Featured price cuts are a popular tool among brand manufacturers and retailers. However, there is increasing concern about the net sales and revenue gains from these promotions, because retailers and manufacturers may simply be subsidizing consumers who shop around. Thus, the (co-)occurrence of a brand's promotions across retailers has been placed high on the promotion-planning agenda. This article examines the mechanisms underlying out-of-phase versus in-phase schedules and empirically demonstrates their sales and revenue implications in four product categories, covering purchases of a national panel of households across eight years. The results reveal that calendar effects primarily materialize in categories in which the chosen retailer is driven by brand promotions. In those categories, alternating the timing of featured price cuts across chains substantially increases the manufacturer and retailers' immediate sales lift. However, with regard to net gains, striving for out-of-phase promotions—the dominant approach among chains—is not necessarily the best practice, because retailers observe the revenue advantage diminish, and manufacturers may even earn less.
AilawadiKusum L., BeauchampJ.P., DonthuNaveen, GauriDinesh, and ShankarVenkatesh (2009), “Communication and Promotion Decisions in Retailing: A Review and Directions for Future Research,”Journal of Retailing, 85(1), 42– 55.
2.
AilawadiKusum L., HarlamBari A., CesarJacques, and TrounceDavid (2006), “Promotion Profitability for a Retailer: The Role of Promotion, Brand, Category, and Store Characteristics,”Journal of Marketing Research, 43(November), 518– 35.
3.
AilawadiKusum L. and NeslinScott A. (1998), “The Effect of Promotion on Consumption: Buying More and Consuming It Faster,”Journal of Marketing Research, 35(August), 390– 98.
4.
AndersonEric T. and SimesterDuncan (2013), “Advertising in a Competitive Market: The Role of Product Standards, Customer Learning, and Switching Costs,”Journal of Marketing Research, 50(August), 489– 504.
5.
BellDavid R., ChiangJeongwen, and PadmanabhanV. (1999), “The Decomposition of Promotional Response: An Empirical Generalization,”Marketing Science, 18(4), 504– 526.
6.
BesankoDavid, DubéJean-Pierre, and GuptaSachin (2005), “Own-Brand and Cross-Brand Retail Pass-Through,”Marketing Science, 24(1), 123– 37.
7.
BijmoltTammo H.A., van HeerdeHarald J., and PietersRik G.M. (2005), “New Empirical Generalizations on the Determinants of Price Elasticity,”Journal of Marketing Research, 42(May), 141– 56.
8.
BlattbergRobert and WisniewskiKenneth J. (1989), “Price-Induced Patterns of Competition,”Marketing Science, 8(4), 291– 307.
9.
BrieschRichard A., ChintaguntaPradeep K., and FoxEdward J. (2009), “How Does Assortment Affect Grocery Store Choice?”Journal of Marketing Research, 46(April), 176– 89.
10.
BrieschRichard A., DillonWilliam R., and FoxEdward J. (2013), “Category Positioning and Store Choice: The Role of Destination Categories,”Marketing Science, 32(3), 488– 509.
11.
BucklinRandolph E. and LattinJames M. (1992), “A Model of Product Category Competition Among Grocery Retailers,”Journal of Retailing, 68(3), 271– 93.
12.
CachonGérard P., RandallTaylor, and SchmidtGlen M. (2007), “In Search of the Bullwhip Effect,”Manufacturing and Service Operations Management, 9(4), 457– 79.
13.
CampoKatia, GijsbrechtsEls, and NisolPatricia (2000), “Towards Understanding Consumers' Response to Stockouts,”Journal of Retailing, 76(2), 219– 42.
14.
CarpenterGregory S., CooperLee G., HanssensDominique M., and MidgleyDavid F. (1988), “Modeling Asymmetric Competition,”Marketing Science, 7(4), 393– 412.
15.
ChintaguntaPradeep, ErdemTülin, RossiPeter E., and WedelMichel (2006), “Structural Modeling in Marketing: Review and Assessment,”Marketing Science, 25(6), 604– 616.
16.
CosslettStephen R. (1981), “Maximum Likelihood Estimator for Choice-Based Samples,”Econometrica, 49(5), 1289– 1316.
17.
FoubertBram and GijsbrechtsEls (2010), “Please or Squeeze? Brand Performance Implications of Constrained and Unconstrained Multi-Item Promotions,”European Journal of Operational Research, 202(3), 880– 92.
18.
FoxEdward J., MontgomeryAlan L., and LodishLeonard M. (2004), “Consumer Shopping and Spending Across Retail Formats,”Journal of Business, 77 (S2), S25– S60.
19.
FreimerMarshall and HorskyDan (2008), “Try It, You Will Like It—Does Consumer Learning Lead to Competitive Price Promotions?”Marketing Science, 27(5), 796– 810.
20.
FreimerMarshall and HorskyDan (2012), “Periodic Advertising Pulsing in a Competitive Market,”Marketing Science, 31(4), 637– 48.
21.
GauriDinesh, SudhirKarunakaran, and TalukdarDebabrata (2008), “The Temporal and Spatial Dimensions of Price Search: Insights from Matching Household Survey and Purchase Data,”Journal of Marketing Research, 45(April), 226– 40.
22.
GeyskensInge, GielensKatrijn, and GijsbrechtsEls (2010), “Proliferating Private-Label Portfolios: How Introducing Economy and Premium Private Labels Influences Brand Choice,”Journal of Marketing Research, 47(October), 791– 807.
