It is widely assumed that there is a high level of medical pluralism in
contemporary society. For example, both orthodox and non-orthodox medicines are
simultaneously available to the public. What forms the boundaries that demarcate
orthodox medicines from non- orthodox ones? These issues arise when examining
medical pluralism from a critical realist viewpoint. The aim of the paper is to
argue that: firstly, orthodox and non-orthodox medicines reflect political
economic aspects of the social context in which they are located. They do not
exist in a social vacuum ensuring their ontological distinctiveness. Secondly,
there are more similarities between orthodox and non- orthodox medicines than
distinctly different features. In contemporary capitalist societies the key
structuring/generative mechanism affecting the form and content of medical
systems derives from the commodification of health care. This pervades both
orthodox medicine and its various alternatives. Thus the reality of medical
pluralism is illusory.
ADAMSV.
(1988) ‘Modes of production and medicine: an
examination of the theory in light of sherpa medical
traditionalism’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 27, No.
5, pp.
505–513.
2.
ALUBOS.O.
(1990) ‘Doctoring as business: a study of
entrepreneurial medicine in Nigeria’,Medical Anthropology, vol. 12, pp.
305–324. ANDERSON, R., LEWIS, S. Z.,
GIACHELLO, A. L., ADAY, L. and CHIU, G. (1981) ‘Access to medical care among the
Hispanic population of the Southern United States’, Journal of Health and Social
Behavior, Vol. 22, pp. 78-79.
3.
AUMEERUDDYA.,
LAUTIERB.,
and TORTAJADAR. G.
(1978) ‘Labour power and the
state’,Capital and Class, vol. 6, pp.
42–65.
4.
AZEVEDOJ.
(1998) Mapping Reality: An Evolutionary Realist
Methodology for Natural and Social Sciences.New York: State University of New
York Press.
5.
BAERH.A.
(1992) ‘The potential rejuvenation of American
naturopathy as a consequence of the holistic movement’,Medical Anthropology, vol. 13, pp.
369–383.
6.
BAERH. A.,
HAYSJ.,
McCLENDONN.,
McGOLDRICKN.,
and VESPUCCIR.
(1998) ‘The holistic health movement in the San
Francisco bay area: some preliminary observations’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 47, No.
10, pp.
1495–1501.
7.
BEN-DAVIDJ.
(1968) Fundamental Research and the
Universities.Paris: Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development.
8.
BENTONT.
(1977) Philosophical Foundations of the Three
Sociologies.London: Routledge and Kegan
Paul.
9.
BERLINERH.S.
(1982) ‘Medical modes of
production,’ in
WrightP.,
TreacherA.
(editors), The Problem of Medical Knowledge.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press, pp.
162–173.
10.
BERLINERH.
S., and SALMONJ.
W. (1979) ‘The holistic
health movement and scientific medicine: the naked and the
dead’,Socialist Review, vol. 9, No.
1, pp. 31–52.
11.
BERLINERH.
S., and SALMONJ.
W. (1980) ‘The holistic
alternative to scientific medicine: history and analysis’,International Journal of Health Services, vol.
10, No. 1, pp.
133–147.
12.
BHASKARR.
(1978) A Realist Theory of Science
(Second Edition).
Brighton: Harvester
Wheatsheaf.
13.
BHASKARR.
(1983) ‘Beef, structure and place: notes from a
critical naturalist perspective’,Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, vol.
13, No. 1, pp.
81–95.
14.
BHASKARR.
(1989) Reclaiming Reality: A Critical Introduction to
Contemporary Philosophy.London:
Verso.
15.
BHOPALR.S.
(1986) ‘The inter-relationship of folk,
traditional and western medicine within an Asian community in
Britain’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 22, pp.
99–105.
16.
BLANED.,
BARTLEYM.,
and DAVEY SMITHG.
(1997) ‘Diease aetiology and materialist
explanations of socio-economic mortality differentials’,European Journal of Public Health, vol. 7, pp.
385–391.
17.
BRAINARDJ.,
and ZAHARLICKA.
(1989) ‘Changing health beliefs and behaviors of
resettled Laotian refugees: ethnic variation in adaptation’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 29, No.
7, pp.
845–852.
18.
BRASSP.
(1972) ‘The politics of ayurvedic education: a
case study of revivalism and modernization in India,’ in
RudolphS. H.,
RudolphL. I.
