How does political violence affect public health risks? While past research provides useful insights, it remains unclear how the effect of violence on health risks varies by perpetrator identity, target, and the intensity of attacks. We argue that indiscriminate attacks by militants will discourage civilians from accessing healthcare services. In contrast, clashes between militants and governments are likely to induce state actors to augment healthcare provision, while reinforced state control may facilitate civilians’ access. We test our arguments by employing multilevel modeling using subnational data on political violence events within Pakistan between 2005 and 2011, and immunization rates for under-5 infectious diseases.
AcerraJRIskyanKQureshiZA, et al. (2009) Rebuilding the health care system in Afghanistan: An overview of primary care and emergency services. International Journal Of Emergency Medicine2: 77–82.
AldisW (2008) Health security as a public health concept: A critical analysis. Health Policy and Planning23(6): 369–375.
4.
AliHE (2011) Military expenditures and human development: Guns and butter arguments revisited: A case study from Egypt. Peace Economics, Peace Science And Public Policy17.
5.
AliMAhmadNKhanH, et al. (2019) Polio vaccination controversy in Pakistan. The Lancet394: 915–916.
6.
ArjonaA. (2014). Wartime institutions: a research agenda. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 58(8), 1360–1389.
7.
ArjonaA (2016) Rebelocracy: Social Order in the Colombian Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
8.
BarberBK (2008) Contrasting portraits of war: Youths’ varied experiences with political violence in Bosnia and Palestine. International Journal of Behavioral Development32: 298.
9.
BermanEFelterJHShapiroJN, et al. (2013) Modest, secure, and informed: Successful development in conflict zones. American Economic Review103(3 ): 512–517.
10.
Bueno de MesquitaEChristine FairCJordanJ, et al. (2015) Measuring political violence in Pakistan: Insights from the BFRS dataset. Conflict Management and Peace Science32(5): 536–558.
11.
BurchettHEDMounier-JackSGriffithsUK, et al. (2012) New vaccine adoption: Qualitative study of national decision-making processes in seven low -and middle-income countries. Health Policy and Planning27(suppl_2): ii5–ii16.
12.
CallawayE (2012) Taliban halts polio vaccinations over drone strikes. Available from: blogs.nature.com/news/2012/06/taliban-halts-polio-vaccinations-over- drone-strikes.html (accessed 10 January 2020).
13.
ChiPCBulagePUrdalH, et al. (2015) Perceptions of the effects of armed conflict on maternal and reproductive health services and outcomes in Burundi and Northern Uganda: A qualitative study. BMC International Health and Human Rights15(1): 7.
14.
Coward M (2008) Urbicide: The politics of urban destruction. London: Routledge.
15.
CrostBFelterJJohnstonP (2014) Aid under fire: development projects and civil conflict. American Economic Review104(6): 1833–1856.
16.
DavenportC (2007) State repression and political order. Annual Reviews in Political Science10: 1–23.
17.
De JongKVan De KamSFordN, et al. (2008) Conflict in the Indian Kashmir Valley II: Psychosocial impact. Conflict and Health2(1): 11.
18.
FarmerP (2004) Political violence and public health in Haiti. New England Journal of Medicine350(15): 1483–1486.
FindleyMG (2018) Does foreign aid build peace?Annual Review of Political Science21(2018): 359–384.
21.
FlaniganST (2008) Nonprofit service provision by insurgent organizations: The cases of Hizballah and the Tamil Tigers. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism31(6): 499–519.
22.
FloresWRuanoALFunchalDP (2009) Social participation within a context of political violence: Implications for the promotion and exercise of the right to health in Guatemala. Health and Human Rights11(1): 37–48.
GhobarahHAHuthPRussettB (2004) Comparative public health: The political economy of human misery and well-being. International Studies Quarterly48: 73–94.
25.
GiacamanRWickLAbdul-RahimH, et al. (2005) The politics of childbirth in the context of conflict: Policies or de facto practices?Health Policy72(2): 129–139.
26.
