The rights to social security and social assistance are protected by the European Social Charter and its quasi-judicial body, the European Committee of Social Rights. Less is known about the precise content of these rights. Following a decision, published on 15 February 2023, on a collective complaint lodged by the Finnish Society of Social Rights, an NGO, this paper proposes to critically question the positive content given by the Committee to these rights, when it attaches – and even assimilates – certain legal requirements to one specific social indicator, the poverty threshold, defined restrictively.
Akandji-KombéJ-F (2001) Charte sociale et droit Communautaire. In: Akandji-KombéJ-FLeclercS (eds) La Charte sociale européenne. Brussels: Bruylant, pp. 149–177.
2.
AngeliriSCaslaKVan DrooghenbroeckS (eds) (2024 – in press) The European Social Charter. A commentary, vol. 3, Articles 11 to 19. Leiden: Brill.
3.
AtkinsonTCantillonBMarlierE, et al. (2002) Social indicators. The EU and social inclusion. Oxford / New-York: Oxford University Press.
4.
AtkinsonTMarlierENolanB (2004) Indicators and targets for social inclusion in the European Union. Journal of Common Market Studies42(1): 47–75.
5.
BenelhocineC (2011) La Charte Sociale Européenne. Strasbourg: Edition du Conseil de l’Europe.
6.
BonnechèreM (2001) Charte sociale et droits nationaux. In: Akandji-KombéJ-FLeclercS (eds) La Charte sociale européenne. Brussels: Bruylant, pp. 105–121.
7.
BrillatR (2005) The supervisory machinery of the European Social Charter: Recent developments and their impact. In: De BúrcaGDe WitteB (eds) Social rights in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 31–43.
8.
CousinsM (2008) The European Convention on Human Rights and social security law. Antwerp/Oxford/Portland: Intersentia.
9.
CullenH (2009) The collective complaints system of the European Social Charter: Interpretative methods of the European Committee of Social Rights. Human Rights Law Review9(1): 61–93.
10.
DalliM (2020) The content and potential of the right to social assistance in light of Article 13 of the European Social Charter. European Journal of Social Security22(1): 3–23.
11.
De BeckerE (2015) The constraints of fundamental social rights on EU economic monitoring: Collective complaint No. 76-80/2012, Ika-etam, Panhellenic Federation of Public Service Pensioners, ISAP, POS-DEI, ATE V. Greece. European Journal of Social Security17(1): 123–134.
12.
De BeckerE (2019) Het recht op sociale zekerheid in de Europese Unie. Een rechtsvergelijkende analyse op basis van het Europees Sociaal Handvest, het Europees Verdrag voor de Rechten van de Mens en de constitutionele tradities gemeen aan de lidstaten. Bruges: Die Keure.
13.
De BeckerE (2022) Overview of recent cases before the European Court of Human Rights and the European Committee of Social Rights (April 2022–September 2022). European Journal of Social Security24(4): 376–386.
14.
De BeckerE (2023a) Overview of recent cases before the European Court of Human Rights (January – May 2023) and the European Committee of Social Rights (September 2022 – May 2023). European Journal of Social Security25(3): 296–305.
15.
De BeckerE (2023b) The role of social security in the combat of in-work poverty. In: RattiLSchoukensP (dir) Working yet poor. Challenges to EU social citizenship. Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 139–186.
16.
De BeckerE (2024) Overview of recent cases before the European Court of Human Rights and the European Committee of Social Rights (June 2023 – December 2023). European Journal of Social Security21(1): 73–83.
17.
DecancqKGoedeméTVan den BoschK, et al. (2014) The evolution of poverty in the European Union: Concepts, measurement, and data. In: CantillonBVandenbrouckeF (eds) Reconciling work and poverty reduction. How successful are European welfare states?NewYork: Oxford University Press, pp. 60–93.
18.
DecauxEDe SchutterO (2019) Le Pacte international relatif aux droits économiques, sociaux et culturels. Paris: Economica.