(editors), Education and Politics in India.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
Press, pp.
342–371.
19.
BRITISH MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION., (1993) Complementary Medicine:
New Approaches to Good Practice.Oxford: Oxford University
Press/BMA.
20.
CANTS., and
SHARMAU.
(1999) A New Medical Pluralism? Alternative Medicine,
Doctors, Patients and the State.London: University College of
London Press.
21.
CHOH.J.
(2000) ‘Traditional medicine, professional
monopoly and structural interests: a Korean case’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 50, No.
1, pp.
123–135.
22.
CHOWKAP.
(1995) ‘Naturopathic medicine and the new political
realities’, Paper presented at the Tenth Annual Convention
of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP), Snowmass
Village, Colorado, 13 October. <http://www.healthy.net/library/articles/naturopathic/art.natru2.pc.htm>
23.
CLEMENTW.,
and MYLESJ.
(1997) Relations of Ruling: Class and Gender in
Postindustrial Societies.Montreal: McGill-Queen's
University Press.
24.
COCKERHAMW.C.
(1986) Medical Sociology (3rd
edition). Englewood Cliffs, New
Jersey:
Prentice-Hall.
25.
COLLIERA.
(1994) Critical Realism: An Introduction to Roy
Bhaskar's Philosophy.London:
Verso.
26.
COMAROFFJ.
(1981) ‘Healing and cultural transformation: the
Tswana of Southern Africa’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 15B, pp.
367–378.
27.
COMAROFFJ.
(1982) ‘Medicine: symbol and
ideology,’ in
WrightP.,
TreacherA.
(editors), The Problem of Medical Knowledge.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press, pp.
49–68.
28.
COWARDR.
(1989) The Whole Truth: The Myth of Alternative
Health.London: Faber and
Faber.
29.
CRAWFORDR.
(1977) ‘You are dangerous to your health: the
ideology and politics of victim blaming’,International Journal of Health Services, vol.
7, No. 4, pp.
663–680.
30.
DAVEY
SMITHG.,
BARTLEYM.,
and BLANED.
(1990) ‘The Black Report on socio-economic
inequaities ten years on’,British Medical Journal, No. 301, pp.
373–377.
31.
DAYKINN.
(1996) ‘Women, health, and
healing’,Women's Studies International Forum, vol. 19,
No. 3, pp.
339–341.
32.
DURKIN-LONGLEYM.
(1984) ‘Multiple therapeutic use in urban
Nepal’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 19, No.
8, pp.
867–872.
33.
ELLICOTTJ.
(1994) ‘Naturopathy “unworthy” of degree
status’,Campus Review. (September 15-21), pp.
2.
34.
ELLINGR.H.
(1981) ‘The capitalist world system and
international health’,International Journal of Health Services, vol.
11, pp.
21–51.
35.
FABREGAH.Jr.,
and MANNINGP. K.
(1979) ‘Illness episodes, illness severity and
treatment options in a pluralistic setting’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 13B, pp.
41–51.
36.
FOSTERP.
(1995) Women and the Health Care Industry: An Unhealthy
Relationship.Buckingham: Open University
Press.
37.
FOXR.C.
(1976) ‘The sociology of modern medical
research,’ pp. 102–114 in
LeslieC.
(editor), Asian Medical Systems: A Comparative Study.Berkeley: University of
California Press.
38.
FRANKENBERGR.
(1980) ‘Medical anthropology and development: a
theoretical perspective’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 14B, pp.
197–207.
39.
FRANKENBERGR.
(1981) ‘Allopathic medicine, profession, and
capitalist ideology in India’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 15B, pp.
115–125.
40.
FRANKENBERGR.,
and LEESONJ.
(1976) ‘Disease, illness and sickness: social
aspects of the choice of healer in a Lusaka suburb’, in
LoudonJ. B.
(editor). Social Anthropology and Medicine.London: Academic
Press, pp.
223–258.
41.
GIDDENSA.
(1984) The Constitution of Society: Outline of the
Theory of Structuration.Cambridge:
Polity.
42.
GOLDSTEINM.S.
(1992) The Health Movement: Promoting Fitness in
America.New York: Twayne
Publishers.
43.
GOLDSTEINM.S.
