In a paper entitled ‘Lessons from Ireland’, Paddy Hillyard argued
that Northern Ireland essentially served as a testing ground for the development of
repressive policy measures that eventually would transfer elsewhere. In this
article, I engage with the important thesis advanced by Hillyard and others, and
argue that it stands in need of theoretical refinement and empirical elaboration.
First, I highlight some factors that might be considered in any re-evaluation of
this approach. Second, I examine the impact of the Northern conflict on policing in
Britain and the Republic of Ireland, both to demonstrate the salience of these
issues and to highlight ways in which the conflict’s impact was tempered
by other factors. Finally, I suggest that a focus on the negative lessons of
conflict should be complemented by attention to positive lessons of conflict and its resolution
Ackroyd, C.
,
Margolis, K.
,
Rosenhead, J.
and
Shallice, T.
(1980). The technology of political control.
London: Pluto
.
2.
Alderson, J.
(1998). Principled policing.
Winchester: Waterside Press
.
3.
Bennett, D.
(1988). Are they always right? Investigation and proof in
a citizen anti-heroin movement. In
M. Tomlinson
,
T. Varley
and
C. McCullagh
(eds) Whose law and order?, 21-40.
Belfast: Sociological Association of Ireland
.
4.
Brady, C.
(2000). Guardians of the peace.
London: Prendeville
.
5.
Brewer, J.
(1990). The RIC: An oral history.
Belfast: Institute of Irish Studies
.
6.
Brewer, J.
,
Lockhart, B.
and
Rodgers, P.
(1997). Crime in Ireland 1945-95.
Oxford:Clarendon
.
7.
BSSRS [British Society for Social Responsibility in Science]
(1985). TechnoCop: New police technologies.
London: Free Association Books
.
8.
Bryett, K. (1987). The effect of political terrorism on policing in Great
Britain and Northern Ireland since 1969. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Aberdeen.
9.
Bunyan, T.
(1977). The history and practice of the political police in
Britain.
London: Quartet
.
10.
Campbell, C.
and
Connelly, I.
(2003).
A model for the ‘war against terrorism’?Military
intervention in Northern Ireland and the 1970 Falls Road curfew
. Journal of Law and Society30,
341-375
.
11.
Committee on the Administration of Justice
(1996). The misrule of law.
Belfast:Committee on the Administration of Justice
.
12.
Council of Europe
(1999). Report to the Irish Government on the visit to
Ireland carried out by the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and
Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) from 31 August to 9 September
1998. URL:http://www.cpt.coe.int/en/reports/inf9915en.htm.
13.
Crawford, A.
(ed.) (2002). Crime and insecurity.
Cullompton, Devon: Willan
.
14.
Department of Justice
(1997). Tacking crime.
Dublin: Stationery Office
.
15.
Downes, D.
and
Morgan, R.
(2002). The skeletons in the cupboard: The politics of law
and order at the turn of the millennium. In
M. Maguire
,
R. Morgan
and
R. Reiner
(eds) The Oxford handbook of criminology, 3rd edn,
286-321.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
16.
Dunn, S.
,
Murray, D.
and
Walsh, D.
(2002). Cross border police co-operation in Ireland.
Limerick: University of Limerick/University of Ulster
.
17.
Dunne, D.
and
Kerrigan, G.
(1984). Round up the usual suspects.
Dublin:Magill
.
18.
Ellison, G.
and
Smyth, J.
(2000). The crowned harp: Policing Northern Ireland.
London: Pluto
.
19.
Farrell, M.
(1993). Anti-terrorism and Ireland: The experience of the
Irish Republic. In
T. Bunyan
(ed.) Statewatching the new Europe, 121-129.
London: Statewatch
.
20.
Farrell, M.
(1997). The special criminal court - The facts.
Dublin: Irish Council for Civil Liberties
.
21.
Farrell, M.
(2000).
The role of the police in a democratic society
. Paper presented to ‘Policing and Human
Rights’ Conference, Dublin Castle,
3 November.
22.
