The vast majority of research in nursing ethics over the last decade indicates that nurses may not be fully prepared to ‘deliver the good(s)’ for their patients, or to contribute appropriately in the wider current health care climate. When suitable research projects were evaluated for this article, one key question emerged: if nurses are educationally better prepared than ever before to exercise their ethical decision-making skills, why does research still indicate that the expected practice-based improvements remain elusive? Hence, a number of ideas gleaned from recent research about the current nature of nursing ethics, and especially teaching nursing ethics to student nurses, are analysed and critiqued in this article, which concludes with a cluster of ideas and conclusions based on that analysis. It is hoped that such a review may serve as a catalyst for nurse educators to re-examine their teaching practices with a view to enhancing good (i.e. ethical) nursing practice through educational means.
Woods M.The ethical preparation and practice of nurses: a pilot research project. (Occasional Paper.) Palmerston North: Massey University , 1992.
2.
Allmark P.Uncertainties in the teaching of ethics to students of nursing . J Adv Nurs1995; 22: 374-378 .
3.
Birkelund R.Ethics and education . Nurs Ethics2000; 7: 473-480 .
4.
Leino-Kilpi H.The need to research the teaching of ethics and the outcomes of such teaching [Editorial Comment] . Nurs Ethics2001; 8: 297-298 .
5.
Gastmans C.A fundamental ethical approach to nursing: some proposals for ethics education . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 494-507 .
6.
Weber JR.Teaching moral reasoning to student nurses . J Holistic Nurs1992; 10: 263-274 .
7.
Giarelli E. A historical study of nursing ethics education in the United States - 1873-1933 [Dissertation]. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers State University of New Jersey, 1989.
8.
Veatch RM.Nursing ethics, physician ethics, and medical ethics . Law Med Health Care1981; (Oct): 17-19 .
9.
Mayberry M.Ethical decision making: a response of hospital nurses . Nurs Adm Q1986; 10(3): 75-86 .
10.
Caffrey RA , Caffrey PA.Nursing: caring or co-dependent?Nurs Forum1994; 29(1): 12-17 .
11.
Yarling R , McElmurry B.The moral foundations of nursing . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1986; 8(2): 63-73 .
12.
Grunstein-Amado R.Differences in ethical decision making processes among nurses and doctors . J Adv Nurs1992; 17: 129-137 .
13.
Gallagher U , Boyd K.Teaching and learning nursing ethics. London: Scutari Press , 1991.
14.
Peter E , Lunardi VL , Macfarlane A.Nursing resistance as ethical action: literature review . J Adv Nurs2004; 46: 403-416 .
15.
Vallance E. ‘Navigating through’ a grounded theory of the ethical context of undergraduate nursing education [Thesis]. Palmerston North: Massey University, 2003.
16.
Haywood JM. The relationship of moral development stages to ethics content in nursing curricula [Dissertation]. Nashville, TN: Peabody College for Teachers of Vanderbilt University, 1996.
17.
Wuest J.Professionalism and the evolution of nursing as a discipline: a feminist perspective . J Prof Nurs1994; 10: 357-367 .
18.
Parsons S , Barker PJ , Armstrong AE.The teaching of health care ethics to students of nursing in the UK: a pilot study . Nurs Ethics2001; 8: 45-56 .
19.
Woods M.Nursing ethics education and contemporary concerns: a reflective report. (Occasional Paper.) Palmerston North: Manawatu Polytechnic , 1994.
20.
Woods M. Maintaining a nursing ethic: a grounded theory of the moral practice of experienced nurses [Thesis]. Palmerston North: Massey University, 1997.
Penticuff JH , Walden M.Influence of practice environment and nurse characteristics on perinatal nurses’ responses to ethical dilemmas . Nurs Res2000; 49: 64-72 .
23.
Erlen JA , Frost B.Nurses’ perceptions of powerlessness in influencing ethical decisions . West J Nurs Res1991; 13: 397-407 .
24.
Sleutel MR.Intrapartum nursing care: a case study of supportive interventions and ethical conflicts . Birth2000; 27(1): 38-48 .
25.
Fry ST , Harvey RM , Hurley AC , Foley BJ.Development of a model of moral distress in military nursing . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 373-387 .
26.
Schroeter K.Ethical perception and resulting action in perioperative nurses . AORN J1999; 69: 991-1002 .
27.
Woods M.A nursing ethic: the moral voice of experienced nurses . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 423-433 .
28.
Lützén K , Schreiber R.Moral survival in a nontherapeutic environment . Issues Ment Health Nurs1998; 19: 303-315 .
29.
Å ström G , Furåker C , Norberg A.Nurses’ skills in managing ethically difficult care situations: interpretation of nurses’ narratives . J Adv Nurs1995; 21: 1073-1080 .
30.
Gaudine AP , Beaton MR.Employed to go against one’s values: nurse managers’ accounts of ethical conflict with their organizations . Can J Nurs Res, 2002; 34(2): 17-43 .
31.
Hutchinson SA.Responsible subversion: a study of rule bending among nurses . Sch Inq Nurs Pract1990; 4: 3-17 .
32.