GostinLO (2014) Global polio eradication: Espionage, disinformation, and the politics of vaccination. The Milbank Quarterly92(3): 413.
GregoryD (2008) The biopolitics of Baghdad: Counterinsurgency and the counter-city. Human Geography1(1): 6–27.
29.
GrundyJBiggsBA (2019) The impact of conflict on immunisation coverage in 16 countries. International Journal of Health Policy and Management8(4): 211.
30.
GrynkewichAG (2008) Welfare as warfare: how violent non-state groups use social services to attack the state. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism31(4): 350–370.
31.
GuarinoKVoormanAGasteenM, et al. (2017) Violence, insecurity, and the risk of polio: A systematic analysis. PloS one12(10): e0185577.
32.
GuentherTSadruddinSChimunaT, et al. (2012) Beyond distance: An approach to measure effective access to case management for sick children in Africa. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene87(5_Suppl): 77–84.
33.
HachiyaMSakuradaSMizunoT, et al. (2012) Poliovirus eradication. The Lancet Infectious Diseases12(6): 433.
34.
Haj-YahiaMM (2008) Political violence in retrospect: Its effect on the mental health of Palestinian adolescents. International Journal of Behavioral Development32(4): 283–289. Chicago.
35.
HamiehCSMac GintyR (2010) A very political reconstruction: Governance and reconstruction in Lebanon after the 2006 war. Disasters34: S103–S123.
36.
HasanQBosanAHBileKM (2010) A review of EPI progress in Pakistan towards achieving coverage targets: Present situation and the way forward. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal16(Supplement): S31–S38.
37.
HazeltonJL (2017) The “hearts and minds” fallacy: Violence, coercion, and success in counterinsurgency warfare. International Security42(1): 80–113.
38.
HerpMVParquéVRackleyE, et al. (2003) Mortality, violence and lack of access to healthcare in the democratic Republic of Congo. Disasters27(2): 141–153.
39.
HeudtlassPSpeybroeckNGuha-SapirD (2016) Excess mortality in refugees, internally displaced persons and resident populations in complex humanitarian emergencies (1998–2012)—Insights from operational data. Conflict and Health10(1): 15.
40.
HilsenrathP (2005) Health policy as counter-terrorism: Health services and the Palestinians. Defence and Peace Economics16(5): 365–374.
41.
HuangR (2016) The Wartime Origins of Democratization: Civil War, Rebel Governance, and Political Regimes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
42.
IbrahimMMOmarHMPerssonLA, et al. (1996) Child mortality in a collapsing African society. Bulletin of the World Health Organization74(5): 547–552.
JadoonA (2019) Playing dirty to survive: The vulnerability of civilian targets within US military aid recipient states. Small Wars & Insurgencies30(3): 587–614.
45.
KalyvasSNKocherMA (2007) How “free” is free riding in civil wars?: Violence, insurgency, and the collective action problem. World Politics59(2): 177–216.
46.
KennedyJMcKeeMKingL (2015) Islamist insurgency and the war against polio: A cross-national analysis of the political determinants of polio. Globalization and Health11(1): 40.
47.
KhalidHAshleyMF (2019) Political and governance challenges to achieving global HIV goals with injecting drug users: The case of Pakistan. International Journal Health Policy and Management8(5): 261–271.
48.
KhalidMSattarA (2016) Households study on out-of-pocket health expenditures in Pakistan. Forman Journal of Economic Studies 12: 75–88.
49.
KhalilATAliMTanveerF, et al. (2017) Emerging viral infections in Pakistan: Issues, concerns, and future prospects. Health Security15(3): 268–281.
50.
KhannaGZimmermannL (2017) Guns and butter? Fighting violence with the promise of development. Journal of Development Economics124: 120–141.
KumarSBanoS (2017) Comparison and analysis of health care delivery systems: Pakistan versus Bangladesh. Journal of Hospital and Medical Management3(1): 1–7.
53.
KyddAWalterB (2006) The strategies of terrorism. International Security31(1): 49–80.
54.
