Restricted accessOtherFirst published online 2001-05
Airborne Asbestos Concentrations during Abatement of Floor Tile and Mastic: Evaluation of Two Different Containment Systems and Discussion of Regulatory Issues
Regulatory agencies in the United States identify asbes tos-containing floor tile as a friable material when abated. Such categorisation appears to be based on legislation rather than science and exposure data or health risks. This investigation suggests that occupation al (personal) exposure during abatement of floor tile and mastic results in low airborne concentrations of asbestos as determined by phase contrast microscopy. Compari son of personal exposure results for two asbestos abate ment school projects, which collected exposure data dur ing abatement of floor tile and mastic together, one involving full containment and the other a partial con tainment system (critical barriers), suggests a statistical difference in concentrations. However, this difference was not considered to be biologically (health) significant. Other studies that collected exposure data on floor tile and mastic separately support findings of low exposure in studies reporting measurements of these building components together. Summary results as arithmetic and geometric means for occupational samples were below the Occupational Safety and Health Administra tion permissible exposure limit for airborne asbestos fibres. The basis for classifying floor tile and mastic as a friable asbestos-containing material does not appear to be supported by scientific evidence. A discussion of reg ulatory issues associated with asbestos-containing floor tile and mastic is presented.
Lange JH, Kelly DF, Koller KS, Komorek KM, Mamros CT, Mosbacher EM, Polon TM, Thomulka KW: Characteristics of asbestos abatement projects in public buildings in Erie County, Pennsylvania, USA: 1992-1994. Indoor Built Environ1996;5:76-81.
2.
Lange JH: Cost and distribution of bids for asbestos abatement projects in the public sector. Indoor Built Environ2000;9:201-206.
3.
Lange JH, Wade JW, Thomulka KW: Environmental cleanup: A discussion of cost, quality and liability in the asbestos abatement industry. Fresenius Environ Bull1994;3:269-274.
4.
Jaffery Samt , Burdett GJ, Rood AP: An investigation of airborne asbestos concentrations in two U.K. buildings: Before, during and after removal of asbestos. Int J Environ Stud1988; 32:169-180.
5.
Maltoni C.: Call for an international ban on asbestos. Environ Epi Toxicol2000;2:5-7.
6.
HealthEffects Institute - Asbestos Research: Asbestos in Public and Commercial Buildings: A Literature Review and Synthesis of CurrentKnowledge. Cambridge, 1991.
7.
Dement JM, Harris RL, Symans MJ, Shy C.: Estimates of dose-response for respiratory cancer among chrysotile asbestos workers. Ann Occup Hyg1982;28:869-887.
8.
Lange JH, Kaiser G., Thomulka KW: Environmental site assessments and audits: Building inspection requirements . Environ Manage1994;18:151-160.
9.
Lange JH, Grad JW, Lange PA, Thomulka KW, Dunmyre GR, Lee RJ, Richardson CF, Blumershine Rvh: Asbestos abatement of ceiling panels and mold growth in a public school building after water damage: A case study of contaminant levels. Fresenius Environ Bull1993;2:13-18.
10.
Ross M.: The schoolroom asbestos abatement program: A public policy debacle . Environ Geol1995;26:182-188.
11.
Mossman GT, Bignon J., Corn M., Seaton A., Gee Jbl: Asbestos: Scientific developments and implications for public policy . Science1990;247:294-301.
Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Occupational exposure to asbestos: Final rule. 29 CFR 1910.1001 and 29 CFR 1926.1101. Federal Register August 10. Washington, 1994, vol 59, pp 40964-41162.
14.
Mlynarek S. , Corn M., Blake C.: Asbestos exposure of building maintenance personnel. Regul ToxicolPharmacol1996;23:213-224.
15.
US Environmental Protection Agency: Asbestos-containing materials in schools: Final rule and notice. 40 CFR 763, appendix A to subpart E. Federal Register October 30. Washington, 1987, vol 52, pp 41825-41905.
