Abstract
Introduction
Following Giovanna Di Chiro's (2008) argument for a ‘coalitional’ approach to social reproduction as an environmental issue, this article examines global representations of magic and witchcraft in Yaba Badoe's young adult novel
Social reproduction theorists have long argued that unpaid work such as caregiving, domestic labour and earthcare, which is predominantly undertaken by women and marginalised groups, is omitted from accounts of productive labour, despite its necessity for the maintenance and reproduction of capitalist social relations (Barca, 2020: 31). Reproduction is here defined three-fold as relating to ‘“biological reproduction, the reproduction of labour power, and the social practices connected to caring, socialization, and the fulfilment of human needs” (p. 4)’ (Bakker and Gill, cited in Di Chiro, 2008: 281). A materialist approach to social reproduction theory and ecology involves acknowledging how this understanding of reproduction, as a biological, economic and social practice, is impacted by conditions ‘inside and outside the workplace such as lack of housing, exposure to asbestos, toxic waste, factory fumes, lack of adequate food, healthcare, and so on’ (Gimenez, 2019: 304). Crucially, if we consider capitalism as a web of life, or a bundle of human and extra-human relations (Moore, 2015), then the role of nature, as the site of and condition for the future flourishing of society and capitalism, must be foregrounded within social reproduction theory, which has had until now a limited focus on ecology.
This article treats social reproduction theory as a way not only of grasping the invisible calculus of gendered forms of unpaid work, but also of registering and challenging the compound pressures put on reproduction, through the exposure of sacrifice zones and communities to the wasteful, polluting impact of capitalist industries. Relatedly, Françoise Vergès (2017) argues, via Isabelle Stengers, for a commitment to ‘counterpowers’, or revealing the hazards of capitalist production ‘to human health, biodiversity, and the lives and well-being of minorities, indigenous communities, and poor peasants, the majority of whom are women’, while maintaining the ‘possibility of a world which does not answer the probabilities offered by green capitalism’. I argue that the resurgence of witches and feminist magical figures is a form of literary resistance by Yaba Badoe, whose work in documentary film and speculative fiction is consistently interested in reigniting the political potential of folklore and witches as earth-defending figures who respond to the worsening socio-ecological conditions brought about by the maturation of extractivist capitalism.
Rather than focusing on texts that engage with particular sites and modes of extraction, this article takes up Martín Arboleda's point that extractive activities now embody uneven ‘reconfigurations in the social composition of the global working class’ that are bound up with the neoliberal ‘dematerialisation’ of value and labour in core regions (2020: Ch. 1). For Arboleda, workers from rural sites of extraction and those from urban manufacturing hubs share ‘increasingly common conditions of existence’. The fragmentation and specialisation of labour, and the racialised and gendered dynamics upon which they depend, are not contrary to the rise and spread of ‘megafactories’ in East Asia, or the ‘casino capitalism’ of financial capitalism, but are part of a wider ‘metabolic process’. This metabolic process is under-defined in Arboleda's text, but implicitly refers to the global reorganisation of biogeographical and social conditions for planetary supply chains in the search for surplus value. Putting this dynamic more baldly, Mezzadra and Neilson argue that it is ‘possible to locate extractive dimensions in operations of capital that are seemingly remote from these domains’ of ‘mines and plantations’ (2017: 186), such as digital ‘mining’, but also in the broadening of debt and consumption. This expanded idea of extraction is focused on how capitalism aims ‘at extracting value’ from populations ‘in such a way that it expands and complements the notion of exploitation’ (Gago and Mezzadra, 2017: 579). The point is not to collapse differently experienced and articulated struggles, but to understand how capitalism expropriates un- and under-paid labour, and treats nature as a ‘sink’ for the extraction of value. Moreover, the struggles over social reproduction, for access to the conditions for flourishing, of ‘universal health care and free education, for environmental justice and access to clean energy, and for housing and public transportation’ are always intertwined with ‘political struggles for women's liberation, against racism and xenophobia, war and colonialism’ (Arruzza et al., 2019: 25). While
Badoe's fictional representation of witches takes inspiration from her research for the documentary film (The Witches of Gambaga 2011), about a community of women accused of being witches and exiled to live in a sanctuary village in Northern Ghana, under the protection of a local chief. Badoe's prose essays, written about the experience of making the film, reveal an astute and materialist understanding that contemporary Ghanian witchcraft accusations are grounded in the diminishment of socio-economic conditions due to the effects of neoliberal deregulation. Her articulation of a feminist-materialist politics of storytelling provides the critical and contextual grounding for the second section here, which considers how Badoe fictionalises these conditions in
