Abstract
Introduction
Career choice involves decision making about the profession or occupation one chooses to pursue. It is a developmental process that extends throughout life and involves not a solitary decision but a series of decisions as one responds to several contextual factors (Weiten, Dunn, & Hammer, 2015). Career choice remains a worrisome problem among Nigerian students across the country as many students are dependent on chance and luck elements in career decision making and are not aware of new career opportunities (Ofem & Ajayi, 2008). When people actively engage in making the choice of their career rather than allow chance to dictate the pursuit of an occupation, they are more satisfied with their careers. Awareness of occupational options has significant contribution to career choice intentions of students. Oluwatimilehin and Wale (2009) argue that due to globalization, lucrative professions have emerged as offshoots of the traditional professions like medicine, law, nursing, engineering, and so on. However, majority of students still indicate the traditional professions as their future careers. This suggests that they may lack awareness of the new professions which offer equally great career prospects and opportunities.
Career Choice
Career choice is the act of choosing a profession or career in response to specific factors such as events, people, conditions, situations, or any influence that affects the individual’s choice (Doud, 2003). Career choice is one of the most important decisions in the life of an individual. It has far-reaching implications on the individual’s future in terms of lifestyle, status, income, security, and job satisfaction. Making a career choice is a complex process because of the growing rate of change in the world of work which has increased the number of career transitions which individuals make during their lifetime (Issa, 2007). In career decision making, every person consider the factors of extrinsic, intrinsic, and altruistic elements in career decision making (Dockery & Barns, 2005; Jaw, Wang, Ling, & Chang, 2006; Pang, 2014). Altruistic motivation for choosing a profession comes from a steadfastness and responsibility toward bettering society. It includes promoting social fairness and making a difference in the world (Dundar, 2014). Altruistic considerations in career decision making are prevalent in egalitarian professions, such as librarianship, that allow individuals to help society. They include opportunities to work closely with people and to influence others, as well as the ability to contribute to society. Altruistic factors relate to occupations that allow individuals to contribute to society. Various altruistic motives also include the desire to help and support people, to answer a calling, and to make a difference (Jungert, Alm, & Thornberg, 2014). These motivations are peculiar to service professions.
Intrinsic motivations also play a role in many people’s career decision making. Intrinsic considerations include factors such as responsibility, recognition, and the nature of the work itself. Intrinsic factors are directly connected to the occupation itself. It has to do with the inherent attractiveness and interest in the career. It includes opportunities for creativity and originality, enjoyable work, responsibility level involved in the job, and challenging work (Sinclair, 2008). Extrinsic factors are related to a profession’s characteristics not intrinsic to the job itself, such as pecuniary interests, vacation opportunity, material benefits of the job, and other external incentives. Extrinsic factors are external motivations that are distinguishable from the work. They are the motives coming from outside sources, which include a good salary, a decent future income potential, good job opportunities, high status of the profession, opportunities for exposure, promotion and travel, job security, and availability of jobs. These factors have been described as safety resources because they empower people to accomplish their basic survival needs. Extrinsic motivations serve as strong incentive for people to pursue careers they know that will empower them to accomplish admired societal status and wealth.
Law Librarianship
The profession of librarianship, which is dedicated to the egalitarian service of providing information to all classes of persons, has existed for centuries, beginning in ancient periods when documented records were inscribed in stone and other materials (Hessel, 1955; Lahiri, 1999). As the volume of information increased and the formats for documenting information correspondingly increase, the profession of librarianship evolved to cater for the organization, preservation, management, retrieval, and dissemination of information (Baruchson-Arbib & Mendelovitz, 2004; Verma, 2015). Law librarianship is a specialized form of the profession of librarianship dedicated to the service of the legal profession, which on its own part thrives on information. As a service profession, academic law librarianship is committed to serving the needs of law students, law faculty, the legal communities, and the general public.
Significant changes have occurred in law students’ career options. Many law students upon graduation do not proceed to mainstream legal practice. Observations have shown that they pursue careers in corporate secretaryship, arbitration, human resources, journalism, but not in law librarianship. Many students get admission into law school without a clear knowledge of whether they want to practice law (Haas, 2006). A U.K. study conducted by the Higher Education Statistics Agency reported in The Guadian (2014) revealed that 54.5% of law graduates in 2009 got jobs in accountancy, personnel relations, advertising and recruitment, public administration, finance, and education. Berkovic (2011) reports that fewer law graduates are making law practice a career choice. He also reports that the proportion of law graduates starting work in law firms have dropped from 49.1% in 2005 to 43.7% in 2010. In contrast, the proportion of law graduates taking jobs in industry jumped from 13.5% to 20.1% in the same 5-year period. Traditionally, the legal industry covers professions in the areas of law, courts, law enforcement, corrections, and rehabilitation. However, this industry also includes a wide range of legal-related occupations that are found in other fields and industries. Many of these professions offer different litigation services to attorneys, such as trial consulting, expert witness services, or private investigation. Some professionals perform legal-related work in such areas as compliance, conflict resolution, contract administration, patent prosecution, or human resource management. Other legal-related occupations are found in the areas of politics, publishing, education, career services, and library services (Echaore-McDavid, 2007). In spite of listing of library services as a legal-related occupation, findings have shown that law students have low perception of a career in law librarianship (Gates, 1966; Mosley, 2009). Probably, glamour and attraction has not accorded law librarianship as a result of low level of awareness and environmental factors.
