Symptom perception in heart failure has been identified as crucial for effective self-care that is a modifiable factor related to decreased hospital readmission and improved survival.
Aims:
To review systematically the heart failure symptom perception literature and synthesise knowledge on definition, description, factors and instruments.
Methods:
We conducted a scoping review including studies reporting patient-reported symptom perception in adults with heart failure. Structured searches were conducted in Medline, PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsychINFO, Web of Science, Cochrane, JBI and grey literature. Two authors independently reviewed references for eligibility. Data were charted in tables and results narratively summarised.
Results:
The search yielded 3057 references, of which 106 were included. The definition of heart failure symptom perception comprised body listening, monitoring signs, recognising, interpreting and labelling symptoms, and furthermore awareness of and assigning meaning to the change. Symptom monitoring, recognition and interpretation were identified as challenging. Symptom perception facilitators include prior heart failure hospitalisation, heart failure self-care maintenance, symptom perception confidence, illness uncertainty and social support. Barriers include knowledge deficits, symptom clusters and lack of tools/materials. Factors with inconsistent impact on symptom perception include age, sex, education, experiences of living with heart failure, comorbidities, cognitive impairment, depression and symptom progression. One instrument measuring all dimensions of heart failure symptom perception was identified.
Conclusion:
Heart failure symptom perception definition and description have been elucidated. Several factors facilitating or hampering symptom perception are known. Further research is needed to determine a risk profile for poor symptom perception – which can then be taken into consideration when supporting heart failure self-care.
RiegelBDicksonVVFaulknerKM. The situation-specific theory of heart failure self-care: revised and updated. J Cardiovasc Nurs2016; 31: 226–235.
2.
SeganLNanayakkaraSMakV, et al. Enhancing self-care strategies in heart failure through patient-reported outcome measures. Intern Med J2018; 48: 995–998.
3.
JurgensCYHokeLByrnesJ, et al. Why do elders delay responding to heart failure symptoms?Nurs Res2009; 58: 274–282.
4.
HorowitzCRReinSBLeventhalH. A story of maladies, misconceptions and mishaps: effective management of heart failure. Soc Sci Med2004; 58: 631–643.
5.
SetharesKAChinEJurgensCY. Predictors of delay in heart failure patients and consequences for outcomes. Curr Heart Fail Rep2015; 12: 94–105.
6.
LeeCSBidwellJTPaturzoM, et al. Patterns of self-care and clinical events in a cohort of adults with heart failure: 1 year follow-up. Heart Lung2018; 47: 40–46.
7.
JaarsmaTStrombergABen GalT, et al. Comparison of self-care behaviors of heart failure patients in 15 countries worldwide. Patient Educ Couns2013; 92: 114–120.
8.
RiegelBDicksonVV. A situation-specific theory of heart failure self-care. J Cardiovasc Nurs2008; 23: 190–196.
9.
JaarsmaTCameronJRiegelB, et al. Factors related to self-care in heart failure patients according to the middle-range theory of self-care of chronic illness: a literature update. Curr Heart Fail Rep2017; 14: 71–77.
10.
MoserDKWatkinsJF. Conceptualizing self-care in heart failure: a life course model of patient characteristics. J Cardiovasc Nurs2008; 23: 205–218; quiz 219–220.
11.
MoserDKDicksonVJaarsmaT, et al. Role of self-care in the patient with heart failure. Curr Cardiol Rep2012; 14: 265–275.
12.
RiegelBCarlsonBMoserDK, et al. Psychometric testing of the self-care of heart failure index. J Cardiac Fail2004; 10: 350–360.
13.
RiegelBLeeCSDicksonVV, et al. An update on the self-care of heart failure index. J Cardiovasc Nurs2009; 24: 485–497.
14.
JaarsmaTStrombergAMartenssonJ, et al. Development and testing of the European Heart Failure Self-Care Behaviour Scale. Eur J Heart Fail2003; 5: 363–370.