Neoliberalism and contemporary witchcraft accusations in Yaba Badoe's The Witches of Gambaga (2011)
Yaba Badoe is a Ghanaian-British writer, producer and film maker, whose most recent work includes a documentary film on the celebrated author Ama Ata Aidoo, several short stories, a children's fairy tale and three young adult novels. Key to Badoe's oeuvre are the interconnections made between folkloric traditions from West Africa to Cornwall, through the foregrounding of magical female protagonists, and an articulation of the transnational effects of environmental destruction. Her prose writing about the making of
Writing about Gambaga, Badoe places Ghanaian familial and social dynamics in dialogue with systemic pressures, noting that accused witches are often from combative, polygamous families, and they are generally ‘assertive argumentative, determined’ women, whose refusal to remain subdued and obedient to male authority figures is punished by domestic violence and, ultimately, witchcraft accusations and banishment (2012: 92). They exceed normative gendered social roles, existing, as in Maria Mies ([1986] 2014) and Silvia Federici's (2004) accounts of early modern witch hunts, outside of traditional heteronormative notions of women as docile wives and mothers. For Badoe, this includes women who are at extreme poles of vulnerability and wealth: those without children lack the leverage that this brings them within complex family dynamics, and they are vulnerable as they age to attempts to sever ‘kinship obligations’ given that they are ‘competing with other women in the household for limited resources’ (2005: 50). In a contrary but related process, wealthy women are also subject to witchcraft accusations, in order to dispossess them of their assets.
What unites Badoe's witness accounts are the manifold pressures of neoliberal economic deregulation on extended family communities in which individuals vie for increasingly smaller portions of land and wealth. Post-colonial West African states struggled after colonisation to assert an economic alternative to global capitalism, with Ghana requiring, after two decades of political instability, drought and the knock-on impact of Nigeria's refugee crisis, World Bank and IMF Structural Adjustment (SAPs) loans in the 1980s, and frequently thereafter, as the nation struggled to meet debt repayments amidst worsening economic conditions (Opoku, 2010). Furthermore, women's work, which has traditionally relied on informal food-selling and small-scale mining, has become increasingly vulnerable to the Ghanaian government's formalisation of labour – especially through mining conglomerates, who demand monopoly access to land and minerals (Hilson and Maconachie, 2020). Silvia Federici, working in Nigeria in the mid-1980s, describes the impact of SAPs leading to witch hunts due to ‘the decline in the status of women brought about by the rise of capitalism and the intensifying struggle for resources which, in recent years, has been aggravated by the imposition of the neo-liberal agenda’ (2004: 237). These are a very different set of conditions to those of early modern Europe – when a rush of bullion from the Americas, inflation and demographic changes catalysed the role of women in guilds. This made them a target for state and regional powers in Continental Europe, who required additional capital to fund intra-state wars and colonial expansion, while also protecting the role of women as child-bearers, thus ensuring the reproduction of future workers and soldiers (Mies, [1986] 2014: 74–111).
In contrast, the contemporary increase in witchcraft accusations in Africa is tied to a loosening of the social contract between the state and its population, and the privatisation of welfare structures amidst the diminishment of employment prospects. In a parallel vein to the dynamics registered by Badoe, Jean Comaroff and John Comaroff (1999) describe the emergence of ‘occult economies’ in turn-of-the-millennium South Africa. There, capitalist narratives of sudden and miraculous wealth creation metamorphose in a post-revolutionary and neoliberal society stricken by ongoing and severe racial and class inequalities, leading to attacks on elderly ‘wealth gate keepers’ blamed for the lack of economic opportunities for youth (Comaroff and Comaroff, 1999: 287). Neoliberalism is here defined from a world-systemic and world-ecological perspective, as ‘based less on formal characteristics and more as a dynamic phenomenon that registers the changing global composition of class relations governing the exploitation of peoples and the appropriation of natural resources’ (Deckard and Shapiro, 2019: 25). In the post-colonial context, this means attending to how the period from the 1980s onwards is characterised by the effort to, in Jameson's terms, ‘“proletarianize all those unbound social forces which gave the 60s their energy, by an extension of the class struggle, into the furthest reaches of the globe as well as the most minute configurations of local institutions”’ (cited in Deckard and Shapiro, 2019: 4). This neoliberal ‘proletarianisation’ includes the withdrawal of the state from basic provisions, the reemphasis on competitive market forces, the commodification of nature and the disciplining of radical social energies, with tremendous consequences for the labour of social reproduction.