16.
Lange JH: A statistical evaluation of asbestos air concentrations. Indoor Built Environ1999; 8:293-303.
17.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW: An evaluation of personal airborne asbestos exposure measurements during abatement of drywall and floor tile/mastic. Int J Environ Health Res2000; 10: 5-19.
18.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Air sampling during asbestos abatement of floor tile and mastic. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol1999 ;64:673-678.
19.
City of Philadelphia, Department of Public Health, Air and Waste Management Services:, Vinyl asbestos floor tile and mastic, asbestos abatement projects. Memorandum from Ed O'Neill, Operations Manager, Asbestos Control Unit, December 28. Philadelphia, 1995.
20.
Allegheny County Health Department: Toxic Hazardous Air Pollutants, Asbestos Abatement. Pittsburgh, 1996.
21.
Crossman RN , Williams MG, Lauderdale J., Schosek K., Dodson RF: Quantification of fibre releases for various floor tile removal methods. Appl Occup Environ Hyg1996;11:1113-1124.
22.
Lange JH, Kuhn BD, Thomulka KW, Sites Slm: A study of matched area and personal airborne asbestos samples: Evaluation for relationship and distribution. Indoor Built Environ2000; 9:192-200.
23.
Oehlert GW, Lee RJ, Van Orden DR: Statistical analysis of fibre counts. Environmentrics1995;6:115-126.
24.
Daniel WW: Biostatistics: A Foundation for Analysis in the Health Sciences. New York, Wiley & Sons, 1991 .
25.
Shapiro SS, Wilk MB: An analysis of variance test for normality. Biometrika1965 ;52:591-611.
26.
Grubbs RO: Statistical criteria for testing outlying observations. Ann Math Stat1950;21:27-58.
27.
Taylor JK: Statistical Techniques for DataAnalysis. Boca Raton, Lewis, 1990 .
28.
Leidel NA, Busch KA, Lynch JR: Occupational Exposure Sampling Strategy Manual. DEHW (NIOSH) Publication No 77-173, National Technical Information Service No PB-274-792. Cincinnati, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1977.
29.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Effectiveness of engineering controls for airborne lead exposure during renovation/demolition of a commercial building. Indoor Built Environ2000;9:207-215.
30.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Occupational exposure to airborne asbestos during abatement of asbestos-containing pipe and boiler insulation. Fresenius Environ Bull2000;9:477-482.
31.
Lange JH: Occupational exposure during removal of windows with lead-based paint and asbestos caulking. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol2001;66:146-149.
32.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Occupational exposure during lead abatement of steel surfaces by needle gun methodology. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol2000 ;64:463-466.
33.
Lange JH, Lange PR, Reinhard TK, Thomulka KW: A study of personal and area airborne asbestos concentrations during asbestos abatement: A statistical evaluation of fibre concentration data. Ann Occup Hyg1996;40:449-466.
34.
Environ Corporation: Evaluation of worker exposure to airborne fibres during the removal of resilient floor coverings and asphaltic cutback adhesives using recommended work practices (May 1, 1992). Prepared for Resilient Floor Covering Institute and Armstrong World Industries, Arlington, 1992.
35.
Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Administration, Standards Interpretation and Compliance Letters: Sampling of resilient floor covering. Memorandum from Ellen I Roznowski, Acting Director Office of Compliance Assistance, dated 1/6/92. Salt Lake Technical Center, 1992. Internet http://www. OSHA.com.
36.
Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Directives, CPL-2-2.63 - Inspection procedures for occupational exposure to asbestos: Final rule 29 CFR 1910.1001, 1926.1101, and 1915.1001, information date 11/03/95, includes settlement agreement for abatement of floor tile. Washington, Department of Labor, 1995. Internet http://www.OSHA.com.
37.
Paik NW, Walcott RJ, Brogan PA: Worker exposure to asbestos during removal of sprayed materials and renovating activity in building containing sprayed material. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J1983;44:428-432.
