BACKGROUND: Due to the heterogeneity of the lesion following a traumatic brain injury (TBI) and the complexity of the driving task, driving assessment and rehabilitation in TBI individuals is challenging. Conventional driving assessment (on-road and in-clinic evaluations) has failed demonstrating effectiveness to assess fitness to drive in TBI individuals.
OBJECTIVE: We aimed to determine if driving simulators represent an interesting opportunity in assessing and rehabilitating driving skills in TBI individuals.
METHODS: We searched PubMed, CINAHL and Cochrane library databases between 27-02-2014 and 08-04-2014 for articles published since 2000 with the contents of simulator driving assessment and rehabilitation.
RESULTS: Out of 488, eight articles with the subject of simulator driving assessment and two with the subject of simulator driving rehabilitation in individuals with TBI were reviewed.
CONCLUSIONS: Driving simulators represent a promising avenue for the assessment and rehabilitation of driving skills in TBI individuals as it allows control of stimuli in a safe, challenging and ecologically valid environment and offer the opportunity to measure and record driving performance. Additional studies, however, are needed to document strengths and limitations of this method.
AkinwuntanA. E., De WeerdtW., FeysH., PauwelsJ., BatenG., ArnoP., & KiekensC. (2005). Effect of simulator training on driving after stroke: A randomized controlled trial. Neurology, 65(6), 843–850.
2.
AkinwuntanA. E., WachtelJ., & RosenP. N. (2012). Driving simulation for evaluation and rehabilitation of driving after stroke. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis, 21(6), 478–486.
3.
AmickM. M., KraftM., & McGlincheyR. (2013). Driving simulator performance of veterans from the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. J Rehabil Res Dev, 50(4), 463–470.
4.
BazarianJ. J., WongT., HarrisM., LeaheyN., MookerjeeS., & DombovyM. (1999). Epidemiology and predictors of post-concussive syndrome after minor head injury in an emergency population. Brain Inj, 13(3), 173–189.
5.
BedardM. B., ParkkariM., WeaverB., RiendeauJ., & DahlquistM. (2010). Assessment of driving performance using a simulator protocol: Validity and reproducibility. Am J Occup Ther, 64(2), 336–340.
6.
BergerJ. T., RosnerF., KarkP., & BennettA. J. (2000). Reporting by physicians of impaired drivers and potentially impaired drivers. The Committee on Bioethical Issues of the Medical Society of the State of New York. J Gen Intern Med, 15(9), 667–672.
7.
BivonaU., D’IppolitoM., GiustiniM., VignallyP., LongoE., TaggiF., & FormisanoR. (2012). Return to driving after severe traumatic brain injury: Increased risk of traffic accidents and personal responsibility. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 27(3), 210–215.
8.
BottariC., LamotheM. P., GosselinN., GelinasI., & PtitoA. (2012). Driving difficulties and adaptive strategies: The perception of individuals having sustained a mild traumatic brain injury. Rehabil Res Pract, 837301(10), 13.
9.
BrouwerW. H., WithaarF. K., TantM. L., & van ZomerenA. H. (2002). Attention and driving in traumatic brain injury: A question of coping with time-pressure. J Head TraumaRehabil, 17(1), 1–15.
10.
Canadian Council of Motor Transport Administrators (2013). Determining Driver Fitness in Canada: Part 1: Administration of Driver Fitness Programs and Part 2: CCMTA Medical Standards for DriversCCMTA Reports(Edition 13), 1–317.
11.
Canadian Institute for Health Information. (2006). Head injuries in Canada: A Decade of Change (1994-1995 to 2003-2004). Retrieved from www.cihi.ca.
12.
Canadian Institute for Health Information. (2007), The burden of Neurological Diseases, Disorders and Injuries in Canada.
13.
Canadian Medical Association. (2012). CMA Driver’s Guide: Determining medical fitness to operate motor vehicles8th ed. : Retrieved from www.cma.ca/driversguide.
14.
CantinV., LavalliereM., SimoneauM., & TeasdaleN. (2009). Mental workload when driving in a simulator: Effects of age and driving complexity. Accid Anal Prev, 41(4), 763–771.
15.
