This article examines the form and effects of differentiation that surface
within the artifice of racial sameness. Using contemporary debates between
‘native-born’ and ‘foreign-born’ blacks in
the USA over the right to ‘African American’ identity and the
socioeconomic threat posed to the former by the latter, I show how the operation of
the logic of race internally within a racial group reiterates familiar effects of
racialization. Drawing on Freud’s notion of the ‘narcissism of
minor differences’ as a framing device, I point out that this
difference/sameness relation is not simply antagonistic through an analysis of the
ambiguity of Africa as posing a socioeconomic threat in the migrants it sends while
also presenting the historical and symbolic basis for African American claims to
cultural distinctiveness. The article builds a critique of the invention of sameness
that makes difference in two key ways: first, through the representation of
difference as an antithesis that affirms the racialized self characterized by
sameness; and second, that this makes a political difference in the sense that this
dialectic of black as self and other reifies the social problematic of its
sameness/difference relation as intrinsically (intra)racial to the extent that the
substantive socioeconomic causality of racial stratification and racism are obscured.
African Ancestry
(n.d.) ‘DNA Database May Help ID African
Ancestry’, press release [http://www.africanancestry.com/press.html].
2.
Alexander, J.C.
(2004) ‘Toward a Theory of Cultural
Trauma’, in J.C. Alexander, R. Eyerman, B. Giesen, N.J. Smelser
and P. Sztmpka, Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity, pp.
1-30.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
3.
Appiah, K.A.
(1996) ‘Race, Culture, Identity: Misunderstood
Connections’, in K.A. Appiah and A. Gutmann, Color
Conscious: The Political Morality of Race, pp.
30-105.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
4.
Banton, M.
(1997) Ethnic and Racial Consciousness (2nd
edition).
London: Longman
.
5.
Bhatt, C.
(2004) ‘Contemporary Geopolitics and
“Alterity” Research’, in
M. Bulmer
and
J. Solomos
(eds) Researching Race and Racism, pp.
16-36.
London: Routledge
.
6.
Bonilla-Silva, E.
(2003) Racism without Racists: Color-Blind Racism and the
Persistence of Racial Inequality in the United States.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield
.
7.
Bourdieu, P.
(1985)
‘The Social Space and the Genesis of Groups’
, Theory and Society14(6):
723-744
.
8.
Brown, M.K.
,
Carnoy, M.
,
Currie, E.
,
Duster, T.
,
Oppenheimer, D.B.
,
Shultz, M.M.
and
Wellman, D.
(2003) Whitewashing Race: The Myth of a Color-Blind
Society.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
9.
Charles, C.
(2003) ‘Being Black Twice’,
in
P.C. Hintzen
and
J.M. Rahier
(eds) Problematizing Blackness: Self-Ethnographies by Black Immigrants
to the United States, pp. 169-179.
New York: Routledge
.
10.
Elias, N.
(1994) The Civilizing Process: The History of Manners and
State Formation and Civilization, trans. E. Jephcott.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
11.
Eyerman, R.
(2004) ‘Cultural Trauma: Slavery and the
Formation of African American Identity’, in J.C. Alexander,
R. Eyerman, B. Giesen, N.J. Smelser and P. Sztmpka, Cultural Trauma and
Collective Identity, pp. 60-111.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
12.
Ford, R.T.
(2005) Racial Culture: A Critique.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
13.
Freud, S.
(1917)
‘The Taboo of Virginity’
, S.E.XI:
191-208
.
14.
Freud, S.
(1921)
‘Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego’
. S.E.XVIII:
69-143
.
15.
Freud, S.
(1929)
‘Civilization and its Discontents’
, S.E.XXI:
64-145
.
16.
Gates, H.L.
(2004) ‘America Behind the Color
Line’, 28 January. [http://www.commonwealthclub.org/archive/04/04-01gates-speech.html]
17.
Gilroy, P.
(1993) The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double
Consciousness.
London: Verso
.
18.
Hall, S.
(1990) ‘Cultural Identity and
Diaspora’, in
J. Rutherford
(ed.) Identity: Community, Culture, Difference, pp.
222-237.
London: Lawrence and Wishart
.
19.
Hall, J.R.
(1992) ‘The Capital(s) of Cultures: A
Nonholistic Approach to Status Situations, Class, Gender, and
Ethnicity’, in
M. Lamont
and
M. Fournier
(eds) Cultivating Differences: Symbolic Boundaries and the Making of
Inequality, pp. 257-285.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
20.
