California Cryobank. Available at
http://www.cryobank.com/sbanking.cfm?page=2&sub=126 (accessed 8
February 2004).
14.
Fox, D.
(1986) Health Policies, Health Politics: The British and
American Experiences, 1911-1965.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
15.
Harlow, H.
(1996)
‘Paternalism Without Paternity: Discrimination Against Single
Women Seeking Artificial Insemination by Donor’
, Southern California Review of Law and Women’s Studies6 (Fall 1996):
173-220
.
16.
Harne, L.
and
Rights of Women
(1997) Valued Families: The Lesbian Mothers’ Legal
Handbook.
London: Namara Group
.
17.
Herman, D.
(1994) Rights of Passage: Struggles for Lesbian and Gay Legal
Equality.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
.
18.
HFEA
(2003) ‘HFEA Expresses Concern Over Unregulated
Sperm Donation Services’.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Administration
. Available at http://www.hfea.gov.uk (accessed 11 February 2004).
19.
Hill, Amelia
(2003)
‘Gay Couples Find Unlikely Ally in the Baby-Making Business’
, the Observer 24 August.
20.
Illingworth, N.
(2001) ‘The Internet Matters: Exploring the Use
of the Internet as a Research Tool’, Sociological
Research Online, vol. 6, no.2. Available at
http://www.socresonline.org.uk/6/2/illingworth.html (accessed 20 June 2004).
21.
Koven, S.
and
Michel, S.
(eds) (1992) Mothers of a New World: Maternalist Politics and
the Origins of the Welfare State.
London: Routledge
.
22.
Mann, C.
and
Stewart, F.
(2000) Internet Communication and Qualitative Research: A
Handbook for Researching Online.
London: Sage
.
23.
Plotz, D.
(2001a) ‘Merchant Semen’,
Slate. Available at http://slate.msn.com/id/111905 (accessed
10 February 2004).
24.
Plotz, D.
(2001b) ‘The Rise of the Smart Sperm Shopper:
How the Repository for Germinal Choice Accidentally Revolutionized Sperm
Banking’, Slate. Available at
http://www.slate.msn.com/id/104633 (accessed 10 February 2004).
25.
Polikoff, N.
(1990)
‘This Child Does Have Two Mothers’
, Georgetown Law Journal78(459):
461-475
.
26.
Radford, J.
(1991)
‘Immaculate Conceptions’
, Trouble and Strife21 (summer):
8-12
.
27.
Rothman, Barbara Katz
(1989) Recreating Motherhood: Ideology and Technology in a
Patriarchal Society.
New York: Norton
.
28.
Saffron, L.
(2001) It’s a Family Affair: The Complete Lesbian
Parenting Book.
London: Diva Press
.
29.
Saffron, L.
(2002)
‘Can Fertility Service Providers Justify Discrimination Against Lesbians?’Human Fertility5:
42-46
.
30.
Saffron, L.
(2004) ‘Man Not Included - Can a Service run by a
Straight Man be Good for Lesbians?’ Available at
http://www.lsbr28029.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/ManNotIncluded-PPAdvice.htm
(accessed 27 June 2004).
31.
Schater, J. S.
(2000)
‘Symposium on Unfinished Feminist Business: Constructing Families
in a Democracy: Courts, Legislatures, and Second-Parent Adoption’
, Chicago-Kent Law Review75:
933-951
.
32.
Squires, Sally
(1992)
‘Shopping for Safe Sperm’
, Washington Post 11 February:
1, 10-12
.
33.
The Times
(2004)
‘Sperm Decision Will Make Shortage Worse’
, The Times 21 January 2004.
34.
Tuohy, C. Hughes
(1999) Accidental Logics: The Dynamics of Change in the
Health Care Arena in the United States, Britain and Canada.
New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
35.
Vercollon, C. Frost
,
Moss, H.
and
Moss, R.
(1997) Helping the Stork: The Choices and Challenges of Donor
Insemination.
New York: John Wiley and Sons
.
36.
Washington Post
(2004)
‘More Tissue Banks Must Register with FDA’
, Washington Post 21 January.
37.
American Association of Tissue Banks. Available at
http://www.aatb.org (accessed 10 February 2004).
38.
Clinical Laboratories Improvement Amendments. Available at
http://www.cms.hhs.gov/clia (accessed 10 February 2004).
39.
Cryobank of California. Available at http://www.cryobank.com
(accessed 8 February 2004).
40.
Cryogenic Laboratories Incorporated. Available at
(http://www.cryolab.com (accessed 30 June 2004).
41.
Fairfax Cryobank. Available at http://www.fairfaxcryobank.com
(accessed 21 January 2004).
42.
Idant Laboratories. Available at http://www.idant.com (accessed 4
February 2004).
43.
PinkParents. Available at www.PinkParents.org.uk (accessed
December 2004)
44.
Rainbow Network. Available at
http://www.rainbownetwork.com/forums/msg.asp?msgid=138756 (accessed 29
June 2004).
45.
Xytex. Available at http://www.Xytex.com (accessed 30 June 2004).
