This article critically examines the making of the ‘Guardian Angels’ program, a Canadian special immigration program for Asylum claimants working on the frontlines of the COVID-19 pandemic. The program was the product of community organizing and mediatized ‘essential worker’ discourse which resulted in contest over the terms of migrant inclusion. These debates were waged by migrant justice organizers, who called for “Status for All”, and the Federal and Quebec provincial governments each with their own plans. At first proposed as wide-spanning amnesty for migrant healthcare workers, the Guardian Angels program’s final form was restrictive and exclusionary. Based on our ethnographic work with Montreal’s Immigrant Workers Center, we analyze the program’s logics through a conjectural framework, centering the debates around two overlapping crises: First, the Trump-era rise in asylum-claimant land-border crossings at Roxham Road, and second, the pandemic public health crisis. These moments were seized on by Quebec Premier François Legault’s nationalist CAQ party to increase provincial immigration sovereignty in Canada’s federated immigration framework. We contend these goals were pushed through by bordering through the mechanism of status, a power which we argue is continuous with a broader assertion of territorial control that operates through selection powers.
AgnewJ (2005) Sovereignty regimes: territoriality and state authority in contemporary world politics. Annals of the Association of American Geographers95(2): 437–461.
2.
AgnewJ (2017) Globalization and Sovereignty: Beyond the Territorial Trap. 2nd edition. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
3.
AgnewJ (2019) Taking back control? The myth of territorial sovereignty and the Brexit fiasco. Territory, Politics, Governance8: 1–14.
4.
BélangerÉChasséP (2021) The 2018 provincial election in Quebec. Canadian Political Science Review15(1): 34–43.
5.
BenhadjoudjaL (2022) Racial secularism as settler colonial sovereignty in Quebec. Islamophobia Studies Journal7(2): 183–199, Pluto Journals.
ColemanM (2012) The “Local” migration state: the site-specific devolution of immigration enforcement in the U.S. South: the “Local” migration state. Law & Policy34(2): 159–190.
CornwallAJewkesR (1995) What is participatory research?Social Science & Medicine41(12): 1667–1676.
17.
CostaMDJamesS (1972) The Power of Women and the Subversion of the Community. 3rd edition. Falling Wall Press.
18.
Côté-BoucherKVivesLJannardL-P (2023) Chronicle of a “crisis” foretold: asylum seekers and the case of Roxham road on the Canada-US border. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space41(2): 408–426, Sage Publications Ltd STM.
19.
DalexisRDCénatJM (2020) Asylum seekers working in Quebec (Canada) during the COVID-19 pandemic: risk of deportation, and threats to physical and mental health. Psychiatry Research292: 113299.
20.
De GenovaN (2004) The legal production of Mexican/migrant “illegality”. Latino Studies2(2): 160–185.
21.
De GenovaN (2013) Spectacles of migrant ‘illegality’: the scene of exclusion, the obscene of inclusion. Ethnic and Racial Studies36(7): 1180–1198, Routledge.
22.
De GenovaN (2016) The European question: migration, race, and postcoloniality in Europe. Social Text34(3 128): 75–102.
23.
De GenovaN (ed) (2017) The Borders of ‘Europe’: Autonomy of Migration, Tactics of Bordering. Duke University Press.
24.
Debout Pour La Dignité (2021) Mission, Vision – Debout Pour la Dignité. Debout Pour La Dignité. Available at. https://www.dpld.ca/mission-vision/ (accessed 13 June 2025).
EldenS (2009) Terror and Territory: The Spatial Extent of Sovereignty. NED-New Edition. University of Minnesota Press. (accessed 15 June 2025).
29.
FraserN (2017) Crisis of care? On the social-reproductive contradictions of contemporary capitalism. In Social Reproduction Theory. Remapping Class, Recentering Oppression. Pluto Press, 21–36. Available at. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1vz494j.6 (accessed 11 November 2024).
30.
GagnonAC (2020) Immigration policy in Québec-Canada as a case study of incrementalism. Canadian Public Administration63(2): 247–270.
JessopBBonnettKBromleyS, et al. (1984) Authoritarian Populism, Two Nations, and Thatcherism. New Left Review, 147.
45.
Justin Trudeau [@JustinTrudeau] (2017) To Those Fleeing Persecution, Terror & War, Canadians Will Welcome You, Regardless of Your Faith. Diversity is Our Strength #WelcomeToCanada Twitter. Tweet. Available at. https://x.com/JustinTrudeau/status/825438460265762816 (accessed 14 June 2025).
