Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The effective application of technology is a key source of competitive advantage for modern industry. However, the integration of technology management systems into established business processes represents a continuing challenge to many firms. This paper describes the development of a practical technique for the assessment of technology management practices. Based on a process model of technology management, it provides a means whereby manufacturing companies can assess the effectiveness of the technology management activities critical to their business, and identify areas for improvement or transfer of good practice.

The development of the assessment methodology is discussed in the context of the wider research project of which it is part. Its basis in theory and literature is reviewed, together with the results of its application in a range of manufacturing companies. The main output from the project is a practical management guide [technology management assessment procedure (TMAP)]. The procedure comprises three levels, which span the full range of technology management activities in the firm, linking broad strategic concerns to detailed operational activities in the format of a series of facilitated workshops.

Keywords

technology management business process assessment and improvement manufacturing

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Gaynor

G. H.

(Ed.) Handbook of Technology Management, 1996 (McGraw-Hill, London).

Clarke

T. E.

Reavley

Science and Technology Management Bibliography 1993, 1993 (Stargate Consultants Limited, Ottawa).

Drejer

The discipline of management of technology, based on considerations relating to technology. Technovation, 1996, 17(5), 253–265.

Gregory

M. J.

Technology management: A process approach. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part B, Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 1995, 209(B5), 347–356.

Cruickshank

C. M.

Lamb

M. C. A.

Paterson

C. J.

Skilbeck

J. N.

Probert

D. R.

Gregory

M. J.

Technology management: Linking strategy and process. In Proceedings of the British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, September 1995, pp. 85–94.

Gregory

M. J.

Probert

D. R.

Cowell

D. R.

Auditing technology management processes. Int. J. Technol. Mgmt, 1996, 12(3), 306–319.

Paterson

C. J.

Skilbeck

J. N.

Probert

D. R.

Gregory

M. G.

Assessment of technology management processes–development of a practical approach within an industrial context. In Proceedings of 6th International Conference on Management of Technology, Gotëborg, Sweden, 25–28 June 1997, Vol. 2, pp. 822–834.

Paterson

C. J.

Phaal

Probert

D. R.

Gregory

M. J.

Technology management process assessment: Implementation factors. In Proceedings of 7th Conference of the International Association for the Management of Technology, Orlando, 16–20 February 1998.

Phaal

Paterson

C. J.

Probert

D. R.

Hughes

D. J.

Linking technology to the market: A top-down appraisal within a multi-business organisation. In Proceedings of 7th International Forum on Technology Management, Kyoto, 3–7 November 1997, pp. 154–159.

10.

Farrukh

C. J. P.

Phaal

Probert

D. R.

Technology Management Assessment Procedure (TMAP)–A Guide for Supporting Technology Management in the Business, 1998 (Cambridge Centre for Technology Management, Cambridge).

11.

Betz

Strategic Technology Management, 1993 (McGraw-Hill, New York).

12.

Roussel

P. A.

Erikson

T. J.

Saad

K. N.

Third Generation R&D–Managing the Link to Corporate Strategy, 1991 (Harvard Business School Press, Boston).

13.

Whipp

Managing technological changes: Opportunities and pitfalls. Int. J. Veh. Des., 1991, 12, 469–477.

14.

Pavitt

What we know about the strategic management of technology. California Managmt Rev., Spring 1990, 17–26.

15.

Matthews

W. H.

Conceptual framework for integrating technology into business strategy. Int. J. Veh. Des., 1992, 13(5/6), 524–532.

16.

Twiss

Managing Technological Innovation, 4th edition, 1992 (Pitman Publishing, London).

17.

Nonaka

Takeuchi

The Knowledge Creating Company, 1995 (Oxford University Press, New York).

18.

Skilbeck

J. N.

Cruickshank

C. M.

A framework for evaluating technology management processes in technology based businesses. In Proceedings of Portland International Conference on Management of Engineering and Technology (PICMET), Portland, 27–31 July 1997.

19.

Perrino

A. C.

Tipping

J. W.

Global technology management. Res. Technol. Mgmt, 1989, 32(3), 12–19.

20.

Steele

L. W.

Managing Technology–The Strategic View, 1989 (McGraw-Hill).

21.

Dussauge

Hart

Ramanantsoa

Strategic Technology Management: Integrating Product Technologies into Global Business Strategies, 1992 (John Wiley, Chichester).

22.

Wheelwright

S. C.

Clark

K. B.

Revolutionising Product Development, 1992 (Free Press, New York).

23.

Probert

D. R.

Jones

S. W.

Gregory

M. J.

The make or buy decision in the context of manufacturing strategy development. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part B, Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 1993, 207(B4), 241–250.

24.

Seaton

Al-Ghailani

H. A.

'Innovative effort' in small manufacturing companies in development economies. In Proceedings of 6th International Conference on Management of Technology (IAMOT), Göteborg, 25–28 June 1997, pp. 667–676.

25.

Checkland

Systems Thinking, Systems Practice, 1993 (John Wiley, Chichester).

26.

Brady

Rush

Hobday

Davies

Probert

Banerjee

Tools for technology management: An academic perspective. Technovation, 1997, 17(8), 417–426.

27.

Platts

K. W.

A process approach to researching manufacturing strategy. Int. J. Ops Prod. Managmt, 1993, 13(8), 4–17.

28.

Maslen

Lewis

M. A.

Procedural action research. Working Papers in Manufacturing, 1994 (Cambridge University Engineering Department).

29.

Coghlan

Research as a process of change: Action research in organisations. Irish Business Adm. Res., 1994, 15, 119–130.

30.

Phaal

Paterson

C. J.

Probert

D. R.

Technology management in manufacturing business: Process and practical assessment. Technovation, 1998, 18(8/9), 541–553.

31.

Chiesa

Coughlan

Voss

C. A.

Development of a technical innovation audit. J. Prod. Innovation Managmt, 1996, 13, 105–136.

32.

Neely

A. D.

Mills

J. F.

Platts

K. W.

Richards

A. H.

Gregory

M. J.

Bourne

M. C. S.

Developing and testing a process for performance measurement system design. In Proceedings of 3rd International Conference of the European Operations Management Association, London, 2–4 June 1996.