Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Preston's (2011) challenge to the moral presumption against geoengineering is applied to carbon dioxide capture and storage (CCS) in Scotland, United Kingdom. Qualitative data is analysed to assess if and how Preston's arguments play out in practice. We argue that the concepts of ‘lesser evil’ and prioritising human well-being over non-interference in natural processes do bring different value positions together in support of CCS, but that not all people see short-term carbon abatement as the ‘least worst’ option or a suitable way to prioritise human well-being.

Keywords

Carbon dioxide capture and storage (CCS)climate change environmental ethics epistemic justice ethics of science and technology

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

2012. ‘Epistemic justice as a virtue of social institutions’. Social Epistemology 26(2): 163–173. CrossRef.

de Best-Waldhober

, Daamen

and Faaij

. 2009. ‘Informed and uninformed public opinions on CO₂ capture and storage technologies in the Netherlands’. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 3(3): 322–332. CrossRef.

Boele

, Fabig

and Wheeler

. 2001. ‘Shell, Nigeria and the Ogoni. A study in unsustainable development: II. Corporate social responsibility and “stakeholder management” versus a rights-based approach to sustainable development’. Sustainable Development 9: 121–135. CrossRef.

Borgmann

2012. ‘The setting of the scene: Technological fixes and the design of the good life’, in Preston

(ed.) Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management, pp. 189–200. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.

Brandani

2012. ‘Carbon dioxide capture from air: A simple analysis’. Energy and Environment 23 (2–3): 319–328. CrossRef.

Brown

2011. ‘Comparative ethical issues entailed in the geological disposal of radioactive waste and carbon dioxide in the light of climate change’, in Toth

(ed.) Geological Disposal of Carbon Dioxide and Radioactive Waste: A Comparative Assessment, pp. 317–337. Paris: IAEA. CrossRef.

Brunsting

, Mastop

, Pol

, Kaiser

, Zimmer

, Shackley

, Mabon

and Howell

. 2012. SiteChar Deliverable 8.2: Trust Building and Raising Public Awareness. Amsterdam: ECN. http://www.sitechar-co2.eu/FileDownload.aspx?Id-File=590&From=Publications (accessed 11 Feb. 2014).

Carr

, Preston

, Yung

, Szerszynski

, Keith

and Mercer

. 2013. ‘Public engagement on solar radiation management and why it needs to happen now’. Climatic Change 121: 567–577. CrossRef.

CASSEM Project. 2011. CO₂ Aquifer Storage Site Evaluation and Monitoring. Understanding the Challenges of CO₂ Storage: Results of the CASSEM Project Edinburgh: Scottish Carbon Capture and Storage.

10.

Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. 2010. Communication/Engagement Toolkit for CCS Projects. Canberra: CSIRO, http://cdn.globalccsinstitute.com/sites/default/files/publications/13571/publication-20110601-communication-engagement-toolkit.pdf (accessed 11 Feb. 2014).

11.

Department for Energy and Climate Change. 2014. Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS): Increasing the Use of Low-carbon Technologies. London: DECC, https://www.gov.uk/government/policies/increasing-the-use-of-low-carbon-technologies/supporting-pages/carbon-capture-and-storage-ccs (accessed 11 Feb. 2014).

12.

Doucet

and Mauthner

. 2008. ‘What can be known and how? Narrated subjects and the Listening Guide’. Qualitative Research 8(3): 399–409. CrossRef.

13.

Douglas

1992. Risk and Blame: Essays in Cultural Theory. London: Routledge. CrossRef.

14.

Ekins

and Lockwood

. 2011. Tackling Fuel Poverty During the Transition to a Low-carbon Economy. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, http://www.jrf.org.uk/publications/tackling-fuel-poverty-low-carbon-economy (accessed 11 Feb. 2014).

15.

Commission

European

. 2009. Work Programme 2010: Cooperation Theme 5: Energy. Brussels: EC, ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/fp7/docs/wp/cooperation/energy/e_wp_201001_en.pdf (accessed 5 Aug. 2013).

16.

Evar

2014. Epistemologies of Uncertainty: Governing CO₂ Capture and Storage Science and Technology. Ph.D. thesis, University of Edinburgh: Edinburgh. CrossRef.

17.

Fricker

2007. Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing. New York: OUP.

18.

Gardiner

2006. ‘A perfect moral storm: Climate change, intergenerational ethics and the problem of moral corruption’. Environmental Values 15(3): 397–414. CrossRef.

19.

Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute. 2014. What is CCS? Canberra: GCCSI. http://www.globalccsinstitute.com/understanding-ccs/what-is-ccs (accessed 11 Feb.2014).