15.
JaarsmaTArestedtKFMartenssonJ, et al. The European Heart Failure Self-care Behaviour scale revised into a nine-item scale (EHFScB-9): a reliable and valid international instrument. Eur J Heart Fail2009; 11: 99–105.
16.
LamCSmeltzerSC. Patterns of symptom recognition, interpretation, and response in heart failure patients: an integrative review. J Cardiovasc Nurs2013; 28: 348–359.
17.
LeeSRiegelB. State of the science in heart failure symptom perception research: an integrative review. J Cardiovasc Nurs2017; 33: 204–210.
18.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. J Clin Epidemiol2009; 62: 1006–1012.
19.
ArkseyHO’MalleyL. Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol2005; 8: 19–32.
20.
OuzzaniMHammadyHFedorowiczZ, et al. Rayyan – a web and mobile app for systematic reviews. Syst Rev2016; 5: 210.
21.
CarlsonBRiegelBMoserDK. Self-care abilities of patients with heart failure. Heart Lung2001; 30: 351–359.
22.
DolanskyMAHawkinsMASchaeferJT, et al. Cognitive function predicts risk for clinically significant weight gain in adults with heart failure. J Cardiovasc Nurs2016; 32: 568–575.
23.
FriedmanMMFederico-FieldsPAGriffinJA. The relationship between heart failure patients’ symptom interpretation and time until admission. Circulation1998; 98: 482.
24.
GallagherR. Self management, symptom monitoring and associated factors in people with heart failure living in the community. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2010; 9: 153–160.
25.
GaryR. Self-care practices in women with diastolic heart failure. Heart Lung2006; 35: 9–19.
26.
HarknessKHeckmanGAAkhtar-DaneshN, et al. Cognitive function and self-care management in older patients with heart failure. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2014; 13: 277–284.
27.
JurgensCY. Somatic awareness, uncertainty, and delay in care-seeking in acute heart failure. Res Nurs Health2006; 29: 74–86.
28.
JurivichDAKedlayaIDimahKP. Self-efficacy in elderly heart failure patients: barriers to weight management. J Am Geriatr Soc2001; 49: S51.
29.
KatoNKinugawaKNakayamaE, et al. Symptom-monitoring and treatment-seeking behaviors in japanese patients with heart failure: a multicenter study. J Cardiac Fail2011; 17: S96.
30.
LinCYDracupKPelterMM, et al. Why don’t heart failure patients respond to worsening symptoms?Circulation2015; 132: A11015.
31.
OkadaAAokiYFukawaM, et al. Symptom perception, evaluation, and response and care-seeking delay among patients with heart failure. J Cardiac Fail2016; 32: S80–S81.
32.
PalmieriVPalermoA. Patients’ self-evaluation of symptoms, signs and compliance to therapy for heart failure surveillance: a pilot study on identification of worsening heart failure. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis2018; 88: 84–90.
33.
QuinnCDunbarSBHigginsM. Recognition of shortness of breath and edema as heart failure symptoms. Circulation2009; 120: S501–S502.
34.
ReederKMErcolePMPeekGM, et al. Symptom perceptions and self-care behaviors in patients who self-manage heart failure. J Cardiovasc Nurs2015; 30: E1–E7.
35.
Ronan KernanRLennonEGallagherJ, et al. Evaluating the patient and carers perspective of the heart failure pathway following an admission with an acute decompensation of heart failure. Eur J Heart Fail2018; 20: 304.
36.
SamirANourW. Self-management among Egyptian heart failure patients. Int J Nurs Pract2011; 17: 221–230.
37.
SetharesKA. Symptom severity, attribution and delay in seeking treatment for heart failure. J Cardiac Fail2008; 14: S86–S87.
38.
SetharesKASosaMEFisherP, et al. Factors associated with delay in seeking care for acute decompensated heart failure. J Cardiovasc Nurs2014; 29: 429–438.
