The number of patients with disorders of consciousness (DoC) has increased dramatically with the advancement of intensive care and emergency medicine, which brings tremendous economic burdens and even ethical issues to families and society.
OBJECTIVE:
To evaluate the effectiveness of neuromodulation therapy for patients with DoC.
METHODS:
First, we conducted a literature review of individual patient data (IPD) on PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane-controlled trials following PRISMA guidelines. Then, we collected neuromodulation cases from our institution. Finally, we conducted a pooled analysis using the participants from the medical literature (n = 522) and our local institutions (n = 22).
RESULTS:
In this pooled analysis of 544 patients with DoC with a mean age of 46.33 years, our results revealed that patients have improved CRS-R scores [1.0 points (95% CI, 0.57–1.42)] after neuromodulation. Among them, patients have better effectiveness in traumatic than non-traumatic etiology (P < 0.05). The effectiveness of consciousness improvement could be affected by the age, baseline consciousness state, and duration of stimulation. Compared with non-invasive intervention, an invasive intervention can bring more behavioral improvement (P < 0.0001) to MCS rather than UWS/VS patients. Importantly, neuromodulation is a valuable therapy even years after the onset of DoC.
CONCLUSION:
This pooled analysis spotlights that the application of neuromodulation can improve the behavioral performance of patients with DoC. A preliminary trend is that age, etiology, baseline consciousness state, and stimulation duration could impact its effectiveness.
Annen,J, Filippini,M. M, Bonin,E, Cassol,H, Aubinet,C, Carriere,M, Gosseries,O, Thibaut,A, Barra,A, Wolff,A, Sanz,L. R. D, Martial,C, Laureys,S, Chatelle,C. (2019). Diagnostic accuracy of the CRS-R index in patients with disorders of consciousness. Brain Inj33(11), 1409–1412. https://doi.org/10.1080/02699052.2019.1644376
Edlow,B. L. (2021). Dopaminergic modulation of human consciousness via default mode network connectivity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 118(31). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2111268118
6.
Edlow,B. L, Barra,M. E, Zhou,D. W, Foulkes,A. S, Snider,S. B, Threlkeld,Z. D, Chakravarty,S, Kirsch,J. E, Chan,S. T, Meisler,S. L, Bleck,T. P, Fins,J. J, Giacino,J. T, Hochberg,L. R, Solt,K, Brown,E. N, Bodien,Y. G. (2020). Personalized connectome mapping to guide targeted therapy and promote recovery of consciousness in the intensive care unit. Neurocrit Care33(2), 364–375. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12028-020-01062-7
7.
Edlow,B. L, Sanz,L. R. D, Polizzotto,L, Pouratian,N, Rolston,J. D, Snider,S. B, Thibaut,A, Stevens,R. D, Gosseries,O, Curing Coma,C, its contributing, m. (2021). Therapies to restore consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries: A gap analysis and future directions. Neurocrit Care35(Suppl 1), 68–85. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12028-021-01227-y
8.
Estraneo,A, Fiorenza,S, Magliacano,A, Formisano,R, Mattia,D, Grippo,A, Romoli,A. M, Angelakis,E, Cassol,H, Thibaut,A, Gosseries,O, Lamberti,G, Noe,E, Bagnato,S, Edlow,B. L, Chatelle,C, Lejeune,N, Veeramuthu,V, Bartolo,M, DoC-SIG, I. (2020). Multicenter prospective study on predictors of short-term outcome in disorders of consciousness. Neurology95(11), e1488–e1499. https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.0000000000010254
9.
Estraneo,A, Masotta,O, Bartolo,M, Pistoia,F, Perin,C, Marino,S, Lucca,L, Pingue,V, Casanova,E, Romoli,A, Gentile,S, Formisano,R, Salvi,G. P, Scarponi,F, De Tanti,A, Bongioanni,P, Rossato,E, Santangelo,A, Diana,A. R, De Bellis, F. (2021). Multi-center study on overall clinical complexity of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness of different etiologies. Brain Inj35(1), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1080/02699052.2020.1861652
10.
Estraneo,A, Moretta,P, Loreto,V, Lanzillo,B, Santoro,L, Trojano,L. (2010). Late recovery after traumatic, anoxic, or hemorrhagic long-lasting vegetative state. Neurology75(3), 239–245. https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.0b013e3181e8e8cc
11.
Giacino,J. T, Fins,J. J, Laureys,S, Schiff,N. D. (2014). Disorders of consciousness after acquired brain injury: The state of the science. Nat Rev Neurol10(2), 99–114. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrneurol.2013.279
12.
Giacino,J. T, Kalmar,K, Whyte,J. (2004). The JFK coma recovery scale-revised: Measurement characteristics and diagnostic utility. Arch Phys Med Rehabil85(12), 2020–2029. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2004.02.033
13.
