Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article examines discourse about men in popular Roman Catholic literature between 1900 and 1960 in Quebec. From 1940 to 1960, particular attention was paid to the spiritual life of men, whose attitude toward piety was that it was women's—not men's—business. Catholic Action movements offered alternate models and masculine rituals for Christian life. Like the 19th and early 20th century Christian men's movements in the United States, these strategies attempted to counteract the “lack of manhood” in the churches. French Canadian movements, however, tried to attract men to the church by extolling the virtues of humble obedience. Partly influenced by feminism in the ‘60s, different pastoral issues surfaced in relation to men, and the older movements declined. While men's movements previously had recourse to symbol and ritual, symbolic activity declined in favor of productive activities. This raises the issue of the place of symbolism in the construction of contemporary masculinities.

Keywords

Quebec's “Quiet Revolution”Roman Catholic Church masculine Catholic movements

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anonymous. (1939, December 23). Le 40ième anniversaire du régiment des Zouaves pontificaux canadiens [The fortieth anniversary of the Canadian Pontifical Zouave regiments]. L'Action catholique, 11–12.

Anonymous. (1939, December 29). La brigade du feu a eu sa messe à Notre-Dame des Victoires [The fire brigade celebrated their mass at Our Lady of Victories]. L'Action catholique, 20.

Anonymous. (1940, January 5). Le mari parfait [The perfect husband]. L'Action catholique, 6.

Anonymous. (1951, June). Des époux modèles [Model husbands]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 302–303.

Bouchard

(1996). Quelques arpents d'Amérique. Population, économie, famille au Saguenay, 1838–1971 [Some acres of ground in America: Population, economy, and family in the Saguenay Region 1838–1971]. Montréal: Boréal.

Chalvin

(1966, May). Facture à payer [Bills to be paid]. Maintenant, 150–151.

de Certeau

(1975). La formalité des pratiques. Du système religieux à l'éthique des Lumières (XVIIe-XVIIIe) [The formality of practice: From religious system to enlightenment ethics (Seventeenth to the Eighteenth Century)]. In L'écriture de l'histoire (pp. 153–156). Paris: Gallimard.

Cholette-Pérusse

(1967, March). Le père au foyer! [A father in the home!]. Maintenant, 99–100.

Colozza

(1955, July/August). Saint Joseph, modèle de charité [Saint Joseph, model of charity]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 363–365.

10.

Doyon

(1963, January). Réformer les Instituts familiaux [Reforming family institutions]. Maintenant, 14–15.

11.

Dugré

(1947, September). Une jeunesse vaillante [Valliant youth]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 420.

12.

Dugré

(1948, March). Saint Joseph, chez lui et chez nous [Saint Joseph at home and among us]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 133–134.

13.

Dugré

(1952, May). Changements heureux [Positive changes]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 236.

14.

Dulac

(1994). Penser le masculin [Reflecting on masculinity]. In Dulac

(Ed.), Penser le masculin. Essai sur la trajectoire des militants de la condition masculine et paternelle [Reflecting on masculinity: Essay on the trajectory of militants for paternity and the status of men] (pp. 15–50). Quebec City: Institut Québécois de recherche sur la Culture.

15.

Gingras

P-E.

(1954, June). Les ligues du Sacré-Cœur et la temperance [The Sacred Heart and Temperance Leagues]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 330.

16.

Jacob

H-L.

(1951, July/August.) Un cavalier sans dame [Knight without lady]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 365–367.

17.

Kimmel

(1996). Manhood in America: A cultural history. New York: The Free Press.

18.

LeBlanc

(1947, February). La journée apostolique de Saint-Édouard [Apostolical Day in the parish of St. Eduard's] Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 106.

19.

Legrand

(1967, September 15). Une parole enfin libérée [A word freely expressed]. Maintenant, 270.

20.

Paul

. (1970, April). Saint Joseph, notre modèle et notre protecteur [Saint Joseph, our model and protector]. L'Église canadienne, 140–141.

21.

Pelletier-Baillargeon

(1964, May). Fête des mères [Mother's Day]. Maintenant, 151–152.

22.

Plourde

J-A.

(1970, November). Le patron de l'Église [Patron of the Church]. L'Église canadienne, 329–332.

23.

Pugh

(1983). Sons of liberty: The masculine mind in nineteenth-century America. Westport CT: Greenwood Press.

24.

Racine

(1947, September). Les enterrements de vies de garcons [Burying the single man's life]. Le Messager Canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 465–467.

25.

Racine

(1948, January). Bureaux, chantiers et usines au Sacré-Cœur [The Sacred Heart in the workplace, office, and factory]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 49.

26.

Ringuet. (1938). Trente arpents [Thirty acres of ground]. Montreal: Fides.

27.

Roy

(1951, September). Marie, modèle du travailleur [Mary, the worker's model]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 415–416.

28.

Roy

(1952, October). Le rosaire quotidien récité en famille [Praying the daily rosary in the family]. Le Messager canadien du Sacré-Cœur, 450.