39.
van der WalMHJaarsmaTMoserDK, et al. Unraveling the mechanisms for heart failure patients’ beliefs about compliance. Heart Lung2007; 36: 253–261.
40.
WebelARFrazierSKMoserDK, et al. Daily variability in dyspnea, edema and body weight in heart failure patients. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2007; 6: 60–65.
ZengWChiaSYChanYH, et al. Factors impacting heart failure patients’ knowledge of heart disease and self-care management. Proc Sing Healthcare2017; 26: 26–34.
43.
VelloneERiegelBD’AgostinoF, et al. Structural equation model testing the situation-specific theory of heart failure self-care. J Adv Nurs2013; 69: 2481–2492.
44.
BaasLSBeeryTAAllenG, et al. An exploratory study of body awareness in persons with heart failure treated medically or with transplantation. J Cardiovasc Nurs2004; 19: 32–40.
45.
JurgensCYMasterson CreberRMLeeCS. Identifying heart failure patients less likely to report dyspnea. Circulation2016; 134: A17942.
46.
LeeSDausMMoserD, et al. Why don’t heart failure patients respond to early symptoms? Determinants of symptom perception. Circulation2017; 136: A17102.
47.
MakayaMMatsuokaSKatoN. Combination of depression and poor knowledge regarding heart failure: A strong determinant of self-care behavior in patients with heart failure. Eur Heart J2013; 34: 952.
48.
SetharesKA. Correlations between heart failure symptoms, uncertainty and cognitive and emotional reasons for delay. J Cardiac Fail2009; 15: S87–S88.
49.
SetharesKAFlimlinHEElliottKM. Perceived benefits and barriers of heart failure self-care during and after hospitalization. Home Healthc Nurse2014; 32: 482–488.
50.
LeeYWJengYJHuangLH. Development and testing of a scale to assess fluid overload symptoms. Appl Nurs Res2015; 28: 206–209.
51.
RiegelBBarbaranelliCCarlsonB, et al. Psychometric testing of the revised self-care of heart failure index. J Cardiovasc Nurs2019; 34: 183–192.
52.
AthilingamPLabradorMARemoEF, et al. Features and usability assessment of a patient-centered mobile application (HeartMapp) for self-management of heart failure. Appl Nurs Res2016; 32: 156–163.
53.
BuckHGHarknessKAliMU, et al. The Caregiver Contribution to Heart Failure Self-Care (CACHS): further psychometric testing of a novel instrument. Res Nurs Health2017; 40: 165–176.
54.
HattoriYTaruCMiyawakiI. Development of an evaluation scale for self-monitoring by patients with heart failure. Kobe J Med Sci2011; 57: E63–E74.
55.
JurgensCYFainJARiegelB. Psychometric testing of the heart failure somatic awareness scale. J Cardiovasc Nurs2006; 21: 95–102.
56.
JurgensCYLeeCSRiegelB. Psychometric analysis of the heart failure somatic perception scale as a measure of patient symptom perception. J Cardiovasc Nurs2017; 32: 140–147.
57.
LewisEFColesTLewisS, et al. Psychometric evaluation and health care provider feedback on a symptom tracker for use by patients with heart failure. Eur J Heart Fail2017; 19: 223.
58.
Masterson CreberRMJurgensCYLeeCS. Refinement of the heart failure somatic perception scale dyspnea subscale. Circulation2017; 136: A14003.
59.
RiegelBCarlsonBGlaserD. Development and testing of a clinical tool measuring self-management of heart failure. Heart Lung2000; 29: 4–15.
60.
VelloneERiegelBCocchieriA, et al. Validity and reliability of the caregiver contribution to self-care of heart failure index. J Cardiovasc Nurs2013; 28: 245–255.
61.
WangXHQiuLBPangJH, et al. Establishment of a weight management scale for patients with congestive heart failure. Acta Cardiologica Sinica2014; 30: 74–81.