Giacino,J. T, Katz,D. I, Schiff,N. D, Whyte,J, Ashman,E. J, Ashwal,S, Barbano,R, Hammond,F. M, Laureys,S, Ling,G. S. F, Nakase-Richardson,R, Seel,R. T, Yablon,S, Getchius,T. S. D, Gronseth,G. S, Armstrong,M. J. (2018). Practice guideline update recommendations summary: Disorders of consciousness: Report of the Guideline Development, Dissemination, and Implementation Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology; the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine; and the National Institute on Disability, Independent Living, and Rehabilitation Research. Neurology91(10), 450–460. https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.0000000000005926
14.
Giacino,J. T, Kezmarsky,M. A, DeLuca,J, Cicerone,K. D. (1991). Monitoring rate of recovery to predict outcome in minimally responsive patients. Arch Phys Med Rehabil72(11), 897–901. https://doi.org/10.1016/0003-9993(91)90008-7
15.
Harbinson,M, Zarshenas,S, Cullen,N. K. (2017). Long-term functional and psychosocial outcomes after hypoxic-ischemic brain injury: A case-controlled comparison to traumatic brain injury. PM R9(12), 1200–1207. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmrj.2017.04.015
16.
Hirschberg,R, Giacino,J. T. (2011). The vegetative and minimally conscious states: Diagnosis, prognosis and treatment. Neurol Clin29(4), 773–786. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ncl.2011.07.009.
17.
Kondziella,D, Bender,A, Diserens,K, van Erp,W, Estraneo,A, Formisano,R, Laureys,S, Naccache,L, Ozturk,S, Rohaut,B, Sitt,J. D, Stender,J, Tiainen,M, Rossetti,A. O, Gosseries,O, Chatelle,C, Ean Panel on Coma, D. o. C. (2020). European Academy of Neurology guideline on the diagnosis of coma and other disorders of consciousness. Eur J Neurol27(5), 741–756. https://doi.org/10.1111/ene.14151
18.
La Porta,F, Caselli,S, Ianes,A. B, Cameli,O, Lino,M, Piperno,R, Sighinolfi,A, Lombardi,F, Tennant,A. (2013). Can we scientifically and reliably measure the level of consciousness in vegetative and minimally conscious States? Rasch analysis of the coma recovery scale-revised. Arch Phys Med Rehabil94(3), 527–535e521. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2012.09.035
19.
Longo,V, Barbati,S. A, Re,A, Paciello,F, Bolla,M, Rinaudo,M, Miraglia,F, Alu,F, Di Donna,M. G, Vecchio,F, Rossini,P. M, Podda,M. V, Grassi,C. (2022). Transcranial direct current stimulation enhances neuroplasticity and accelerates motor recovery in a stroke mouse model. Stroke53(5), 1746–1758. https://doi.org/10.1161/STROKEAHA.121.034200
Pallanti,S, Marras,A, Dickson,S. L, Adan,R. A, Vieta,E, Dell Osso,B, Arango,C, Fusar-Poli,P, Soriano-Mas,C, Carmi,L, Meyer Lindenberg,A, Zohar,J. (2021). Manifesto for an ECNP Neuromodulation Thematic Working Group (TWG): Non-invasive brain stimulation as a new Super-subspecialty. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol52, 72–83. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euroneuro.2021.07.002
22.
Qin,P, Wu,X, Duncan,N. W, Bao,W, Tang,W, Zhang,Z, Hu,J, Jin,Y, Wu,X, Gao,L, Lu,L, Guan,Y, Lane,T, Huang,Z, Bodien,Y. G, Giacino,J. T, Mao,Y, Northoff,G. (2015). GABAA receptor deficits predict recovery in patients with disorders of consciousness: A preliminary multimodal [(11) C]Flumazenil PET and fMRI study. Hum Brain Mapp36(10), 3867–3877. https://doi.org/10.1002/hbm.22883
23.
Qin,P, Wu,X, Huang,Z, Duncan,N. W, Tang,W, Wolff,A, Hu,J, Gao,L, Jin,Y, Wu,X, Zhang,J, Lu,L, Wu,C, Qu,X, Mao,Y, Weng,X, Zhang,J, Northoff,G. (2015). How are different neural networks related to consciousness? Ann Neurol78(4), 594–605. https://doi.org/10.1002/ana.24479
24.
Sel,A, Verhagen,L, Angerer,K, David,R, Klein-Flugge,M. C, Rushworth,M. F. S. (2021). Increasing and decreasing interregional brain coupling increases and decreases oscillatory activity in the human brain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 118(37). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2100652118
25.