(1999) Alternative Health Care: Medicine, Miracle or
Mirage?Philadelphia: Temple University
Press.
44.
GRAYR.E.
(1998) ‘Four perspectives on unconventional
therapies’,Health, vol. 2, No. 1, pp.
55–74.
45.
HANG.-S.
(1997) ‘The rise of Western medicine and revival
of traditional medicine in Korea: a brief history’,Korean Studies, vol. 21, No. 4,
pp. 96–121.
46.
HANG.-S.
(2000) Health and Medicine under Capitalism: Korean
Immigrants in Australia.London & Madison, N.J.:
Associated University Presses & Fairleigh Dickinson
University Press.
47.
HANG.-S.
(2001) ‘The provision of hanbang herbal medicine
in the Korean community in Australia: entrepreneurial or caring for fellow
Koreans?’Australian Health Review, vol. 24, No.
4, pp.
146–155.
48.
HEGGENHOUGENH.K.
(1979) ‘Why does traditional medicine
persist?’Bulletin of the Public Health Society, vol.
13, pp. 60–64.
49.
HUISMANM.
(1989) Chiropractic Practice in Britain.
Unpublished MSc thesis. Anglo European College of
Chiropractic.
50.
JANZENJ.M.
(1978) ‘The comparative study of medical systems
as changing social systems’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 12, pp.
121–129.
51.
JOHANNESSENH.
(1996) ‘Individualised knowledge:
reflexologists, biopaths and kinesiologists in Denmark’, in
CantS.,
SharmaU.
(editors). Complementary and Alternative Medicines: Knowledge in
Practice.London: Free Association
Books, pp.
114–132.
52.
KEATR., and
URRYJ.
(1975) Social Theory as Science.London: Routledge and Kegan
Paul.
53.
LAURELLA.C.
(1979) ‘Work and health in
Mexico’,International Journal of Health Services, Vol.
9, No. 4, pp.
543–563.
54.
LESLIECharles
(1973) ‘The professionalizing ideology of
medical revivalism,’ in
SingerM.
(editor), Entrepreneurship and Modernization of Occupational Cultures in
South Asia.Durham, NC: Duke University
Press, pp.
216–242.
55.
LESLIEC.
(1976a) ‘The ambiguities of medical revivalism
in India,’ in
LeslieC.
(editor), Asian Medical Systems: A Comparative Study.Berkeley: University of
California Press, pp.
356–367.
56.
LESLIEC.
(1976b) ‘Introduction,’ in
LeslieC.
(editor), Asian Medical Systems: A Comparative Study.Berkeley: University of
California Press, pp.
1–12.
57.
LESLIEC.
(1980) ‘Medical pluralism in world
perspectives’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 14B, pp.
191–195.
58.
LOVELLT.
(1980) Pictures of Reality: Aesthetics, Politics,
Pleasure.London: British Film
Institute.
MILLERJ.K.
(1988) Health Beliefs and Health Utilization Patterns
among Korean Immigrants in Southern California. Unpublished PhD
dissertation, University of Southern
California.
61.
MILLERJ.K.
(1990) ‘Use of traditional Korean health care by
Korean immigrants to the United States’,Sociology and Social Research, vol. 75, pp.
38–48.
62.
MYNTTIC.
(1988) ‘Hegemony and healing in rural North
Yemen’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 27, No.
5, pp.
515–520.
63.
NAVARROV.
(1982a) ‘The labor process and health: an
historical materialist interpretation’,International Journal of Health Services, vol.
12, No. 1, pp.
5–29.
64.
NAVARROV.
(1982b) ‘The limits of the world systems theory
in defining capitalist and social formations’,Science and Society, Spring, pp.
77–90.
65.
NAVARROV.
(1983) ‘Radicalism, Marxism, and
medicine’,International Journal of Health Services, vol.
13, No. 2, pp.
179–202.
66.
PORTERS.
(1993) ‘Critical realist ethnography: the case
of racism and professionalism in a medical setting’,Sociology, vol. 27, No. 4, pp.
591–609.
67.
PORTERS.
(1996) ‘Real bodies, real needs: a critique of
the application of Foucault's philosophy of nursing’,Social Science in Health, vol. 2, No.
4, pp.
218–227.
68.
RAHAMANM.
M., AZIZK. M.
S., MUNSHIM.
H.,
PATWARIY.,
and RAHMANM.