20.

Gough

and Boucher

. 2013. ‘Ethical attitudes to underground CO₂ storage: Points of convergence and potential faultlines’. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 13: 156–167. CrossRef.

21.

de Groot

and Steg

. 2011. ‘Psychological perspectives on the geological disposal of radioactive waste and carbon dioxide’, in Toth

(ed.) Geological Disposal of Carbon Dioxide and Radioactive Waste: A Comparative Assessment. pp. 339–363, Paris: IAEA. CrossRef.

22.

Ha-Duong

and Loisel

. 2011. ‘Actuarial risk assessment of expected fatalities attributable to carbon capture and storage in 2050’. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 5: 1346–1358. CrossRef.

23.

Hale

and Grundy

. 2009. ‘Remediation and respect: Do remediation technologies alter our responsibility?’ Environmental Values 18: 397–415. CrossRef.

24.

Hammond

, Howard

and Jones

. 2013. ‘The energy and environmental implications of UK more electric transition pathways: A whole systems perspective’. Energy Policy 52: 103–116. CrossRef.

25.

International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme. 2014. What is CCS? IEAGHG: Cheltenham. http://www.ieaghg.org/ccs-resources/what-is-ccs (accessed 11 Feb.2014).

26.

Jamieson

2010. ‘Climate change, responsibility and justice’. Science and Engineering Ethics 16: 431–445. CrossRef.

27.

Littlecott

2012. ‘Stakeholder interests and the evolution of UK CCS policy’. Energy and Environment 23 (2–3): 425–436. CrossRef.

28.

Mabon

, Shackley

, Vercelli

, Anderlucci

and Boot

. 2015. ‘Deliberative decarbonisation? Assessing the potential of an ethical governance framework for low-carbon energy through the case of carbon dioxide capture and storage’. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 33(2): 256–271.

29.

Markusson

, Shackley

and Evar

. 2012. The Social Dynamics of Carbon Capture and Storage. London: Earthscan.

30.

McLaren

2012. ‘Procedural justice in carbon capture and storage: A review’. Energy and Environment 23(2–3): 345–365. CrossRef.

31.

Medvecky

, Lacey

and Ashworth

. 2013. ‘Examing the role of carbon capture and storage through an ethical lens’. Science and Engineering Ethics 20(4): 1111–1128. CrossRef.

32.

Preston

2011. ‘Re-thinking the unthinkable: Environmental ethics and the presumptive argument against geoengineering’. Environmental Values 20: 457–479. CrossRef.

33.

Rawls

1973. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

34.

Scott

, Gilfillan

, Markusson

, Chalmers

and Haszeldine

. 2013. ‘Last chance for carbon capture and storage’. Nature Climate Change 3: 105–111. CrossRef.

35.

Shackley

, Waterman

, Godfroij

, Reiner

, Anderson

, Draxlbauer

and Flach

. 2007. ‘Stakeholder perceptions of CO₂ capture and storage in Europe: Results from a survey’. Energy Policy 35(10): 5091–5108. CrossRef.

36.

Shell , 2014. Carbon Capture and Storage. Amsterdam: Shell, http://www.shell.com/global/environment-society/environment/climate-change/ccs.html (accessed 11 Feb. 2014).

37.

Shepherd

, Caldeira

, Cox

, Haigh

, Keith

, Launder

, Mace

, MacKerron

, Pyle

, Rayner

, Redgwell

and Watson

. 2009. Geoengineering the Climate: Science, Governance and Uncertainty. London: Royal Society.

38.

Shrader-Frechette

2002. Environmental Justice: Creating Equality, Reclaiming Democracy. New York: OUP. CrossRef.

39.

Stephens

, Hansson

, Liu

, de Coninck

and Vajjhala

. 2011. ‘Characterising the international CCS community’. Global Environmental Change 21(2) 379–390. CrossRef.

40.

Timilsina

, van Kooten

and Narbel

. 2013. ‘Global wind power development: economics and policies’. Energy Policy 61: 642–652. CrossRef.

41.

Weinberg

1967. ‘Can technology replace social engineering?’ in Thompson

W.B.

(ed.) Controlling Technology: Contemporary Issues, pp. 41–48. New York: Prometheus.

42.

Weston

2009. The Incompleat Eco-Philosopher: Essays from the Edge of Environmental Ethics. Albany: State University of New York Press.

43.

Wynne

2006. ‘Public engagement as a means of restoring public trust in science – Hitting the notes, but missing the music?’ Community Genetics 9(3): 211–220. CrossRef.