Ignatieff, M.
(1997) The Warrior’s Honor: Ethnic War and the
Modern Conscience.
New York: Henry Holt
.
21.
Logan, J.R.
and
Deane, G.
(2003) Black Diversity in Metropolitan America Report.
Albany, NY: Lewis Mumford Center for
Comparative Urban and Regional Research, State University of New York at Albany
.
22.
Malone, N.
,
Baluja, K.F.
,
Costanzo, J.M.
and
Davis, C.J.
(2003) The Foreign-Born Population: 2000, Census
2000 Brief, Series C2KBR-34,
Washington, DC: US Census Bureau
.
23.
Morrison, T.
(1993)
‘On the Back of Blacks’
, Time, Fall:
57
.
24.
Neal, M.A.
(1999) What the Music Said: Black Popular Music and Black
Public Culture.
London: Routledge
.
25.
Noguera, P.A.
(2003) ‘Anything but Black: Bringing Politics
Back to the Study of Race’, in
P.C. Hintzen
&
J.M. Rahier
(eds) Problematizing Blackness: Self-Ethnographies by Black Immigrants
to the United States, pp. 193-200.
New York: Routledge
.
26.
Obama, B.
(2004) Dreams from My Father: A Story of Race and
Inheritance.
New York: Three Rivers Press
.
27.
Patterson, O.
(1975) ‘Context and Choice in Ethnic
Allegiance’, in
N. Glazer
and
D. Moynihan
(eds) Ethnicity: Theory and Experience, pp.
305-349.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
28.
Pessar, P.R.
(2003) ‘Transnationalism and Racialization
within Contemporary US Immigration’, in
P.C. Hintzen
and
J.M. Rahier
(eds) Problematizing Blackness: Self-Ethnographies by Black Immigrants
to the United States, pp. 21-33.
New York: Routledge
.
29.
Reimers, D.M.
(2005) Other Immigrants: The Global Origins of the American
People.
New York: New York University Press
.
30.
Sansone, L.
(2003) Blackness without Ethnicity: Constructing Race in
Brazil.
Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
31.
Sartre, J-P.
(1989) Being and Nothingness: An Essay on Phenomenological
Ontology, trans. H.E. Barnes.
London: Routledge
.
32.
Simmel, G.
(1950[1917]) ‘Fundamental Problems of Sociology
(Individual and Society)’, in
K.H. Wolff
(trans. and ed.) The Sociology of Georg Simmel, pp.
3-84.
New York: Free Press
.
33.
Simpson, L.C.
(2001) The Unfinished Project: Toward a Postmetaphysical
Humanism.
New York: Routledge
.
34.
Solomos, J.
(1986) ‘Varieties of Marxist Conceptions of
“Race”, Class and the State: A Critical
Analysis’, in
J. Rex
and
D. Mason
(eds) Theories of Race and Ethnic Relations, pp.
94-109.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
35.
Swarns, R.L.
(2004)
‘“African-American” Becomes a Term for Debate’
, New York Times, 29 August:
1, 14
.
36.
Taguieff, P-A.
(2001) The Force of Prejudice: On Racism and its
Doubles, trans. H. Melehy.
Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press
.
37.
UNESCO
(1952) The Race Concept: Results of an Inquiry.
Paris: UNESCO
.
38.
US Bureau of the Census
(1999) Profile of the Foreign-Born Population in the United
States: 1997, Current Population Reports, Special Studies.
Washington, DC: US Dept of Commerce, Economics
and Statistics Administration, Bureau of the Census
.
39.
US Department of Labor
(2004) ‘Labor Force Characteristics of Foreign-Born
Workers Summary’, press release 1 December,
Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Department of Labor
[http://www.bls.gov/news.release/forbrn.nr0.htm].
40.
Wallertsein, I.
(1990) ‘Culture as the Ideological Battleground
of the Modern World-System’, in
M. Featherstone
(ed.) Global Culture: Nationalism, Globalization and Modernity,
pp. 31-55.
London: Sage
.
41.
Wilson, W.J.
(1999) The Bridge Over the Racial Divide: Rising Inequality
and Coalition Politics,
Berkeley, CA/New York: University of California
Press/Russell Sage Foundation
.
42.
Wieviorka, M.
(1995) The Arena of Racism, trans. C. Turner.
London: Sage
.
43.
Winant, H.
(2004) The New Politics of Race: Globalism, Difference,
Justice.
Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press
.