ChanE., PradhanA. K., PollatsekA., KnodlerM. A., & FisherD. L. (2010). Are driving simulators effective tools for evaluating novice drivers’ hazard anticipation, speed management, and attention maintenance skills. Transp Res Part F Traffic Psychol Behav, 13(5), 343–353. doi: 10.1016/j.trf.2010.04.001
16.
ChaumetG., Quera-SalvaM. A., MacleodA., HartleyS., TaillardJ., SagaspeP., … PhilipP. (2008). Is there a link between alertness and fatigue in patients with traumatic brain injury?Neurology, 71(20), 1609–1613.
17.
ClassenS., LevyC., McCarthyD., MannW. C., LanfordD., & Waid-EbbsJ. K. (2009). Traumatic brain injury and driving assessment: An evidence-based literature review. Am J Occup Ther, 63(5), 580–591.
18.
ClassenS., LevyC., MeyerD. L., BewernitzM., LanfordD. N., & MannW. C. (2011). Simulated driving performance of combat veterans with mild tramatic brain injury and posttraumatic stress disorder: A pilot study. Am J Occup Ther, 65(4), 419–427.
19.
ColemanR. D., RapportL. J., ErghT. C., HanksR. A., RickerJ. H., & MillisS. R. (2002). Predictors of driving outcome after traumatic brain injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 83(10), 1415–1422.
20.
CoxD. J., DavisM., SinghH., BarbourB., NidifferF. D., TrudelT., … MoncriefR. (2010). Driving rehabilitation for military personnel recovering from traumatic brain injury using virtual reality driving simulation: A feasibility study. Mil Med, 175(6), 411–416.
21.
CyrA. A., StinchcombeA., GagnonS., MarshallS., HingM. M., & FinestoneH. (2009). Driving difficulties of brain-injured drivers in reaction to high-crash-risk simulated road events: A question of impaired divided attention?J Clin Exp Neuropsychol, 31(4), 472–482.
22.
de WinterJ. C., de GrootS., MulderM., WieringaP. A., DankelmanJ., & MulderJ. A. (2009). Relationships between driving simulator performance and driving test results. Ergonomics, 52(2), 137–153.
23.
Di StefanoM., & MacdonaldW. (2003). Assessment of older drivers: Relationships among on-road errors, medical conditions and test outcome. J Safety Res, 34(4), 415–429.
24.
FiskG. D., SchneiderJ. J., & NovackT. A. (1998). Driving following traumatic brain injury: Prevalence, exposure, advice and evaluations. Brain Inj, 12(8), 683–695.
25.
FormisanoR., BivonaU., BrunelliS., GiustiniM., LongoE., & TaggiF. (2005). A preliminary investigation of road traffic accident rate after severe brain injury. Brain Inj, 19(3), 159–163.
26.
GalskiT., BrunoR. L., & EhleH. T. (1992). Driving after cerebral damage: A model with implications for evaluation. Am J Occup Ther, 46(4), 324–332.
27.
GamacheP. L., LavalliereM., TremblayM., SimoneauM., & TeasdaleN. (2011). In-simulator training of driving abilities in a person with a traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 25(4), 416–425.
HartvigsenJ., BoyleE., CassidyJ. D., & CarrollL. J. (2014). Mild traumatic brain injury after motor vehicle collisions: What are the symptoms and who treats them? A population-based 1-year inception cohort study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 95(3 Suppl), 029.
30.
HawleyC. A. (2001). Return to driving after head injury. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 70(6), 761–766.
31.
HoffmanL., & McDowdJ. M. (2010). Simulator driving performance predicts accident reports five years later. Psychol Aging, 25(3), 741–745.
32.
HuchlerS. J. A., GolzD., KüstJ., NetzJ., HömbergV., & KarbeH. (2002). Evaluation of driving simulation. Europa Medicophysica, 37(4), 283–289.
33.
Korner-BitenskyN., BitenskyJ., SoferS., Man-Son-HingM., & GelinasI. (2006). Driving evaluation practices of clinicians working in the United States and Canada. Am J Occup Ther, 60(4), 428–434.
34.
KotterbaS., OrthM., ErenE., FangerauT., & SindernE. (2003). Assessment of driving performance in patients with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis by a driving simulator. Eur Neurol, 50(3), 160–164.