GielensKatrijn (2012), “New Products: The Antidote to Private Label Growth?”Journal of Marketing Research, 49(June), 408– 423.
25.
GijsbrechtsEls, CampoKatia, and NisolPatricia (2008), “Beyond Promotion-Based Store Switching: Antecedents and Patterns of Systematic Multiple-Store Shopping,”International Journal of Research in Marketing, 25(1), 5– 21.
26.
GordonBrett R., GoldfarbAvi, and LiYang (2013), “Does Price Elasticity Vary with Economic Growth? A Cross-Category Analysis,”Journal of Marketing Research, 50(February), 4– 23.
27.
GuptaSunil (1988), “Impact of Sales Promotion on When, What, and How Much to Buy,”Journal of Marketing Research, 25(November), 342– 55.
28.
HaansHans and GijsbrechtsEls (2011), “‘One-Deal-Fits-All?’ On Category Sales Promotion Effectiveness in Smaller Versus Larger Supermarkets,”Journal of Retailing, 87(4), 427– 33.
LeeflangPeter S.H., SelvaJosefa Parreno, Van DijkAlfred, and WittinkDick R. (2008), “Decomposing the Sales Promotion Bump Accounting for Cross-Category Effects,”International Journal of Research in Marketing, 25(3), 201– 214.
31.
ManskiCharles F. and McFaddenDaniel (1981), “Alternative Estimators and Sample Designs for Discrete Choice Models,”inStructural Analysis of Discrete Data, ManskiCharles F. and McFaddenDaniel, eds. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2– 49.
32.
MehtaNitin and MaYu (2012), “A Multi-Category Model of Consumers' Purchase Incidence, Quantity, and Brand Choice Decisions: Methodological Issues and Implications on Promotional Decisions,”Journal of Marketing Research, 49(August), 435– 51.
33.
NarasimhanChakravarthi (1988), “Competitive Promotional Strategies,”Journal of Business, 61(4), 427– 49.
34.
NeslinScott A. (2002), “Sales Promotions,”inHandbook of Marketing, WeitzBarton A. and WensleyRobin, eds. London: Sage Publications.
35.
NeslinScott A. and van HeerdeHarald J. (2008), “Promotion Dynamics,”Foundations and Trends in Marketing, 3(4), 177– 268.
36.
RaoRam C., ArjunjiRamesh V., and MurthiB.P.S. (1995), “Game Theory and Empirical Generalizations Concerning Competitive Promotions,”Marketing Science, 14 (3), G89– G100.
37.
SethuramanRaj, SrinivasanVivek, and KimDoyle (1999), “Asymmetric and Neighborhood Cross-Price Effects: Some Empirical Generalizations,”Marketing Science, 18(1), 23– 41.
38.
Silva-RissoJorge M., BucklinRandolph E., and MorrisonDonald G. (1999), “A Decision Support System for Planning Manufacturers' Promotion Calendars,”Marketing Science, 18(3), 274– 300.
39.
SrinivasanShuba, PauwelsKoen, HanssensDominique M., and DekimpeMarnik G. (2004), “Do Promotions Benefit Manufacturers, Retailers, or Both?”Management Science, 50(5), 617– 29.
40.
SteenkampJan Benedict E.M., GeyskensInge, GielensKatrijn, and KollOliver (2004), “A Global Study into Drivers of Private Label Success,”research report, AIM, Brussels.
41.
SteenkampJan Benedict E.M., NijsVincent R., HanssensDominique M., and DekimpeMarnik G. (2005), “Competitive Reactions to Advertising and Promotion Attacks,”Marketing Science, 24(1), 35– 54.
TellisGerard and ZufrydenFred (1995), “Tackling the Retailer Decision Maze: Which Brands to Discount, How Much, When, and Why?”Marketing Science, 14 (3, Part 1), 271– 99.
44.
TrainKenneth (2003), Discrete Choice Models with Simulation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
45.
Van HeerdeHarald J., DekimpeMarnik G., and PutsisWilliam P.Jr. (2005), “Marketing Models and the Lucas Critique,”Journal of Marketing Research, 42(February), 15– 21.
46.
Van HeerdeHarald J., LeeflangPeter S.H., and WittinkDick R. (2000), “The Estimation of Pre- and Postpromotion Dips with Store-Level Scanner Data,”Journal of Marketing Research, 37(August), 383– 95.
47.
Van HeerdeHarald J., LeeflangPeter S.H., and WittinkDick R. (2004), “Decomposing the Sales Promotion Bump with Store Data,”Marketing Science, 23(3), 317– 34.
48.
Van HeerdeHarald J. and NeslinScott A. (2008), “Sales Promotion Models,”inHandbook of Marketing Decision Models, BerendWierenga, ed. New York: Springer Publishers, 107– 162.
49.
WenChieh-Hua and KoppelmanFrank S. (2001), “The Generalized Nested Logit Model,”Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 35(7), 627– 41.
50.
WierengaBerend and SoethoudtHan (2009), “Sales Promotions and Channel Coordination,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 38(3), 383– 97.
51.
ZhangJie and KrishnamurthiLakshman (2004), “Customizing Promotions in Online Stores,”Marketing Science, 23(4), 561– 78.
52.
ZhangQin, GangwarManish, and SeetharamanP.B. (2010), “Store Loyalty as a Category-Specific Trait: What Drives It?”working paper, University of Iowa.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