Flyghed, J.
(2002).
Normalizing the exceptional: The case of political violence
. Policing and Society13,
23-41
.
23.
An Garda Síochána (various years).
Annual report on crime.
Dublin: Stationery Office
.
24.
Geraghty, T.
(1998). The Irish war.
London: Harper Collins
.
25.
Hermon, J.
(1997). Holding the line.
Dublin: Gill and Macmillan
.
26.
Hillyard, P.
(1985). Lessons from Ireland. In
B. Fine
and
R. Millar
(eds) Policing the miners’ strike,
177-187.
London: Lawrence & Wishart
.
27.
Hillyard, P.
(1987). The normalization of special powers: From Northern
Ireland to Britain. In
P. Scraton
(ed.) Law, order and the authoritarian state,
279-312.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
28.
Hillyard, P.
(1993). Suspect community.
London: Pluto
.
29.
Hillyard, P.
(1997). Policing divided societies: Trends and prospects
in Northern Ireland and Britain. In
P. Francis
,
P. Davies
and
V. Jupp
(eds) Policing futures, 163-185.
London: Macmillan
.
30.
Hogan, G.
and
Walker, C.
(1989). Political violence and the law in Ireland.
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
31.
Inglis, T.
(2003). Truth, power and Lies.
Dublin: University College Dublin Press
.
32.
Irish Council for Civil Liberties
(2003). Police reform: Why the Patten Report should apply
here and how this can be achieved.
Dublin: ICCL
.
33.
Jefferson, T.
(1990). The case against paramilitary policing.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
34.
Johnston, L.
and
Shearing, C.
(2003). Governing security.
London: Routledge
.
35.
Karstedt, S.
(2002).
Durkheim, Tarde and beyond: The global travel of crime policies
. Criminal Justice2,
111-123
.
36.
Loader, I.
(2002).
Policing, securitization and democratization in Europe
. Criminal Justice2,
125-153
.
37.
Loader, I.
and
Mulcahy, A.
(2003). Policing and the condition of England.
Oxford:Oxford University Press
.
38.
Loader, I.
and
Walker, N.
(2004).
State of denial?Punishment and Society6,
221-228
.
39.
McCullagh, C.
(1996). Crime in Ireland.
Cork: Cork University Press
.
40.
McEvoy, K.
and
Mika, H.
(2001).
Punishment, policing and praxis: Restorative justice and non-violent
alternatives to paramilitary punishments in Northern Ireland
. Policing and Society11,
359-382
.
41.
McNiffe, L.
(1997). A history of the Garda
Síochána.
Dublin: Wolfhound
.
42.
Maguire, M.
,
Morgan, R.
and
Reiner, R.
, eds (2002). The Oxford handbook of criminology,
3rd edn.Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
43.
Manwaring-White, S.
(1983). The policing revolution.
Brighton: Harvester
.
44.
Mark, R.
(1978). In the office of constable.
Glasgow: Collins
.
45.
Moloney, E.
(2003). A secret history of the IRA.
London: Penguin
.
46.
Matassa, M.
and
Newburn, T.
(2003). Policing and terrorism. In
T. Newburn
(ed.)Handbook of policing, 467-500.
Cullompton, Devon: Willan
.
47.
Mulcahy, A.
(2000).
Policing history
. British Journal of Criminology40,
68-87
.
48.
Mulcahy, A.
(2002). The impact of the Northern
‘Troubles’ on criminal justice in the Irish
Republic. In
P. O’Mahony
(ed.) Criminal justice in Ireland, 275-296.
Dublin: Institute of Public Administration
.
49.
Mulcahy, A.
and
Ellison, G.
(2001).
The language of policing and the struggle for legitimacy in Northern Ireland
. Policing and Society11,
383-404
.
50.
Mulcahy, A.
and
O’Mahony, E.
(2005). Policing and social marginalization in Ireland.
Dublin: Combat Poverty Agency
.
51.
National Crime Forum
(1998). Report of the National Crime Forum.
Dublin:Institute of Public Administration
.