35.
LaneA. K., & BenoitD. (2011). Driving, brain injury and assistive technology. NeuroRehabilitation, 28(3), 221–229.
36.
LavalliereM., LaurendeauD., SimoneauM., & TeasdaleN. (2011). Changing lanes in a simulator: Effects of aging on the control of the vehicle and visual inspection of mirrors and blind spot. Traffic Inj Prev, 12(2), 191–200.
37.
LeeH. C., CameronD., & LeeA. H. (2003). Assessing the driving performance of older adult drivers: On-road versus simulated driving. Accid Anal Prev, 35(5), 797–803.
38.
LengenfelderJ., SchultheisM. T., Al-ShihabiT., MourantR., & DeLucaJ. (2002). Divided attention and driving: A pilot study using virtual reality technology. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 17(1), 26–37.
39.
Leon-CarrionJ., Dominguez-MoralesM. R., & MartinJ. M. (2005). Driving with cognitive deficits: Neurorehabilitation and legal measures are needed for driving again after severe traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 19(3), 213–219.
40.
LewH. L., PooleJ. H., LeeE. H., JaffeD. L., HuangH. C., & BroddE. (2005). Predictive validity of driving-simulator assessments following traumatic brain injury: A preliminary study. Brain Inj, 19(3), 177–188.
41.
LewH. L., RosenP. N., ThomanderD., & PooleJ. H. (2009). The potential utility of driving simulators in the cognitive rehabilitation of combat-returnees with traumatic brain injury. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 24(1), 51–56.
42.
LundqvistA., & AlinderJ. (2007). Driving after brain injury: Self-awareness and coping at the tactical level of control. Brain Inj, 21(11), 1109–1117.
43.
LundqvistA., AlinderJ., Modig-ArdingI., & SamuelssonK. (2011). Driving after brain injury: A clinical model based on a quality improvement project. SciRes, 2(6), 615–623. doi: 10.4236/psych.2011.26094
44.
LustigC., ShahP., SeidlerR., & Reuter-LorenzP. A. (2009). Aging, training, and the brain: A review and future directions. Neuropsychol Rev, 19(4), 504–522. doi: 10.1007/s11065-009-9119-9
45.
MarcotteT. D., RosenthalT. J., RobertsE., LampinenS., ScottJ. C., AllenR. W., & Corey-BloomJ. (2008). The contribution of cognition and spasticity to driving performance in multiple sclerosis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 89(9), 1753–1758.
46.
MarinoM., de BelvisA., BassoD., AvolioM., PeloneF., TanzarielloM., & RicciardiW. (2013). Interventions to evaluate fitness to drive among people with chronic conditions: Systematic review of literature. Accid Anal Prev, 50, 377–396.
47.
MarshallS., Man-Son-HingM., MolnarF., HuntL., & FinestoneH. (2005). An exploratory study on the predictive elements of passing on-the-road tests for disabled persons. Traffic Inj Prev, 6(3), 235–239.
48.
MayhewD. R., SimpsonH. M., WoodK. M., LoneroL., ClintonK. M., & JohnsonA. G. (2011). On-road and simulated driving: Concurrent and discriminant validation. J Safety Res, 42(4), 267–275.
49.
Milleville-PennelI., PothierJ., HocJ. M., & MatheJ. F. (2010). Consequences of cognitive impairments following traumatic brain injury: Pilot study on visual exploration while driving. Brain Inj, 24(4), 678–691.
50.
NalderE., FlemingJ., CornwellP., FosterM., OwnsworthT., ShieldsC., & HainesT. (2012). Recording sentinel events in the life course of individuals with acquired brain injury: A preliminary study. Brain Inj, 26(11), 1381–1396.
51.
NeyensD. M., & BoyleL. N. (2012). Crash risk factors related to individuals sustaining and drivers following traumatic brain injuries. Accid Anal Prev, 49, 266–273.
52.
NovackT. A., BanosJ. H., AldersonA. L., SchneiderJ. J., WeedW., BlankenshipJ., & SalisburyD. (2006). UFOV performance and driving ability following traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 20(5), 455–461.