46.
KatzC (1998) Excavating the hidden city of social reproduction: a commentary. City and Society10(1): 37–46.
47.
KatzC (2013) Missing subjects. Dialogues in Human Geography3(1): 30–33, Sage Publications.
KostovC (2008) Canada-Quebec immigration agreements (1971–1991) and their impact on federalism. American Review of Canadian Studies38(1): 91–103, Routledge.
LegaultF (2020) Je veux rendre hommage à nos anges gardiens qui veillent sur nous et qui combattent cet ennemi invisible qu’est la COVID-19. In: Je Vous Remercie Du Fond Du Cœur Pour Tout Ce Que Vous Faites Pour Nous!Available at. https://twitter.com/francoislegault/status/1246588360157564929 (accessed 22 February 2022).
MasonMKhawlieM (2016) Fluid sovereignty: state–nature relations in the Hasbani Basin, Southern Lebanon. Annals of the Association of American Geographers106(6): 1344–1359, Taylor & Francis Ltd.
61.
MasseyD (2004) Geographies of responsibility. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography86(1): 5–18.
62.
McDonaldJ (2009) Migrant illegality, nation-building, and the politics of regularization in Canada. Refuge: Canada’s Journal on Refugees26(2): 65–77, Toronto: Centre for Refugee Studies, York University.
Migrant Rights Network (2021) Status for All - March to Ottawa. Migrant Rights Network. Available at. https://migrantrights.ca/marchtoottawa/ (accessed 15 June 2025).
69.
MillsS (2016) A Place in the Sun: Haiti, Haitians, and the Remaking of Quebec Études D’Histoire Du Québec = Studies on the History of Quebec 31. McGill-Queen’s University Press.
70.
MitchellKKatzCMarstonS (eds) (2004) Life’s Work: Geographies of Social Reproduction. Blackwell.
71.
MotomuraH (1999) Federalism, international human rights, and immigration exceptionalism symposium - part II: role of the states in foreign affairs. University of Colorado Law Review70(4): 1361–1394.
72.
MountzA (2013) Political geography I: reconfiguring geographies of sovereignty. Progress in Human Geography37(6): 829–841.
73.
MountzA (2020) The Death of Asylum: Hidden Geographies of the Enforcement Archipelago. University of Minnesota Press.
74.
MugaboD (2019) Black in the city: on the ruse of ethnicity and language in an antiblack landscape. Identities: Global Studies in Power and Culture26(6): 631–648.
75.
MurallCLFournierEGalvezJH, et al. (2021) A small number of early introductions seeded widespread transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in Québec, Canada. Genome Medicine13: 169.
76.
NyersP (2005) The regularization of non-status immigrants in Canada: limits and prospects. Canadian Review of Social Policy55: 109–114.
77.
PaquetM (2019) Province Building and the Federalization of Immigration in Canada. University of Toronto Press. (accessed 20 March 2021).
78.
PâquetMDuchesneÉ (2008) Étude de la complexité d’un événement : les responsables politiques québécois et les immigrants illégaux Haïtiens, 1972–1974. Revue d’Histoire de l’Amerique Française50(2): 173–200.
RodriguezC (2017) Enforcement, integration, and the future of immigration federalism. Journal on Migration and Human Security5(2): 509–540, New York, United States: Sage PUBLICATIONS, INC.
86.
SchoenbergerE (2001) Interdisciplinarity and social power. Progress in Human Geography25(3): 365–382.
StevanoSMezzadriALombardozziL, et al. (2021) Hidden abodes in plain sight: the social reproduction of households and labour in the COVID-19 pandemic. Feminist Economics27(1/2): 271–287, Routledge.
VarsanyiMWLewisPGProvineDM, et al. (2012) A multilayered jurisdictional patchwork: immigration federalism in the United States. Law & Policy34(2): 138–158.
99.
WaliaHKelleyRDGEstesN (2021) Border and Rule: Global Migration, Capitalism, and the Rise of Racist Nationalism. Haymarket Books.
WindersJSmithBE (2019) Social reproduction and capitalist production: a genealogy of dominant imaginaries. Progress in Human Geography43(5): 871–889.
102.
WrightC (2003) Moments of Emergence: Organizing by and with Undocumented and Non-Citizen People in Canada After September 11. Refuge: Canada’s Journal on Refugees 21. York University, Centre for Refugee Studies, 5–15.
