This article critically evaluates the GLOBE project as an example of existing
cross-cultural studies into leadership, recognising the project's value in
communicating leadership differences across countries and summarising its
methodological limitations. It is suggested that a dynamic and interactive
approach is needed to overcome the shortfalls of the GLOBE project. Ailon-Souday
and Kunda's (2003) work points the way towards such an approach, and it is the
contribution of this article to apply this approach to the relationship between
cultural context and leadership in the German and UK chemical industry. Analyses
of a mixed methods data set support the theoretical arguments for the dynamic
nature of different contexts such as national, organisational, hierarchical and
departmental and the importance of this interaction for individual
participants'understanding of leadership. Implications are drawn for the
development of global managers in light of these new perspectives on the
interaction of cultural context and leadership.
Ailon, G.
(2008)
`Mirror, Mirror on the Wall: Culture's Consequences in a Value-Test of its
Own Design'
, Academy of Management Review33(4).
2.
Ailon-Souday, G.
, &
Kunda, G.
(2003)
`The Local Selves of Global Workers: The Social Construction Of National
Identity in the Face of Organizational Globalization'
, Organization Studies24(7):
1073-96.
3.
Alvesson, M.,
&
Skoldberg, K.
(eds) (2000) Reflexive Methodology: New Vistas for
Qualitative Research. London:
SAGE.
4.
Alvesson, M.
, &
Sveningsson, S.
(2003a)
`Good Visions, Bad Micro-Management and Ugly Ambiguitiy: Contradictions of
(Non-) Leadership in Knowledge-Intensive Organization'
, Organization Studies24(6):
961-88.
5.
Alvesson, M.
, &
Sveningsson, S.
(2003b)
`The Great Disappearing Act: Difficulties in Doing "Leadership"'
, Leadership Quarterly14(3):
359-81.
6.
Ardichvili, A.
, &
Kuchinke, K.P.
(2002)
`Leadership Styles and Cultural Values Among Managers and Subordinates: A
Comparative Study of Four Countries of the Former Soviet Union, Germany and
the US'
, Human Resource Development International5(1):
99-117.
7.
Armbruester, T.
(2004) Management and Organization in Germany.
Aldershot:
Ashgate.
8.
Avolio, B.J.
, &
Bass, B.
(1995)
`Individual Consideration Viewed at Multiple Levels of Analysis: A
Multi-Level Framework for Examining the Diffusion of Transformational
Leadership'
, Leadership Quarterly6(2):
199-218.
9.
Berger, P.
, &
Luckman, T.
(1966) The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the
Sociology of Knowledge. London:
Penguin.
Brodbeck, F.C.
,
Frese, M.
,
Javidan, M.
, &
Kroll, M.G.
(2002)
`Leadership Made in Germany: Low on Compassion, High on Performance'
, Academy of Management Executive16(1):
6-30.
12.
Brodbeck, F.C.
,
Frese, M.
,
Akerblom, S.
,
Audia, G.
,
Bakacsi, G.
,
Bendova, Bodega, D.
,
Bodur, M.
,
Booth, S.
,
Brenk, K.
,
Castel, P.
,
Hartog, D.
,
Donnelly-Cox, G.
,
Gratchev, M.V.
,
Holmberg, I.
,
Jarmuz, S.
,
Jesuino, J.C.
,
Jorbenadse, R.
,
Kabasakal, H.E.
, &
Keating, M.
(2000)
`Cultural Variation of Leadership Prototypes Across 22 European
Countries'
, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology73(1):
1-29.
13.
Bryman, A.
(2004)
`Qualitative Research On Leadership: A Critical But Appreciative
Review'
, Leadership Quarterly15(6):
729-69.
14.
Bryman, A.
,
Bresnen, M.
,
Beardsworth, A.
, &
Keil, T.
(1988)
`Qualitative Research and the Study of Leadership'
, Human Relations41(1):
13-30.
15.
Burr, V.
(ed) (1995) An Introduction to Social Constructionism.
London:
Routledge.
16.
Calder, B.J.
(1977) `An Attribution Theory of Leadership', in
B. Staw
&
G. Salancik
(eds) New Directions in Organizational Behaviour pp.
179-202. Chicago, IL:
St. Clair Press.
17.
Collinson, D.
(2006)
`Rethinking Followership: A Post-Structuralist Analysis of Follower
Identities'
, Leadership Quarterly17(2):
179-89.