Awareness and Law Librarianship as Career Choice
Awareness of careers includes having a knowledge and understanding of the world of work; the difference between jobs, occupations, and careers; and having knowledge of a wide range of local, regional, national, and global career pathways and opportunities while giving consideration to economic, cultural influences, and the impact of stereotypes on career choice (Kolbert, Williams, Morgan, Crothers, & Hughes, 2016). It includes the possession of accurate information about the qualification for eligibility to gain entrance into an occupation and knowledge about the duties and roles of an occupation (Arulmani & Nag-Arulmani, 2006).
Awareness influences individuals in making informed career choices (Denga, 2001). Borchert (2002) observes that before graduating, some students have not considered enough alternative occupational options in career selection. Before making a career choice, students must have access to a number of career options from which they can make a choice. They can make better decisions about their career paths when they know and understand the career options open to them. Oluwatimilehin and Wale (2009) argue that globalization has resulted in the expansion of professions leading to the development of lucrative and vibrant professions as products of the popular professions. Hence, several new, high profile, and rewarding professions offering promises of fulfilling careers have developed across the globe.
Awareness of librarianship as a vibrant career option involves having knowledge of the career of law librarianship, including knowledge of the specialized competencies, educational qualification, and professionalism of law librarians. The specialized competencies of law librarianship include library management which involves providing leadership, maintaining an understanding of trends, developments, emerging technologies, reference, research, and client services; evaluating the quality, authenticity, and accuracy of information resources in a variety of formats; assisting and educating users in the use of the library’s information systems, collection development, acquisition and management of a diverse collection of legal and nonlegal resources, and organizing and cataloging of information resources; and teaching that determines the educational needs of users through observation, discussion, and needs assessment tools and that effectively teaches library users and colleagues with differing needs and technological skill levels, providing training and guidance on the organization and use of legal resources in various formats (American Association of Law Libraries, 2010).
The education and training of law librarians requires minimally, entry-level candidates who must possess a master’s degree in library and information science (Sherr & Webb, 1989) and a degree in law (Hambleton, 1991). The law profession has a wide range of career choices. There are many career opportunities in the field of law. There are about 107 law-related occupation ranging from legal practitioner, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) practitioner, legal secretary, and law teacher to academic law librarian, law firm librarian, patent agent, human resources manager, and legal reporter (Echaore-McDavid, 2007). Law librarianship is a legal-related specialized profession that combines the practice of the legal profession and the library profession, providing specialized library services to legal clientele. Law students upon graduation pursue careers in other areas without giving any attention to law librarianship.
Statement of the Problem
Studies have shown that law students upon graduation pursue careers in other fields as corporate secretaryship, human resources, journalism, insurance, real property, investment banking, public policy/public administration teaching, and so on (Bowman, 2010), without giving a thought to law librarianship which is a legal career. The fact that majority of law students do not consider law librarianship as a career option is undesirable for the future of the career of law librarianship. Globalization has resulted in the expansion of professions leading to the development of lucrative and vibrant professions as offshoots of the popular professions, so that several new and lucrative professions, offering promises of fulfilling careers have evolved across the globe (Oluwatimilehin & Wale, 2009). Law librarianship is a lucrative and vibrant profession that has evolved from the progressions of law and librarianship. Literature highlights the lack of exposure to a variety of emerging occupations by students. Can the fact that law librarianship is not considered as a career option by law students be a result of the level of awareness of law students?
Objective of the Study
The main objective of the study is to investigate the influence of awareness of law librarianship on the career choice of law librarianship among law students in South-West Nigeria. The specific objectives are to
find out the level of awareness of law librarianship as career among law students in South-West Nigeria;
ascertain the inclination of law students in South-West Nigeria toward law librarianship as a career choice;
determine the influence of awareness of law librarianship on the choice of law librarianship among law students in South-West Nigeria.
Research Questions
Based on the main objective to investigate the influence of awareness of law librarianship and environmental factors on law librarianship as career choice among law students in South-West Nigeria, the following research questions are raised:
Research Hypothesis
The following hypothesis for the study were formulated and tested at .05 level of significance:
Scope of the Study
The study covered the six states in South-West Nigeria. The study was limited to the universities that offer approved law program up to 500 level in South-West Nigeria. They are the University of Lagos, University of Ibadan, Obafemi Awolowo University, Adekunle Ajasin University, Ekiti State University, Osun State University, Olabisi Onabanjo University, Lagos State University, Babcock University, Afe Babalola University, Adeleke University, Crescent University, and Bowen University. The study involved law students of the 400 and 500 levels. This category is selected for the study because the career intentions of these levels would have matured as they are nearing graduation. The focus is on law students because they are the primary source of new service law librarians in academic libraries. By the mandate of the Council of Legal Education, academic law libraries in Nigeria are to be headed by librarians who hold a law degree in addition to a master’s degree in library and information studies.