62.
PortzJDVehovecADolanskyMA, et al. The development and acceptability of a mobile application for tracking symptoms of heart failure among older adults. Telemed J & E Health2017; 12: 12.
63.
AnderDSAisikuIPRatcliffJJ, et al. Measuring the dyspnea of decompensated heart failure with a visual analog scale: how much improvement is meaningful?Congest Heart Fail2004; 10: 188–191.
64.
BennettSJCordesDKWestmorelandG, et al. Self-care strategies for symptom management in patients with chronic heart failure. Nurs Res2000; 49: 139–145.
65.
CraigG. Hospital readmissions for congestive heart failure: the patient perspective. PhD Thesis, Walden University, Ann Arbor, USA, 2004.
66.
CuljisMJ. The Experience of Older Men with Heart Failure Who Are Receiving Palliative Care. PhD Thesis, University of California, San Francisco, USA, 2013.
67.
DicksonVVCaceresBMartellyMT, et al. “I regret not coming in sooner”: a qualitative descriptive study of the reasons for emergency department visits and care preferences of older adults with heart failure. J Cardiac Fail2016; 22: S83.
68.
HargreavesSHawleyMSHaywoodA, et al. Informing the Design of “Lifestyle Monitoring” Technology for the Detection of Health Deterioration in Long-term Conditions: a qualitative study of people living with heart failure. J Med Internet Res2017; 19: 1–12.
69.
HedemalmASchaufelbergerMEkmanI. Symptom recognition and health care seeking among immigrants and native Swedish patients with heart failure. BMC Nurs2008; 7: 1–7.
70.
HoppFPMarsackCCampJK, et al. Go to the hospital or stay at home? A qualitative study of expected hospital decision making among older African Americans with advanced heart failure. J Gerontol Social Work2014; 57: 4–23.
71.
LarssonMOlssonMStrömbergA. Perceptions of symptoms in individuals with heart failure receiving home care. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2006; 5: S24–S25.
72.
PatelHShafazandMSchaufelbergerM, et al. Reasons for seeking acute care in chronic heart failure. Eur J Heart Fail2007; 9: 702–708.
73.
ReederKMSimsJLPeekGM. Self-management of heart failure in the post-discharge environment: a harbinger of hospital readmission or effective symptom self-care?Heart Lung: J Acute Crit Care2014; 43: 380.
74.
RiegelBCarlsonB. Facilitators and barriers to heart failure self-care. Patient Educ Couns2002; 46: 287–295.
75.
RiegelBDicksonVVTopazM. Qualitative analysis of naturalistic decision making in adults with chronic heart failure. Nurs Res2013; 62: 91–98.
76.
RogersAAddington-HallJMMcCoyAS, et al. A qualitative study of chronic heart failure patients’ understanding of their symptoms and drug therapy. Eur J Heart Fail2002; 4: 283–287.
77.
SanoMMajimaT. Self-management of congestive heart failure among elderly men in Japan. Int J Nurs Pract2018; 24: 1–6.
78.
SchnellKNNaimarkBJMcClementSE. Influential factors for self-care in ambulatory care heart failure patients: a qualitative perspective. Can J Cardiovasc Nurs2006; 16: 13–19.
79.
SchuhE. It has to be really bad: advanced heart failure patients delay seeking care. Nurs Res2016; 65: E13.
80.
SchumacherCL. Understanding Self-Management Decision Making in Heart Failure. PhD Thesis, Walden University, USA, 2017.
81.
ScottoCJ. Factors influencing adherence to a prescribed health regimen for individuals with heart failure. PhD Thesis, Duquesne University School of Nursing, Ann Arbor, USA, 2003.
82.
SilcockJ. The self management of heart failure: a place in practice? PhD Thesis, University of Leeds, Ann Arbor, USA, 2009.
83.