18.
Conger, J.A.
(1998)
`Qualitative Research as the Cornerstone Methodology For Understanding
Leadership'
, Leadership Quarterly9(1):
107-22.
19.
Day, D.
(2001)
`Leadership Development: A Review in Context'
, Leadership Quarterly11(4):
581-613.
20.
Dickson, M.W.
,
Den Hartog, D.N.
, &
Mitchelson, J.K.
(2003)
`Research on Leadership in a Cross-Cultural Context: Making Progress, and
Raising New Questions'
, Leadership Quarterly14(6):
729-68.
21.
Dorfman, P.W.
(2004) `International and Cross-Cultural Leadership
Research' , in
B. J. Punnett
&
O. Shenkar
(eds) Handbook For International Management Research, pp.
265-355. Ann Arbor, MI:
University of Michigan Press.
22.
Edwards, G.
, &
Gill, R.
(2003)
An Investigation of Transformational, Transactional And Laissez-Faire
Leadership at Different Hierarchical Levels in UK Manufacturing Companies
Using Multiple Rating
. Second Annual International Conference on Leadership
Research, Lancaster University.
23.
Egri, C.P.
, &
Herman, S.
(2000)
`Leadership in the North American Environmental Sector: Values, Leadership
Styles, and the Contexts of Environmental Leaders and Their
Organisations'
, Academy of Management Journal43(4):
571-604.
24.
Fear, J.
(1997) `German Capitalism', in
T. K. McGraw
(ed.) Creating Modern Capitalism: How Entrepreneurs, Modern Companies
and Countries Triumphed in Three Industrial Revolutions, pp.
000-000. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
25.
Fiedler, F. E.
(ed.) (1967) A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness.
New York:
McGraw-Hill.
26.
Geertz, C.
(1973) The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays
. New York: Basic
Books.
27.
Graen, G.B.
(2006)
`In the Eye of the Beholder: Cross-Cultural Lesson in Leadership from
Project GLOBE: A Response Viewed from the Third Culture Bonding (TCB) Model
of Cross-Cultural Leadership'
, Academy of Management Perspectives20(4):
95-101.
28.
Graen, G.B.
,
Hui, C.
,
Wakabayashi, M.
, &
Wang, Z.-M.
(1997) `Cross-Cultural Research Alliances in Organizational
Research', in.
P. C. Earley
&
M. Erez
(eds) New Perspectives on International Industrial/Organizational
Psychology, pp. 160-89. San
Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
29.
Hamlin, R.
(2005)
`Toward Universalistic Models of Managerial Leader Effectiveness: A
Comparative Study of Recent British and American Derived Models of
Leadership'
, Human Resource Development International8(1):
5-25.
Herrigel, G.
(1997) `The Limits of German Manufacturing Flexibility'
, in
L. Turner
(ed.) Negotiating the New Germany: Can Social Partnership
Survive?, pp. 177-205. Ithaca,
NY: ILR Press.
32.
Hersey, P.,
&
Blanchard, K. H.
(eds) (1984) The Management of Organizational
Behaviour. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
33.
Hofstede, G.
(1980) Culture's Consequences: International Differences in
Work-Related Values. Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE.
34.
House, R.J.
(1977) `A 1976 Theory of Charismatic Leadership', in
J. G. Hunt
&
L. L. Larson
(eds) Leadership: The Cutting Edge, pp.
189-207. Carbondale, IL:
Southern Illinois University
Press.
35.
House, R.J.
, &
Dessler, G.
(1974) `The Path Goal Theory of Leadership: Some Post Hoc and
A Priori Tests', in
J. G. Hunt
&
L. L. Larson
(eds) Contingency Approaches to Leadership, pp.
000-000. Carbondale, IL:
Southern Illinois University
Press.
36.
House, R. J.,Hanges, P. J.,Javidan, M.,Dorfman, P. W.,
&
Gupta, V.
(eds) (2004) Leadership, Culture and Organizations: The GLOBE
Study of 62 Societies. London:
SAGE.
37.
Jung, D.I.
, &
Avolio, B.J.
(1999)
`Effects of Leadership Styles and Followers' Cultural Orientation on
Performance in Group and Individual Task Conditions'
, Academy of Management Journal42(2):
208-18.
38.
Kakabadse, A.K.
,
Kakabadse, N.K.
, &
Myers, A.