Shou,Z, Li,Z, Wang,X, Chen,M, Bai,Y, Di,H. (2021). Non-invasive brain intervention techniques used in patients with disorders of consciousness. Int J Neurosci131(4), 390–404. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207454.2020.1744598
26.
Spindler,L. R. B, Luppi,A. I, Adapa,R. M, Craig,M. M, Coppola,P, Peattie,A. R. D, Manktelow,A. E, Finoia,P, Sahakian,B. J, Williams,G. B, Allanson,J, Pickard,J. D, Menon,D. K, Stamatakis,E. A. (2021). Dopaminergic brainstem disconnection is common to pharmacological and pathological consciousness perturbation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 118(30). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2026289118
27.
Steadman,P. E, Xia,F, Ahmed,M, Mocle,A. J, Penning,A. R. A, Geraghty,A. C, Steenland,H. W, Monje,M, Josselyn,S. A, Frankland,P. W. (2020). Disruption of oligodendrogenesis impairs memory consolidation in adult mice. Neuron, 105(1), 150–164e156. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2019.10.013
28.
Stewart,L. A, Clarke,M, Rovers,M, Riley,R. D, Simmonds,M, Stewart,G, Tierney,J. F, Group,P. -I. D. (2015). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviewand meta-analyses of individual participant data: The PRISMA-IPD state-ment. JAMA, 313(16), 1657–1665. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2015.3656
Thibaut,A, Bruno,M. A, Ledoux,D, Demertzi,A, Laureys,S. (2014). tDCS in patients with disorders of consciousness: Sham-controlled randomized double-blind study. Neurology82(13), 1112–1118. https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.0000000000000260
31.
Thibaut,A, Schiff,N, Giacino,J, Laureys,S, Gosseries,O. (2019). Therapeutic interventions in patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness. Lancet Neurol18(6), 600–614. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1474-4422(19)30031-6
32.
van der Eerden,A. W, Khalilzadeh,O, Perlbarg,V, Dinkel,J, Sanchez,P, Vos,P. E, Luyt,C. E, Stevens,R. D, Menjot de Champfleur,N, Delmaire,C, Tollard,E, Gupta,R, Dormont,D, Laureys,S, Benali,H, Vanhaudenhuyse,A, Galanaud,D, Puybasset,L, Consortium,N. (2014). White matter changes in comatose survivors of anoxic ischemic encephalopathy and traumatic brain injury: Comparative diffusion-tensor imaging study. Radiology270(2), 506–516. https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.13122720
33.
Wannez,S, Heine,L, Thonnard,M, Gosseries,O, Laureys,S, Coma Science Group, C. (2017). The repetition of behavioral assessments in diagnosis of disorders of consciousness. Ann Neurol81(6), 883–889. https://doi.org/10.1002/ana.24962
34.
Weng,L, Xie,Q, Zhao,L, Zhang,R, Ma,Q, Wang,J, Jiang,W, He,Y, Chen,Y, Li,C, Ni,X, Xu,Q, Yu,R, Huang,R. (2017). Abnormal structural connectivity between the basal ganglia, thalamus, and frontal cortex in patients with disorders of consciousness. Cortex90, 71–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cortex.2017.02.011
35.
Wu,X, Zhang,J, Cui,Z, Tang,W, Shao,C, Hu,J, Zhu,J, Zhao,Y, Lu,L, Chen,G, Northoff,G, Gong,G, Mao,Y, He,Y. (2018). White matter deficits underlying the impaired consciousness level in patients with disorders of consciousness. Neurosci Bull34(4), 668–678. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12264-018-0253-3
36.
Xu,C, Zheng,R, Zhou,L, Feng,D. (2023). Alteration in ventral tegmental area and default mode network interplay and prediction of coma recovery in patients with sTBI. Heliyon9(4), e15279. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e15279.
37.
Yamamoto,T, Katayama,Y, Obuchi,T, Kobayashi,K, Oshima,H, Fukaya,C. (2013). Deep brain stimulation and spinal cord stimulation for vegetative state and minimally conscious state. World Neurosurg, 80(3-4), S30e31–39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2012.04.010
38.
Zhang,Y, Song,W. (2018). Transcranial direct current stimulation in disorders of consciousness: A review. Int J Neurosci128(3), 255–261. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207454.2017.1381094
39.
Zheng,R. Z, Qi,Z. X, Wang,Z, Xu,Z. Y, Wu,X. H, Mao,Y. (2022). Clinical decision on disorders of consciousness after acquired brain injury: Stepping forward. Neurosci Bull. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12264-022-00909-7
40.
Zheng,R. Z, Xu,C. X, Zhou,L. Y, Feng,D. F. (2023). Default mode network overshadow executive control network in coma emergence and awakening prediction of patients with sTBI. Neuroimage Clin37, 103361. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nicl.2023.103361