StevensonCWPoriDPayneK, et al. Hearing the veteran’s voice in congestive heart failure readmissions. Profess Case Manage2015; 20: 177–185; quiz 186–177.
84.
TaylorCJHobbsFDMarshallT, et al. From breathless to failure: symptom onset and diagnostic meaning in patients with heart failure-a qualitative study. BMJ Open2017; 7: e013648.
85.
ThornhillKLyonsACNouwenA, et al. Experiences of living with congestive heart failure: a qualitative study. Br J Health Psychol2008; 13: 155–175.
86.
TurriseSHadleyNPhillips-KuhnD, et al. The experience of illness control and hospital readmission in adults with chronic heart failure. Heart Lung: J Acute Crit Care2017; 46: 219.
87.
XuJArrudaSGalloJJ, et al. Using vignettes to understand heart failure self-care. J Clin Nurs2018; 26: 1–7.
88.
BuckHGHupceyJWatachA. Pattern versus change. Clin Nurs Res2017; 27: 148–161.
89.
WintersCA. Heart failure: living with uncertainty. Prog Cardiovasc Nurs1999; 14: 85–91.
90.
ClarkAMSavardLASpalingMA, et al. Understanding help-seeking decisions in people with heart failure: a qualitative systematic review. Int J Nurs Stud2012; 49: 1582–1597.
91.
ClarkAMSpalingMHarknessK, et al. Determinants of effective heart failure self-care: a systematic review of patients’ and caregivers’ perceptions. Heart2014; 100: 716–721.
92.
DicksonVVBuckHRiegelB. A qualitative meta-analysis of heart failure self-care practices among individuals with multiple comorbid conditions. J Cardiac Fail2011; 17: 413–419.
93.
HerberORBuckerBMetzendorfMI, et al. A qualitative meta-summary using Sandelowski and Barroso’s method for integrating qualitative research to explore barriers and facilitators to self-care in heart failure patients. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2017; 16: 662–677.
94.
IvynianSEDiGiacomoMNewtonPJ. Care-seeking decisions for worsening symptoms in heart failure: a qualitative metasynthesis. Heart Fail Rev2015; 20: 655–671.
95.
EvansMM. Symptom Recognition and Healthcare Utilization in Adult Patients with Heart Failure: An Integrative Review of the Literature. Medsurg Nurs2016; 25: 319-368.
96.
FalkHEkmanIAndersonR, et al. Older patients’ experiences of heart failure – an integrative literature review. J Nurs Scholarship2013; 45: 247–255.
97.
Gravely-WitteSJurgensCYTamimH, et al. Length of delay in seeking medical care by patients with heart failure symptoms and the role of symptom-related factors: a narrative review. Eur J Heart Fail2010; 12: 1122–1129.
ZavertnikJE. Self-care in older adults with heart failure: an integrative review. Clin Nurse Spec2014; 28: 19–32.
100.
DicksonVV. A mixed methods study investigating biobehavioral variables that influence self -care management in persons with heart failure. PhD Thesis, University of Pennsylvania, Ann Arbor, USA, 2007.
101.
Goetz-PerryC. Supporting health promotion behaviours in rural older adults with heart failure: a mixed methods study. PhD Thesis, McMaster University, Canada, 2011.
102.
RiegelBDicksonVVLeeCS, et al. A mixed methods study of symptom perception in patients with chronic heart failure. Heart Lung2018; 47: 107–114.
103.
EvansMM. Somatic awareness and self-symptom recognition in advanced heart failure patients. PhD Thesis, The Pennsylvania State University, Ann Arbor, USA, 2016.
104.
RiegelBDicksonVVCameronJ, et al. Symptom recognition in elders with heart failure. J Nurs Scholarship2010; 42: 92–100.
105.
RiegelBDicksonVVKuhnL, et al. Gender-specific barriers and facilitators to heart failure self-care: a mixed methods study. Int J Nurs Stud2010; 47: 888–895.