(1982) ‘A diarrhoea clinic in rural Bangladesh:
influence of distance, age and sex on attendance and diarrhoeal
mortality’,American Journal of Public Health, vol. 72,
No. 10, pp.
1124–1128.
69.
REEDERL.G.
(1972) ‘The patient-client as a consumer: some
observations on the changing professional client
relationship’,Journal of Health and Social Behavior, vol.
13, pp. 406–412.
70.
SACKSM.
(1994) ‘The alternatives to
medicine’, in
GabeJ.,
KelleherD.,
WilliamsG.
(editors). Challenging Medicine.London:
Routledge, pp.
84–103.
71.
SAYERA.
(1981) ‘Abstraction: a realist
interpretation’,Radical Philosophy, vol. 28, (Summer), pp.
6–15.
72.
SAYERA.
(1992) Method in Social Science: A Realist
Approach.London:
Routledge.
73.
SCAMBLERG.
(2001) ‘Critical realism, sociology and health
inequalities: social class as a generative mechanism and its media of
enactment’,Journal of Critical Realism, vol. 4, No.
1, pp. 35–42.
74.
SHARMAU.
(1990) ‘Using alternative therapies: marginal
medicine and central concerns’, in
AbbottP.,
PayneG.
(editors) New Directions in the Sociology of Health.London: Falmer
Press,
127–139.
75.
SHARMAU.
(1992) Complementary Medicine Today: Practitioners and
Patients.London:
Routledge.
76.
SHARPR., and
O'LEARYJ.
(1991) ‘Making sense of New Age therapies: towards a
preliminary conceptualization’, A Draft Paper for The Australian
Sociological Association Conference in Perth, December 1991.
77.
SHAWM.,
DORLINGD.,
DAVEY SMITHG.
(1999) The Widening Gap: Health Inequalities and Policy
in Britain.Bristol: The Policy
Press.
78.
SOIFFERS.
M., and HOWEG.
N. (1982) ‘Patrons,
clients and the articulation of modes of production: an examination of the
penetration of capitalism into peripheral agriculture in Northern
Brazil’,Journal of Peasant Studies, vol. 3, No.
3, pp.
321–341.
79.
TURNERBryan
S. (1987) Medical Power and Social
Knowledge.London:
Sage.
80.
TURNERVictor
W. (1977) ‘Ndembu
divination and its symbolism’, in
LandyD.
(editor). Culture, Disease, and Healing.New York:
MacMillan, pp.
175–183.
81.
UNSCHULDP.U.
(1975) ‘Medico-cultural conflicts in Asian
settings: an explanatory theory’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 9, pp.
303–312.
82.
UNSCHULDP.U.
(1976) ‘The social organization and ecology of
medical practice in Taiwan,’ in
LeslieC.
(editor). Asian Medical Systems: A Comparative Study.Berkeley: University of
California Press, pp.
300–316.
83.
UNSCHULDP.U.
(1987) ‘Traditional Chinese medicine: some
historical and epistemological reflections’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 24, pp.
1023–1029.
84.
WATSONI.G.
(1986) Class Analysis and Environmental Politics:
Timber Workers and Conservationists in Northern New South Wales
1960-1986, PhD Thesis, Australian National
University.
85.
WEISBERGD.H.
(1982) ‘Northern Thai health care
alternatives’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 16, pp.
1507–1517.
86.
WILKINSONS.,
and KITZINGERC.
(editors). (1994) Women and Health: Feminist
Perspectives.London: Taylor and
Francis.
87.
WOLFFR.J.
(1965) ‘Modern medicine and traditional culture:
confrontation on the Malay Peninsula’,Human Organization, vol. 24, pp.
339–345.
88.
WORSLEYP.
(1999) Knowledges: Culture, Counterculture,
Subculture.New York: New
Press.
89.
YOUNGA.
(1981) ‘The creation of medical knowledge: some
problems in interpretation’,Social Science & Medicine, vol. 15B, pp.
379–386.
90.
YOUNGA.
(1982) ‘The anthropologies of illness and
sickness’,Annual Review of Anthropology, vol. 11, pp.
257–285.
91.
YOUNGT.K.
(1986) ‘Socialist development and primary health
care: the case of Tanzania’,Human Organization, vol. 45, pp.
128–134.