Rodney P , Varcoe C.Towards ethical inquiry in the economics evaluation of nursing practice . Can J Nurs Res2001; 33(1): 35-57 .
33.
Spence K.Ethical issues for neonatal nurses . Nur Ethics1998; 5: 206-217 .
34.
Sundin-Huard D , Fahy K.Moral distress, advocacy and burnout: theorizing the relationships . Int J Nurs Pract1999; 5: 8-13 .
35.
Wurzbach ME.Acute care nurses’ experiences of moral certainty . J Adv Nurs, 1999; 30: 287-293 .
36.
Kelly B.Preserving moral integrity: a follow up study with new graduate nurses . J Adv Nurs1998; 28: 1134-1145 .
37.
Nolan PW , Markert D.Ethical reasoning observed: a longitudinal study of nursing students . Nurs Ethics2001; 9: 243-258 .
38.
Cameron ME , Schaffer M , Park H-A.Nursing students’ experience of ethical problems and use of ethical decision-making models . Nurs Ethics2001; 8: 432-447 .
39.
Edlund-Sjoberg M , Thorell-Ekstrand I.Ethical reflection on patient care situations - a study in a group of Swedish nurse students . Int Nurs Perspect2001; 1(1): 15-22 .
40.
Chiarella M.The legal and professional status of nursing. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone , 2002.
41.
International Council of Nurses . Code of ethics for nurses. Geneva: ICN , 2000.
42.
Darbyshire P.Preserving nursing in a destitute time . J Adv Nurs1993; 18: 507-508 .
43.
Schnieder W , Snell L.CARE. An approach for teaching ethics in medicine . Soc Sci Med2000; 51: 1563-1567 .
44.
Schön DA.The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action. Aldershot: Arena Ashgate Publishing , 1995.
45.
Cartwright T , Davson-Galle P , Holden RJ.Moral philosophy and nursing curricula: indoctrination of the new breed . J Nurs Educ1992; 31: 225-228 .
46.
Holt J , Long T.Moral guidance, moral philosophy, and moral issues in practice . Nurs Educ Today1999; 19: 246-249 .
47.
Webb J , Warwick C.Getting it right: the teaching of philosophical health care ethics . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 150-156 .
48.
Glen S.Educating for interprofessional collaboration: teaching about values . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 202-213 .
49.
Raya A.Can knowledge be promoted and values ignored? Implications for nursing education . J Adv Nurs1990; 15: 504-509 .
50.
Austin W.Using the human rights paradigm in health ethics: the problems and the possibilities . Nurs Ethics2001; 8: 183-195 .
51.
Sellman D.The virtues in the moral education of nurses: Florence Nightingale revisited . Nurs Ethics1997; 4: 3-11 .
52.
van Hooft S.Moral education for nursing decisions . J Adv Nurs1990; 15: 210-215 .
53.
Han S-S , Ahn S-H.An analysis and evaluation of student nurses’ participation in ethical decision making . Nurs Ethics2000; 7: 113-123 .
Crigger NJ.Universal prescriptivism: traditional moral decision-making theory revisited . J Adv Nurs1994; 20: 538-544 .
56.
Kikuchi JF.Multicultural ethics in nursing education: a potential threat to responsible practice . J Prof Nurs1996; 12: 159-165 .
57.
Le Veille Gaul A.Casuistry, care, compassion, and ethics data analysis . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1995; 17(3): 47-57 .
58.
Zimmermann M.Ethics and nursing: a contribution to nursing education . Pflege1998; 11: 219-223 .
59.
Diekelmann N , Diekelmann J.Learning ethics in nursing and genetics: narrative pedagogy and the grounding of values . J Pediatr Nurs2000; 15: 226-231 .
60.
Carse AL.The ‘voice of care’: implications for bioethical education . J Med Philos1991; 16: 5-28 .
61.
Tschudin V.Ethics in nursing: the caring relationship, second edition. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann , 1992.
62.
Peter E , Gallop R.The ethic of care: a comparison of nursing and medical students . Image J Nurs Sch1994; 26: 47-51 .
Winslow BJ , Winslow GR.Integrity and compromise in nursing ethics . J Med Philos1991; 16: 307-323 .
65.
Callery P.Moral learning in nursing education: a discussion of the usefulness of cognitive-developmental and social learning theories . J Adv Nurs1990; 15: 324-328 .
66.
Beauchamp TL , Childress JF.Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press , 1994.
67.
Yankou D.Educational innovations. Using gaming to help nursing students understand ethics . J Nurs Educ2003; 42: 212-215 .
68.
White GB , Davis AJ.Teaching ethics using games . J Adv Nurs1987; 12: 621-624 .
69.
Candela L , Michael SR , Mitchell S.Ethical debates: enhancing critical thinking in nursing students . Nurs Educ2003; 28(1): 37-39 .
70.
Pang MS , Wong KT.Cultivating a moral sense of nursing through model emulation . Nurs Ethics1998; 5: 424-440 .
71.
Dinç L , Görgülü RS.Teaching ethics in nursing . Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 259-268 .
72.
Holland S.Teaching nursing ethics by cases: a personal perspective . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 434-436 .
73.
Tschudin V ed. Ethics: education and research. Harrow: Scutari Press , 1994.