38.
Vasconcelos Mtsd, Machado Aasc, Laquipai Pap: Metals and fluoride from electric arc welding fume in real task. Part I. Correlation between the levels of the difference pollutants. Occup Hyg1996;3:311-329.
39.
Letters to the Editor: A log-normal distribution-based exposure assessment method for unbalanced bias. Ann Occup Hyg1998 ;42:413-422.
40.
Rappaport SM : Assessment of long-term exposures to toxic substances in air. Ann Occup Hyg1991;35:61-121.
41.
Kumagai S., Kusaka Y., Goto S.: Log-normality of distribution of occupational exposure concentration to cobalt . Ann Occup Hyg1997;41: 281-286.
42.
Esmen NA, Hammad Y.: Log-normality of environmental sampling data. J Environ SciHealth1977;A12:29-41.
43.
Lange JH, Thomulka KW, Lee RJ, Dunmyre GR: Evaluation of lift and passive sampling methods during asbestos abatement activities. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol1995 ;55:325-331.
44.
Corn M.: Strategies of air sampling. Scand J Work Environ Health1985;11:173-180.
45.
Scheeper B. , Kromhout H., Boleij SM: Wood-dust exposure during wood-working processes . Ann Occup Hyg1995;39:141-154.
46.
Corn M.: Assessment and control of environmental exposure. J Allergy Clin Immunol1983; 72:231-241.
47.
Seixas NS, Heyer NJ, Welp Eae, Checkoway H.: Quantification of historical dust exposures in the diatomaceous earth industry . Ann Occup Hyg1997;41:591-604.
48.
Zock J., Heederik D., Kromhout H.: Exposure to dust, endotoxin and micro-organisms in the potato processing industry . Ann Occup Hyg1995;39:841-854.
49.
NivenRMcL, Fishwick D, Pickering CAC, Fletcher AM, Warburton CJ, Crank P: A study of the performance and comparability of the sampling response to cotton dust of work area and personal sampling techniques. Ann Occup Hyg1992;36:349-362.
50.
Donaldson HM , Stringer WT: Beryllium sampling methods. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J1980;41: 85-90.
51.
Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Standards 29 CFR 1910.1001 to 1910. 1047. Washington, 1996.
52.
Seixas NS, Robins TG, Moulton LH: Use of geometric and arithmetic mean exposures in occupational epidemiology . Am J Ind Med1988;14:465-477.
53.
Armstrong BG : Confidence intervals for arithmetic means of lognormality distribution exposures. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J1992;53:481-485.
54.
Davis Jmg, Addison J., Bolton RE, Donaldson K., Jones AD, Smith T.: The pathogenicity of long versus short fibre samples of amosite asbestos administered to rats by inhalation and intraperitoneal injection. Br JExp Pathol1986; 67:415-430.
55.
Lange JH, Weyel DA, Rosato LM, Tucker D., Malek DE, Mayernick JA, Ryan L.: Preliminary results of smoking patterns for workers attending an asbestos abatement course. Scand J Work Environ Health1987;62:495.
56.
Lange JH: A survey of smoking patterns during an initial asbestos training program . Int J Environ Stud1992;B42:73-79.
57.
United States Court of Appeals: American Iron and Steel Institute and Bethlehem Steel Corporation vs. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Federal Reporter Second Series (DC Cir.), 939, 975-1010, 1991.
58.
Lange JH: Health effects of respirator use at low airborne concentrations. Med Hypotheses2000;54:1005-1007.
59.
Gad SC: Statistical and Experimental Design for Toxicologists. Boca Raton, CRC Press, 1998.
60.
Environmental Protection Agency: Lead exposure associated with renovation and remodeling activities: Environmental field sampling study, vol 2: Appendices. EPA 747-R-96-008. Washington, Office of Pollution Prevention and Toxics, 1997.