Taking a cue from world-systems theory, the use of witchcraft accusations to expropriate women's capital emerged both in early modern Europe and in late twentieth-century West Africa as
Wolf Light : triangulating extraction across the world-system
Although these environmental threats could be read as an example of Rob Nixon's (2011) ‘slow violence’, or the displacement of toxic industries to the Global South, instead the text's triangulation of extraction suggests how the logic of social reproduction, of care of the earth and others, is outsourced between and across cores and peripheries. Cindi Katz (2001: 714) argues that such processes are yet more evidence of the interrelation between social reproduction and nature, comparing the logic of offshoring hazardous industries to the transnational ‘geography of social reproduction’ (2001: 715) which relies on cheap labour in the Global South to both enable the relocation of industrial work (or the externalisation of toxic harm) and supply the migrants who will undertake caring and domestic labour in core regions. Writing almost two decades before Cinzia Arruzza, Tithi Bhattacharya and Nancy Fraser's
This more totalising way of considering the ‘topographies’ of domination finds its formal correlative in ‘Aba!’ said Adoma. ‘Once those skin-walkers know the source of your power, they’ll know how to control you, like you British did when you stole the Golden Stool of Asante …’ ‘Not that again!’ Linet snapped. ‘I wasn’t even alive then!’ ‘Linet, my sister, I’m not blaming you, I’m talking facts. Simple facts. You British conquered us, and after you took the Golden Stool and sent our chiefs into exile, we became your slaves.’ ‘And so?’ said Linet. Adoma sighed: ‘As for you, you are too sensitive! Fact: I am linking my history to Zula's. That. Is. All.’ (Badoe, 2019: loc. 2086).
Linet's reaction is a reflexive moment, illustrating that her historical relationship to extraction is a racialised one, the consequences of which are still playing out in West Africa and Central Asia. To return to Martín Arboleda's point, the dematerialisation of extraction means reconsidering the ‘uneven reconfigurations in the social composition of the global working class’ (2020: Ch. 1). That Linet reroutes excess water from her lake in Cornwall to replenish Adoma's river, and helps recover a sub-Saharan environment struggling with the compound effects of climate change and extraction – ignited by capitalist colonialisation, and externalised onto the Global South – is an unconsciously anti-imperialist gesture, one that imagines solidarity across moments and geographies of oppression. Critically, Nana Merrimore notes that while witchcraft is a distantly remembered memory in Cornwall, Zula and Adoma are in immediate harm, living in places where ‘“people […] are sometimes murdered for what we do, murdered for simply practising our craft”’ (Badoe, 2019: loc. 1394), as the text neatly relativises each character's experience of oppression.
United, the witches of
The harrowing tales from Gambaga, of witchcraft as a dangerous trait designed to discipline women amidst constrained neoliberal conditions, are overturned by
In materialist terms, then, the flooding of the Asuo Nyamaa river is a collective and reparative process: only with their combined knowledge and power can the magical trio undo the immiseration of Adoma's village. To push this reading further, given the anti-colonial context of Nkrumah-era modernisation, particularly dam building, the energetic potential of water to cleanse and renew the river contains the kernels of post-colonial utopian thought (Okoth, 2022). The witches’ magical connection gestures to the potentiality of the non-aligned Asia-Africa Bandung movement, combined with a contemporary feminist stance that transcends the problematic link between dams and energy-intensive extraction (like the multiple Volta River dam projects in Ghana), to provide a liberatory and enchanting conclusion. Namely, those most vulnerable to exploitation by a patriarchal capitalist world-system, young teenage women living in rural areas historically associated with internal and external forms of colonisation, can harness the excess water generated by climate change to overthrow an international mining operation and stop extraction in its tracks.
Eros and kernels of utopianism? A conclusion
Badoe's work marries local witchcraft mythologies from sub-Saharan Africa with a rich engagement with regional struggles over extraction, and a materialist-feminist approach that has anti-colonial and anti-capitalist roots. In broad terms, it also taps into the popular Global Northern re-emergence of witches in fourth-wave feminist cultural imaginaries as anti-patriarchal, ecologically conscious, anti-capitalist, and in coalition with queer allies (see: Sollée, 2017). This reappropriation of the witch has a longer lineage in post-1960s feminist and queer North American activism and culture (see: Castro, 2019; Brandl, 2022). But
Witchcraft is thus both threat and promise in