(1996)
`Leadership and the Public Sector: An Internationally Comparative
Benchmarking Analysis'
, Public Administration & Development16(4):
377-96.
39.
Katz, D.,
&
Kahn, R. L.
(eds) (1966) The Social Psychology of Organisations.
New York: John
Wiley .
40.
Katz, D.,
&
Kahn, R. L.
(eds) (1978) The Social Psychology of Organisations,
2nd edition. New York: John
Wiley.
41.
Kenney, R.A.
,
Blascovich, J.
, &
Shaver, P.R.
(1994)
`Implicit Leadership Theories: Prototypes for New Leaders'
, Basic and Applied Social Psychology15(4):
409-37.
42.
Kotter, J. P.
(ed) (1990) A Force For Change: How Leadership Differs From
Management. New York: Free
Press.
Lewin, K.
,
Lippitt, R.
, &
White, R.K.
(1939)
`Patterns of Aggressive Behaviour in Experimentally Created Social
Climates'
, Journal of Social Psychology10: 271-301.
45.
Lord, R.
,
Foti, R.J.
, &
De Vader, C.L.
(1984)
`A Test of Leadership Categorization Theory: Internal Structure,
Information Processing, and Leadership Perceptions'
, Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance34(3):
343-78.
46.
McCarthy, G.
(2005)
`Leadership Practices in German and UK Organisations'
, Journal of European Industrial Training29(3):
217-34.
47.
McGregor, D.
(ed) (1960) The Human Side of Enterprise.
New York:
McGraw-Hill.
48.
McSweeney, B.
(2002)
`Hofstede's Model of National Cultural Differences and their Consequences:
A Triumph of Faith - A Failure of Analysis'
, Human Relations55(1):
89-118.
49.
Meindl, J.R.
(1990) `On Leadership: An Alternative to the Conventional
Wisdom',
B. A. in Straw
(ed) Research in Organizational Behaviour, pp.
159-203. New York:
JAI.
50.
Phillips, J.S.
, &
Lord, R.
(1982)
`Schematic Information Processing and Perception of Leadership in Problem
Solving Groups'
, Journal of Applied Psychology67(4)
486-92.
51.
Potter, J.
, &
Wetherell, M.
(1987) Discourse and Social Psychology: Beyond Attitudes and
Behaviour. London:
SAGE.
52.
Schneider, J.
, &
Littrell, R.F.
(2003)
`Leadership Preferences of German and English Managers'
, Journal of Management Development22(2):
130-48.
53.
Smith, P.B.
,
Peterson, M.F.
,
Schwartz, S.H.
, &
Parry, K.W.
(2002)
`Cultural Values, Sources Of Guidance, and Their Relevance to Managerial
Behaviour - A 47-Nation Study'
, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology33(2):
188-208.
54.
Suutari, V.
(1996)
`Variation in the Average Leadership Behaviour of Managers Across
Countries: Finnish Expatriates' Experiences From Germany
, Sweden, France and Great Britain', International Journal of Human
Resource Management7(3):
677-707.
55.
Suutari, V.
(1998)
`Leadership Behaviour in Eastern Europe: Finnish Expatriates' Experiences
in Russia and Estonia'
, International Journal of Human Resource Management9(2):
235-58.
56.
Sveningsson, S.F.
, &
Larsson, M.
(2006)
`Fantasies of Leadership: Identity Work'
, Leadership2(2):
203-24.
57.
Tayeb, M.
(2001)
`Conducting Research Across Cultures: Overcoming Drawbacks and
Obstacles'
, International Journal of Cross Cultural Management1(1):
91-108.
58.
Van Maanen, J.
(1979)
`The Fact of Fiction in Organizational Ethnography'
, Administrative Science Quarterly24(4): 539-
50.
59.
Vroom, V. H.,
&
Yetton, P. W.
(eds) (1973) Leadership and Decision-Making .
Pittsburgh, PA: University of
Pittsburgh Press.
60.
Wittgenstein, L.
(1953) Philosophical Investigations.
London:
Blackwell.
61.
Yeung, A.K.
, &
Ready, D.A.
(1995)
`Developing Leadership Capabilities of Global Corporations: A Comparative
Study in Eight Nations'
, Human Resource Management34(4):
529-47.
62.
Yukl, G. A.
(ed) (1994) Leadership in Organisations, 3rd
edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall International.