106.
DavidsonPMInglisSCNewtonPJ. Self-care in patients with chronic heart failure. Expert Rev Pharmacoecon Outcomes Res2013; 13: 351–359.
107.
JurgensCYShurpinKMGumersellKA. Challenges and strategies for heart failure symptom management in older adults. J Gerontol Nurs2010; 36: 24–33.
108.
SkotzkoCE. Symptom perception in CHF: (why mind matters). Heart Fail Rev2009; 14: 29–34.
109.
DicksonVVTkacsNRiegelB. Cognitive influences on self-care decision making in persons with heart failure. Am Heart J2007; 154: 424–431.
110.
RiegelBLeeCSDicksonVV. Self care in patients with chronic heart failure. Nature Rev Cardiol2011; 8: 644–654.
111.
RushtonCASatchithanandaDKKadamUT. Comorbidity in modern nursing: a closer look at heart failure. Br J Nurs2011; 20: 280–285.
112.
WakefieldBGrovesPDrwalK, et al. Evaluation of feasibility of 2 novel heart failure monitoring instruments to facilitate patient recognition of symptoms. J Cardiovasc Nurs2016; 31: 42–52.
113.
WolfAOlssonLESwedbergK, et al. Use of smartphones in person-centred e-health diaries in patients above 75 years. Eur J Heart Fail Suppl2012; 11: S1.
114.
EastwoodCATravisLMorgensternTT, et al. Weight and symptom diary for self-monitoring in heart failure clinic patients. J Cardiovasc Nurs2007; 22: 382–389.
115.
GaoBGottliebSH. Acute heart failure in an elder with multimorbidities: the “nonlinear patient trap”. J Am Geriatr Soc2012; 60: S137.
116.
MiaskowskiCAouizeratBEDoddM, et al. Conceptual issues in symptom clusters research and their implications for quality-of-life assessment in patients with cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr2007: 39–46.
117.
AdamsonPB. Pathophysiology of the transition from chronic compensated and acute decompensated heart failure: new insights from continuous monitoring devices. Curr Heart Fail Rep2009; 6: 287–292.
118.
RiegelBJaarsmaTStrombergA. A middle-range theory of self-care of chronic illness. ANS Adv Nurs Sci2012; 35: 194–204.
119.
RiegelBJaarsmaTLeeCSStrömbergA.Integrating Symptoms Into the Middle–Range Theory of Self–Care of Chronic Illness. ANS Adv Nurs Sci2019; 42: 206–2015.
120.
Schmid-MohlerGCaressALSpirigR, et al. “Thrust out of normality” – how adults living with cystic fibrosis experience pulmonary exacerbations: a qualitative study. J Clin Nurs2019; 28: 190–200.
ZrelakPA. Sex-based differences in symptom perception and care-seeking behavior in acute stroke. Perm J2018; 22: 18–042.
123.
LewisEFColesTMLewisS, et al. Development, psychometric evaluation, and initial feasibility assessment of a symptom tracker for use by patients with heart failure (HFaST). J Patient Rep Outcomes2019; 3: 26.
124.
OkadaATsuchihashi-MakayaMKangJ, et al. Symptom perception, evaluation, response to symptom, and delayed care seeking in patients with acute heart failure: an observational study. J Cardiovasc Nurs2019; 34: 36–43.
125.
LeeKSChoiJOJeonES, et al. Cognition is associated with symptom perception ability in patients with heart failure. Conference abstract. Circulation2018; 138: A12506.
126.
LeeSCarlsonBDausM, et al. Comorbidity, age, self-care maintenance, and confidence influence heart failure symptom perception. Conference abstract. Circulation2018; 138: A15270.
127.
VehovecADolanskyMJosephsonR, et al. Body awareness but not interoceptive awareness is associated with better heart failure self-management. Conference abstract. Circulation2018; 138: A17298.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