Method
The study adopted the survey design. The target population for this study comprised law students at the 400 and 500 levels in universities that run approved undergraduate law program in South-West Nigeria. This category is selected for the study because the career intentions of these levels would have matured as they are nearing graduation. There are 14 universities that run approved law program in South-West Nigeria. In all, 12 of these universities run the law program up to 500 level. The total population of 400 and 500 law students in these 12 universities in South-West Nigeria is 2,945. The population is presented in Table 1.
Population of Law Students in South-West Nigeria.
Purposive sampling technique was used for the study. The 12 universities that run the approved undergraduate law program up to 500 level in South-West, Nigeria were purposively selected for the study. Krejcie and Morgan’s formula was used to select the sample size of 597 law students.
Presentation of Results
Table 2 shows the distribution of respondents by institutions selected for the study. It reveals that out of the 12 law schools, the highest percentage (18.2%) of the respondents were selected from University of Lagos, closely followed by Obafemi Awolowo University (17.3%). Others include Afe Babalola University (10.7%), Olabisi Onabanjo University (10.7%), among others.
Distribution of Respondents by Institutions.
Demographic Characteristics of the Respondents
Table 3 presents the distribution of the demographic characteristics of the respondents used for the study.
Distribution of the Demographic Characteristics of the Respondents.
Table 3 reveals that majority of the respondents (56.7%) were in 400 level, whereas 43% were in 500 level, respectively. Besides, the table shows that more females (65.2%) participated in the study than their male counterparts (34.8%).
Presentation of Results
The results of the study are presented in line with the research questions and hypothesis raised.
Table 4 indicates that the respondents are slightly aware of law librarianship as a career choice with an average mean of 2.17. Each of the answers in the result has a value: 4 =
The Level of Awareness of Law Librarianship as a Career Choice Among Law Students in South-West Nigeria.
Table 5 shows the various elements on the inclination to the choice of law librarianship. They are the altruistic, intrinsic, and extrinsic considerations on career choice of law librarianship. The answers in the result have a value ascribed to them: 4 =
Inclination of Law Students in South-West Nigeria Toward Law Librarianship.
Table 6 reveals that 16.1% of the variation in the dependent variable (choice of law librarianship as career) is accounted for by the independent variable (awareness of law librarianship; Adjusted
Influence of Awareness on the Choice of Law Librarianship as a Career.
Discussion of Findings
The study examined awareness of law librarianship as a determinant of law librarianship as career choice among law students in South-West Nigeria.
The findings of the study show that the respondents were slightly aware of law librarianship as a career choice among law students in South-West Nigeria. This accords with Ismail’s (2006) exploratory study that reveal that the respondents had a very low level of awareness toward a career in librarianship. Mugot’s (2012) study of students’ awareness and motivation in the choice of library and information science revealed that the respondents had an average level of awareness of the career of librarianship. A study by Ajidahun (1997) on students’ perception of librarianship revealed a lack of awareness on the part of the students about who a librarian is, his duties, required qualification, and status. Newbutt and Sen’s (2009) study also found that a lack of awareness of librarianship as a professional career choice resulted in young people not wanting to become librarians.
In respect to the inclination to law librarianship as a career by law students, the study showed that eight of the 14 items were agreed to determine their choice in the career of law librarianship. These eight items are based on altruistic and intrinsic considerations. This finding is in consonance with the findings of Akilli, Keskin, and Boylan (2016) on their study which found that intrinsic and altruistic variable have the greatest effect on the choice of the teaching profession. Erten (2014) however found in her study that respondents reported more intrinsic reasons than extrinsic reasons for choosing to teach.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The study revealed that awareness of law librarianship is critical in determining law librarianship as a career choice. Law students in South-West Nigeria showed a slight awareness of law librarianship as career. This has accounted for its low-level preference and popularity among other law-related careers. The following recommendations are suggested based on the findings:
The career of law librarianship should be given more exposure and awareness, so that law students can have a clear understanding and have an accurate knowledge and experience of another viable legal profession they can specialize on.
Authorities of the faculties of law in Nigerian universities should endeavor to include choice of varied legal career options in the curriculum of undergraduate law students with a view to acquaint the students with the various career options in the field of law.
The study showed that law students are inclined to law librarianship for altruistic reasons. Law schools should give further exposure to law students on selfless service and altruism, to encourage them to engage in a service profession like law librarianship.
The finding of this study will help the government at federal, state, and local levels to incorporate in the education curricula programs that will provide opportunities to participate in work-situation services/activities as part of undergraduate experience for students to gain awareness of career opportunities, including law librarianship.
Law librarians and other stakeholders should take up the responsibility in organizing and supporting, through multiple ways, publicity programs on awareness of the career of law librarianship. This will ignite wider outreach, provoking public awareness about the profession of law librarianship.
Library schools should work with law schools with the purpose of enlisting law students’ interest in law librarianship as a career and to incorporate law career information into existing curricula.