52.
Newburn, T.
and
Sparks, R.
, eds (2004a). Criminal justice and political cultures.
Cullompton, Devon: Willan
.
53.
Newburn, T.
and
Sparks, R.
(2004b). Criminal justice and political cultures.
In
T. Newburn
and
R. Sparks
(eds) Criminal justice and political cultures,
1-15.
Cullompton, Devon: Willan
.
54.
Ní Aoláin, F.
(2000). The politics of force.
Belfast: Blackstaff Press
.
55.
Northam, G.
(1988). Shooting in the dark.
London: Faber & Faber
.
56.
Northern Ireland Affairs Committee
(2002). The financing of terrorism in Northern Ireland.
London: HMSO
.
O’Donnell, I.
and
O’Sullivan, E.
(2001). Crime control in Ireland.
Cork: Cork University Press
.
59.
O’Halpin, E.
(1999). Defending Ireland.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
60.
O’Leary, B.
and
McGarry, J.
(1996). The politics of antagonism: Understanding Northern
Ireland, 2nd edn.London: Athlone
.
61.
O’Mahony, P.
(1993). Crime and punishment in Ireland.
Dublin: Round Hall/Sweet& Maxwell
.
62.
Palmer, S.
(1988). Police and protest in England and Ireland
1780-1850.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
63.
Patten Commission
(1999). A new beginning: Report of the Independent Commission
on Policing.
Belfast: Stationery Office
.
64.
Poole, M.
(1997). Political violence: The overspill from Northern
Ireland. In
A. O’Day
(ed.) Political violence in Northern Ireland,
153-177.
London: Praeger
.
65.
Reiner, R.
(2000). The politics of the police, 3rd edn.Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
66.
Rolston, B.
(2002). Resistance and terror: Lessons from
Ireland. In
P. Scraton
(ed.)Beyond September 11: An anthology of dissent,
59-66.
London: Pluto
.
67.
Rolston, B.
and
Tomlinson, M.
(1982). Spectators at the ‘carnival of
reaction’? In
M. Kelly
,
L. O’Dowd
and
J. Wickham
(eds) Power, conflict and inequality, 21-43.
Dublin: Turoe Press
.
68.
Scraton, P.
, ed. (2002). Beyond September 11: An anthology of
dissent.
London:Pluto
.
69.
Shearing, C.
(2001).
A nodal conception of governance: Thoughts on a policing commission
. Policing and Society11,
259-272
.
70.
Sheehy Inquiry
(1993). Inquiry into police responsibilities and
rewards.
London:HMSO
.
71.
Sim, J.
,
Scraton, P.
and
Gordon, P.
(1987). Introduction: Crime, the state and critical
analysis. In
P. Scraton
(ed.) Law, order and the authoritarian state,
1-70.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
72.
Taylor, P.
(2001). Brits: The war against the IRA.
London: Bloomsbury
.
73.
Tomlinson, M.
(1993). Policing the new Europe: The Northern Ireland
factor. In
T. Bunyan
(ed.) Statewatching the new Europe, 87-114.
London: Statewatch
.
74.
Tomlinson, M.
(1995).
Can Britain leave Ireland?Race and Class37,
1-22
.
75.
Tomlinson, M.
,
Varley, T.
and
McCullagh, C.
(1988b). Introduction. In
M. Tomlinson
,
T. Varley
and
C. McCullagh
(eds) Whose law and order?, 9-20.
Belfast: Sociological Association of Ireland
.
76.
Waddington, P. A. J.
(1999). Policing citizens.
London: University College London Press
.
77.
Walker, C.
and
McGuinness, M.
(2002). Commercial risk, political violence and policing
the City of London. In
A. Crawford
(ed.) Crime and insecurity, 234-259.
Cullompton, Devon: Willan
.
78.
Walsh, D.
(1999). The Irish police.
Dublin: Round Hall/Sweet & Maxwell
.
79.
Williams, P.
(1998). The general, revised edn.Dublin: O’Brien Press
.