19.
De SchutterO (2010) The two lives of the European Social Charter. In: CarlierJ-YDe SchutterOVerdussenM (eds) La Charte sociale européenne : une constitution sociale pour l’Europe. Brussels: Bruylant, pp. 11–37.
20.
De SchutterO (2015) The accession of the European Union to the European Social Charter: A fresh start. European Journal of Human Rights7(3): 155–197.
21.
De SchutterOSant’anaM (2012) The European Committee of Social Rights (the ECSR). In: de BecoG (ed) Human rights monitoring mechanisms of the Council of Europe. London – New-York: Routledge, pp. 71–99.
22.
EleveldAKatrougalosG (2023) The right to social security and social assistance in the ‘case law’ and conclusions of the Social Rights Committee. In: PenningsFVonkG (eds) Research Handbook on European Social Security Law. 2nd ed. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 64–83.
23.
GhailaniD (2017) Violations of fundamental rights: Collateral damage of the eurozone crises? In: VanherckeBNataliDBougetD (eds) Social policy in the European Union: State of play 2016. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute, pp.157–188.
24.
GoedeméTDecerfBVan den, et al. (2022) A new poverty indicator for Europe: The extended headcount ratio. Journal of European Social Policy. 32(3): 239–358.
25.
HachezI (2014) Le Comité européen des droits sociaux confronté à la crise financière grecque : Des décisions osées mais inégalement motivées. Tijdschrift voor Sociaal Recht (TSR) / Revue de Droit Social (RDS)3: 244–279.
26.
LukasK (2021) The Revised European Social Charter. An article by article commentary. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
27.
MikkolaM (2015) The development of European social security standards. In: PenningsFVonkG (eds) Research Handbook on European Social Security Law. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 149–169.
28.
MorsaMPraetB (2020) Le Code européen de sécurité sociale : Un étalon de valeur comme référence pour les systèmes de sécurité sociale européens ?Revue belge de sécurité sociale4(62): 603–649.
29.
NicklessJ (2022) European Code of Social Security. Short Guide. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
30.
NivardC (2013) Seconde condamnation des mesures d’austérité grecques par le Comité européen des droits sociaux. Lettre « Actualités Droits-Libertés » du CREDOF.
31.
PapadopoulosN (2019) Austerity measures in Greece and social rights protection under the European Social Charter. Comment on GSEE v. Greece case, Complaint No. 111/2014, European Committee of Social Rights, 5 July 2017. European Journal of Human Rights10(1): 85–97.
32.
SaulBKinleyDMowbrayJ (2014) The international covenant on economic, social, and cultural rights. Commentary, cases, and materials. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
ServaisJ-M (2004) Normes internationales du travail. Paris: Librairie Générale de Droit et de Jurisprudence.
34.
StangosP (2013) Les rapports entre la Charte sociale européenne et le droit de l’Union européenne – Le rôle singulier du Comité européen des droits sociaux et de sa jurisprudence. Cahiers droit européen2: 319–393.
35.
Świa¸tkowskiA (2007) Charter of Social Rights of the Council of Europe. Alphen: Kluwer Law International.
36.
Van DrooghenbroeckSKrencF (2016) La reception de la « jurisprudence » du Comité européen des droits sociaux par les juridictions européennes. In: Van DrooghenbroeckSDorssemontFVan LimberghenG (eds) Charte sociale européenne, droits sociaux et droits fondamentaux au travail. Brussels: La Charte, pp. 75–95.
37.
Van LimberghenGDumontDLouckxF, et al. (2021) Un regard critique et propositionnel sur les assurances sociales des salariés et des indépendants. Analyse au départ de la recommandation de l’Union européenne relative à l’accès des travailleurs à la protection sociale. Revue belge de sécurité sociale63(4): 49–134.
38.
WassenbergB (2013) Histoire du Conseil de l’Europe. Strasbourg: Conseil de l’Europe.