53.
NovackT. A., LabbeD., GroteM., CarlsonN., ShererM., Arango-LasprillaJ. C., … SeelR. T. (2010). Return to driving within 5 years of moderate-severe traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 24(3), 464–471.
54.
OrtolevaC., BruggerC., Van der LindenM., & WalderB. (2012). Prediction of driving capacity after traumatic brain injury: A systematic review. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 27(4), 302–313.
55.
Ponsford DowningM. G., OlverJ., PonsfordM., AcherR., CartyM., & SpitzG. (2014). Longitudinal follow-up of patients with traumatic brain injury: Outcome at two, five, and ten years post-injury. J Neurotrauma, 31(1), 64–77.
56.
PreeceM. H., GeffenG. M., & HorswillM. S. (2013). Return-to-driving expectations following mild traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj, 27(1), 83–91.
57.
PreeceM. H., HorswillM. S., & GeffenG. M. (2010). Driving after concussion: The acute effect of mild traumatic brain injury on drivers’ hazard perception. Neuropsychology, 24(4), 493–503.
58.
RapportL. J., BryerR. C., & HanksR. A. (2008). Driving and community integration after traumatic brain injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 89(5), 922–930.
59.
ReimerB., D’AmbrosioL. A., CoughlinJ. E., KafrissenM. E., & BiedermanJ. (2006). Using self-reported data to assess the validity of driving simulation data. Behav Res Methods, 38(2), 314–324.
60.
SchankeA. K., RikeP. O., MolmenA., & OstenP. E. (2008). Driving behaviour after brain injury: A follow-up of accident rate and driving patterns 6-9 years post-injury. J Rehabil Med, 40(9), 733–736.
61.
SchultheisM. T., MatheisR. J., NeadR., & DeLucaJ. (2002). Driving behaviors following brain injury: Self-report and motor vehicle records. J Head Trauma Rehabil, 17(1), 38–47.
62.
SchultheisM. T., & RizzoA. A. (2001). The application of virtual reality technology in rehabilitation. Rehabilitation Psychology, 46(3), 296–311.
63.
SchultheisM. T., SimoneL. K., RosemanE., NeadR., RebimbasJ., & MourantR. (2006). Stopping behavior in a VR driving simulator: A new clinical measure for the assessment of driving. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 1, 4921–4924.
ShechtmanO., ClassenS., AwadziK., & MannW. (2009). Comparison of driving errors between on-the-road and simulated driving assessment: A validation study. Traffic Inj Prev, 10(4), 379–385.
66.
TamiettoM., TorriniG., AdenzatoM., PietrapianaP., RagoR., & PerinoC. (2006). To drive or not to drive (after TBI)? A review of the literature and its implications for rehabilitation and future research. NeuroRehabilitation, 21(1), 81–92.
67.
van ZomerenA. H., BrouwerW. H., & MinderhoudJ. M. (1987). Acquired brain damage and driving: A review. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 68(10), 697–705.
68.
VanderploegR. D., CurtissG., LuisC. A., & SalazarA. M. (2007). Long-term morbidities following self-reported mild traumatic brain injury. J Clin Exp Neuropsychol, 29(6), 585–598.
69.
VrkljanB. H., McGrathC. E., & LettsL. J. (2011). Assessment tools for evaluating fitness to drive: A critical appraisal of evidence. Can J Occup Ther, 78(2), 80–96.
70.
WangY., MehlerB., ReimerB., LammersV., D’AmbrosioL. A., & CoughlinJ. F. (2010). The validity of driving simulation for assessing differences between in-vehicle informational interfaces: A comparison with field testing. Ergonomics, 53(3), 404–420. doi: 10.1080/00140130903464358
71.
WillerB., & LeddyJ. J. (2006). Management of concussion and post-concussion syndrome. Curr Treat Options Neurol, 8(5), 415–426.
72.
World Health Organisation (2006). Neurological disorders: Public health challenges. WHO library140.
73.
YuenH. K., BrooksJ. O., AzueroA., & BurikJ. K. (2012). Certified driver rehabilitation specialists’ preferred situations for driving simulator scenarios. Am J Occup Ther, 66(1), 110–114.