LorettiA (1997) Armed conflicts, health and health services in Africa. An epidemiological framework of reference. Medicine, Conflict and Survival13(3): 219–228.
55.
MampillyZ. (2015). Performing the nation-state: Rebel governance and symbolic processes. In Arjona A, Kasfir N, and Mampilly Z (eds), Rebel Governance in Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 74–97.
56.
MathersCDSteinCMa FatD, et al. (2002) Global Burden of Disease 2000: Version 2 Methods and Results. Geneva: World Health Organization.
57.
McCormickJMMitchellNJ (1997) Human rights violations, umbrella concepts, and empirical analysis. World Politics49(4): 510–525.
58.
MohammadiD (2012) The final push for polio eradication?The Lancet380(9840): 460–462.
MurrayCJKingGLopezAD, et al. (2002) Armed conflict as a public health problem. Bmj324(7333): 346–349.
62.
NarangN.StantonJA. (2017). A strategic logic of attacking aid workers: Evidence from violence in Afghanistan. International Studies Quarterly, 61(1), 38–51.
63.
NorrisAHacheyKCurtisA, et al. (2016) Crippling violence: Conflict and incident polio in Afghanistan. PLoS ONE11(3): e0149074.
64.
O’ReillyKMDurryEul IslamO, et al. (2012) The effect of mass immunization campaigns and new oral poliovirus vaccines on the incidence of poliomyelitis in Pakistan and Afghanistan, 2001–11: A retrospective analysis. The Lancet380(9840): 491–498.
65.
OzarasRLeblebiciogluHSunbulM, et al. (2016) The Syrian conflict and infectious diseases. Expert Review of Anti-Infective Therapy14(6): 547–555.
66.
PatelPGibson-FallFSullivanR, et al. (2017) Documenting attacks on health workers and facilities in armed conflicts. Bulletin of the World Health Organization95(1): 79.
67.
PenchanskyRThomasJW (1981) The concept of access: Definition and relationship to consumer satisfaction. Medical Care: 127–140.
68.
ReilleyBAbeyasingheRPakianatharMV (2002) Barriers to prompt and effective treatment of malaria in northern Sri Lanka. Tropical Medicine & International Health7(9): 744–749.
SalmonDADudleyMZGlanzJM, et al. (2015) Vaccine hesitancy: Causes, consequences, and a call to action. Vaccine33: D66–D71.
72.
SextonR (2016) Aid as a tool against insurgency: Evidence from contested and controlled territory in Afghanistan. American Political Science Review110(4): 731–749.
73.
SidelVWLevyBS (2008) The health impact of war. International Journal of Injury Control and Safety Promotion15(4): 189–195.
74.
SteelFisherGKBlendonRJGuirguisS, et al. (2015) Threats to polio eradication in high-conflict areas in Pakistan and Nigeria: A polling study of caregivers of children younger than 5 years. The Lancet Infectious Diseases15(10): 1183–1192.
75.
StewartMA (2018) Civil war as state-making: Strategic governance in civil war. International Organization72(1): 205–226.
76.
The World Bank (2019) World Bank Open Data. Available at: https://data.worldbank.org/ (accessed 24 January 2019).
WisePH (2017) The epidemiologic challenge to the conduct of just war: Confronting indirect civilian casualties of war. Daedalus146(1): 139–154.
80.
WoodRMSullivanC (2015) Doing harm by doing good? The negative externalities of humanitarian aid provision during civil conflict. The Journal of Politics77(3): 736–748.
YachD (1988) The impact of political violence on health and health services in Cape Town, South Africa, 1986: Methodological problems and preliminary results. American Journal of Public Health78(7): 772–776.
84.
YusufzaiA (2008) Health infrastructure: A casualty of war on terror within Pakistan. Canadian Medical Association179(9): 889–890.
85.
ZaidiSABigdeliMLangloisEV, et al. (2019) Health systems changes after decentralisation: Progress, challenges and dynamics in Pakistan. BMJ Global Health4(1): e001013.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
